Skip to content

Magic™ Editor doesn't think e.g. requires a comma. #212

@dbwiddis

Description

@dbwiddis

Grammar style guides for e.g. (exempli gratia) and i.e. (id est) generally state that a comma should be expected after them.

For example, Grammarly states:

E.g. and i.e. are both lowercase when they show up in the middle of a sentence (i.e., like this). Most American style guides recommend a period after both letters in both abbreviations.

In general, you add a comma after e.g. and between each subsequent example if there is more than one item in your list.

The AP style guide requires the commas:

AP Style has a specific way that it requires these two abbreviations to be written in writing. AP Style requires that a comma follow these abbreviations. Consider the following,

  • Wrong: The bulk (i.e. about 80 percent) of the work needs to be done in the next three days.
  • Correct: The bulk (i.e., about 80 percent) of the work needs to be done in the next three days.
  • Wrong: I have many hobbies (e.g. golf, sailing, writing).
  • Correct: I have many hobbies (e.g., golf, sailing, writing).

Presently, Magic™ Editor not only does not require the commas, it actively removes them. While I'm generally okay with not requiring they be added if they aren't already there, removing them is a bug.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions