🔍 Agentic Workflow Audit Report - 2025-10-12

[github-actions[bot]]

🔍 Agentic Workflow Audit Report - October 12, 2025

Audit Summary

• Period: Last 24 hours
• Runs Analyzed: 14
• Workflows Active: 9 unique workflows
• Success Rate: 92.86% (13/14 successful)
• Issues Found: 1 failure (Smoke GenAIScript)
• Missing Tools: 0

Performance Metrics

• Total Token Usage: 3.42M tokens
• Total Cost (24h): $2.50
• Average Cost per Run: $0.18
• Average Turns: 17.86
• Total Duration: 44.8 minutes

Top Resource Consumers

Workflow	Tokens	Cost	Turns	Duration
Documentation Unbloat	537k	$0.43	53	3.1m
Changeset Generator (avg)	465k	$0.29	28	2.6m
CLI Version Checker	268k	$0.29	22	1.9m
Duplicate Code Detector	N/A	N/A	31	7.5m

Missing Tools

✅ No missing tools detected across all 14 workflow runs. All requested tools were available and functioning properly.

Error Analysis

Critical Issues

1 Workflow Failure Detected:

Run ID	Workflow	Status	Reason	URL
18440146612	Smoke GenAIScript	❌ Failure	Custom engine (GenAIScript) failure on push to v0.20.0 tag	View Run

Note: The audit system detected 44 "error" lines in logs, but investigation reveals these are false positives from grep matching the word "error" in JSON log structures. No actual critical errors were found in the 13 successful runs.

MCP Server Status

✅ All MCP servers functioning normally:

• github: 312 calls across workflows
• safe-outputs: 23 calls
• serena: 29 calls

No MCP server failures detected.

Active Workflows Analysis

By Engine

Engine	Runs	Workflows
Claude	8	CLI Version Checker, Changeset Generator, Documentation Unbloat, GitHub MCP Remote Tools Report
Copilot	4	Tidy, Smoke Copilot
Codex	1	Dev, Duplicate Code Detector
Custom	1	Smoke GenAIScript ❌

Workflow Activity

Most Active Workflows (24h):

1. Changeset Generator - 5 runs (all successful)
2. Tidy - 3 runs (all successful)
3. Documentation Unbloat - 1 run (successful)
4. CLI Version Checker - 1 run (successful)
5. GitHub MCP Remote Tools Report - 1 run (successful)
6. Duplicate Code Detector - 1 run (successful)
7. Dev - 1 run (successful)
8. Smoke GenAIScript - 1 run (failed)
9. Agentic Workflow Audit - 1 run (in progress)

Recommendations

1. Investigate GenAIScript Failure (Priority: Medium)

The Smoke GenAIScript workflow failed on push to tag v0.20.0. This is a custom engine workflow, not Claude/Copilot/Codex.

Action Items:

• Review GenAIScript engine configuration
• Check compatibility with v0.20.0 release
• Investigate agent job logs for root cause
• Consider re-running smoke test

2. Monitor High Token Usage (Priority: Low)

The Documentation Unbloat workflow used 537k tokens (15.7% of daily total) in a single run with 53 turns.

Observations:

• Workflow completed successfully
• Created PR as expected
• High turn count (53) suggests iterative refinement
• Cost is acceptable at $0.43 per run

Action Items:

• Monitor future runs for token usage trends
• Consider if workflow can be optimized for fewer turns

3. System Health Assessment ✅

Overall system health is excellent:

• 92.86% success rate
• All agentic engines (Claude, Copilot, Codex) functioning normally
• No missing tools or MCP server failures
• Cost per run is reasonable ($0.18 average)
• All critical workflows operational

Historical Context

This is the first automated audit of the agentic workflow system. Future audits will include:

• Trend analysis comparing to previous periods
• Pattern detection across multiple days
• Cost trajectory analysis
• Success rate trends

Cache Memory Updated

The following persistent data has been stored in /tmp/gh-aw/cache-memory/:

audits/
├── index.json          # Master index of all audits
└── 2025-10-12.json     # Today's detailed audit report

patterns/
├── errors.json         # Error pattern tracking (none found)
└── missing-tools.json  # Missing tool requests (none found)

Next Steps

1. Immediate: No urgent action required - system is healthy
2. Short-term: Investigate GenAIScript smoke test failure
3. Ongoing: Continue daily audits to establish baseline trends
4. Future: Implement automated alerting for success rate < 85%

---

Audit Completed: 2025-10-12
Next Audit: 2025-10-13 (automated daily)
Status: ✅ System Healthy

AI generated by Agentic Workflow Audit Agent

[github-actions[bot]]

This discussion was automatically closed because it was created by an agentic workflow more than 1 month ago.