Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

multiple connections to different gateways kill each other #49

Open
FalcoGer opened this issue Nov 12, 2018 · 0 comments
Open

multiple connections to different gateways kill each other #49

FalcoGer opened this issue Nov 12, 2018 · 0 comments

Comments

@FalcoGer
Copy link

FalcoGer commented Nov 12, 2018

I used the knxlib to connect to two different knx gateways (tunneling connection to ethernet interface) on the same knx-bus with the same machine and with the same network adapter.
they are physically different gateways.

connection works fine with the first connection.
when connecting to the second interface (using a different program but from the same machine) the connection opens briefly. I even get a package or three. but then it just disconnects.

the reason why I have multiple knx gateways in the first place is because i want to use different machines on the same bus. (which works). but for testing I wanted to run the program on a machine that's already connected.

I use linux on a raspberry pi and mono to run the .net application.

I use a simple test program to inject and log knx messages. here is the output of that test program when running wit with another connection open at the same time:

16:44:37.167 [ERROR] KNXLib.KnxConnectionTunneling: Cannot access a disposed object.
Object name: 'System.Net.Sockets.UdpClient'.
16:44:37.181 [ERROR] KNXLib.KnxConnectionTunneling: System.ObjectDisposedException: Cannot access a disposed object.
Object name: 'System.Net.Sockets.UdpClient'.
  at System.Net.Sockets.UdpClient.CheckDisposed () [0x00016] in <bd46d4d4f7964dfa9beea098499ab597>:0 
  at System.Net.Sockets.UdpClient.Send (System.Byte[] dgram, System.Int32 bytes, System.Net.IPEndPoint endPoint) [0x00000] in <bd46d4d4f7964dfa9beea098499ab597>:0 
  at KNXLib.KnxSenderTunneling.SendData (System.Byte[] datagram) [0x00000] in <SOMEPATH>\knx.net\src\KNXLib\KnxSenderTunneling.cs:36 
  at KNXLib.KnxConnectionTunneling.DisconnectRequest () [0x000b3] in <SOMEPATH>\knx.net\src\KNXLib\KnxConnectionTunneling.cs:257 
  at KNXLib.KnxConnectionTunneling.Disconnect () [0x00006] in <SOMEPATH>\knx.net\src\KNXLib\KnxConnectionTunneling.cs:128 
16:44:37.208 [ERROR] KNXLib.KnxConnectionTunneling:   at System.Net.Sockets.UdpClient.CheckDisposed () [0x00016] in <bd46d4d4f7964dfa9beea098499ab597>:0 
  at System.Net.Sockets.UdpClient.Send (System.Byte[] dgram, System.Int32 bytes, System.Net.IPEndPoint endPoint) [0x00000] in <bd46d4d4f7964dfa9beea098499ab597>:0 
  at KNXLib.KnxSenderTunneling.SendData (System.Byte[] datagram) [0x00000] in <SOMEPATH>\knx.net\src\KNXLib\KnxSenderTunneling.cs:36 
  at KNXLib.KnxConnectionTunneling.DisconnectRequest () [0x000b3] in <SOMEPATH>\knx.net\src\KNXLib\KnxConnectionTunneling.cs:257 
  at KNXLib.KnxConnectionTunneling.Disconnect () [0x00006] in <SOMEPATH>\knx.net\src\KNXLib\KnxConnectionTunneling.cs:128 
16:44:37.229 Disonnected
16:44:37.260 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxConnection: KNX is disconnected
16:44:37.266 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxConnection: Send locked - 0 free locks
16:44:37.276 [INFO] KNXLib.KnxConnectionTunneling: KNXLib connecting...
16:44:37.302 Connected
16:44:37.310 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxConnection: KNX is connected. Unlocking send - 1 free locks
16:44:39.453 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16:44:39.471 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: 29-00-BC-D0-14-31-34-15-03-00-80-0C-4E
16:44:39.483 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Header Length: 6
16:44:39.495 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Protocol Version: 10
16:44:39.510 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Service Type: 0x0420
16:44:39.523 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Total Length: 23
16:44:39.540 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Message Code: 29
16:44:39.558 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Aditional Info Length: 0
16:44:39.574 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Control Field 1: 10111100
16:44:39.583 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Control Field 2: 11010000
16:44:39.593 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Source Address: 1.4.49
16:44:39.602 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Destination Address: 6/4/21
16:44:39.611 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Data Length: 3
16:44:39.619 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event APDU: 0x00800C4E
16:44:39.636 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Data: 0x0C4E
16:44:39.644 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16:44:39.815 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16:44:39.826 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: 29-00-BC-D0-14-64-0C-7C-03-00-80-02-BC
16:44:39.836 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Header Length: 6
16:44:39.843 [Event]     1.4.49 ==( 0x00000C4E [2] )==>    6/4/21

16:44:39.850 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Protocol Version: 10
16:44:39.857 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxConnection: Device 1.4.49 sent event 0x0C4E to 6/4/21
16:44:39.864 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Service Type: 0x0420
16:44:39.882 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Total Length: 23
16:44:39.890 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Message Code: 29
16:44:39.911 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Aditional Info Length: 0
16:44:39.919 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Control Field 1: 10111100
16:44:39.926 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Control Field 2: 11010000
16:44:39.935 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Source Address: 1.4.100
16:44:39.945 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Destination Address: 1/4/124
16:44:39.954 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Data Length: 3
16:44:39.962 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event APDU: 0x008002BC
16:44:39.971 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Data: 0x02BC
16:44:39.979 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16:44:39.989 [Event]    1.4.100 ==( 0x000002BC [2] )==>   1/4/124

[...]

16:45:19.076 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxConnection: Device 1.2.10 sent event 0x00C8 to 1/2/4
16:45:20.375 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16:45:20.402 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: 29-00-BC-D0-1C-28-09-22-03-00-80-00-C8
16:45:20.427 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Header Length: 6
16:45:20.450 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Protocol Version: 10
16:45:20.468 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Service Type: 0x0420
16:45:20.487 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Total Length: 23
16:45:20.501 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Message Code: 29
16:45:20.516 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Aditional Info Length: 0
16:45:20.531 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Control Field 1: 10111100
16:45:20.545 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Control Field 2: 11010000
16:45:20.560 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Source Address: 1.12.40
16:45:20.575 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Destination Address: 1/1/34
16:45:20.603 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Data Length: 3
16:45:20.617 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event APDU: 0x008000C8
16:45:20.631 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: Event Data: 0x00C8
16:45:20.645 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiver: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16:45:20.662 [Event]    1.12.40 ==( 0x000000C8 [2] )==>    1/1/34

16:45:20.677 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxConnection: Device 1.12.40 sent event 0x00C8 to 1/1/34
16:45:22.127 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxReceiverTunneling: Received connection state response - No active connection with channel ID 92
16:45:22.153 Disonnected
16:45:22.177 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxConnection: KNX is disconnected
16:45:22.203 [DEBUG] KNXLib.KnxConnection: Send locked - 0 free locks

sometimes the connection lasts 2 minutes, sometimes it dies right away after just a few seconds.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant