diff --git a/environment.yml b/environment.yml index ab5ba874..18675b46 100644 --- a/environment.yml +++ b/environment.yml @@ -37,3 +37,4 @@ dependencies: - signac-dashboard - signac-flow=0.20.0 - unyt + - camelot-py diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/.gitignore b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/.gitignore new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b5682685 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/.gitignore @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +*.pdf +*.ipynb diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..a094d9a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,659.22,1.25,-16.759,0.061,temp: 98.0,0.0011377211445378135 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,590.63,1.91,-14.366,0.086,temp: 173.0,0.026344163920897275 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,523.63,2.48,-12.241,0.102,temp: 248.0,0.0375724383875568 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,478.16,3.03,-10.908,0.113,temp: 298.0,0.09396659999071405 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,659.22,0.05,-16.759,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.0011377211445378135 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,590.66,0.07,-14.365,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.03142482410564051 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,523.73,0.11,-12.245,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.056677068076155676 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,478.13,0.15,-10.908,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.08768665395172569 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,660.02,0.09,-16.787,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.12249464322959451 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,590.8,0.1,-14.371,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.05513457163446153 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,524.04,0.08,-12.256,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.1159014201107883 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,477.99,0.12,-10.905,0.003,temp: 298.0,0.05838023910314501 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,659.17,0.85,-16.758,0.032,temp: 98.0,-0.006447086485789009 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,590.47,1.17,-14.361,0.037,temp: 173.0,-0.0007526903977525743 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,523.55,1.88,-12.241,0.053,temp: 248.0,0.02228873463667335 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,477.87,6.77,-10.904,0.061,temp: 298.0,0.033260454947215315 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,658.96,0.8,-16.758,0.03,temp: 98.0,-0.03830327853310648 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,590.44,1.2,-14.366,0.039,temp: 173.0,-0.005833350582495811 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,523.3,1.86,-12.238,0.054,temp: 248.0,-0.025472839584812983 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,477.43,2.22,-10.893,0.059,temp: 298.0,-0.05884542029118957 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,658.92,0.13,-16.748,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.04437112463737139 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,590.09,0.13,-14.347,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.06510771940455799 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,522.71,0.16,-12.215,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.1381901547475051 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,477.15,0.2,-10.88,0.003,temp: 298.0,-0.11745824998836282 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,659.09,0.05,-16.744,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.018582778694284333 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,590.26,0.07,-14.344,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.03631731169099373 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,523.07,0.11,-12.219,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.06941348786856216 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,477.06,0.14,-10.871,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.13629808810530414 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,659.1,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,-0.01706581716822242 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,590.5,1.4,,,temp: 173.0,0.004327969786990662 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,523.4,1.4,,,temp: 248.0,-0.006368209896214106 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,477.9,1.4,,,temp: 298.0,0.03954040098619179 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,590.42,0.3,-14.362,0.01,temp: 173.0,-0.009220457372343888 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,523.47,0.37,-12.238,0.011,temp: 248.0,0.007005030885811624 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,477.71,0.35,-10.897,0.01,temp: 298.0,-0.00023259059402823293 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..14b9bf40 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,646.13,1.36,-16.529,0.062,temp: 98.0,-0.01005888315445661 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,567.39,2.08,-13.866,0.086,temp: 173.0,0.050353256503779954 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,477.8,3.32,-11.194,0.011,temp: 248.0,0.08355424392720442 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,394.04,4.86,-9.009,0.131,temp: 298.0,1.9725340449024766 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,646.48,0.05,-16.542,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.04410433383113176 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,567.56,0.09,-13.87,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.08033009792432234 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,478.4,0.16,-11.207,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.20923472225778816 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,393.74,0.26,-9.001,0.006,temp: 298.0,1.8948978652926096 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,647.03,0.16,-16.56,0.006,temp: 98.0,0.12921796052275805 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,567.23,0.14,-13.86,0.005,temp: 173.0,0.02213975869620946 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,475.32,2.9,-11.14,0.067,temp: 248.0,-0.43592506650590834 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,354.88,25.0,-8.205,0.5,temp: 298.0,-8.16157526683842 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,646.18,0.83,-16.531,0.029,temp: 98.0,-0.0023212807279515252 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,567.03,1.57,-13.855,0.046,temp: 173.0,-0.013127113563268688 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,477.72,2.99,-11.192,0.079,temp: 248.0,0.0667968468164623 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,392.15,7.16,-8.968,0.154,temp: 298.0,1.4834261133603233 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,645.96,0.85,-16.532,0.03,temp: 98.0,-0.03636673140459149 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,567.12,1.63,-13.865,0.05,temp: 173.0,0.002742978953498484 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,477.61,3.22,-11.193,0.082,temp: 248.0,0.04375542578918445 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,392.37,6.47,-8.977,0.146,temp: 298.0,1.5403593117408971 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,645.93,0.12,-16.523,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.04100929286051213 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,566.68,0.13,-13.843,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.07484414001734542 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,477.24,0.29,-11.178,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.033747535848014217 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,376.01,18.57,-9.209,0.044,temp: 298.0,-2.693400349650347 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,645.95,0.07,-16.513,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.03791425188989251 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,566.75,0.09,-13.838,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.06250073472652207 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,476.76,0.2,-11.16,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.13429191851249073 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,391.04,0.47,-8.93,0.01,temp: 298.0,1.1961722488038384 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,645.9,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,-0.045651854316415184 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,567.0,1.3,,,temp: 173.0,-0.018417144402184397 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,478.3,1.6,,,temp: 248.0,0.1882879758693635 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,392.7,2.0,,,temp: 298.0,1.6257591093117432 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,567.18,0.35,-13.862,0.01,temp: 173.0,0.0133230406313299 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,477.46,0.28,-11.187,0.007,temp: 248.0,0.01233530620652958 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,390.83,0.82,-8.938,0.019,temp: 298.0,1.1418269230769242 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..a9dab7b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,668.53,1.15,-16.907,0.059,temp: 98.0,0.020571744895408837 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,605.46,1.83,-14.659,0.086,temp: 173.0,0.03304365066253271 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,546.57,2.3,-12.733,0.102,temp: 248.0,0.03396062194712044 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,508.63,2.53,-11.57,0.11,temp: 298.0,0.011360781272193598 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,668.48,0.04,-16.904,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.013091110387996718 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,605.51,0.06,-14.66,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.0413045633281565 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,546.79,0.08,-12.738,0.002,temp: 248.0,0.07422531144127438 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,508.83,0.1,-11.575,0.003,temp: 298.0,0.05068656259899953 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,669.11,0.09,-16.925,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.10734710518147442 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,605.44,0.08,-14.659,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.029739285596283197 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,546.66,0.05,-12.737,0.002,temp: 248.0,0.05043254037653854 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,508.8,0.15,-11.576,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.04478769539998367 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,668.25,0.68,-16.896,0.026,temp: 98.0,-0.021319808346133038 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,605.29,0.97,-14.654,0.032,temp: 173.0,0.004956547599374272 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,546.39,1.35,-12.727,0.04,temp: 248.0,0.001016785088242621 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,508.67,1.79,-11.573,0.05,temp: 298.0,0.019225937537559256 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,668.09,0.79,-16.898,0.03,temp: 98.0,-0.045257838769868816 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,605.19,1.09,-14.657,0.037,temp: 173.0,-0.0115652777318733 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,546.26,1.38,-12.729,0.041,temp: 248.0,-0.02277598597649322 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,508.34,1.82,-11.568,0.053,temp: 298.0,-0.045661601651682274 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,668.03,0.1,-16.887,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.05423460017878037 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,604.92,0.1,-14.639,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.056174206126298094 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,545.82,0.12,-12.71,0.002,temp: 248.0,-0.10330536496482193 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,508.27,0.15,-11.559,0.003,temp: 298.0,-0.05942562511606379 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,668.25,0.06,-16.885,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.021319808346133038 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,604.97,0.06,-14.633,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.04791329346065552 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,546.12,0.09,-12.711,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.0483989702000533 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,508.28,0.11,-11.552,0.003,temp: 298.0,-0.05745933604972517 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,668.4,1.0,,,temp: 98.0,0.001122095176120322 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,605.3,1.3,,,temp: 173.0,0.006608730132499029 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,546.4,1.5,,,temp: 248.0,0.0028469982470668547 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,508.7,1.5,,,temp: 298.0,0.025124804736575117 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,,,,,temp: 173.0, +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,546.45,0.3,-12.731,0.009,temp: 248.0,0.011998064041208829 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,508.63,0.35,-11.571,0.01,temp: 298.0,0.011360781272193598 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ddcbb4f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,700.76,1.13,-20.95,0.073,temp: 98.0,0.061875886491074734 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,636.87,1.44,-17.87,0.084,temp: 173.0,-0.012908695401899867 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,577.39,2.24,-15.18,0.124,temp: 248.0,-0.036165043407683485 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,538.79,2.56,-13.507,0.135,temp: 298.0,0.07078469894833354 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,698.96,0.05,-20.944,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.19514702662565478 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,636.83,0.09,-17.879,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.019188601273082816 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,577.22,0.13,-15.178,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.06559723298945075 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,538.37,0.17,-13.51,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.00722292846411696 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,699.09,0.08,-20.944,0.001,temp: 98.0,-0.1765842606783356 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,636.68,0.1,-17.878,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.042738248290054584 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,577.26,0.19,-15.182,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.0586720119113925 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,538.78,0.06,-13.522,0.003,temp: 298.0,0.06892737448613385 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,700.41,0.76,-20.965,0.034,temp: 98.0,0.011899208940595042 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,636.96,1.03,-17.875,0.04,temp: 173.0,0.0012210928082796244 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,577.47,1.37,-15.176,0.056,temp: 248.0,-0.02231460125154729 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,538.31,1.81,-13.506,0.063,temp: 298.0,-0.01836687523733624 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,701.19,1.08,-20.982,0.038,temp: 98.0,0.12327580462452634 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,636.92,1.31,-17.873,0.041,temp: 173.0,-0.005058813062921176 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,577.88,1.9,-15.174,0.054,temp: 248.0,0.048668914798608874 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,538.05,2.27,-13.495,0.066,temp: 298.0,-0.06665731125457053 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,700.59,0.13,-20.961,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.037601500252277736 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,636.63,0.17,-17.858,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.05058813062903327 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,577.83,0.2,-15.171,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.04001238845103606 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,537.84,0.26,-13.49,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.10566112496078522 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,700.91,0.08,-20.97,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.08329446258413283 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,637.1,0.08,-17.867,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.023200763357437804 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,577.74,0.13,-15.171,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.024430641025385297 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,538.45,0.16,-13.493,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.007635667233501709 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,700.5,1.0,,,temp: 98.0,0.02475035459643639 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,637.2,1.5,,,temp: 173.0,0.03890052803541303 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,577.9,1.9,,,temp: 248.0,0.052131525337638006 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,538.6,2.2,,,temp: 298.0,0.03549553416651824 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,700.53,0.38,-20.966,0.017,temp: 98.0,0.02903406981504476 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,637.38,0.3,-17.881,0.012,temp: 173.0,0.06716010445575417 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,577.7,0.34,-15.176,0.012,temp: 248.0,0.017505419947327044 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,538.49,0.36,-13.504,0.014,temp: 298.0,0.015064965082300485 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..36d60e31 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,686.72,1.08,-20.678,0.073,temp: 98.0,-0.016015607937936212 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,,,,,temp: 173.0, +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,539.59,2.49,-14.142,0.121,temp: 248.0,-0.10901738313027194 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,482.48,3.35,-11.957,0.142,temp: 298.0,0.1312078733947854 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,684.91,0.08,-20.643,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.2795451567345902 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,614.12,0.1,-17.301,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.14532195418394378 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,539.42,0.23,-14.139,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.14048843901506433 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,481.18,0.36,-11.946,0.01,temp: 298.0,-0.13858687506196793 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,685.21,0.2,-20.653,0.005,temp: 98.0,-0.2358662259948048 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,614.43,0.23,-17.311,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.09491657706840037 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,539.76,0.26,-14.157,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.0775463272455006 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,480.98,0.2,-11.937,0.003,temp: 298.0,-0.18009375943992728 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,687.23,0.73,-20.703,0.036,temp: 98.0,0.058238574319680776 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,615.15,1.21,-17.32,0.048,temp: 173.0,0.02215397623224167 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,540.55,2.04,-14.17,0.076,temp: 248.0,0.06870152068964172 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,482.2,3.37,-11.954,0.105,temp: 298.0,0.0730982352656329 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,688.04,1.71,-20.705,0.049,temp: 98.0,0.17617168731706664 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,615.13,1.49,-17.312,0.051,temp: 173.0,0.018902016418338028 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,540.63,2.85,-14.153,0.086,temp: 248.0,0.08351142934130995 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,481.8,4.14,-11.944,0.111,temp: 298.0,-0.009915533490285762 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,687.42,0.09,-20.68,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.08590189712152997 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,615.12,0.27,-17.3,0.005,temp: 173.0,0.017276036511386206 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,540.31,0.3,-14.141,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.024271794734658046 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,481.25,0.45,-11.913,0.009,temp: 298.0,-0.12405946552968276 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,686.84,0.08,-20.678,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.0014559643579746394 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,615.02,0.1,-17.304,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.0010162374418495094 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,539.94,0.19,-14.134,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.04422403277925232 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,481.43,0.28,-11.931,0.007,temp: 298.0,-0.08670326958951584 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,687.5,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,0.09754961198547606 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,615.5,1.5,,,temp: 173.0,0.07906327297561086 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,540.8,2.2,,,temp: 248.0,0.11498248522608129 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,483.2,2.5,,,temp: 298.0,0.2806326571554414 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,687.6,0.47,-20.7,0.02,temp: 98.0,0.11210925556540453 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,615.64,0.28,-17.321,0.011,temp: 173.0,0.10182699167295484 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,540.61,0.56,-14.156,0.019,temp: 248.0,0.07980895217839817 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,482.11,0.52,-11.944,0.015,temp: 298.0,0.05442013729555533 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5db4df54 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,710.05,0.93,-21.146,0.069,temp: 98.0,0.07172084618069652 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,650.92,1.17,-18.201,0.083,temp: 173.0,0.00034139829915918503 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,597.74,1.88,-15.702,0.125,temp: 248.0,-0.06241849370799316 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,564.47,2.28,-14.194,0.14,temp: 298.0,-0.05764130973645769 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,708.65,0.05,-21.119,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.1255897786832577 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,650.76,0.08,-18.2,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.02423927923990043 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,597.85,0.11,-15.703,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.0440273303833144 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,564.93,0.14,-14.198,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.023804090368974844 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,708.7,0.18,-21.13,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.11854297065239248 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,650.6,0.23,-18.2,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.04881995677896004 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,598.26,0.27,-15.714,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.024521551099565348 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,564.67,0.0,-14.206,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.022230266212362713 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,709.7,0.72,-21.154,0.034,temp: 98.0,0.02239318996471998 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,650.94,0.87,-18.204,0.039,temp: 173.0,0.003413982991556919 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,598.0,1.2,-15.7,0.046,temp: 248.0,-0.01894847130421391 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,564.58,1.51,-14.192,0.056,temp: 298.0,-0.0381652357981964 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,710.03,0.95,-21.147,0.033,temp: 98.0,0.06890212296835684 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,650.96,1.23,-18.202,0.041,temp: 173.0,0.006486567683937187 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,598.19,1.41,-15.705,0.044,temp: 248.0,0.012818083529327323 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,565.1,1.61,-14.188,0.054,temp: 298.0,0.05390347736447872 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,709.5,0.15,-21.123,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.005794042158708925 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,650.66,0.16,-18.186,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.03960220270181924 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,598.25,0.17,-15.691,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.022849627160959916 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,564.83,0.2,-14.174,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.00609856860693742 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,709.66,0.06,-21.136,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.016755743540024584 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,650.93,0.08,-18.195,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.0018776906453493193 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,597.99,0.1,-15.691,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.02062039524281934 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,564.82,0.14,-14.188,0.003,temp: 298.0,0.0043280164307336775 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,709.7,1.0,,,temp: 98.0,0.02239318996471998 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,651.0,1.4,,,temp: 173.0,0.012631737068697723 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,598.3,1.7,,,temp: 248.0,0.03120924685398708 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,564.9,1.8,,,temp: 298.0,0.018492433840363615 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,709.88,0.53,-21.142,0.025,temp: 98.0,0.04776169887579317 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,651.49,0.32,-18.214,0.014,temp: 173.0,0.08791006203208417 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,598.44,0.24,-15.708,0.01,temp: 248.0,0.05461618199450115 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,564.86,0.28,-14.195,0.011,temp: 298.0,0.011410225135548646 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..8d13126e --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,769.75,1.11,-27.164,0.087,temp: 98.0,-0.08278659087992593 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,710.15,1.69,-22.914,0.131,temp: 173.0,-0.026904132130574843 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,654.46,1.9,-19.12,0.162,temp: 248.0,-0.07718811336981712 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,618.97,2.19,-16.766,0.18,temp: 298.0,0.042202579565342006 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,776.23,0.08,-27.368,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.7583482488616783 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,711.96,0.08,-22.951,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.22790302624561268 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,656.46,0.13,-19.148,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.2281714560053324 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,619.02,0.19,-16.765,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.050283924588483214 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,774.57,0.16,-27.319,0.005,temp: 98.0,0.5428723485575067 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,712.62,0.18,-22.979,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.3208161337197951 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,656.0,0.16,-19.165,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.15793875504904245 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,619.79,0.33,-16.795,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.17473663794496816 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,768.62,1.43,-27.136,0.051,temp: 98.0,-0.22946596879782816 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,709.49,1.1,-22.898,0.046,temp: 173.0,-0.11981723960475725 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,654.99,1.82,-19.13,0.066,temp: 248.0,0.003732172514593338 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,619.07,2.38,-16.756,0.073,temp: 298.0,0.05836526961164281 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,768.63,1.37,-27.139,0.055,temp: 98.0,-0.2281679212056355 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,709.29,1.51,-22.902,0.052,temp: 173.0,-0.14797272671815362 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,654.33,1.82,-19.123,0.069,temp: 248.0,-0.09703648537920113 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,618.26,1.97,-16.75,0.065,temp: 298.0,-0.07255251976337349 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,769.7,0.2,-27.162,0.007,temp: 98.0,-0.0892768288408892 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,709.76,0.3,-22.902,0.006,temp: 173.0,-0.08180733200168336 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,654.02,0.28,-19.111,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.14436721863235835 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,617.9,0.29,-16.735,0.005,temp: 298.0,-0.13073820393004534 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,767.19,0.09,-27.091,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.41508677448153936 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,709.78,0.11,-22.904,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.07899178329034692 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,654.61,0.15,-19.118,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.054286145666684375 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,618.36,0.15,-16.749,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.05638982971707268 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,769.5,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,-0.1152377806847717 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,710.0,1.8,,,temp: 173.0,-0.04802074746561412 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,655.2,2.2,,,temp: 248.0,0.035794927298989594 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,618.6,2.4,,,temp: 298.0,-0.017599373605958105 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,769.3,0.64,-26.866,0.025,temp: 98.0,-0.1411987325286542 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,710.02,0.31,-22.917,0.017,temp: 173.0,-0.04520519875427768 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,654.62,0.34,-19.127,0.014,temp: 248.0,-0.05275934781981002 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,618.41,0.52,-16.747,0.022,temp: 298.0,-0.04830848469393147 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..04c169eb --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,754.74,0.82,-26.779,0.086,temp: 98.0,-0.49396605521519465 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,690.0,1.84,-22.318,0.128,temp: 173.0,-0.376196167451403 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,625.09,2.38,-18.174,0.158,temp: 248.0,-0.33129536487666855 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,580.42,2.9,-15.471,0.181,temp: 298.0,-0.12885908093268642 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,765.06,0.06,-27.09,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.8666379545234872 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,694.1,0.1,-22.405,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.21577136256809198 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,628.39,0.18,-18.233,0.005,temp: 248.0,0.1948796263980318 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,582.26,0.28,-15.506,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.1877442395784728 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,764.52,0.31,-27.081,0.01,temp: 98.0,0.7954435586650722 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,695.59,0.33,-22.458,0.007,temp: 173.0,0.4309010259166402 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,628.68,0.38,-18.257,0.007,temp: 248.0,0.24111924684337907 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,582.74,0.33,-15.524,0.008,temp: 298.0,0.27033641014660303 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,756.28,1.71,-26.819,0.064,temp: 98.0,-0.29093018554489103 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,692.38,1.49,-22.371,0.054,temp: 173.0,-0.03256623539130848 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,626.92,2.73,-18.209,0.084,temp: 248.0,-0.039507415169796854 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,580.91,3.28,-15.468,0.1,temp: 298.0,-0.04454624014438848 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,756.68,1.52,-26.841,0.055,temp: 98.0,-0.23819359602013862 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,692.18,1.63,-22.367,0.059,temp: 173.0,-0.061442700270314635 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,627.46,2.57,-18.219,0.083,temp: 248.0,0.04659394703880399 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,580.49,2.96,-15.463,0.092,temp: 298.0,-0.11681438939149262 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,757.29,0.13,-26.845,0.005,temp: 98.0,-0.15777029699488476 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,692.16,0.22,-22.356,0.006,temp: 173.0,-0.06433034675821196 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,626.9,0.31,-18.19,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.04269635451085278 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,580.48,0.38,-15.447,0.008,temp: 298.0,-0.11853505961166037 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,756.9,0.1,-26.843,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.20918847178151953 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,691.94,0.11,-22.354,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.09609445812509904 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,627.22,0.19,-18.205,0.005,temp: 248.0,0.008326674946096535 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,582.2,0.22,-15.488,0.006,temp: 298.0,0.17742021825746632 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,757.1,1.0,,,temp: 98.0,-0.1828201770191358 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,692.9,1.8,,,temp: 173.0,0.04251257329408784 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,627.2,2.8,,,temp: 248.0,0.005137735605040602 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,580.4,2.8,,,temp: 298.0,-0.13230042137302192 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,757.81,0.45,-26.866,0.025,temp: 98.0,-0.0892127306127051 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,692.2,0.41,-22.365,0.019,temp: 173.0,-0.05855505378240088 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,626.65,0.46,-18.19,0.019,temp: 248.0,-0.08255809627408821 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,580.62,0.49,-15.463,0.019,temp: 298.0,-0.09444567652929232 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..067703bf --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,777.87,1.07,-27.353,0.092,temp: 98.0,-0.0826361355404014 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,722.27,1.6,-23.258,0.129,temp: 173.0,-0.02076354475237271 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,671.43,1.83,-19.65,0.161,temp: 248.0,-0.006288007280850461 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,640.28,2.21,-17.445,0.182,temp: 298.0,0.07328551829532279 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,783.11,0.06,-27.498,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.5904416109336486 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,724.06,0.12,-23.29,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.22701475595911969 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,673.08,0.12,-19.676,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.23944069829976958 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,639.83,0.13,-17.437,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.0029522602156918957 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,782.2,0.33,-27.481,0.007,temp: 98.0,0.4735521549620144 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,723.9,0.27,-23.301,0.006,temp: 173.0,0.20486697488994 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,672.66,0.23,-19.682,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.17689157324287708 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,640.28,0.27,-17.454,0.006,temp: 298.0,0.07328551829532279 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,777.29,1.22,-27.339,0.048,temp: 98.0,-0.1571371074783739 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,721.72,1.17,-23.243,0.043,temp: 173.0,-0.09689654217768685 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,671.61,1.62,-19.652,0.054,temp: 248.0,0.02051876060067973 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,640.07,2.24,-17.434,0.064,temp: 298.0,0.040463331191502146 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,777.19,1.23,-27.333,0.048,temp: 98.0,-0.16998210264008068 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,722.28,1.3,-23.257,0.046,temp: 173.0,-0.01937930843554996 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,671.08,1.58,-19.651,0.055,temp: 248.0,-0.05841227816157162 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,639.3,1.99,-17.43,0.057,temp: 298.0,-0.07988468818923278 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,777.39,0.1,-27.333,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.14429211231665248 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,721.97,0.26,-23.245,0.006,temp: 173.0,-0.062290634257086655 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,670.78,0.25,-19.638,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.10309022463078296 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,639.09,0.3,-17.409,0.005,temp: 298.0,-0.11270687529305343 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,776.6,0.06,-27.317,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.24576757409422384 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,721.68,0.1,-23.239,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.10243348744499359 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,671.38,0.12,-19.646,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.013734331692377219 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,639.73,0.15,-17.42,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.012677352690898671 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,777.3,1.1,,,temp: 98.0,-0.1558526079622032 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,721.8,1.6,,,temp: 173.0,-0.08582265164310486 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,671.6,2.2,,,temp: 248.0,0.019029495718374374 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,640.0,2.0,,,temp: 298.0,0.02952260215688342 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,777.67,0.38,-27.347,0.021,temp: 98.0,-0.10832612586384421 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,722.1,0.42,-23.26,0.02,temp: 173.0,-0.04429556213837518 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,669.63,0.84,-19.586,0.291,temp: 248.0,-0.27435568609605077 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,639.72,0.32,-17.431,0.013,temp: 298.0,-0.01424031398155595 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..45731bc8 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,765.5,1.02,-26.539,0.086,temp: 98.0,0.3701247859981984 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,705.61,1.49,-22.549,0.136,temp: 173.0,0.07597983596460639 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,652.16,1.96,-18.304,0.18,temp: 248.0,0.08616172533920213 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,617.27,2.12,-15.708,0.205,temp: 298.0,0.11283543635108545 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,761.35,0.06,-27.21,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.1740110962511683 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,705.08,0.09,-22.547,0.005,temp: 173.0,0.0008104515836331746 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,651.89,0.11,-18.363,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.0447251704050759 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,617.05,0.15,-15.724,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.07715441541049226 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,761.28,0.19,-27.306,0.011,temp: 98.0,-0.1831892918553811 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,704.56,0.1,-22.556,0.018,temp: 173.0,-0.07294064252601827 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,651.76,0.04,-18.299,0.008,temp: 248.0,0.02477423654790336 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,616.8,0.11,-15.719,0.015,temp: 298.0,0.03660780070527772 +12,ms2(KL),98.0,762.67,0.1,-27.347,0.006,temp: 98.0,-0.0009365505718590569 +13,ms2(KL),173.0,706.25,0.13,-22.325,0.024,temp: 173.0,0.16675041333031262 +14,ms2(KL),248.0,652.14,0.17,-18.306,0.009,temp: 248.0,0.08309235089963982 +15,ms2(KL),298.0,616.95,0.18,-15.685,0.009,temp: 298.0,0.06093576952842119 +16,ms2(PB),98.0,763.13,0.08,-27.372,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.05937730625578669 +17,ms2(PB),173.0,704.96,0.09,-22.647,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.016209031672437754 +18,ms2(PB),248.0,652.13,0.14,-18.323,0.007,temp: 248.0,0.08155766367985864 +19,ms2(PB),298.0,616.67,0.16,-15.66,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.015523561058566901 +20,Tinker(AA),98.0,762.5,1.1,,,temp: 98.0,-0.023226454182068836 +21,Tinker(AA),173.0,703.4,1.6,,,temp: 173.0,-0.2374623140013598 +22,Tinker(AA),248.0,648.9,1.8,,,temp: 248.0,-0.41414630830990995 +23,Tinker(AA),298.0,613.9,2.1,,,temp: 298.0,-0.4337329298752072 +24,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,762.31,0.34,-27.187,0.01,temp: 98.0,-0.04813869939349292 +25,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,705.66,0.42,-22.584,0.031,temp: 173.0,0.08307128732129589 +26,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,652.21,0.45,-18.316,0.024,temp: 248.0,0.09383516143812538 +27,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,617.38,0.35,-15.697,0.014,temp: 298.0,0.13067594682138206 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..552b0957 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,753.48,1.15,-26.246,0.088,temp: 98.0,0.09545805633733052 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,687.41,1.61,-22.064,0.134,temp: 173.0,0.047197272122416714 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,624.43,2.28,-17.399,0.175,temp: 248.0,0.0757835931955047 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,579.14,3.03,-14.426,0.208,temp: 298.0,0.047136401888430775 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,749.93,0.06,-26.919,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.3761389019097422 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,686.63,0.1,-22.057,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.06632568196939567 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,624.24,0.15,-17.408,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.04533278384505513 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,578.71,0.26,-14.447,0.009,temp: 298.0,-0.02714661888859554 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,749.6,0.08,-27.019,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.4199774923946708 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,686.72,0.15,-22.021,0.006,temp: 173.0,-0.05322687957418147 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,624.24,0.11,-17.421,0.008,temp: 248.0,0.04533278384505513 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,579.4,0.19,-14.445,0.009,temp: 298.0,0.09205171677686895 +12,ms2(KL),98.0,762.18,0.07,-23.551,0.005,temp: 98.0,1.2512027145766043 +13,ms2(KL),173.0,688.11,0.18,-21.8,0.029,temp: 173.0,0.14907684630738674 +14,ms2(KL),248.0,624.55,0.19,-17.394,0.008,temp: 248.0,0.09501568331158484 +15,ms2(KL),298.0,579.47,0.23,-14.411,0.012,temp: 298.0,0.10414430155453445 +16,ms2(PB),98.0,751.24,0.07,-27.05,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.20211298210588832 +17,ms2(PB),173.0,687.12,0.11,-22.12,0.005,temp: 173.0,0.004990019960080029 +18,ms2(PB),248.0,624.24,0.16,-17.454,0.008,temp: 248.0,0.04533278384505513 +19,ms2(PB),298.0,579.56,0.2,-14.416,0.008,temp: 298.0,0.11969191055436483 +20,Tinker(AA),98.0,751.1,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,-0.22071117200858759 +21,Tinker(AA),173.0,685.9,1.7,,,temp: 173.0,-0.1725715236194316 +22,Tinker(AA),248.0,621.0,2.2,,,temp: 248.0,-0.4739336492890902 +23,Tinker(AA),298.0,576.3,2.4,,,temp: 298.0,-0.44347703766222424 +24,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,751.8,0.6,-26.993,0.037,temp: 98.0,-0.12772022249509116 +25,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,687.71,0.35,-22.054,0.025,temp: 173.0,0.09085994677312524 +26,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,625.0,0.29,-17.438,0.016,temp: 248.0,0.1671360212468899 +27,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,579.49,0.51,-14.425,0.02,temp: 298.0,0.10759932577671896 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..836c2080 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLS n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,773.75,0.99,-26.728,0.086,temp: 98.0,0.13810877868947308 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,717.44,1.56,-22.965,0.134,temp: 173.0,0.052794839254665014 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,669.19,1.76,-18.789,0.184,temp: 248.0,0.0743454714421554 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,638.6,2.05,-16.361,0.202,temp: 298.0,0.12475837863384596 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,770.17,0.06,-27.405,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.32521197016702114 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,717.03,0.09,-22.857,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.004382967787181831 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,669.04,0.11,-18.85,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.05191364816218198 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,638.14,0.13,-16.346,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.05263594071625247 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,769.98,0.16,-27.515,0.009,temp: 98.0,-0.3498016188493411 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,716.63,0.06,-22.932,0.016,temp: 173.0,-0.06016619416945713 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,668.81,0.09,-18.82,0.011,temp: 248.0,0.017518185799574176 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,637.8,0.12,-16.382,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.0006719481793608897 +12,ms2(KL),98.0,781.89,0.11,-23.977,0.006,temp: 98.0,1.1915810959218234 +13,ms2(KL),173.0,717.9,0.18,-22.673,0.022,temp: 173.0,0.11694554959427446 +14,ms2(KL),248.0,669.2,0.13,-18.816,0.009,temp: 248.0,0.07584092632748471 +15,ms2(KL),298.0,638.05,0.15,-16.351,0.012,temp: 298.0,0.03852502894976291 +16,ms2(PB),98.0,770.68,0.05,-27.492,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.2592081763355113 +17,ms2(PB),173.0,717.01,0.09,-23.014,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.007172129106293218 +18,ms2(PB),248.0,669.12,0.1,-18.853,0.005,temp: 248.0,0.06387728724483334 +19,ms2(PB),298.0,638.34,0.13,-16.314,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.08399352241955864 +20,Tinker(AA),98.0,771.4,1.0,,,temp: 98.0,-0.1660263497498452 +21,Tinker(AA),173.0,715.7,1.5,,,temp: 173.0,-0.1898621955082476 +22,Tinker(AA),248.0,666.3,1.9,,,temp: 248.0,-0.35784099041841905 +23,Tinker(AA),298.0,635.3,2.0,,,temp: 298.0,-0.3926417194705989 +24,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,770.91,0.74,-27.394,0.045,temp: 98.0,-0.2294417595095334 +25,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,717.72,0.76,-22.915,0.041,temp: 173.0,0.09184309772225614 +26,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,669.19,0.3,-18.828,0.015,temp: 248.0,0.0743454714421554 +27,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,638.4,0.35,-16.35,0.022,temp: 298.0,0.0934007969305398 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..974fc5c6 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,,,,,temp: 173.0, +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,530.89,0.47,-11.366,0.166,temp: 248.0,2.3879397631024886 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,486.69,6.41,-9.826,0.192,temp: 298.0,3.19846906049721 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,663.92,0.09,-16.498,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.9955567110534355 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,597.04,0.11,-13.81,0.002,temp: 173.0,2.008977804010499 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,529.0,0.14,-11.352,0.003,temp: 248.0,2.0234326031404204 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,481.76,0.2,-9.791,0.004,temp: 298.0,2.1531045523539323 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,657.37,1.5,-16.409,0.019,temp: 98.0,-0.0008297458350381748 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,593.43,2.9,-13.776,0.029,temp: 173.0,1.3921809229431008 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,533.52,4.7,-11.398,0.036,temp: 248.0,2.8951640121502367 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,489.68,5.5,-9.846,0.034,temp: 298.0,3.832473092819402 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,663.88,0.07,-16.487,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.9894719082632824 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,595.02,0.1,-13.771,0.004,temp: 173.0,1.6638449231916268 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,527.92,0.12,-11.33,0.004,temp: 248.0,1.8151427974478007 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,482.02,0.13,-9.775,0.004,temp: 298.0,2.2082353377732513 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,647.39,0.8,-16.265,0.029,temp: 98.0,-1.5189880419796267 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,572.69,1.16,-13.569,0.037,temp: 173.0,-2.151411130613055 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,505.81,2.04,-11.181,0.056,temp: 248.0,-2.4490123913148274 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,463.26,2.82,-9.678,0.06,temp: 298.0,-1.7696628717131297 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,645.9,1.66,-16.252,0.059,temp: 98.0,-1.7456469459130382 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,568.18,3.13,-13.537,0.096,temp: 173.0,-2.9219800872928388 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,495.51,5.14,-11.125,0.135,temp: 248.0,-4.435479982642517 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,447.63,6.63,-9.594,0.159,temp: 298.0,-5.083871241343841 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,647.88,0.18,-16.234,0.003,temp: 98.0,-1.4444492078001816 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,577.42,0.22,-13.535,0.003,temp: 173.0,-1.3432534443391704 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,509.66,0.39,-11.138,0.005,temp: 248.0,-1.7064978062069014 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,460.38,0.56,-9.617,0.005,temp: 298.0,-2.380342340973298 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,664.27,0.08,-16.507,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.0487987354673272 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,595.41,0.09,-13.79,0.003,temp: 173.0,1.730479489290318 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,528.03,0.09,-11.344,0.003,temp: 248.0,1.8363574998794583 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,482.1,0.12,-9.788,0.003,temp: 298.0,2.22519865636382 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,650.41,0.05,-16.291,0.002,temp: 98.0,-1.0595854313226505 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,591.39,0.07,-13.728,0.002,temp: 173.0,1.0436308848884013 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,526.25,0.12,-11.303,0.004,temp: 248.0,1.4930650423490475 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,473.44,0.17,-9.706,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.3889194189356657 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,647.95,3.14,-16.27,0.084,temp: 98.0,-1.4338008029173965 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,571.53,4.72,-13.558,0.13,temp: 173.0,-2.349606250291235 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,498.61,6.68,-11.133,0.176,temp: 248.0,-3.8376110959322376 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,452.69,7.93,-9.61,0.198,temp: 298.0,-4.010941340490904 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,654.1,0.9,,,temp: 98.0,-0.4982623739305058 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,580.9,0.8,,,temp: 173.0,-0.7486680853046696 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,508.9,1.2,,,temp: 248.0,-1.8530721139165263 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,457.5,6.2,,,temp: 298.0,-2.991021810233467 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,688.06,0.79,-17.543,0.034,temp: 98.0,4.667735194914185 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,595.09,0.31,-13.786,0.01,temp: 173.0,1.6758049735170417 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,528.0,0.6,-11.343,0.017,temp: 248.0,1.8305716719435576 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,482.12,0.61,-9.789,0.018,temp: 298.0,2.229439486011456 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..344226e0 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,,,,,temp: 173.0, +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,492.13,7.15,-10.439,0.198,temp: 248.0,4.969818484312014 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,418.9,10.13,-8.216,0.263,temp: 298.0,29.599455490471065 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,652.5,0.14,-16.298,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.378836929439482 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,580.91,0.18,-13.409,0.003,temp: 173.0,3.4305211821814665 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,483.17,0.27,-10.327,0.006,temp: 248.0,3.0586779856237936 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,402.0,0.43,-7.968,0.01,temp: 298.0,24.370926491213588 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,645.03,1.9,-16.185,0.029,temp: 98.0,0.21822403769555 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,570.61,3.8,-13.282,0.049,temp: 173.0,1.5966151241406954 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,483.35,6.3,-10.33,0.081,temp: 248.0,3.0970714331420854 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,375.37,12.0,-7.538,0.2,temp: 298.0,16.13212606220608 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,650.48,0.08,-16.246,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.0649898020870439 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,572.09,0.12,-13.278,0.004,temp: 173.0,1.8601278392766554 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,483.25,0.18,-10.311,0.005,temp: 248.0,3.075741740076364 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,399.5,0.4,-7.91,0.009,temp: 298.0,23.59747545582047 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,632.39,0.99,-15.982,0.035,temp: 98.0,-1.7456510562325938 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,545.3,1.75,-12.958,0.05,temp: 173.0,-2.909808402947871 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,446.51,3.94,-9.842,0.095,temp: 248.0,-4.760787492267985 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,203.17,64.19,-4.212,1.382,temp: 298.0,-37.14318125567198 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,631.46,1.88,-15.981,0.065,temp: 98.0,-1.8901450307067296 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,540.69,4.05,-12.905,0.118,temp: 173.0,-3.7306149007699885 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,433.13,8.6,-9.662,0.21,temp: 248.0,-7.61470042446089 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,97.84,8.56,-1.938,0.246,temp: 298.0,-69.73022027885489 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,634.34,0.18,-15.96,0.003,temp: 98.0,-1.4426798194319628 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,552.65,0.31,-12.93,0.004,temp: 173.0,-1.601147283860515 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,456.0,0.79,-9.774,0.006,temp: 248.0,-2.73659962033146 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,306.62,2.51,-5.708,0.177,temp: 298.0,-5.137777411104699 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,651.19,0.08,-16.277,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.1753024062554818 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,572.29,0.12,-13.294,0.004,temp: 173.0,1.895737665646367 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,483.49,0.14,-10.325,0.003,temp: 248.0,3.126933003434086 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,399.15,0.37,-7.913,0.008,temp: 298.0,23.489192310865427 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,636.17,0.06,-16.028,0.002,temp: 98.0,-1.1583529664344656 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,570.16,0.09,-13.244,0.003,temp: 173.0,1.5164930148088085 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,478.43,0.2,-10.232,0.005,temp: 248.0,2.0476505343088163 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,369.21,0.75,-7.419,0.016,temp: 298.0,14.226342710997427 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,634.27,3.29,-16.007,0.089,temp: 98.0,-1.453555709983788 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,544.42,5.47,-12.939,0.149,temp: 173.0,-3.0664916389746555 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,440.08,8.96,-9.743,0.226,temp: 248.0,-6.132286756393576 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,121.17,15.07,-2.429,0.403,temp: 298.0,-62.512375216566284 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,640.5,0.8,,,temp: 98.0,-0.48560145087204865 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,556.8,1.0,,,temp: 173.0,-0.8622433866887484 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,463.2,2.9,,,temp: 248.0,-1.2008617195998539 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,387.1,10.9,,,temp: 298.0,19.761158320270603 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,671.55,1.26,-17.108,0.049,temp: 98.0,4.33863285818403 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,572.15,0.59,-13.293,0.018,temp: 173.0,1.8708107871875628 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,483.22,0.9,-10.321,0.024,temp: 248.0,3.0693428321566545 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,398.69,0.11,-7.901,0.026,temp: 298.0,23.346877320353094 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..8f815da0 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,,,,,temp: 173.0, +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,561.46,6.51,-11.885,0.162,temp: 248.0,3.294371604135743 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,515.77,5.8,-10.469,0.179,temp: 298.0,2.1338530313056374 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,671.11,0.08,-16.616,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.9955619035110774 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,610.99,0.12,-14.09,0.002,temp: 173.0,1.7231619605754094 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,550.6,0.13,-11.838,0.003,temp: 248.0,1.2964075895649534 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,513.62,0.15,-10.468,0.003,temp: 298.0,1.7081055391728945 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,668.03,1.6,-16.572,0.021,temp: 98.0,0.5320517030032348 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,608.3,2.8,-14.069,0.023,temp: 173.0,1.2753063399041162 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,556.08,3.7,-11.863,0.018,temp: 248.0,2.3045883261992026 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,520.11,4.3,-10.489,0.011,temp: 298.0,2.9932688991457015 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,672.79,0.07,-16.618,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.248385649242617 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,609.86,0.09,-14.065,0.003,temp: 173.0,1.5350293020778074 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,550.78,0.1,-11.82,0.004,temp: 248.0,1.3295230152208137 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,512.9,0.11,-10.449,0.004,temp: 298.0,1.5655296348307597 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,657.12,0.8,-16.429,0.03,temp: 98.0,-1.1097977410034148 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,589.89,1.18,-13.923,0.038,temp: 173.0,-1.7897575919019526 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,533.82,1.68,-11.764,0.04,temp: 248.0,-1.7906859799099777 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,498.09,2.42,-10.425,0.053,temp: 298.0,-1.367177508651096 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,656.11,1.47,-16.423,0.053,temp: 98.0,-1.2617929690920222 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,584.92,2.72,-13.889,0.087,temp: 173.0,-2.6172083111347755 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,524.01,4.27,-11.733,0.114,temp: 248.0,-3.5954766781548706 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,484.85,5.22,-10.42,0.13,temp: 298.0,-3.988989971831354 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,657.89,0.13,-16.4,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.9939201908764584 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,593.59,0.23,-13.882,0.003,temp: 173.0,-1.1737480021310338 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,533.77,0.34,-11.725,0.003,temp: 248.0,-1.7998847092588428 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,496.04,0.41,-10.406,0.003,temp: 298.0,-1.7731227918474275 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,673.12,0.07,-16.638,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.2980474564398914 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,609.79,0.09,-14.071,0.003,temp: 173.0,1.5233750665956467 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,550.9,0.08,-11.833,0.002,temp: 248.0,1.3515999656580608 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,512.87,0.09,-10.46,0.002,temp: 298.0,1.5595889721498433 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,660.23,0.06,-16.453,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.6417728307503702 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,605.42,0.06,-14.013,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.795817794352705 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,548.55,0.1,-11.79,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.919259686261984 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,509.12,0.12,-10.417,0.003,temp: 298.0,0.8170061370345861 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,657.47,2.98,-16.429,0.079,temp: 98.0,-1.057126127309339 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,588.15,4.47,-13.901,0.125,temp: 173.0,-2.079448588172599 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,527.34,5.91,-11.736,0.157,temp: 248.0,-2.9828413035212793 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,489.01,6.53,-10.418,0.172,temp: 298.0,-3.1652180800768357 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,663.2,0.9,,,temp: 98.0,-0.1948165659749523 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,596.4,1.0,,,temp: 173.0,-0.7059136920617836 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,534.6,1.1,,,temp: 248.0,-1.6471858020678818 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,494.7,1.2,,,temp: 298.0,-2.0384723915952856 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,672.37,0.61,-16.614,0.024,temp: 98.0,1.1851797128097363 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,609.73,0.52,-14.073,0.017,temp: 173.0,1.513385721896668 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,550.73,0.41,-11.829,0.012,temp: 248.0,1.3203242858719695 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,512.85,0.54,-10.461,0.016,temp: 298.0,1.5556285303625654 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b9a3b41a --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,,,,,temp: 173.0, +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,584.6,4.85,-13.384,0.201,temp: 248.0,1.13443215680508 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,545.74,5.77,-11.289,0.233,temp: 298.0,1.3148429196660394 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,702.5,0.11,-20.337,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.7352270208966116 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,646.72,0.11,-16.74,0.003,temp: 173.0,1.7770408214360944 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,590.46,0.13,-13.427,0.004,temp: 248.0,2.148198445616026 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,546.13,0.18,-11.306,0.005,temp: 298.0,1.387245141857318 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,701.19,1.9,-20.313,0.032,temp: 98.0,0.5473791242455525 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,646.15,3.0,-16.739,0.035,temp: 173.0,1.6873375290248134 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,596.03,2.4,-13.473,0.018,temp: 248.0,3.1117954129670315 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,553.88,2.9,-11.347,0.016,temp: 298.0,2.826007249504571 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,707.99,0.08,-20.384,0.004,temp: 98.0,1.522467442739634 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,644.97,0.09,-16.689,0.004,temp: 173.0,1.5016359763137648 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,585.1,0.11,-13.353,0.004,temp: 248.0,1.2209309869084028 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,545.75,0.13,-11.26,0.004,temp: 298.0,1.3166993869017116 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,688.26,1.02,-20.094,0.034,temp: 98.0,-1.3067226343027742 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,624.9,1.67,-16.503,0.048,temp: 173.0,-1.6568641617463347 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,572.11,3.18,-13.284,0.059,temp: 248.0,-1.0263086191759263 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,535.02,3.58,-11.217,0.066,temp: 298.0,-0.6752899569763593 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,685.47,1.62,-20.054,0.069,temp: 98.0,-1.7067956355672553 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,616.56,3.15,-16.438,0.108,temp: 173.0,-2.9693649665007573 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,557.03,5.43,-13.219,0.145,temp: 248.0,-3.635113335092151 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,517.39,6.37,-11.16,0.173,temp: 298.0,-3.9482416934693996 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,688.23,0.12,-20.085,0.003,temp: 98.0,-1.311024494531421 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,622.13,0.26,-16.468,0.004,temp: 173.0,-2.092790688025677 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,564.23,0.68,-13.237,0.005,temp: 248.0,-2.389530181604294 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,526.91,0.72,-11.169,0.005,temp: 298.0,-2.180884885107874 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,708.45,0.07,-20.437,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.5884292995789453 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,644.97,0.07,-16.715,0.003,temp: 173.0,1.5016359763137648 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,585.39,0.09,-13.391,0.003,temp: 248.0,1.2711003083683237 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,546.11,0.08,-11.295,0.003,temp: 298.0,1.3835322073859737 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,686.66,0.07,-20.071,0.002,temp: 98.0,-1.5361551798307984 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,627.96,0.1,-16.527,0.003,temp: 173.0,-1.1752991182752799 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,575.3,0.13,-13.301,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.4744460831167368 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,538.08,0.19,-11.232,0.005,temp: 298.0,-0.10721098286014263 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,692.29,2.81,-20.152,0.098,temp: 98.0,-0.728839410254076 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,627.14,4.08,-16.527,0.149,temp: 173.0,-1.3043459599897511 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,563.26,5.9,-13.251,0.199,temp: 248.0,-2.5573379120047446 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,527.16,6.67,-11.204,0.228,temp: 298.0,-2.1344732042160275 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,701.9,0.9,,,temp: 98.0,0.6491898163236006 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,643.1,1.2,,,temp: 173.0,1.2073462275259028 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,577.6,1.7,,,temp: 248.0,-0.07655146464143993 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,535.7,2.4,,,temp: 298.0,-0.5490501849505239 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,708.16,0.73,-20.43,0.034,temp: 98.0,1.5468446507019804 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,645.11,0.53,-16.727,0.023,temp: 173.0,1.5236683639235489 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,585.4,0.36,-13.391,0.013,temp: 248.0,1.2728302849703885 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,546.02,0.4,-11.294,0.015,temp: 298.0,1.3668240022649027 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b60aa8be --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,,,,,temp: 173.0, +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,546.27,5.79,-12.362,0.224,temp: 248.0,1.4529448908588993 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,490.88,7.66,-9.787,0.278,temp: 298.0,2.6229965156794455 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,694.22,0.07,-20.146,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.3963134986708818 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,630.01,0.13,-16.267,0.004,temp: 173.0,2.7013128665067225 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,551.35,0.22,-12.427,0.006,temp: 248.0,2.3963995196057963 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,491.53,0.34,-9.792,0.01,temp: 298.0,2.7588850174216013 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,688.64,2.0,-20.038,0.037,temp: 98.0,0.5813104314550315 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,625.23,3.2,-16.203,0.045,temp: 173.0,1.9220994008444323 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,561.02,3.7,-12.554,0.046,temp: 248.0,4.192306263696817 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,500.81,3.8,-9.921,0.053,temp: 298.0,4.698954703832757 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,695.43,0.08,-21.371,0.004,temp: 98.0,1.5730435544649874 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,623.71,0.11,-18.309,0.004,temp: 173.0,1.674316039378601 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,548.79,0.15,-15.45,0.005,temp: 248.0,1.9209578169301875 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,491.09,0.23,-13.461,0.007,temp: 298.0,2.6668989547038313 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,673.8,1.28,-19.764,0.04,temp: 98.0,-1.5861887652265378 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,598.23,1.96,-15.816,0.058,temp: 173.0,-2.4793155725618337 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,524.47,3.19,-12.058,0.079,temp: 248.0,-2.5957383584879796 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,460.87,5.28,-9.335,0.127,temp: 298.0,-3.650871080139368 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,671.23,1.76,-19.721,0.074,temp: 98.0,-1.9615575614173386 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,591.28,3.91,-15.738,0.128,temp: 173.0,-3.6122723897904905 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,509.01,7.37,-11.887,0.201,temp: 248.0,-5.466960516052338 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,441.41,12.51,-9.072,0.3,temp: 298.0,-7.719163763066193 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,673.2,0.21,-19.744,0.004,temp: 98.0,-1.6738235036368305 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,597.6,0.28,-15.803,0.005,temp: 173.0,-2.582015255274646 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,521.15,0.68,-12.014,0.009,temp: 248.0,-3.2123268166454046 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,458.26,1.14,-9.294,0.021,temp: 298.0,-4.196515679442507 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,695.42,0.09,-20.163,0.004,temp: 98.0,1.5715829754914836 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,623.81,0.08,-16.177,0.003,temp: 173.0,1.6906175763171278 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,549.43,0.13,-12.401,0.004,temp: 248.0,2.0398182425990843 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,492.03,0.17,-9.796,0.004,temp: 298.0,2.86341463414634 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,674.86,0.08,-19.782,0.003,temp: 98.0,-1.431367394034989 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,607.34,0.12,-15.932,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.9942455574606802 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,537.14,0.22,-12.224,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.24267336907399345 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,480.4,0.32,-9.612,0.008,temp: 298.0,0.4320557491289191 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,679.28,2.98,-19.854,0.104,temp: 98.0,-0.7857914877457418 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,602.11,4.54,-15.868,0.163,temp: 173.0,-1.8468159393464154 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,525.78,6.59,-12.097,0.226,temp: 248.0,-2.352445924696961 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,457.31,9.67,-9.305,0.293,temp: 298.0,-4.395121951219508 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,689.8,0.9,,,temp: 98.0,0.7507375923816181 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,624.8,1.5,,,temp: 173.0,1.8520027920086926 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,537.7,1.3,,,temp: 248.0,-0.13867049661369546 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,483.9,5.3,,,temp: 298.0,1.1637630662020897 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,695.38,0.64,-20.169,0.03,temp: 98.0,1.5657406595974686 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,623.71,0.61,-16.174,0.025,temp: 173.0,1.674316039378601 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,549.25,0.39,-12.397,0.015,temp: 248.0,2.0063887478797158 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,491.51,0.49,-9.78,0.015,temp: 298.0,2.7547038327526154 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b89a53f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,658.0,3.33,-17.036,0.138,temp: 173.0,1.1739561630776727 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,602.24,4.54,-13.897,0.188,temp: 248.0,0.6310606609149138 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,569.4,5.3,-11.972,0.223,temp: 298.0,0.6472367967523409 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,712.49,0.06,-20.53,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.8137244939305266 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,660.25,0.1,-17.056,0.003,temp: 173.0,1.519915739623151 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,608.58,0.11,-13.924,0.003,temp: 248.0,1.6904405171021541 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,573.08,0.15,-11.971,0.004,temp: 298.0,1.2977141964925147 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,710.06,1.8,-20.49,0.031,temp: 98.0,0.46989180782930756 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,660.15,2.6,-17.062,0.026,temp: 173.0,1.5045397584433484 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,612.98,2.4,-13.943,0.012,temp: 248.0,2.4256568210806733 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,581.04,1.9,-11.992,0.006,temp: 298.0,2.704725093756549 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,716.64,0.09,-21.773,0.004,temp: 98.0,1.4009284640210675 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,658.86,0.09,-19.181,0.004,temp: 173.0,1.3061896012239465 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,605.49,0.1,-16.974,0.004,temp: 248.0,1.1741181581717772 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,571.72,0.1,-15.659,0.004,temp: 298.0,1.0573203748494087 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,698.38,0.93,-20.3,0.034,temp: 98.0,-1.182769004377325 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,639.8,1.56,-16.881,0.039,temp: 173.0,-1.6244724116457592 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,593.45,2.77,-13.844,0.052,temp: 248.0,-0.8377010008967203 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,562.64,3.07,-11.946,0.06,temp: 298.0,-0.5476619049442607 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,696.03,1.46,-20.271,0.065,temp: 98.0,-1.515282095874383 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,633.6,3.25,-16.852,0.101,temp: 173.0,-2.5777832447932894 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,582.02,4.92,-13.844,0.129,temp: 248.0,-2.7475924450954845 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,549.52,6.08,-11.983,0.145,temp: 298.0,-2.8667552431483196 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,697.62,0.14,-20.279,0.003,temp: 98.0,-1.2903051531167966 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,638.45,0.32,-16.865,0.003,temp: 173.0,-1.8320481575730323 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,586.43,0.58,-13.834,0.004,temp: 248.0,-2.0107051949715613 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,555.61,0.69,-11.941,0.004,temp: 298.0,-1.790285850643534 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,717.53,0.07,-20.602,0.004,temp: 98.0,1.5268589539922905 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,658.83,0.06,-17.039,0.002,temp: 173.0,1.301576806870011 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,605.72,0.08,-13.91,0.003,temp: 248.0,1.2125499195161122 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,571.96,0.08,-11.971,0.003,temp: 298.0,1.0997428139628993 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,696.11,0.06,-20.3,0.002,temp: 98.0,-1.5039625012702222 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,638.98,0.1,-16.872,0.003,temp: 173.0,-1.7505554573201016 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,595.18,0.13,-13.854,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.5486273177415442 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,564.81,0.17,-11.941,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.16409235129313934 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,701.16,2.65,-20.334,0.093,temp: 98.0,-0.7894130918829403 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,642.2,4.09,-16.896,0.143,temp: 173.0,-1.2554488633305685 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,588.5,5.09,-13.854,0.186,temp: 248.0,-1.6648193428725662 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,555.18,5.73,-11.961,0.209,temp: 298.0,-1.8662927207218794 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,710.5,0.8,,,temp: 98.0,0.5321495781521681 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,656.2,1.1,,,temp: 173.0,0.897188501841297 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,595.4,1.2,,,temp: 248.0,-0.5118665025426135 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,562.0,2.4,,,temp: 298.0,-0.6607884092468952 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,717.61,0.48,-20.614,0.024,temp: 98.0,1.5381785485964514 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,659.06,0.4,-17.051,0.016,temp: 173.0,1.336941563583534 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,605.57,0.39,-13.904,0.016,temp: 248.0,1.1874857273350299 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,571.9,0.31,-11.973,0.013,temp: 298.0,1.0891372041845166 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..26ded822 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,720.35,3.25,-21.32,0.175,temp: 173.0,-0.002082277734186513 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,666.51,4.21,-16.44,0.235,temp: 248.0,0.20182886265487396 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,626.77,5.03,-13.417,0.282,temp: 298.0,-0.411397307578755 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,783.2,0.06,-26.494,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.8745379374299761 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,721.03,0.13,-21.232,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.09231431288306309 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,665.83,0.18,-16.499,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.09959897319094949 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,630.23,0.22,-13.507,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.13836826083674217 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,782.52,0.47,-26.482,0.014,temp: 98.0,0.7869553457580419 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,723.85,0.27,-21.299,0.007,temp: 173.0,0.48378252691345747 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,666.62,0.28,-16.526,0.005,temp: 248.0,0.21836605065639442 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,630.58,0.37,-13.523,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.1939803848094111 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,777.7,0.1,-26.234,0.006,temp: 98.0,0.1661493283188106 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,720.35,0.08,-21.16,0.005,temp: 173.0,-0.002082277734186513 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,664.65,0.11,-16.42,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.07779995264353032 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,628.35,0.12,-13.418,0.007,temp: 298.0,-0.16034829078785937 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,778.71,1.37,-26.338,0.05,temp: 98.0,0.2962352365374053 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,721.81,1.65,-21.209,0.053,temp: 173.0,0.20059275506167712 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,663.7,1.89,-16.416,0.063,temp: 248.0,-0.2206211217475427 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,629.77,2.43,-13.435,0.076,temp: 298.0,0.06527804075837626 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,771.49,3.73,-26.173,0.118,temp: 98.0,-0.6336858103321646 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,719.09,2.6,-21.195,0.113,temp: 173.0,-0.17699360740733708 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,664.76,2.73,-16.485,0.139,temp: 248.0,-0.06126276464200986 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,629.46,3.49,-13.494,0.169,temp: 298.0,0.01602158809688137 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,772.22,0.65,-26.168,0.016,temp: 98.0,-0.5396633222137712 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,720.54,0.42,-21.186,0.008,temp: 173.0,0.02429324023239167 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,663.77,0.35,-16.415,0.007,temp: 248.0,-0.21009745665567692 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,628.48,0.28,-13.423,0.006,temp: 298.0,-0.1396923590265844 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,780.17,0.07,-26.759,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.4842802127741774 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,721.37,0.08,-21.875,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.13951260819169578 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,666.03,0.08,-17.42,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.12966658773915452 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,630.08,0.1,-14.61,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.11453449341988922 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,772.57,0.25,-26.196,0.007,temp: 98.0,-0.4945840470885122 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,719.9,0.14,-21.183,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.06455060976031848 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,665.22,0.16,-16.455,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.00789274881889079 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,629.1,0.19,-13.443,0.005,temp: 298.0,-0.04117945370357655 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,772.86,2.69,-26.2,0.113,temp: 98.0,-0.45723264769901917 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,719.05,3.5,-21.193,0.171,temp: 173.0,-0.18254634803189232 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,664.34,4.26,-16.474,0.231,temp: 248.0,-0.1244047551932558 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,627.85,5.15,-13.465,0.274,temp: 298.0,-0.23979418217738124 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,769.1,0.6,,,temp: 98.0,-0.9415128604731966 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,716.6,0.9,,,temp: 173.0,-0.5226517112852336 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,665.6,2.9,,,temp: 248.0,0.06502121646049916 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,632.8,2.9,,,temp: 298.0,0.5467201425788745 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,779.97,0.47,-26.4,0.027,temp: 98.0,0.4585206269883257 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,720.44,0.66,-21.212,0.03,temp: 173.0,0.010411388671043036 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,664.98,0.64,-16.48,0.032,temp: 248.0,-0.028188388638968928 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,628.84,0.35,-13.478,0.014,temp: 298.0,-0.08249131722612647 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b4b4cc13 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,703.01,3.62,-20.799,0.173,temp: 173.0,-0.019080961348599896 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,637.54,4.96,-15.543,0.244,temp: 248.0,-0.18435380273751842 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,592.91,6.04,-12.255,0.311,temp: 298.0,-0.0980075541639427 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,772.17,0.07,-26.23,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.9159084590543968 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,704.59,0.15,-20.722,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.20562402447105174 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,640.41,0.16,-15.638,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.2649841283509526 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,593.49,0.24,-12.269,0.007,temp: 298.0,-0.00028082393745132683 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,771.26,0.31,-26.206,0.009,temp: 98.0,0.7969793674065261 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,706.09,0.43,-20.768,0.011,temp: 173.0,0.4189515426542599 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,640.36,0.48,-15.652,0.01,temp: 248.0,0.2571559413981989 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,595.3,0.64,-12.312,0.012,temp: 298.0,0.3046939721141549 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,767.35,0.12,-26.001,0.007,temp: 98.0,0.28597634724917803 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,702.77,0.11,-20.621,0.006,temp: 173.0,-0.05321336425791448 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,637.84,0.15,-15.533,0.007,temp: 248.0,-0.1373846810209429 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,591.7,0.17,-12.165,0.008,temp: 298.0,-0.30188573273987146 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,767.75,1.33,-26.077,0.052,temp: 98.0,0.3382528710504387 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,702.47,1.81,-20.638,0.057,temp: 173.0,-0.09587886789454964 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,638.58,3.11,-15.555,0.082,temp: 248.0,-0.02152751412008154 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,592.7,2.57,-12.189,0.085,temp: 298.0,-0.13339137028041545 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,759.92,4.61,-25.877,0.148,temp: 98.0,-0.6850600823593028 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,702.64,3.04,-20.682,0.125,temp: 173.0,-0.0717017491671252 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,638.36,3.69,-15.602,0.167,temp: 248.0,-0.05597153671223335 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,590.72,4.78,-12.212,0.213,temp: 298.0,-0.46701020795014136 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,760.61,0.8,-25.877,0.023,temp: 98.0,-0.5948830788021159 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,701.21,0.3,-20.607,0.007,temp: 173.0,-0.2750739831684431 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,638.3,0.53,-15.542,0.011,temp: 248.0,-0.06536536105555558 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,591.4,0.52,-12.158,0.011,temp: 298.0,-0.35243404147771973 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,769.4,0.08,-26.51,0.005,temp: 98.0,0.5538935317306484 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,704.12,0.08,-21.348,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.138781402106976 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,639.33,0.12,-16.538,0.005,temp: 248.0,0.09589529017133055 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,593.82,0.12,-13.374,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.05532231567417606 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,759.96,0.29,-25.858,0.009,temp: 98.0,-0.6798324299791664 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,702.58,0.16,-20.649,0.005,temp: 173.0,-0.08023484989444576 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,638.05,0.18,-15.551,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.10450629581935961 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,593.46,0.27,-12.218,0.007,temp: 298.0,-0.00533565481123041 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,761.87,3.53,-25.924,0.135,temp: 98.0,-0.43021202882813653 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,702.14,4.02,-20.668,0.18,temp: 173.0,-0.14281092189486122 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,637.9,5.18,-15.588,0.251,temp: 248.0,-0.12799085667763846 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,590.59,6.46,-12.201,0.306,temp: 298.0,-0.4889144750698699 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,757.9,0.7,,,temp: 98.0,-0.9490565275556819 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,703.0,2.7,,,temp: 173.0,-0.020503144803153323 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,639.6,4.2,,,temp: 248.0,0.13816749971623604 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,603.0,4.4,,,temp: 298.0,1.6021005630519738 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,768.59,0.58,-26.113,0.035,temp: 98.0,0.44803357103309654 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,703.11,0.62,-20.681,0.034,temp: 173.0,-0.004859126803049458 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,638.34,0.59,-15.589,0.03,temp: 248.0,-0.05910281149333483 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,592.81,0.77,-12.255,0.031,temp: 298.0,-0.11485699040989215 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..335ea0c4 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,732.72,3.05,-21.576,0.161,temp: 173.0,0.11648283329975402 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,681.35,4.22,-16.988,0.222,temp: 248.0,-0.07968010637050871 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,649.48,4.57,-14.135,0.269,temp: 298.0,-0.13262242587558934 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,789.47,0.05,-26.616,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.7083307723797471 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,734.71,0.1,-21.599,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.38838997496132655 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,683.36,0.13,-17.026,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.21508740369949106 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,650.81,0.15,-14.162,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.07188519895285526 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,789.61,0.71,-26.629,0.022,temp: 98.0,0.7261897997121748 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,734.11,0.29,-21.598,0.007,temp: 173.0,0.30640792219904067 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,683.31,0.36,-17.04,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.20775487857336164 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,651.65,0.7,-14.185,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.20104790937083222 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,786.37,0.11,-26.435,0.007,temp: 98.0,0.3128808814473753 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,731.84,0.09,-21.468,0.005,temp: 173.0,-0.003757510751593444 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,681.52,0.1,-16.957,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.05474952094170865 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,649.25,0.1,-14.091,0.007,temp: 298.0,-0.16798840610908447 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,787.09,1.19,-26.535,0.051,temp: 98.0,0.4047273077284451 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,731.79,1.24,-21.505,0.046,temp: 173.0,-0.010589348481792996 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,681.73,1.88,-16.952,0.057,temp: 248.0,-0.023952915412001702 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,649.12,2.07,-14.09,0.061,temp: 298.0,-0.18797787319757947 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,779.86,3.66,-26.367,0.11,temp: 98.0,-0.5175638895105981 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,729.98,2.46,-21.511,0.107,temp: 173.0,-0.257901874314672 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,681.04,2.71,-16.999,0.134,temp: 248.0,-0.12514176215245784 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,649.94,3.17,-14.15,0.16,temp: 298.0,-0.061890465408599035 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,780.69,0.62,-26.368,0.017,temp: 98.0,-0.4116853703254747 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,731.57,0.38,-21.503,0.008,temp: 173.0,-0.04064943449461822 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,681.19,0.27,-16.944,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.10314418677408621 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,649.35,0.35,-14.077,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.1526118929640843 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,788.61,0.08,-26.954,0.005,temp: 98.0,0.5986253187662494 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,733.15,0.06,-22.207,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.1752366377793832 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,682.57,0.08,-17.934,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.09923350670680942 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,650.77,0.08,-15.273,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.06573459369486218 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,781.59,0.28,-26.414,0.008,temp: 98.0,-0.29687733747414474 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,730.58,0.19,-21.495,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.17591982155238606 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,681.8,0.12,-16.972,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.013687380235443834 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,648.56,0.14,-14.092,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.27408634680956995 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,782.13,3.09,-26.415,0.119,temp: 98.0,-0.22799251776334964 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,730.17,1.65,-21.506,0.165,temp: 173.0,-0.23194089093995715 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,681.31,2.09,-16.994,0.222,temp: 248.0,-0.08554612647141559 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,649.24,2.44,-14.141,0.261,temp: 298.0,-0.16952605742358276 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,777.7,0.9,,,temp: 98.0,-0.7931031683537929 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,729.3,0.9,,,temp: 173.0,-0.35081486744526785 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,681.6,1.4,,,temp: 248.0,-0.04301748073991156 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,656.2,1.6,,,temp: 298.0,0.9006792574681914 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,779.97,0.47,-26.554,0.038,temp: 98.0,-0.5035317966065445 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,732.49,0.65,-21.553,0.034,temp: 173.0,0.08505637974087649 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,681.94,0.51,-16.48,0.032,temp: 248.0,0.006843690117705245 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,649.74,0.77,-14.142,0.037,temp: 298.0,-0.09264349169859937 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..74ac954b --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,715.34,3.38,-20.982,0.184,temp: 173.0,0.3699529023296261 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,661.01,4.42,-15.626,0.242,temp: 248.0,0.06585172009235274 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,626.74,5.03,-12.357,0.295,temp: 298.0,0.11168068110573022 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,773.49,0.07,-26.49,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.47590424759301814 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,717.81,0.09,-20.801,0.006,temp: 173.0,0.7165206654475078 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,662.05,0.13,-15.668,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.22329031525565196 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,628.42,0.16,-12.429,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.3800337837388039 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,768.71,1.6,-26.302,0.043,temp: 98.0,-0.1450149915742521 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,719.3,2.0,-21.353,0.042,temp: 173.0,0.9255838100004086 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,667.41,1.2,-16.607,0.02,temp: 248.0,1.0347046134049935 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,629.48,0.43,-13.48,0.008,temp: 298.0,0.5493518127811149 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,768.37,0.08,-26.274,0.005,temp: 98.0,-0.18918079519703304 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,714.07,0.12,-21.306,0.006,temp: 173.0,0.19175814153621762 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,659.57,0.13,-16.342,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.15214018090298329 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,625.01,0.12,-12.926,0.005,temp: 298.0,-0.1646591210104818 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,769.52,1.02,-26.511,0.059,temp: 98.0,-0.03979645941411448 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,712.28,1.35,-21.386,0.052,temp: 173.0,-0.05939825359781344 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,659.75,1.98,-16.676,0.065,temp: 248.0,-0.12489119327857275 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,625.64,2.3,-13.728,0.074,temp: 298.0,-0.0640267075230769 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,776.03,3.38,-23.11,0.142,temp: 98.0,0.80584878053964 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,707.92,3.53,-20.526,0.161,temp: 173.0,-0.6711534953767697 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,660.06,3.26,-15.603,0.167,temp: 248.0,-0.07796238125874978 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,626.17,3.66,-12.365,0.191,temp: 298.0,0.020632306998069512 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,776.3,0.61,-23.132,0.026,temp: 98.0,0.8409216245930193 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,709.42,0.68,-20.579,0.023,temp: 173.0,-0.46068724247116616 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,661.15,0.43,-15.588,0.009,temp: 248.0,0.08704537713356478 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,627.07,0.21,-12.354,0.013,temp: 298.0,0.16439289769437782 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,784.9,0.08,-23.209,0.005,temp: 98.0,1.9580566574044354 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,725.62,0.09,-18.299,0.006,temp: 173.0,1.8123482889093583 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,668.16,0.08,-14.616,0.01,temp: 248.0,1.1482420618400693 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,629.64,0.08,-12.607,0.01,temp: 298.0,0.5749092511271177 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,751.84,0.11,-25.97,0.003,temp: 98.0,-2.3364182477985014 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,703.41,0.3,-20.581,0.009,temp: 173.0,-1.303955362446283 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,659.59,0.21,-15.556,0.007,temp: 248.0,-0.14911251561138403 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,627.07,0.19,-12.363,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.16439289769437782 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,756.1,2.6,-25.798,0.117,temp: 98.0,-1.7830467082895933 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,697.81,3.91,-20.749,0.182,temp: 173.0,-2.0896960399605393 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,644.54,4.76,-16.092,0.239,temp: 248.0,-2.4274306475419096 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,613.36,5.52,-13.152,0.282,temp: 298.0,-2.02556010057917 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,769.7,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,-0.016414563378518487 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,713.8,1.2,,,temp: 173.0,0.15387421601319556 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,661.2,1.3,,,temp: 248.0,0.09461454036258014 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,626.7,2.1,,,temp: 298.0,0.1052913215192341 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,773.13,0.63,,,temp: 98.0,0.429140455521841 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,715.66,0.64,-20.851,0.04,temp: 173.0,0.41485236961614586 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,662.41,0.57,-15.662,0.033,temp: 248.0,0.2777882905044903 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,627.19,0.4,-12.397,0.023,temp: 298.0,0.18356097645388436 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ecf5be9a --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,701.26,3.55,-20.482,0.185,temp: 173.0,0.7935205602674263 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,637.12,4.75,-14.826,0.262,temp: 248.0,0.5340027324739749 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,588.35,6.5,-11.139,0.322,temp: 298.0,-0.14624059831356792 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,763.68,0.09,-26.284,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.6954783121525125 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,700.97,0.1,-20.498,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.751838272724327 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,637.72,0.17,-14.808,0.007,temp: 248.0,0.6286794050623203 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,591.73,0.31,-11.202,0.011,temp: 298.0,0.4274072418796839 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,756.89,1.8,-26.004,0.054,temp: 98.0,-0.19982115587010418 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,705.02,1.8,-20.909,0.044,temp: 173.0,1.3339529780676782 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,641.98,0.91,-15.769,0.019,temp: 248.0,1.3008837804395463 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,594.25,1.2,-12.292,0.026,temp: 298.0,0.8550973475858927 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,759.16,0.11,-28.588,0.006,temp: 98.0,0.09949103741580664 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,696.86,0.14,-25.176,0.007,temp: 173.0,0.16109964582032493 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,632.68,0.14,-21.964,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.16660464467976369 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,587.87,0.17,-19.884,0.006,temp: 298.0,-0.22770538035284948 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,758.19,1.87,-26.209,0.048,temp: 98.0,-0.028408886587413612 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,696.74,1.22,-20.855,0.055,temp: 173.0,0.1438518026990396 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,631.9,2.2,-15.794,0.082,temp: 248.0,-0.28968431904460384 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,587.3,2.94,-12.48,0.108,temp: 298.0,-0.3244448090245012 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,764.64,3.63,-22.811,0.145,temp: 98.0,0.8220596802381899 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,689.18,3.35,-20.042,0.161,temp: 173.0,-0.9427623139419035 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,632.03,3.58,-14.697,0.186,temp: 248.0,-0.26917103998379716 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,592.15,4.92,-11.185,0.221,temp: 298.0,0.49868892616404553 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,764.81,0.71,-22.88,0.028,temp: 98.0,0.844475130836689 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,691.82,0.94,-20.048,0.035,temp: 173.0,-0.5633097652736262 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,634.11,0.31,-14.681,0.012,temp: 248.0,0.05904142498912785 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,591.04,0.54,-11.13,0.016,temp: 298.0,0.3103016176982118 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,773.85,0.11,-22.938,0.008,temp: 98.0,2.036449680310116 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,708.52,0.07,-17.822,0.006,temp: 173.0,1.837015069105148 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,640.92,0.14,-13.958,0.022,temp: 248.0,1.1336216588667998 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,593.23,0.12,-11.568,0.021,temp: 298.0,0.681984685752429 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,738.63,0.12,-25.638,0.004,temp: 98.0,-2.6075042613329997 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,685.92,0.35,-19.92,0.012,temp: 173.0,-1.4113287187368024 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,631.19,0.24,-14.69,0.008,temp: 248.0,-0.40171838160746287 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,590.8,0.25,-11.124,0.008,temp: 298.0,0.26956922667857103 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,744.14,2.68,-25.482,0.118,temp: 98.0,-1.8809799507579428 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,677.76,4.0,-20.116,0.191,temp: 173.0,-2.5841820509841558 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,615.73,5.54,-15.11,0.26,temp: 248.0,-2.841220645300411 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,572.33,6.38,-11.762,0.313,temp: 298.0,-2.8651276988744834 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,757.1,1.3,,,temp: 98.0,-0.17213148160135852 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,696.6,1.8,,,temp: 173.0,0.12372931905754278 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,633.8,1.9,,,temp: 248.0,0.010125144151808546 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,590.5,2.2,,,temp: 298.0,0.2186537379040297 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,761.37,0.89,-26.183,0.047,temp: 98.0,0.39089189519637013 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,698.22,0.55,-20.341,0.039,temp: 173.0,0.3565752011948865 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,635.65,0.68,-14.78,0.033,temp: 248.0,0.30204488463253293 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,590.99,0.64,-11.19,0.034,temp: 298.0,0.30181570290246135 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..f8f1aad5 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,,,,,temp: 98.0, +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,727.59,3.04,-21.271,0.183,temp: 173.0,0.36300936835450226 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,678.41,4.07,-16.149,0.243,temp: 248.0,0.13468684386287905 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,649.1,4.73,-13.069,0.29,temp: 298.0,0.41290831579042614 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,781.06,0.11,-26.649,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.3704460890542576 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,729.76,0.09,-21.185,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.6623369159147012 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,679.32,0.13,-16.146,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.26900468267410443 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,649.26,0.14,-13.058,0.006,temp: 298.0,0.43765961039915097 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,776.73,1.8,-26.485,0.048,temp: 98.0,-0.1859823947569703 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,730.62,2.2,-21.663,0.044,temp: 173.0,0.7809644232427104 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,683.17,0.79,-17.09,0.013,temp: 248.0,0.8372724622599935 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,648.4,0.42,-14.101,0.009,temp: 298.0,0.3046214018772266 +12,Ind.MC(PB),98.0,776.2,0.1,-28.883,0.006,temp: 98.0,-0.25409026921885036 +13,Ind.MC(PB),173.0,726.09,0.11,-26.049,0.006,temp: 173.0,0.156100925340536 +14,Ind.MC(PB),248.0,676.27,0.12,-23.398,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.18118148037447773 +15,Ind.MC(PB),298.0,645.96,0.12,-21.82,0.005,temp: 298.0,-0.0728358409058927 +16,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,778.07,1.22,-26.699,0.04,temp: 98.0,-0.01378512724956252 +17,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,725.17,1.41,-21.723,0.046,temp: 173.0,0.029197080291959932 +18,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,676.75,1.79,-17.206,0.062,temp: 248.0,-0.1103325104520768 +19,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,643.38,2.36,-14.374,0.063,temp: 298.0,-0.47195046647166594 +20,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,784.64,3.62,-23.334,0.129,temp: 98.0,0.8304955052307593 +21,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,720.25,4.18,-20.874,0.198,temp: 173.0,-0.6494626127938439 +22,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,676.94,3.81,-16.111,0.157,temp: 248.0,-0.08228812652445279 +23,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,647.37,3.23,-13.035,0.184,temp: 298.0,0.14528494283353313 +24,ms2(KL),98.0,786.49,0.74,-23.332,0.025,temp: 98.0,1.0682305387297897 +25,ms2(KL),173.0,721.53,0.57,-20.974,0.019,temp: 173.0,-0.4729007414219297 +26,ms2(KL),248.0,677.29,0.26,-16.063,0.017,temp: 248.0,-0.030627419289384162 +27,ms2(KL),298.0,647.39,0.3,-12.983,0.01,temp: 298.0,0.14837885465962153 +28,ms2*(KL),98.0,792.79,0.08,-23.366,0.005,temp: 98.0,1.877814706861607 +29,ms2*(KL),173.0,737.28,0.08,-18.631,0.008,temp: 173.0,1.6996379102247166 +30,ms2*(KL),248.0,684.1,0.11,-15.255,0.019,temp: 248.0,0.9745423414846496 +31,ms2*(KL),298.0,650.09,0.11,-13.436,0.023,temp: 298.0,0.5660569511819428 +32,ms2(PB),98.0,761.09,0.1,-26.21,0.003,temp: 98.0,-2.195807218500098 +33,ms2(PB),173.0,717.19,0.29,-20.909,0.007,temp: 173.0,-1.0715558365423277 +34,ms2(PB),248.0,676.14,0.22,-16.088,0.007,temp: 248.0,-0.20036974306179323 +35,ms2(PB),298.0,646.31,0.14,-13.005,0.006,temp: 298.0,-0.018692383949310477 +36,NAMD(FM),98.0,764.36,2.48,-25.99,0.116,temp: 98.0,-1.7755944836126303 +37,NAMD(FM),173.0,709.63,3.82,-21.101,0.176,temp: 173.0,-2.114374389332726 +38,NAMD(FM),248.0,663.25,4.49,-16.673,0.23,temp: 248.0,-2.102959789519527 +39,NAMD(FM),298.0,635.37,4.74,-13.856,0.266,temp: 298.0,-1.7110621528211967 +40,Tinker(AA),98.0,777.5,0.7,,,temp: 98.0,-0.087033218651972 +41,Tinker(AA),173.0,726.7,1.1,,,temp: 173.0,0.2402436921662175 +42,Tinker(AA),248.0,679.2,1.3,,,temp: 248.0,0.2512924401935042 +43,Tinker(AA),298.0,646.5,1.9,,,temp: 298.0,0.010699778398564518 +44,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,781.02,0.39,-26.621,0.039,temp: 98.0,0.36530587211374277 +45,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,727.69,0.83,-21.182,0.05,temp: 173.0,0.3768032645554365 +46,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,679.13,0.56,-16.154,0.024,temp: 248.0,0.24096029874648042 +47,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,648.04,0.51,-13.04,0.03,temp: 298.0,0.24893098900758254 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..8c0febb5 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,663.38,0.92,-15.466,0.05,temp: 98.0,0.029152174350098186 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,589.73,1.16,-13.121,0.069,temp: 173.0,0.049387835889109645 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,517.67,1.34,-11.05,0.08,temp: 248.0,0.08463853545259423 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,468.73,1.61,-9.75,0.087,temp: 298.0,0.12056513721404713 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,663.38,0.05,-15.466,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.029152174350098186 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,589.84,0.07,-13.125,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.06804965174034523 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,517.42,0.11,-11.044,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.03630434642509959 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,468.73,0.16,-9.75,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.12056513721404713 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,663.27,0.05,-15.464,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.012565592392276313 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,589.61,0.18,-13.118,0.005,temp: 173.0,0.029029491324127115 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,517.46,0.09,-11.046,0.002,temp: 248.0,0.044037816669513674 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,468.51,0.23,-9.745,0.006,temp: 298.0,0.07357321365423697 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,663.29,0.88,-15.463,0.03,temp: 98.0,0.015581334566422628 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,589.44,1.24,-13.114,0.036,temp: 173.0,0.00018850319040989723 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,517.16,1.89,-11.036,0.049,temp: 248.0,-0.01396321016349308 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,468.14,2.47,-9.737,0.058,temp: 298.0,-0.0054586577872531294 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,662.95,0.86,-15.459,0.029,temp: 98.0,-0.03568628239409902 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,589.3,1.32,-13.116,0.038,temp: 173.0,-0.023562898802085792 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,517.09,1.97,-11.039,0.05,temp: 248.0,-0.02749678309117927 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,468.18,2.52,-9.741,0.06,temp: 298.0,0.003085328314533849 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,662.87,0.09,-15.449,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.04774925109070142 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,589.07,0.07,-13.102,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.06258305921828464 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,516.66,0.12,-11.023,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.11063158821848235 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,467.51,0.16,-9.72,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.14002643889032823 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,663.07,0.06,-15.456,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.01759182934920398 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,589.29,0.08,-13.109,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.02525942751583273 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,517.03,0.12,-11.034,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.03909698845778942 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,467.75,0.17,-9.729,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.08876252227963065 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,663.3,1.1,,,temp: 98.0,0.017089205653495785 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,589.5,1.3,,,temp: 173.0,0.01036767547289152 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,517.4,1.6,,,temp: 248.0,0.032437611302903534 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,468.1,1.7,,,temp: 298.0,-0.014002643889027966 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,663.17,0.74,-15.464,0.026,temp: 98.0,-0.002513118478472405 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,589.17,0.49,-13.108,0.015,temp: 173.0,-0.045617772080815265 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,517.2,0.58,-11.039,0.015,temp: 248.0,-0.00622973991907899 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,467.84,0.49,-9.731,0.012,temp: 298.0,-0.06953855355062512 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1908fd34 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,648.9,1.01,-15.23,0.051,temp: 98.0,0.045225149294378805 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,562.59,1.39,-12.577,0.068,temp: 173.0,0.07075476359409438 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,459.96,1.78,-9.834,0.079,temp: 248.0,0.30554660373198056 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,337.81,2.52,-7.091,0.094,temp: 298.0,16.417070322222436 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,648.85,0.06,-15.227,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.03751631702829749 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,562.67,0.09,-12.578,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.08498477191468354 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,460.02,0.18,-9.835,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.3186310736776805 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,333.74,0.45,-7.01,0.009,temp: 298.0,15.014455017135422 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,648.64,0.09,-15.223,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.005139221510720881 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,562.15,0.46,-12.567,0.01,temp: 173.0,-0.007510282169226788 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,451.41,9.0,-9.667,0.18,temp: 248.0,-1.5589903635301812 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,226.3,5.2,-5.06,0.087,temp: 298.0,-22.01183205376117 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,648.75,1.07,-15.225,0.035,temp: 98.0,0.022098652496117317 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,562.22,1.77,-12.567,0.049,temp: 173.0,0.0049409751113089345 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,459.6,3.51,-9.825,0.078,temp: 248.0,0.22703978405779326 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,332.81,15.54,-6.992,0.296,temp: 298.0,14.69395569680841 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,648.53,0.89,-15.224,0.029,temp: 98.0,-0.011820209474675554 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,562.13,1.61,-12.569,0.044,temp: 173.0,-0.011067784249374074 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,459.28,4.23,-9.822,0.095,temp: 248.0,0.1572559443473853 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,329.16,17.21,-6.928,0.326,temp: 298.0,13.43608202025618 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,648.4,0.09,-15.212,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.031863173366504516 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,561.64,0.11,-12.548,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.09822658521306346 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,458.3,0.19,-9.794,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.05645706476569729 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,62.74,3.57,-5.242,0.108,temp: 298.0,-78.3783576803048 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,648.36,0.07,-15.212,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.038030239179369575 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,561.94,0.11,-12.559,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.044864054010793505 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,459.07,0.27,-9.812,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.11146029953744169 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,325.68,1.39,-6.861,0.026,temp: 298.0,12.236794240968011 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,648.5,1.1,,,temp: 98.0,-0.016445508834324347 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,562.1,1.4,,,temp: 173.0,-0.016404037369595004 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,459.9,1.5,,,temp: 248.0,0.2924621337862806 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,336.2,3.6,,,temp: 298.0,15.862227412839117 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,648.53,0.53,-15.22,0.017,temp: 98.0,-0.011820209474675554 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,562.29,0.57,-12.569,0.016,temp: 173.0,0.017392232391824435 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,459.49,0.74,-9.825,0.017,temp: 248.0,0.20305158915734134 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,327.11,0.27,-6.899,0.052,temp: 298.0,12.729605023836427 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..8c541fe4 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Ethane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,673.44,0.91,-15.612,0.05,temp: 98.0,0.004784949518766969 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,606.29,1.09,-13.426,0.069,temp: 173.0,0.029514207149402383 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,543.93,1.15,-11.569,0.081,temp: 248.0,0.039849430459663174 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,503.98,1.37,-10.458,0.09,temp: 298.0,0.02624249387491994 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,673.45,0.05,-15.613,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.006269933852180901 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,606.56,0.06,-13.433,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.07406049495874861 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,544.21,0.09,-11.576,0.002,temp: 248.0,0.09134715597680206 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,504.0,0.11,-10.457,0.003,temp: 298.0,0.03021194672994529 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,673.53,0.09,-15.617,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.018149808519492352 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,606.29,0.08,-13.427,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.029514207149402383 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,544.04,0.12,-11.574,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.060080679769964 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,504.15,0.21,-10.461,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.059982843142658025 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,673.51,0.75,-15.615,0.026,temp: 98.0,0.01517983985266449 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,606.2,1.05,-13.424,0.031,temp: 173.0,0.014665444546299481 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,543.81,1.46,-11.565,0.04,temp: 248.0,0.017778976666609624 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,503.75,1.98,-10.451,0.052,temp: 298.0,-0.019406213957916783 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,673.2,0.75,-15.612,0.026,temp: 98.0,-0.030854674483201155 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,605.92,1.16,-13.421,0.035,temp: 173.0,-0.03153070577452138 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,543.6,1.46,-11.566,0.039,temp: 248.0,-0.020844317471218402 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,503.75,1.9,-10.454,0.049,temp: 298.0,-0.019406213957916783 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,673.14,0.07,-15.602,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.03976458048370162 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,605.75,0.05,-13.409,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.05957836846929006 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,543.26,0.1,-11.551,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.08337726988487361 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,503.49,0.1,-10.442,0.003,temp: 298.0,-0.07100910107329153 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,673.23,0.05,-15.605,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.02639972148295936 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,605.91,0.07,-13.415,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.033180568285977256 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,543.32,0.1,-11.552,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.07234204298833637 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,503.6,0.11,-10.445,0.003,temp: 298.0,-0.049177110370629516 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,673.2,1.1,,,temp: 98.0,-0.030854674483201155 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,606.0,1.4,,,temp: 173.0,-0.018331805682855595 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,543.6,1.4,,,temp: 248.0,-0.020844317471218402 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,504.0,1.5,,,temp: 298.0,0.03021194672994529 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,673.97,0.84,-15.635,0.029,temp: 98.0,0.08348911918977286 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,606.08,0.46,-13.422,0.015,temp: 173.0,-0.0051329055911898125 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,543.65,0.34,-11.563,0.009,temp: 248.0,-0.011648295057454803 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,503.91,0.55,-10.455,0.015,temp: 298.0,0.01234940888231991 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..2bd47883 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,741.92,1.09,-20.672,0.072,temp: 98.0,0.10299216989660143 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,671.72,1.65,-17.541,0.099,temp: 173.0,-0.11136409449756204 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,607.84,2.26,-14.829,0.121,temp: 248.0,-0.004935265764056906 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,565.1,2.59,-13.132,0.131,temp: 298.0,0.04307877514649841 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,739.34,0.06,-20.628,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.24511236940457115 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,672.11,0.08,-17.548,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.05336884647287231 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,607.26,0.14,-14.821,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.1003504038692506 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,564.56,0.2,-13.136,0.005,temp: 298.0,-0.0525206984662902 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,739.61,0.23,-20.637,0.006,temp: 98.0,-0.20868282459398477 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,671.73,0.23,-17.54,0.005,temp: 173.0,-0.10987703685590464 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,607.62,0.11,-14.829,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.04112721470051162 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,565.08,0.17,-13.138,0.006,temp: 298.0,0.03953805390158405 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,741.39,0.78,-20.659,0.033,temp: 98.0,0.031482322675819574 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,672.7,1.1,-17.552,0.039,temp: 173.0,0.034367554384999444 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,607.78,1.6,-14.826,0.053,temp: 248.0,-0.01480579729218942 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,564.71,2.15,-13.121,0.069,temp: 298.0,-0.025965289129392166 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,742.08,0.85,-20.674,0.033,temp: 98.0,0.12458004830288734 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,672.72,1.37,-17.549,0.044,temp: 173.0,0.037341669668314266 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,608.12,2.0,-14.826,0.055,temp: 248.0,0.04112721470051162 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,564.96,2.54,-13.128,0.069,temp: 298.0,0.0182937264320777 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,741.75,0.14,-20.663,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.08005504908993988 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,672.51,0.24,-17.536,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.00611345919347483 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,607.86,0.21,-14.805,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.0016450885880189686 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,564.36,0.24,-13.109,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.087927910915454 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,741.18,0.06,-20.656,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.0031482322675788895 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,672.73,0.08,-17.542,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.038828727309971674 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,608.26,0.14,-14.815,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.06415845493279589 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,565.1,0.16,-13.121,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.04307877514649841 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,741.1,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,-0.007645706935548733 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,673.0,1.6,,,temp: 173.0,0.07897928363475558 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,608.1,1.9,,,temp: 248.0,0.037837037524473684 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,564.8,2.1,,,temp: 298.0,-0.010032043527277506 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,742.04,0.4,-20.687,0.018,temp: 98.0,0.11918307870130819 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,673.0,0.39,-17.555,0.016,temp: 173.0,0.07897928363475558 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,607.99,0.32,-14.822,0.013,temp: 248.0,0.019741063056246327 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,565.04,0.33,-13.13,0.011,temp: 298.0,0.03245661141173518 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..428ecffe --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,728.3,1.1,-20.392,0.072,temp: 98.0,0.1133295047714482 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,648.6,2.0,-16.978,0.102,temp: 173.0,-0.20907305248365196 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,568.23,3.07,-13.806,0.124,temp: 248.0,-0.025413606444880818 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,502.05,7.94,-11.516,0.204,temp: 298.0,-0.294584933139153 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,725.55,0.07,-20.353,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.2646900697694299 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,649.34,0.12,-16.995,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.09521969765608027 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,567.75,0.21,-13.8,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.10986497555405893 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,503.05,0.41,-11.544,0.01,temp: 298.0,-0.09598834900040021 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,724.93,0.21,-20.34,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.34991630112046485 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,649.19,0.14,-16.996,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.11829808039139507 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,568.26,0.31,-13.808,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.020135395875562186 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,503.58,0.32,-11.561,0.009,temp: 298.0,0.009267840593133368 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,728.02,0.88,-20.391,0.036,temp: 98.0,0.07484023900001709 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,650.09,1.3,-17.002,0.047,temp: 173.0,0.02017221602051125 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,568.47,2.33,-13.817,0.073,temp: 248.0,0.016812078109708233 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,503.85,4.33,-11.56,0.125,temp: 298.0,0.06288891831060431 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,728.83,1.23,-20.412,0.038,temp: 98.0,0.18618418641024748 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,650.71,1.86,-17.007,0.053,temp: 173.0,0.11556286465982761 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,568.45,2.84,-13.805,0.076,temp: 248.0,0.013293271063495815 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,504.14,4.54,-11.55,0.11,temp: 298.0,0.12048192771083538 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,727.7,0.12,-20.38,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.03085250668981457 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,650.15,0.23,-16.99,0.005,temp: 173.0,0.029403569114630174 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,568.13,0.31,-13.788,0.006,temp: 248.0,-0.043007641675962924 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,504.5,0.54,-11.54,0.009,temp: 298.0,0.19197669800078912 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,727.88,0.07,-20.385,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.05559560611430154 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,650.14,0.13,-16.991,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.027865010265610352 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,568.8,0.2,-13.795,0.005,temp: 248.0,0.07487239437225318 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,503.23,0.32,-11.529,0.008,temp: 298.0,-0.06024096385542334 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,728.2,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,0.09958333842451966 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,651.0,1.6,,,temp: 173.0,0.16018107128143738 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,568.5,2.5,,,temp: 248.0,0.022090288679026866 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,503.9,2.8,,,temp: 298.0,0.07281874751753291 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,727.87,0.49,-20.387,0.021,temp: 98.0,0.05422098947960868 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,650.41,0.46,-17.005,0.017,temp: 173.0,0.0694060991891805 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,568.78,0.31,-13.811,0.009,temp: 248.0,0.07135358732604076 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,503.5,0.53,-11.537,0.002,temp: 298.0,-0.0066198861379636945 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1a6fc7ff --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE Propane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,750.94,1.01,-20.832,0.071,temp: 98.0,0.04396424241615848 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,687.02,3.67,-17.869,0.124,temp: 173.0,-0.02296025612004679 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,628.96,1.98,-15.348,0.122,temp: 248.0,-0.09283608958859124 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,593.07,2.34,-13.815,0.134,temp: 298.0,0.04329637210139121 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,749.61,0.06,-20.815,0.002,temp: 98.0,-0.1332249770187066 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,686.55,0.09,-17.869,0.002,temp: 173.0,-0.09135594864664907 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,629.23,0.12,-15.356,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.049947934132267675 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,592.68,0.15,-13.829,0.003,temp: 298.0,-0.022491621870871004 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,749.33,0.01,-20.814,0.007,temp: 98.0,-0.17052797058393657 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,686.74,0.09,-17.872,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.06370662613588862 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,629.48,0.24,-15.357,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.010236679080113567 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,592.78,0.36,-13.828,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.00562290546772734 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,750.93,0.71,-20.843,0.029,temp: 98.0,0.042631992645957635 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,687.23,0.92,-17.876,0.038,temp: 173.0,0.007599521391842861 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,629.6,1.36,-15.343,0.043,temp: 248.0,0.00882472334492113 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,592.8,1.62,-13.821,0.052,temp: 298.0,-0.0022491621871024423 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,751.04,0.84,-20.836,0.034,temp: 98.0,0.05728674011801551 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,687.36,1.19,-17.873,0.037,temp: 173.0,0.02651747889919918 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,629.67,1.86,-15.348,0.047,temp: 248.0,0.019943874759514167 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,592.51,1.9,-13.816,0.052,temp: 298.0,-0.05116843975620181 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,750.72,0.12,-20.819,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.014654747472042729 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,687.61,0.12,-17.861,0.002,temp: 173.0,0.06289816641334722 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,629.51,0.16,-15.333,0.003,temp: 248.0,-0.005471328473859408 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,592.58,0.25,-13.805,0.003,temp: 298.0,-0.039360338273995495 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,750.74,0.06,-20.828,0.002,temp: 98.0,0.017319247012414135 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,687.23,0.08,-17.865,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.007599521391842861 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,629.75,0.11,-15.338,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.032651476376209985 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,592.96,0.16,-13.811,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.024740784057935093 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,751.3,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,0.09192523414287407 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,687.3,1.6,,,temp: 173.0,0.01778611389579505 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,629.9,1.7,,,temp: 248.0,0.056478229407498845 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,592.8,1.9,,,temp: 298.0,-0.0022491621871024423 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,750.88,0.62,-20.827,0.003,temp: 98.0,0.03597074379502912 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,687.56,0.42,-17.878,0.016,temp: 173.0,0.05562202891050769 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,629.8,0.38,-15.352,0.014,temp: 248.0,0.04059372738663358 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,593.14,0.2,-13.823,0.008,temp: 298.0,0.055104473583578346 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..26bfdedd --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,774.64,1.21,-23.984,0.087,temp: 98.0,-0.13393285594985677 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,710.34,1.6,-19.904,0.122,temp: 173.0,-0.06377850101764823 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,650.01,2.04,-16.265,0.153,temp: 248.0,-0.05501160881620485 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,611.16,2.4,-13.993,0.174,temp: 298.0,-0.0007272092617488972 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,784.33,0.06,-24.201,0.002,temp: 98.0,1.1152954186368562 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,713.67,0.09,-19.962,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.40471210572222843 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,651.72,0.18,-16.283,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.2079165463643738 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,612.35,0.2,-14.013,0.005,temp: 298.0,0.19398307056838393 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,780.97,1.2,-24.148,0.029,temp: 98.0,0.6821264813188636 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,713.68,0.26,-19.976,0.007,temp: 173.0,0.40611898442114563 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,652.06,0.56,-16.301,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.26019465909032313 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,612.39,0.25,-14.022,0.006,temp: 298.0,0.2005279539240124 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,772.86,2.23,-23.937,0.065,temp: 98.0,-0.36340925726712225 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,710.82,1.41,-19.912,0.05,temp: 173.0,0.003751676530446132 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,650.06,2.28,-16.266,0.068,temp: 248.0,-0.04732365106239392 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,610.79,2.82,-13.989,0.074,temp: 298.0,-0.061267380301367996 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,772.61,2.07,-23.94,0.053,temp: 98.0,-0.3956390889128061 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,709.13,1.43,-19.89,0.049,temp: 173.0,-0.2340108235868014 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,650.4,1.95,-16.27,0.059,temp: 248.0,0.004954461663572873 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,611.32,2.84,-13.995,0.073,temp: 298.0,0.025452324160802165 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,773.4,0.09,-23.953,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.2937928209124498 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,710.07,0.23,-19.896,0.005,temp: 173.0,-0.10176422588844729 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,649.41,0.34,-16.251,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.14726710186202346 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,609.98,0.39,-13.97,0.005,temp: 298.0,-0.19380126825295602 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,773.12,0.11,-23.939,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.3298902323556122 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,710.06,0.11,-19.899,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.10317110458738059 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,649.68,0.13,-16.246,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.10575212999140945 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,610.69,0.19,-13.972,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.07762958869043916 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,774.6,0.9,,,temp: 98.0,-0.13908962901316146 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,709.5,2.0,,,temp: 173.0,-0.18195631172681334 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,649.9,2.1,,,temp: 248.0,-0.07192511587460637 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,611.0,2.6,,,temp: 298.0,-0.026906742684281355 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,774.58,0.77,-23.982,4.946,temp: 98.0,-0.14166801554481384 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,709.87,0.76,-19.888,0.025,temp: 173.0,-0.1299017998668253 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,650.07,0.66,-16.268,0.025,temp: 248.0,-0.04578605951161425 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,610.8,0.51,-13.982,0.021,temp: 298.0,-0.059631159462460885 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..69e6b4e9 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,757.2,,1.0,-23.574,0.083,temp: 98.0,-0.653388963237033 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,686.82,,1.82,-19.268,0.123,temp: 173.0,-0.4142037573162327 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,613.36,,2.7,-15.197,0.158,temp: 248.0,-0.40108471493758674 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,559.21,,3.33,-12.468,0.172,temp: 298.0,-0.4273428179697816 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,774.12,,0.1,-23.993,0.003,temp: 98.0,1.5665590805321497 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,693.84,,0.11,-19.394,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.6036645191224823 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,618.36,,0.2,-15.27,0.005,temp: 248.0,0.41082766347853444 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,563.58,,0.29,-12.533,0.008,temp: 298.0,0.35077722975016706 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,768.61,,1.8,-23.872,0.047,temp: 98.0,0.8436327376735088 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,695.58,,0.24,-19.452,0.024,temp: 173.0,0.8559566560175502 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,618.71,,0.37,-15.297,0.012,temp: 248.0,0.4676615299676666 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,564.01,,0.78,-12.553,0.012,temp: 298.0,0.42734281796974105 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,759.68,,2.56,-23.632,0.067,temp: 98.0,-0.32800650764912664 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,688.71,,1.87,-19.299,0.057,temp: 173.0,-0.14016229827504148 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,615.51,,2.98,-15.227,0.079,temp: 248.0,-0.05196239221865834 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,561.96,,3.51,-12.502,0.103,temp: 298.0,0.0623208276205746 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,758.51,,2.4,-23.61,0.065,temp: 98.0,-0.48151355322890554 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,687.97,,1.85,-19.29,0.059,temp: 173.0,-0.24745895419593325 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,616.33,,2.61,-15.239,0.077,temp: 248.0,0.08119123784159366 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,560.69,,4.09,-12.478,0.105,temp: 298.0,-0.163814746888423 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,760.46,,0.29,-23.649,0.008,temp: 98.0,-0.22566847726259243 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,689.04,,0.32,-19.302,0.006,temp: 173.0,-0.09231378955357386 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,614.49,,0.44,-15.198,0.009,temp: 248.0,-0.21759251741554408 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,560.3,,0.47,-12.461,0.009,temp: 298.0,-0.23325795480852773 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,759.3,,0.13,-23.621,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.37786349681179104 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,688.48,,0.15,-19.295,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.17351125889910468 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,614.42,,0.19,-15.199,0.005,temp: 248.0,-0.22895929071337792 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,562.5,,0.28,-12.5,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.15847296166376532 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,760.4,,1.0,,,temp: 98.0,-0.2335406334461789 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,687.8,,1.8,,,temp: 173.0,-0.2721081859615538 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,616.1,,2.7,,,temp: 248.0,0.04384326843444913 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,560.9,,3.5,,,temp: 298.0,-0.1264222503160823 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,761.34,,0.45,-23.675,0.024,temp: 98.0,-0.11021018657010571 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,688.85,,0.41,-19.304,0.018,temp: 173.0,-0.11986293093865878 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,615.19,,0.8,-15.214,0.028,temp: 248.0,-0.10392478443727975 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,561.34,,0.59,-12.485,0.021,temp: 298.0,-0.04807606702161561 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..20e3f06b --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE iso-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,785.18,1.4,-24.203,0.09,temp: 98.0,0.1031257879631787 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,724.47,1.62,-20.267,0.125,temp: 173.0,-0.04568303028723616 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,669.88,2.13,-16.823,0.159,temp: 248.0,-0.07143768760679588 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,636.27,2.32,-14.712,0.176,temp: 298.0,0.019562259510832836 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,792.44,0.04,-24.359,0.002,temp: 98.0,1.0287080661931682 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,726.88,0.09,-20.296,0.003,temp: 173.0,0.28682197874972126 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,671.92,0.14,-16.846,0.003,temp: 248.0,0.23287691667647648 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,636.34,0.15,-14.713,0.004,temp: 298.0,0.030566030485687474 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,788.74,0.84,-24.299,0.023,temp: 98.0,0.5569925800428991 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,727.34,0.25,-20.322,0.004,temp: 173.0,0.3502876651219265 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,671.92,0.26,-16.854,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.23287691667647648 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,637.34,0.37,-14.729,0.002,temp: 298.0,0.18776275869778428 +12,LAMMPS(AA),98.0,782.98,2.04,-24.143,0.054,temp: 98.0,-0.17735369028832054 +13,LAMMPS(AA),173.0,723.84,1.57,-20.255,0.048,temp: 173.0,-0.13260342684046622 +14,LAMMPS(AA),248.0,669.86,1.96,-16.827,0.054,temp: 248.0,-0.07442116411937433 +15,LAMMPS(AA),298.0,635.18,2.3,-14.704,0.063,temp: 298.0,-0.1517821742403577 +16,LAMMPS(KL),98.0,782.6,1.17,-24.144,0.038,temp: 98.0,-0.22580014562267134 +17,LAMMPS(KL),173.0,724.11,1.31,-20.267,0.046,temp: 173.0,-0.09535182831765558 +18,LAMMPS(KL),248.0,669.97,1.78,-16.821,0.057,temp: 248.0,-0.05801204330017594 +19,LAMMPS(KL),298.0,635.9,2.86,-14.706,0.07,temp: 298.0,-0.0386005299276437 +20,ms2(KL),98.0,777.39,0.1,-24.135,0.008,temp: 98.0,-0.8900265463910197 +21,ms2(KL),173.0,723.92,0.4,-20.258,0.007,temp: 173.0,-0.12156591616705015 +22,ms2(KL),248.0,669.64,0.36,-16.811,0.004,temp: 248.0,-0.1072394057577711 +23,ms2(KL),298.0,635.52,0.3,-14.687,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.09833528664823976 +24,ms2(PB),98.0,782.87,0.13,-24.145,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.1913776642008977 +25,ms2(PB),173.0,724.57,0.12,-20.263,0.003,temp: 173.0,-0.03188614194545038 +26,ms2(PB),248.0,670.47,0.15,-16.816,0.004,temp: 248.0,0.01657486951435294 +27,ms2(PB),298.0,635.76,0.15,-14.694,0.004,temp: 298.0,-0.060608071877335114 +28,Tinker(AA),98.0,783.2,1.1,,,temp: 98.0,-0.14930574246316627 +29,Tinker(AA),173.0,723.9,1.7,,,temp: 173.0,-0.12432529383540417 +30,Tinker(AA),248.0,669.5,2.1,,,temp: 248.0,-0.12812374134583715 +31,Tinker(AA),298.0,636.8,2.2,,,temp: 298.0,0.10287652546323986 +32,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,783.94,0.4,-24.175,0.02,temp: 98.0,-0.05496264523311244 +33,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,724.18,0.55,-20.263,0.026,temp: 173.0,-0.08569400647841652 +34,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,670.07,0.47,-16.821,0.021,temp: 248.0,-0.04309466073726677 +35,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,636.2,0.4,-14.71,0.016,temp: 298.0,0.008558488535996068 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..f2831288 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 41 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,790.76,1.15,-24.349,0.087,temp: 98.0,0.25247311360566377 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,725.28,1.69,-20.738,0.131,temp: 173.0,0.08023040121114045 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,665.52,2.0,-16.533,0.173,temp: 248.0,0.03242340239589599 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,627.2,2.41,-13.889,0.195,temp: 298.0,0.12794227317612056 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,787.17,0.09,-25.443,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.20266672462318894 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,723.94,0.12,-20.776,0.028,temp: 173.0,-0.10467406153099328 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,664.71,0.22,-16.442,0.026,temp: 248.0,-0.0893253999780901 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,626.49,0.1,-13.914,0.032,temp: 298.0,0.014595909952334389 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,787.43,0.07,-25.364,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.16970395082388626 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,724.29,0.1,-20.766,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.056378119769997785 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,665.47,0.14,-16.512,0.007,temp: 248.0,0.02490804422466861 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,626.22,0.19,-13.937,0.008,temp: 298.0,-0.028507636625720027 +12,ms2(KL),98.0,790.0,0.1,-25.279,0.005,temp: 98.0,0.15612039019231533 +13,ms2(KL),173.0,725.32,0.14,-20.556,0.02,temp: 173.0,0.08574993741240917 +14,ms2(KL),248.0,665.8,0.14,-16.5,0.01,temp: 248.0,0.0745094081548035 +15,ms2(KL),298.0,626.73,0.2,-13.885,0.012,temp: 298.0,0.052910173577275676 +16,ms2(PB),98.0,788.39,0.09,-25.437,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.04799524756491377 +17,ms2(PB),173.0,724.69,0.1,-20.712,0.006,temp: 173.0,-0.0011827577574046425 +18,ms2(PB),248.0,665.69,0.13,-16.5,0.007,temp: 248.0,0.05797562017810326 +19,ms2(PB),298.0,626.07,0.16,-13.876,0.008,temp: 298.0,-0.052454051391303796 +20,Tinker(AA),98.0,788.8,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,0.003984511118599716 +21,Tinker(AA),173.0,724.2,1.7,,,temp: 173.0,-0.06879707622281712 +22,Tinker(AA),248.0,664.1,1.8,,,temp: 248.0,-0.18101276966714958 +23,Tinker(AA),298.0,625.1,2.1,,,temp: 298.0,-0.20730753354210665 +24,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,788.83,0.82,-25.397,0.058,temp: 98.0,0.0077879080954534165 +25,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,725.17,0.57,-20.747,0.029,temp: 173.0,0.0650516766576789 +26,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,665.84,0.64,-16.51,0.028,temp: 248.0,0.08052169469180248 +27,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,626.98,0.79,-13.907,0.033,temp: 298.0,0.09282086485325468 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..971c9fe7 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 5 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,778.06,1.19,-24.037,0.088,temp: 98.0,0.1612829071381915 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,704.52,1.79,-20.164,0.141,temp: 173.0,-0.024529430248225303 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,633.19,2.54,-15.534,0.183,temp: 248.0,0.007671497453760983 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,581.5,3.0,-12.512,0.199,temp: 298.0,0.09516479246942922 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,774.15,0.16,-25.132,0.006,temp: 98.0,-0.34205952939229095 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,703.91,0.25,-20.197,0.008,temp: 173.0,-0.11109196509116794 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,632.69,0.22,-15.546,0.02,temp: 248.0,-0.07129979986414814 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,580.98,0.23,-12.491,0.018,temp: 298.0,0.005655788699726238 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,774.68,0.09,-25.057,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.2738315264866275 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,704.02,0.11,-20.234,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.09548232766047178 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,633.05,0.19,-15.55,0.007,temp: 248.0,-0.014440465795269374 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,580.58,0.28,-12.523,0.009,temp: 298.0,-0.0631972911231207 +12,ms2(KL),98.0,782.19,0.12,-21.637,0.005,temp: 98.0,0.6929464014785915 +13,ms2(KL),173.0,705.68,0.16,-20.012,0.025,temp: 173.0,0.140081291748182 +14,ms2(KL),248.0,633.35,0.23,-15.517,0.011,temp: 248.0,0.032942312595486876 +15,ms2(KL),298.0,580.56,0.31,-12.447,0.012,temp: 298.0,-0.06663994511427969 +16,ms2(PB),98.0,776.45,0.08,-25.167,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.04597574319787834 +17,ms2(PB),173.0,704.75,0.12,-20.167,0.005,temp: 173.0,0.00810890256141066 +18,ms2(PB),248.0,633.74,0.17,-15.507,0.007,temp: 248.0,0.09453992450345383 +19,ms2(PB),298.0,581.83,0.28,-12.477,0.01,temp: 298.0,0.15196858332328822 +20,Tinker(AA),98.0,776.2,1.4,,,temp: 98.0,-0.0781587634364005 +21,Tinker(AA),173.0,704.5,1.8,,,temp: 173.0,-0.027367546144712582 +22,Tinker(AA),248.0,632.2,2.3,,,temp: 248.0,-0.1486916712357005 +23,Tinker(AA),298.0,579.4,2.7,,,temp: 298.0,-0.2663138766005417 +24,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,775.92,0.73,-25.077,0.037,temp: 98.0,-0.11420374610355644 +25,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,705.47,0.73,-20.194,0.041,temp: 173.0,0.11028107483504945 +26,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,633.77,0.63,-15.537,0.028,temp: 248.0,0.09927820234252407 +27,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,581.78,0.72,-12.515,0.03,temp: 298.0,0.14336194834542013 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..677d9461 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/TraPPE n-Butane at 70 MPa_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +,Program(Group),T / K,ρ / kg m−3,δρ / kg m−3,u / kJ mol−1,δu / kJ mol−1,statepoint,Relative_Error +0,DL_POLY(BS),98.0,800.31,1.0,-24.553,0.085,temp: 98.0,0.20569985350592634 +1,DL_POLY(BS),173.0,738.32,1.53,-21.168,0.136,temp: 173.0,0.04103660000157065 +2,DL_POLY(BS),248.0,684.46,1.97,-17.082,0.183,temp: 248.0,0.03444985666771471 +3,DL_POLY(BS),298.0,650.72,2.05,-14.578,0.201,temp: 298.0,0.05403529427270891 +4,GROMACS(BS),98.0,795.97,0.18,-25.618,0.007,temp: 98.0,-0.3377054986253822 +5,GROMACS(BS),173.0,737.55,0.15,-21.096,0.024,temp: 173.0,-0.06329701981370017 +6,GROMACS(BS),248.0,683.87,0.15,-17.068,0.001,temp: 248.0,-0.051779178506637526 +7,GROMACS(BS),298.0,650.66,0.22,-14.62,0.003,temp: 298.0,0.044809756226141605 +8,GROMACS(KL),98.0,796.28,0.07,-25.533,0.003,temp: 98.0,-0.2988908306160091 +9,GROMACS(KL),173.0,737.68,0.08,-21.107,0.004,temp: 173.0,-0.045682252831904004 +10,GROMACS(KL),248.0,684.26,0.12,-17.053,0.005,temp: 248.0,0.005219675252674983 +11,GROMACS(KL),298.0,650.76,0.14,-14.622,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.06018565297040879 +12,ms2(KL),98.0,804.0,0.09,-22.096,0.004,temp: 98.0,0.667719611424036 +13,ms2(KL),173.0,738.34,0.11,-20.959,0.021,temp: 173.0,0.04374656415261385 +14,ms2(KL),248.0,684.4,0.14,-17.019,0.011,temp: 248.0,0.025680802243196146 +15,ms2(KL),298.0,650.57,0.15,-14.589,0.01,temp: 298.0,0.030971449156316864 +16,ms2(PB),98.0,798.28,0.09,-25.66,0.004,temp: 98.0,-0.04847361765226773 +17,ms2(PB),173.0,738.18,0.11,-21.093,0.005,temp: 173.0,0.02206685094423748 +18,ms2(PB),248.0,684.53,0.11,-17.036,0.006,temp: 248.0,0.044680420162966986 +19,ms2(PB),298.0,650.55,0.14,-14.59,0.007,temp: 298.0,0.027896269807449442 +20,Tinker(AA),98.0,797.8,1.2,,,temp: 98.0,-0.10857374876356794 +21,Tinker(AA),173.0,737.4,1.7,,,temp: 173.0,-0.08362175094653954 +22,Tinker(AA),248.0,683.2,1.9,,,temp: 248.0,-0.14970028624699236 +23,Tinker(AA),298.0,648.6,2.2,,,temp: 298.0,-0.27193371670568206 +24,TOWHEE(BS),98.0,798.03,1.46,-25.588,0.082,temp: 98.0,-0.0797757692727354 +25,TOWHEE(BS),173.0,738.65,0.46,-21.101,0.033,temp: 173.0,0.08575100849381417 +26,TOWHEE(BS),248.0,684.85,0.59,-17.045,0.029,temp: 248.0,0.09144871042702722 +27,TOWHEE(BS),298.0,650.72,0.57,-14.595,0.023,temp: 298.0,0.05403529427270891 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/aggregate_summary_all.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/aggregate_summary_all.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4d826bdc --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/aggregate_summary_all.csv @@ -0,0 +1,57 @@ +,molecule,engine,temperature,pressure,ensemble,forcefield_name,cutoff_style,long_range_correction,r_cut,pressure-avg,pressure-std,pressure-sem,temperature-avg,temperature-std,temperature-sem,potential_energy-avg,potential_energy-std,potential_energy-sem,density-avg,density-std,density-sem +0,ethanolAA,gromacs,320.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,7.386085277182733,16.36290891398086,4.090727228495215,319.7222432843016,0.27728240727497183,0.06932060181874296,-3675.6252809287525,18.771018093961377,4.692754523490344,0.7736642320435503,0.00037277412529925744,9.319353132481436e-05 +1,waterSPCE,gomc,280.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,244.26521875101415,486.27808815879854,121.56952203969963,280.0,0.0,0.0,-6340788.739425104,3976.241470428791,994.0603676071978,1.0068742335552554,0.001648215174777416,0.000412053793694354 +2,waterSPCE,lammps-VU,300.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,0.1699873105149858,1.1940528586039503,0.29851321465098757,299.9855307249328,0.14238807715866109,0.03559701928966527,-51251.07075384754,5.842480086362603,1.4606200215906509,0.9979992850805295,0.00022483770202246937,5.6209425505617344e-05 +3,ethanolAA,mcccs,300.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,144.10388789173697,142.38975855380298,35.597439638450744,300.0,0.0,0.0,-9636.586657425061,23.05769399077928,5.76442349769482,0.7915228869902695,0.0008904100983158416,0.0002226025245789604 +4,waterSPCE,hoomd,320.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,368.66982144427595,824.5618934803778,206.14047337009444,319.5464837093391,0.08411657455238651,0.021029143638096628,-50033.882489138945,5.196860047911769,1.2992150119779422,0.9863582701788145,0.00020292440438574735,5.073110109643684e-05 +5,ethanolAA,mcccs,280.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,95.61641141756772,115.5419757027543,28.885493925688575,280.0,0.0,0.0,-10995.939734889276,22.679869112803736,5.669967278200934,0.8132799817630951,0.0009105163756624017,0.00022762909391560042 +6,waterSPCE,lammps-VU,280.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,-0.2966353234737142,1.0935806012083817,0.27339515030209544,280.0449006680848,0.1109876819501365,0.027746920487534125,-52633.59478870424,7.216325148521126,1.8040812871302816,1.0068795721825756,0.00022887788622402054,5.7219471556005136e-05 +7,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,gomc,372.0,1402.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1402.1451191031786,122.33555496765892,30.58388874191473,372.0,0.0,0.0,-289476.5306132031,695.9399642321441,173.98499105803603,0.540849320879125,0.0005165323368682392,0.0001291330842170598 +8,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,gromacs,372.0,1402.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,17.49920310190135,13.276552718944716,3.319138179736179,372.0263139499642,0.13134130495187382,0.032835326237968455,-499.8800451010373,10.719653087484343,2.6799132718710856,0.5339952516891766,0.001211795303466543,0.00030294882586663575 +9,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,gromacs,372.0,1402.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,14.357145017690527,3.1597071853930756,0.7899267963482689,371.96957083362616,0.1266716916298173,0.03166792290745433,-2425.9794197016618,6.719675700234463,1.6799189250586157,0.5419011696532579,0.00032131570087705043,8.032892521926261e-05 +10,waterSPCE,cassandra,300.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,1111.1605372126428,328.70214818097116,82.17553704524279,300.0,0.0,0.0,-51315.737681796876,36.422571122619566,9.105642780654891,0.997095958226198,0.0015542776846623827,0.0003885694211655957 +11,waterSPCE,lammps-VU,320.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,0.18501473068641294,1.0558209112352044,0.2639552278088011,320.0692139275947,0.1186647097934372,0.0296661774483593,-49918.14367100615,7.612600465387632,1.903150116346908,0.9863388500911472,0.0002236567788209163,5.591419470522907e-05 +12,waterSPCE,mcccs,300.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,346.1675232364062,238.35272346937472,59.58818086734368,0.0,0.0,0.0,-51376.63117764762,19.40948488327741,4.852371220819353,0.9974167823082374,0.0011413710442673161,0.00028534276106682903 +13,ethanolAA,lammps-VU,320.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,0.24833346712508075,1.564784515992586,0.3911961289981465,320.0133517112167,0.045105272993998774,0.011276318248499693,-3105.911366040009,13.721818595408676,3.430454648852169,0.7737386886586286,0.0005190278846760177,0.00012975697116900442 +14,waterSPCE,mcccs,320.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,217.33623681320836,356.7486929276063,89.18717323190158,0.0,0.0,0.0,-50039.82971097703,16.46029181639707,4.115072954099268,0.986378609639563,0.0009200998165328889,0.00023002495413322222 +15,benzeneUA,hoomd,450.0,2260.0,NPT,benzene-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,2251.5109715634776,134.82018403402094,33.705046008505235,450.0315492437884,0.10726901893734267,0.026817254734335667,-8268.853515488903,2.756902247698143,0.6892255619245358,0.6977604365642096,0.0002410219365163394,6.025548412908485e-05 +16,ethanolAA,lammps-VU,280.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,111.82732873174143,430.71588748003336,107.67897187000834,280.012746860633,0.045927991191355384,0.011481997797838846,-6552.472148956111,9.831177369535625,2.4577943423839064,0.8160460979302364,0.0003678107436767363,9.195268591918407e-05 +17,ethanolAA,cassandra,320.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,1634.8622611289443,283.28092659352745,70.82023164838186,320.0,0.0,0.0,-8211.544145572916,24.794962810425634,6.1987407026064085,0.7687202859646355,0.0008468373536246669,0.00021170933840616672 +18,waterSPCE,gromacs,280.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,0.9066718454524352,4.981667918835428,1.245416979708857,279.9817103359171,0.11592430801449954,0.028981077003624886,-52755.273195048125,3.1387680812266017,0.7846920203066504,1.0067388050894401,0.00015772484647609355,3.943121161902339e-05 +19,benzeneUA,cassandra,450.0,2260.0,NPT,benzene-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,2235.812474062985,116.1144865920127,29.028621648003174,450.0,0.0,0.0,-8279.860781446354,10.994613044795699,2.7486532611989247,0.6984355226084895,0.0009722288849456309,0.00024305722123640772 +20,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,hoomd,372.0,1402.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1857.8986043278728,1029.4136806403035,257.35342016007587,370.07282272345594,0.06753494307570201,0.016883735768925504,-598.348686676936,18.29546292690224,4.57386573172556,0.5444344331662561,0.0016273073789420784,0.0004068268447355196 +21,ethanolAA,gomc,300.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,189.33884519343806,160.73121090962596,40.18280272740649,300.0,0.0,0.0,-1153163.4855680207,4151.372410961057,1037.8431027402642,0.7913484722631563,0.0013261621823414586,0.00033154054558536466 +22,methaneUA,lammps-VU,140.0,1318.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1.3727125266159015,0.1451022781692951,0.03627556954232378,140.0187312234737,0.06909822894426526,0.017274557236066315,-5699.011530679262,0.8883769467881574,0.22209423669703934,0.37597173850147536,5.600563041526528e-05,1.400140760381632e-05 +23,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,hoomd,372.0,1402.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1371.946960694772,400.5795327139803,100.14488317849508,371.88057372250626,0.16990409362951864,0.04247602340737966,-2426.950978718094,2.7282250208703003,0.6820562552175751,0.5419898727782437,0.00030186004689047055,7.546501172261764e-05 +24,ethanolAA,gromacs,280.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,-0.1880251244876936,14.8946603224094,3.72366508060235,279.98895524102625,0.26090072711825657,0.06522518177956414,-7045.887545749052,22.953775808713953,5.738443952178488,0.8167763941860889,0.00023989817952917825,5.997454488229456e-05 +25,methaneUA,hoomd,140.0,1318.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1345.1464581169503,84.93437741138331,21.233594352845827,139.99489781041444,0.027113603946789334,0.006778400986697334,-5698.978934502496,1.537298743603749,0.38432468590093727,0.3759024878229348,8.351549941558764e-05,2.087887485389691e-05 +26,ethanolAA,cassandra,300.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,1306.5241974025141,326.08413793394254,81.52103448348564,300.0,0.0,0.0,-9618.100656297396,23.642645476418732,5.910661369104683,0.7912818525394791,0.0008829528154467213,0.00022073820386168033 +27,methaneUA,gomc,140.0,1318.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1301.81422061616,58.83067456113999,14.707668640284998,140.0,0.0,0.0,-685093.8421600625,208.00218845104496,52.00054711276124,0.3757889993377083,0.00011691176661201252,2.922794165300313e-05 +28,waterSPCE,cassandra,280.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,911.4224853985197,380.33294699059564,95.08323674764891,280.0,0.0,0.0,-52704.462343776046,37.35925345726298,9.339813364315745,1.006219489195677,0.001951130264662797,0.00048778256616569926 +29,waterSPCE,gromacs,300.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,2.078137808115704,5.0032406767093,1.250810169177325,300.03317599214233,0.10531469548206666,0.026328673870516666,-51379.23613949193,5.093489371990191,1.2733723429975476,0.997872222479935,0.00010611411405899197,2.6528528514747992e-05 +30,waterSPCE,gomc,300.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,311.771610490875,506.6753819510162,126.66884548775406,300.0,0.0,0.0,-6173561.208366301,2376.258731989235,594.0646829973088,0.9978894387415365,0.001193495558743343,0.00029837388968583574 +31,ethanolAA,hoomd,320.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,139.141174437068,620.2447448690797,155.06118621726992,318.0518146368627,0.0585342039959654,0.01463355099899135,-3638.707472577408,10.776813654689468,2.694203413672367,0.7737540395695532,0.0005696384060432825,0.00014240960151082062 +32,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,mcccs,372.0,1402.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1405.6732120732916,62.34335707970884,15.58583926992721,372.0,0.0,0.0,-2417.163109475033,4.0531456026239985,1.0132864006559996,0.5410886453415661,0.0003461206838981674,8.653017097454186e-05 +33,benzeneUA,gromacs,450.0,2260.0,NPT,benzene-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,598.4628613056768,54.792266845144866,13.698066711286216,449.9749758293657,0.07962156893655552,0.01990539223413888,-4763.000351206376,35.14706410030546,8.786766025076364,0.6994750481091541,0.005320356104800141,0.0013300890262000352 +34,benzeneUA,gomc,450.0,2260.0,NPT,benzene-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,2261.3261238725845,113.57359149858733,28.393397874646833,450.0,0.0,0.0,-996248.5051899063,1104.6892172880082,276.17230432200205,0.6986877138757969,0.0008168704743399857,0.00020421761858499643 +35,ethanolAA,hoomd,300.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,18.19520656087098,561.3429378651543,140.33573446628859,298.18270927920105,0.031193472226197085,0.007798368056549271,-5356.528356876066,12.728565429690816,3.182141357422704,0.795539037556105,0.0006699188454743484,0.0001674797113685871 +36,ethanolAA,cassandra,280.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,1100.9015507314693,355.4507643063722,88.86269107659305,280.0,0.0,0.0,-10989.091105359375,39.15544808085992,9.78886202021498,0.8134909356063542,0.0013345960311544694,0.00033364900778861734 +37,ethanolAA,gromacs,300.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,0.48879268702858414,18.88738372413123,4.721845931032807,299.9842745059775,0.33296690752590247,0.08324172688147562,-5383.192305854824,30.97299823399313,7.743249558498283,0.7956309742518117,0.0003515280944911218,8.788202362278045e-05 +38,waterSPCE,gomc,320.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,265.9610005581678,422.41258608670194,105.60314652167548,320.0,0.0,0.0,-6018771.941017188,2242.8561646967696,560.7140411741924,0.9861967911254947,0.0008218002333186185,0.00020545005832965462 +39,methaneUA,cassandra,140.0,1318.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1292.1047136521488,31.592770246951666,7.8981925617379165,140.0,0.0,0.0,-5695.189620521354,2.915553296563871,0.7288883241409677,0.3757235620453125,0.0001751962404427804,4.37990601106951e-05 +40,waterSPCE,hoomd,280.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,-99.33640054930041,945.3953265290031,236.34883163225078,279.5379865837039,0.04143091216852132,0.01035772804213033,-52744.24093032333,4.92069443580055,1.2301736089501376,1.0065722954367806,0.00017623787459348486,4.4059468648371215e-05 +41,ethanolAA,gomc,280.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,73.82676037295047,229.41972307688044,57.35493076922011,280.0,0.0,0.0,-1316410.1096084896,4920.244044398107,1230.0610110995267,0.8131313624791041,0.0014130531794989858,0.00035326329487474646 +42,waterSPCE,hoomd,300.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,13.152213180670365,620.0950559180179,155.02376397950448,299.50456544410036,0.03483938905237124,0.00870984726309281,-51370.08162540954,5.70235572028213,1.4255889300705324,0.9978713895661253,0.00018895279032016575,4.7238197580041436e-05 +43,benzeneUA,mcccs,450.0,2260.0,NPT,benzene-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,2194.916566386264,62.893504691808054,15.723376172952014,450.0,0.0,0.0,-6025.762650336912,11.953522211499461,2.9883805528748653,0.6983239878468144,0.0007810274199452238,0.00019525685498630594 +44,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,lammps-VU,372.0,1402.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,928.9680976970318,2861.1272486888683,715.2818121722171,371.9753474023654,0.20884629272470256,0.05221157318117564,-452.67791782923,15.456058650662392,3.864014662665598,0.5432271222473475,0.0018561358209731838,0.00046403395524329596 +45,ethanolAA,lammps-VU,300.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,-7.467739908959722,269.38193292433175,67.34548323108294,300.015323409767,0.06284411712385393,0.015711029280963483,-4854.502013981132,7.479035537092114,1.8697588842730286,0.7954329437061574,0.0002927443340395005,7.318608350987512e-05 +46,waterSPCE,cassandra,320.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,1486.9897306185976,430.5591198826744,107.6397799706686,320.0,0.0,0.0,-49985.282374276045,37.55731855137774,9.389329637844435,0.9850267179323438,0.0016883754608489911,0.0004220938652122478 +47,benzeneUA,lammps-VU,450.0,2260.0,NPT,benzene-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,2275.7208916034388,190.05164979065881,47.512912447664704,450.5924355773069,0.2650670841539167,0.06626677103847918,-8268.001035948888,3.8592596056358226,0.9648149014089556,0.6976587115413384,0.00031912413669267124,7.978103417316781e-05 +48,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,cassandra,372.0,1402.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1348.1548122757595,70.96284002873008,17.74071000718252,372.0,0.0,0.0,-2423.008360798958,8.612346519187353,2.1530866297968383,0.541189253940625,0.0008495282868671981,0.00021238207171679952 +49,ethanolAA,gomc,320.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,187.7324407434529,235.43716134138515,58.85929033534629,320.0,0.0,0.0,-982220.6171556511,3957.009782240972,989.252445560243,0.7680116167513229,0.0011735365258760796,0.0002933841314690199 +50,waterSPCE,gromacs,320.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,2.3062657949715435,6.061200588175036,1.515300147043759,320.0216821083835,0.10481191431510796,0.02620297857877699,-50043.963560970675,4.371378596902638,1.0928446492256596,0.9863577172415943,0.00010183277621188933,2.5458194052972332e-05 +51,ethanolAA,hoomd,280.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,-213.60666293220967,622.6881733188677,155.67204332971693,278.280373216568,0.048639019260606924,0.012159754815151731,-7019.56063054578,15.701777553793786,3.9254443884484465,0.8162973288982891,0.0006679099141502698,0.00016697747853756744 +52,ethanolAA,mcccs,320.0,101.325,NPT,oplsaa,hard,energy_pressure,1.0,237.10278940694064,130.13928396070077,32.53482099017519,320.0,0.0,0.0,-8229.879840892247,20.393359453562393,5.098339863390598,0.7687308005306762,0.0008008656849902207,0.00020021642124755517 +53,waterSPCE,mcccs,280.0,101.325,NPT,spce,hard,energy_pressure,0.9,492.521711559375,274.4140746706369,68.60351866765923,0.0,0.0,0.0,-52748.07641691869,41.68320678915052,10.42080169728763,1.006562398238529,0.0017102567726938519,0.00042756419317346297 +54,methaneUA,mcccs,140.0,1318.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,1285.4831025069893,37.20743432388115,9.301858580970288,140.0,0.0,0.0,-5695.738792702148,3.029363327288005,0.7573408318220013,0.37575936057731646,0.0001837137385027993,4.592843462569983e-05 +55,methaneUA,gromacs,140.0,1318.0,NPT,trappe-ua,hard,energy_pressure,1.4,13.588645423936484,1.0591647556941834,0.26479118892354586,140.00376846643206,0.051552152017493635,0.012888038004373409,-5698.862840276335,1.6907945007949114,0.42269862519872786,0.3759555197390835,5.592110954235338e-05,1.3980277385588345e-05 diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/job_density_data.csv b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/job_density_data.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0d95213c --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/csvs/job_density_data.csv @@ -0,0 +1,897 @@ +,associated_work,MCorMD,engine,molecule,replicate,temperature,density,density-std,forcefield +0,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,14,320.0,0.7735207800292969,0.010110613077917021,oplsaa +1,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,7,280.0,1.0068064283735252,0.0072941553581096965,spce +2,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,10,300.0,0.9976709290832094,0.007521107927439588,spce +3,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,4,372.0,0.5346973692820622,0.021955527372966032,trappe-ua +4,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,13,300.0,0.7926841606760833,0.0068209388038109,oplsaa +5,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,1,372.0,0.5412649296850833,0.011499652233530945,trappe-ua +6,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,7,372.0,0.54136970455525,0.01183206654864145,trappe-ua +7,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,0,140.0,0.3756420617758333,0.004490899501958551,trappe-ua +8,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,12,140.0,0.3759078714789572,0.004477798031083108,trappe-ua +9,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,6,300.0,0.9981839407503689,0.007603404003640751,spce +10,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,5,300.0,0.9953463570116666,0.007538525073838185,spce +11,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,7,140.0,0.3758223487533516,0.004322838137520545,trappe-ua +12,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,6,450.0,0.6955600068492275,0.0222127345822273,benzene-ua +13,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,1,300.0,0.7953839208956944,0.007293262637195991,oplsaa +14,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,14,372.0,0.5476375393162778,0.011462411498066408,trappe-ua +15,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,10,280.0,1.0064909798767026,0.006536842264955913,spce +16,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,10,280.0,1.00866087245825,0.006396357909430115,spce +17,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,1,300.0,0.7936346984068231,0.0072882006762512675,oplsaa +18,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,10,280.0,0.816633294977106,0.009312414312709884,oplsaa +19,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,13,280.0,1.006677498531498,0.007223132019273279,spce +20,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,12,372.0,0.5404184629258333,0.011770658750962205,trappe-ua +21,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,5,450.0,0.6991885617545183,0.0136234770284215,benzene-ua +22,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,1,300.0,0.7954616413939083,0.009851687096326875,oplsaa +23,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,3,320.0,0.76909183965425,0.007300385874546468,oplsaa +24,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,4,280.0,1.0066576437343528,0.007125314250470776,spce +25,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,15,280.0,0.8160174638853713,0.006907139650315561,oplsaa +26,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,1,320.0,0.7732451979992732,0.007902867849081528,oplsaa +27,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,12,300.0,0.9980217970013817,0.0074370348884008715,spce +28,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,5,300.0,0.7903367767541668,0.007528735606963092,oplsaa +29,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,4,300.0,0.9983137311286927,0.00776929597398238,spce +30,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,13,140.0,0.37597791136701714,0.0045050993878547226,trappe-ua +31,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,8,280.0,1.0073116083686788,0.0069345809778629565,spce +32,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,13,320.0,0.9852482428944168,0.007292960621740566,spce +33,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,3,450.0,0.6990807010392238,0.013545605214452496,benzene-ua +34,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,6,300.0,0.7949380169639937,0.005740931467535022,oplsaa +35,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,12,300.0,0.7937460940756079,0.007194606953648524,oplsaa +36,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,2,372.0,0.5337417271596461,0.023704938179353027,trappe-ua +37,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,1,320.0,0.7687651442891665,0.008494551347367058,oplsaa +38,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,4,300.0,0.9977159967773438,0.007748975572632542,spce +39,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,4,320.0,0.7677420083179248,0.008202562532075396,oplsaa +40,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,11,320.0,0.7688305247674999,0.007636085987952618,oplsaa +41,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,7,450.0,0.7015875055541992,0.020144943111080792,benzene-ua +42,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,8,300.0,0.9980899644668355,0.007382559654067472,spce +43,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,9,372.0,0.5417095560902451,0.011895465217151503,trappe-ua +44,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,14,450.0,0.6980161558042417,0.02101724728762448,benzene-ua +45,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,5,320.0,0.9863986983398437,0.008027808700097994,spce +46,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,5,140.0,0.37585325953,0.004453246684165636,trappe-ua +47,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,10,320.0,0.9862407811218051,0.00789600227351627,spce +48,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,5,140.0,0.3757046991217542,0.004454722082578434,trappe-ua +49,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,0,450.0,0.697493268442844,0.014807891644667025,benzene-ua +50,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,15,372.0,0.5436382620830973,0.012151315478592781,trappe-ua +51,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,8,280.0,0.8162995665787375,0.0065880272176249985,oplsaa +52,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,10,372.0,0.5356540648678699,0.018850044931047985,trappe-ua +53,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,11,320.0,0.9857354598689999,0.006802925624052288,spce +54,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,2,320.0,0.7742754639451876,0.010704967362562639,oplsaa +55,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,13,372.0,0.5415883279882273,0.011994365175014806,trappe-ua +56,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,1,320.0,0.9863397647074424,0.007804374960252108,spce +57,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,9,320.0,0.9862014098250595,0.007856710818883512,spce +58,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,2,372.0,0.517585522840529,0.013818022378261734,trappe-ua +59,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,7,450.0,0.699170137375236,0.013522077800727318,benzene-ua +60,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,0,280.0,1.0070097578316666,0.0076669211207402825,spce +61,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,7,320.0,0.7685517339091668,0.007701704317743874,oplsaa +62,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,0,140.0,0.37598345830721064,0.00448817789472198,trappe-ua +63,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,0,300.0,0.9977990325195313,0.007710134577166101,spce +64,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,1,280.0,0.8137294027908335,0.006766289750982524,oplsaa +65,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,10,450.0,0.6974448514695,0.012575219366537459,benzene-ua +66,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,3,140.0,0.3759248648845241,0.004363142465141285,trappe-ua +67,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,2,372.0,0.5417748579353641,0.011441572676623395,trappe-ua +68,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,11,450.0,0.6990717188149999,0.013750876384214706,benzene-ua +69,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,1,450.0,0.697447419036042,0.018741846377185734,benzene-ua +70,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,0,300.0,0.7965601509739741,0.007071104398787545,oplsaa +71,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,0,140.0,0.3759440752972613,0.004604455113075375,trappe-ua +72,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,6,372.0,0.5175345422959468,0.013111013999843272,trappe-ua +73,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,9,140.0,0.37557556553782734,0.004456372600154916,trappe-ua +74,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,4,280.0,0.8131172900363333,0.006202875740661543,oplsaa +75,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,3,450.0,0.6987580109066667,0.013011416353327638,benzene-ua +76,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,7,450.0,0.6985329163153334,0.012625332285710483,benzene-ua +77,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,14,320.0,0.9868343906768765,0.007651624302104119,spce +78,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,5,320.0,0.9848698727713217,0.008567771285867923,spce +79,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,1,300.0,0.9965764520173039,0.006997220437610498,spce +80,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,0,300.0,0.9956701152479672,0.007462034761555541,spce +81,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,7,372.0,0.541752778256464,0.011811364099745182,trappe-ua +82,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,10,300.0,1.0004293214091053,0.007731019844479522,spce +83,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,10,372.0,0.5176614068652132,0.013568718071078902,trappe-ua +84,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,12,372.0,0.5414428718175,0.011627161706343418,trappe-ua +85,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,1,280.0,1.0065615221191406,0.007295740895818161,spce +86,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,15,450.0,0.6980508942263334,0.012933354381241349,benzene-ua +87,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,2,320.0,0.9867161100851666,0.0075146082092901745,spce +88,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,7,372.0,0.5467268441570535,0.01123934859156207,trappe-ua +89,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,15,300.0,0.795696101313716,0.00984103587424628,oplsaa +90,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,13,140.0,0.37590654082245883,0.004285534637595984,trappe-ua +91,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,14,140.0,0.37571639066724993,0.0036905036458102377,trappe-ua +92,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,6,372.0,0.5412709809650281,0.011620910975837473,trappe-ua +93,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,7,300.0,0.7914179383031301,0.007567966089775204,oplsaa +94,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,14,450.0,0.6999879425450001,0.013646716139792335,benzene-ua +95,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,10,300.0,0.7909270792391667,0.007199132990132785,oplsaa +96,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,8,300.0,0.7923249660258335,0.007120878291327886,oplsaa +97,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,14,280.0,1.0068618844826258,0.0071717344000953205,spce +98,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,13,300.0,0.9976625227783178,0.007684387575609039,spce +99,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,2,280.0,1.0061146078883334,0.007767776343057137,spce +100,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,13,280.0,0.8128214662187798,0.00677085266308406,oplsaa +101,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,7,280.0,1.0076833474385931,0.005986627173444024,spce +102,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,5,320.0,0.7726585372588706,0.0063999510158108935,oplsaa +103,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,13,372.0,0.541111639269674,0.011857724629145196,trappe-ua +104,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,4,300.0,0.7926487707889167,0.0070311839574822305,oplsaa +105,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,4,372.0,0.5405756008399746,0.012246655194683194,trappe-ua +106,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,0,320.0,0.7742474511267767,0.007662150882785251,oplsaa +107,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,4,320.0,0.9843703881493334,0.0070652185348718515,spce +108,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,14,450.0,0.6989144839285626,0.01365346451857476,benzene-ua +109,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,5,280.0,0.8146520553049066,0.006724025098066204,oplsaa +110,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,15,320.0,0.9863252981933595,0.008407844420443423,spce +111,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,15,280.0,1.0076145279758333,0.006587893375431962,spce +112,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,14,280.0,0.811977828373,0.005904091979467571,oplsaa +113,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,9,450.0,0.7062745624126849,0.01958904444949478,benzene-ua +114,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,6,320.0,0.9861901828548674,0.007917952862632756,spce +115,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,9,280.0,1.0075257736404866,0.006926119554263994,spce +116,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,9,320.0,0.7721485632612528,0.007763499977516371,oplsaa +117,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,7,320.0,0.7685150402899726,0.0077674053885842,oplsaa +118,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,4,280.0,1.00607020755,0.006964760724109512,spce +119,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,15,280.0,1.006371494812728,0.006837546765976118,spce +120,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,13,320.0,0.7742430033754645,0.010473878134559297,oplsaa +121,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,0,300.0,0.7913835546102891,0.007179975555748589,oplsaa +122,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,3,450.0,0.7056203407997841,0.019611056465413747,benzene-ua +123,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,8,320.0,0.9864938466938291,0.00782161997848868,spce +124,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,12,280.0,1.0069304712361167,0.007494080410448596,spce +125,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,15,300.0,0.9981183649984638,0.007926013939986825,spce +126,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,3,280.0,1.006894190625535,0.007297018181270021,spce +127,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,1,280.0,0.8166324632492741,0.009561359088670033,oplsaa +128,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,2,300.0,0.9979591689989998,0.007526838691365427,spce +129,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,10,372.0,0.5415731592918147,0.012100735065595617,trappe-ua +130,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,15,300.0,0.999612324091863,0.007012309532727804,spce +131,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,10,280.0,1.0080349584600001,0.00646958014956026,spce +132,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,11,450.0,0.6934434622982432,0.023663762400038788,benzene-ua +133,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,3,280.0,1.0067034641223007,0.007640360357934512,spce +134,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,9,300.0,0.7951018137905225,0.007209525399811822,oplsaa +135,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,2,320.0,0.9862712860819695,0.00794486094196764,spce +136,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,6,140.0,0.37570472396,0.004534476631039914,trappe-ua +137,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,11,450.0,0.6987005295313742,0.013328749244889741,benzene-ua +138,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,2,140.0,0.37588978405627577,0.0048909855864683275,trappe-ua +139,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,15,372.0,0.5167875225634515,0.013522343566820003,trappe-ua +140,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,5,280.0,1.0054346607283333,0.00592660407841503,spce +141,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,5,280.0,1.00706183789105,0.0073009091731557774,spce +142,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,9,320.0,0.9863587623535157,0.008293109133391216,spce +143,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,6,300.0,0.7908822133783333,0.006944736692032393,oplsaa +144,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,15,280.0,1.0066899241422995,0.007373923436055522,spce +145,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,4,300.0,0.9977903155104679,0.00746546305777971,spce +146,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,13,320.0,0.9864191012249022,0.008009229013547142,spce +147,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,14,280.0,1.0014173659458334,0.007154020421828537,spce +148,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,2,300.0,0.9982857438539168,0.007460451923745858,spce +149,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,4,140.0,0.37601403189554317,0.00446244528849953,trappe-ua +150,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,10,280.0,0.8140468901059809,0.006416422036864792,oplsaa +151,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,0,300.0,0.9970690314283334,0.00725608820826341,spce +152,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,11,300.0,0.9977211135426627,0.007596001893565743,spce +153,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,5,280.0,0.8130381418395833,0.006625589120400698,oplsaa +154,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,9,450.0,0.6996004632558334,0.013633986839795364,benzene-ua +155,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,1,280.0,1.0067668825033165,0.007111227722775099,spce +156,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,2,300.0,0.9979018131859789,0.0076155826744978275,spce +157,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,9,280.0,1.0065214035802608,0.007279067463935973,spce +158,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,6,140.0,0.3759739557160529,0.004425414496255202,trappe-ua +159,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,0,140.0,0.3754841075106382,0.004443184240307229,trappe-ua +160,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,12,280.0,0.8129988369416666,0.006748982589144215,oplsaa +161,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,14,300.0,0.9979401724986066,0.0076272586738974635,spce +162,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,0,140.0,0.37572815823016664,0.003989230012735338,trappe-ua +163,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,4,300.0,0.7952141315869832,0.007114620097712962,oplsaa +164,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,12,320.0,0.985792399661254,0.00834803023075079,spce +165,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,3,320.0,0.7682108090424958,0.007972750309838666,oplsaa +166,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,2,280.0,1.006611885158031,0.007320444879644809,spce +167,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,2,450.0,0.6988133119275002,0.013520670148752668,benzene-ua +168,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,5,300.0,0.9966408805968654,0.007034970722645358,spce +169,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,14,300.0,0.9978833535644531,0.007662106000517119,spce +170,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,7,372.0,0.5174281579367597,0.012930607218306765,trappe-ua +171,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,7,450.0,0.6976360594880974,0.014549282308806907,benzene-ua +172,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,11,140.0,0.3760036661922612,0.004475226308502309,trappe-ua +173,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,4,280.0,1.0067641826394331,0.00749454561728495,spce +174,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,10,300.0,0.7951851925601726,0.00955223603227275,oplsaa +175,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,10,320.0,0.7674580921323333,0.008298101928142856,oplsaa +176,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,13,300.0,0.7937480999557878,0.007245584176958118,oplsaa +177,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,5,300.0,0.7907960149980762,0.007328729435007269,oplsaa +178,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,9,372.0,0.5318711984609629,0.020719859232267816,trappe-ua +179,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,14,372.0,0.5414960432530724,0.011932602837301761,trappe-ua +180,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,3,280.0,0.8127173893560536,0.006626640686052977,oplsaa +181,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,14,450.0,0.6991564700690833,0.013639465593175505,benzene-ua +182,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,8,300.0,0.794777744857855,0.007056299583648943,oplsaa +183,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,0,320.0,0.7745772958212813,0.006803460864980645,oplsaa +184,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,7,320.0,0.7737761878113433,0.007736975748592675,oplsaa +185,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,12,300.0,0.9984779182013185,0.0073463642090040825,spce +186,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,5,320.0,0.7689680700341668,0.007509032645562569,oplsaa +187,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,6,450.0,0.6982251095490835,0.013419449869502543,benzene-ua +188,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,9,320.0,0.9876409592062501,0.006915213358210256,spce +189,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,15,300.0,0.7913930774203333,0.00677966932008703,oplsaa +190,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,9,320.0,0.9867154292333858,0.00786014913169755,spce +191,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,11,280.0,0.8143418539011995,0.006805425919241171,oplsaa +192,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,2,450.0,0.7057310125177556,0.01934780211157998,benzene-ua +193,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,8,320.0,0.7735481330993946,0.007831866096015465,oplsaa +194,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,5,300.0,0.9976592428511667,0.006882930821462541,spce +195,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,2,372.0,0.5408845382643334,0.011241842353417662,trappe-ua +196,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,1,280.0,0.8125734325620432,0.0069601114226653564,oplsaa +197,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,0,450.0,0.6974005564801667,0.01298394699648449,benzene-ua +198,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,14,450.0,0.6976252153762991,0.014372685403633182,benzene-ua +199,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,11,280.0,1.0061795781375,0.007003214920789583,spce +200,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,10,140.0,0.37572125589,0.004519186298337708,trappe-ua +201,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,11,140.0,0.3759710159133338,0.004013455999312959,trappe-ua +202,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,6,280.0,0.814559719214813,0.00683610452619578,oplsaa +203,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,10,320.0,0.7737638676630986,0.010447981361297551,oplsaa +204,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,4,280.0,1.0078165840192064,0.008161303713073227,spce +205,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,8,320.0,0.9859497366364809,0.007910606041262936,spce +206,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,12,320.0,0.98626349976725,0.006769493169674081,spce +207,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,2,280.0,1.006858908966577,0.007347837751609396,spce +208,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,5,140.0,0.3759380639076447,0.0045141703518990035,trappe-ua +209,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,3,450.0,0.6971427311428129,0.014178943383382088,benzene-ua +210,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,10,372.0,0.5415000918400001,0.011780081579618153,trappe-ua +211,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,0,450.0,0.6978507282470311,0.014448167403902588,benzene-ua +212,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,1,280.0,1.006590444270812,0.007450192847297037,spce +213,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,15,450.0,0.6978185734798212,0.014306527534347855,benzene-ua +214,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,1,300.0,0.9981574446990363,0.007817981769968629,spce +215,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,12,372.0,0.5408466937568542,0.011720549611816867,trappe-ua +216,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,7,280.0,1.0066819214660387,0.007455997984651708,spce +217,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,12,300.0,0.997737408264219,0.007588587390988104,spce +218,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,9,280.0,0.8132225294698334,0.006702515756113144,oplsaa +219,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,4,320.0,0.7738939659731183,0.0077008218700856,oplsaa +220,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,15,320.0,0.7697309587562238,0.008497339708640106,oplsaa +221,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,9,450.0,0.6976538367107614,0.014514611939274176,benzene-ua +222,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,8,320.0,0.7686568237594257,0.007634764570474471,oplsaa +223,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,13,140.0,0.3756801445291667,0.0045048049942190685,trappe-ua +224,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,15,320.0,0.7681606114425,0.008142241167627377,oplsaa +225,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,14,300.0,0.9983467086335001,0.007663845040098623,spce +226,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,7,300.0,0.9975106202288725,0.00732874097981875,spce +227,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,15,280.0,0.8147271394131667,0.006362429346867875,oplsaa +228,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,10,280.0,0.8163454017004508,0.006844756865651354,oplsaa +229,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,7,280.0,1.0053361989658334,0.007706795060988185,spce +230,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,2,320.0,0.76790780176,0.008257046237406774,oplsaa +231,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,7,280.0,0.8132965462691811,0.006449354256846958,oplsaa +232,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,5,300.0,0.7954656920166017,0.009650077495628899,oplsaa +233,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,1,300.0,0.7906744146991246,0.007718215821371868,oplsaa +234,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,0,320.0,0.7728936384887695,0.011301935892217856,oplsaa +235,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,10,300.0,0.7952528831398563,0.007075124719481375,oplsaa +236,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,0,280.0,0.8138962551109999,0.005852706991410084,oplsaa +237,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,14,300.0,0.7959687807626993,0.009027424121133411,oplsaa +238,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,15,300.0,0.7957331119897205,0.0071980876339741194,oplsaa +239,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,10,450.0,0.6977795420333333,0.013960907712679051,benzene-ua +240,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,4,320.0,0.7721116021205312,0.007845586846842847,oplsaa +241,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,0,140.0,0.37593310635223076,0.004478365131113419,trappe-ua +242,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,13,300.0,0.7913862280933333,0.007160378912048331,oplsaa +243,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,15,320.0,0.773950762814456,0.00743666397787756,oplsaa +244,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,2,280.0,0.8140039256263802,0.006684082193327793,oplsaa +245,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,9,280.0,0.8141847633592537,0.006564165951723691,oplsaa +246,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,3,300.0,0.7926871204697794,0.007424729209326201,oplsaa +247,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,7,320.0,0.7720054765157061,0.007833947675716744,oplsaa +248,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,7,372.0,0.5419089410300001,0.012043822136101761,trappe-ua +249,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,0,372.0,0.540675595912575,0.012624164060754494,trappe-ua +250,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,8,450.0,0.6978262157241062,0.014584476894200187,benzene-ua +251,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,15,280.0,0.816577134338379,0.00937905360407693,oplsaa +252,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,8,372.0,0.5415899699541666,0.012273046804568049,trappe-ua +253,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,1,372.0,0.5417503138000078,0.01220408964111979,trappe-ua +254,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,15,450.0,0.6986513676151738,0.02273001178436552,benzene-ua +255,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,5,320.0,0.9860976157408001,0.007911901655424353,spce +256,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,3,372.0,0.5404575487600833,0.011738137342828381,trappe-ua +257,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,5,372.0,0.5395209063833334,0.011767971845112475,trappe-ua +258,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,9,140.0,0.375852639066256,0.004330717053792552,trappe-ua +259,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,12,320.0,0.7674759010094999,0.007396282535668162,oplsaa +260,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,7,300.0,0.7935446166879541,0.007129238715601014,oplsaa +261,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,0,372.0,0.5406758590222753,0.012212625946259287,trappe-ua +262,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,13,300.0,0.7951404100022874,0.009840810794643266,oplsaa +263,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,10,300.0,0.7925371801350001,0.006651164661697733,oplsaa +264,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,1,372.0,0.5180426674328716,0.014099479650918017,trappe-ua +265,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,12,320.0,0.9863746633295721,0.008047197908192416,spce +266,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,9,372.0,0.5417775650618912,0.012141421422877368,trappe-ua +267,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,15,450.0,0.6997393581157746,0.013581816392036747,benzene-ua +268,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,1,320.0,0.7687967558309168,0.00754859790542189,oplsaa +269,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,1,320.0,0.9879557924708333,0.008248579625183041,spce +270,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,1,300.0,0.9973694745866666,0.0062400857685199805,spce +271,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,3,280.0,0.81225005201075,0.005914701903870923,oplsaa +272,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,2,320.0,0.7691623017117049,0.007902536886487788,oplsaa +273,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,7,320.0,0.9865713137567089,0.007370354805992023,spce +274,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,11,320.0,0.7740566800188105,0.00848503312160241,oplsaa +275,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,11,372.0,0.5433491775529958,0.011082461932291064,trappe-ua +276,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,0,450.0,0.6928185951011879,0.02061968184981812,benzene-ua +277,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,3,450.0,0.6991776332606047,0.013552561939720183,benzene-ua +278,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,10,300.0,0.9978164666837819,0.0072026165747974946,spce +279,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,4,320.0,0.767752693425,0.007868580326020155,oplsaa +280,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,5,280.0,1.006767226220703,0.007458995532275817,spce +281,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,0,320.0,0.7653072037436667,0.0077133529297239885,oplsaa +282,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,15,280.0,0.8143341164780206,0.00689858588437606,oplsaa +283,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,4,450.0,0.694351626461917,0.020762566373509275,benzene-ua +284,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,2,300.0,0.7892880687525369,0.007344515643359799,oplsaa +285,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,4,372.0,0.5419435598398185,0.011718895869475561,trappe-ua +286,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,5,280.0,0.8110058672466096,0.007174357813160881,oplsaa +287,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,10,280.0,1.0069900667861116,0.007175012080714007,spce +288,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,2,300.0,0.9978534505381741,0.00753129328523883,spce +289,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,8,140.0,0.37586347529325,0.003838459432536458,trappe-ua +290,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,6,320.0,0.7682598441833334,0.00788560307327212,oplsaa +291,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,8,372.0,0.54203998950525,0.011270313296658367,trappe-ua +292,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,4,280.0,0.8168254010144854,0.0094275752104485,oplsaa +293,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,9,300.0,0.7955547575450952,0.005904618060931148,oplsaa +294,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,5,300.0,0.9978716699689444,0.007554416510827713,spce +295,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,0,300.0,0.7897599347408333,0.0070181887157944375,oplsaa +296,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,5,320.0,0.9864537637931167,0.007754823667069454,spce +297,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,12,320.0,0.9864262761771916,0.008115694137426771,spce +298,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,4,300.0,0.9973413681858333,0.007002604496981394,spce +299,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,6,140.0,0.3759577581720038,0.004235158462816783,trappe-ua +300,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,14,280.0,0.8146398215893421,0.0066648880033382905,oplsaa +301,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,15,140.0,0.3759596094799999,0.00442902139038544,trappe-ua +302,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,1,280.0,0.8137888909240001,0.005939301091520963,oplsaa +303,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,13,320.0,0.9881813294641667,0.007049297476259379,spce +304,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,0,372.0,0.5416049213972081,0.011828865129859973,trappe-ua +305,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,3,280.0,0.8167267531474561,0.009068541905991786,oplsaa +306,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,11,300.0,0.7914723436641667,0.007329881758767589,oplsaa +307,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,13,280.0,0.8148950787372499,0.005874095277222907,oplsaa +308,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,4,300.0,0.7930129487808334,0.006959069216358983,oplsaa +309,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,8,450.0,0.6978220128733335,0.01372101748625962,benzene-ua +310,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,2,450.0,0.698593324617822,0.013858295855437172,benzene-ua +311,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,12,300.0,0.9979241749666672,0.007916337718658004,spce +312,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,9,372.0,0.5181083363274362,0.012891731225243779,trappe-ua +313,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,0,280.0,1.0067687088867188,0.007313404011160831,spce +314,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,14,300.0,0.7926873824547391,0.007515595187576854,oplsaa +315,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,7,140.0,0.3759774711249231,0.004341332201667644,trappe-ua +316,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,5,300.0,0.997384614573072,0.007722509872281075,spce +317,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,1,280.0,1.00440263780375,0.005854712340717772,spce +318,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,7,280.0,0.8119509288002499,0.005687026918366588,oplsaa +319,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,6,372.0,0.54094052261,0.011963661067460225,trappe-ua +320,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,3,140.0,0.3759826453408292,0.004452549831648948,trappe-ua +321,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,7,300.0,0.7916537940579168,0.006858733843746477,oplsaa +322,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,13,280.0,0.8170263543701172,0.009368674055389931,oplsaa +323,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,14,280.0,0.8155962087430062,0.006844689020116173,oplsaa +324,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,14,300.0,0.9966296190562082,0.007366149967982414,spce +325,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,13,140.0,0.375841432519,0.0038504390655713736,trappe-ua +326,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,13,450.0,0.6975316665983334,0.013445756679748755,benzene-ua +327,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,3,300.0,0.9982401576063732,0.007618561048764651,spce +328,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,3,280.0,0.8145131275755437,0.0068415128243041875,oplsaa +329,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,3,140.0,0.37553158162518174,0.004493270922488584,trappe-ua +330,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,1,300.0,0.9979244788281924,0.00756196872621184,spce +331,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,11,280.0,1.0065298283937345,0.007257500246641154,spce +332,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,13,300.0,0.9983204048618753,0.007577323137618292,spce +333,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,6,450.0,0.69638637824,0.013897282448491356,benzene-ua +334,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,3,300.0,0.7894161774217501,0.006843700787329744,oplsaa +335,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,3,280.0,1.0075556211459331,0.007884922452154918,spce +336,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,10,140.0,0.37594237758091514,0.004156720647089029,trappe-ua +337,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,6,280.0,0.8125967503006551,0.006879437587343733,oplsaa +338,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,1,372.0,0.5417817458666667,0.011665480053786897,trappe-ua +339,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,4,140.0,0.37609202204450004,0.003817292467165124,trappe-ua +340,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,4,320.0,0.98652832295133,0.008423343795134307,spce +341,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,10,450.0,0.6978442029141615,0.01458280168114875,benzene-ua +342,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,8,280.0,0.8166543702879152,0.008824156107431069,oplsaa +343,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,2,320.0,0.7678550335616666,0.007839603614047503,oplsaa +344,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,1,372.0,0.5448075349223922,0.011110500714510125,trappe-ua +345,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,10,300.0,0.79387092883822,0.007203898454704189,oplsaa +346,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,15,320.0,0.7726013336317563,0.008536465060566305,oplsaa +347,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,1,280.0,0.8146212161205558,0.006641006707376039,oplsaa +348,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,14,280.0,1.0063342374194166,0.006508554353914573,spce +349,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,8,280.0,1.0080874566033335,0.005806417653357263,spce +350,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,13,300.0,0.997794963406627,0.0076201594619743716,spce +351,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,4,300.0,0.7917082820644457,0.00713636715395163,oplsaa +352,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,8,300.0,0.7910366330499659,0.007481821310055259,oplsaa +353,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,7,280.0,1.006821459218156,0.007347146331724842,spce +354,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,14,372.0,0.542290216920237,0.012238009204578978,trappe-ua +355,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,15,140.0,0.37579459900516665,0.003871742050158768,trappe-ua +356,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,13,320.0,0.9862234757598192,0.007881406360419783,spce +357,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,13,300.0,0.9968818622528682,0.006810090908550845,spce +358,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,6,280.0,1.0065725286086973,0.007280416712639912,spce +359,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,10,300.0,0.9980012532048332,0.005722790664385522,spce +360,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,14,320.0,0.9862799516957316,0.007705263118845904,spce +361,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,11,280.0,1.0070668149094588,0.007295618871467762,spce +362,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,3,300.0,0.9978845759913098,0.0077712474541451965,spce +363,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,10,450.0,0.6993044310078718,0.013667801067448377,benzene-ua +364,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,14,372.0,0.54068519484,0.01183676668958887,trappe-ua +365,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,13,372.0,0.5317181615259741,0.022570050464172965,trappe-ua +366,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,7,320.0,0.769351109918,0.007841100116640238,oplsaa +367,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,11,450.0,0.6975751656801776,0.014537700481461491,benzene-ua +368,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,9,450.0,0.6990539909805127,0.013534636710702189,benzene-ua +369,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,9,300.0,0.996801296322,0.005887818217086997,spce +370,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,13,450.0,0.6982411041432555,0.01413287698273001,benzene-ua +371,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,10,300.0,0.9980283908767639,0.0077745962320055545,spce +372,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,12,300.0,0.7895398526610834,0.007038187286239347,oplsaa +373,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,8,372.0,0.5178380013656605,0.01314228287879011,trappe-ua +374,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,1,280.0,1.0072099045499998,0.005917055387798704,spce +375,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,3,372.0,0.5343410080154221,0.021515844485778635,trappe-ua +376,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,13,300.0,0.7957765876587755,0.007157025257061304,oplsaa +377,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,7,300.0,0.9978715280217233,0.007321998541232232,spce +378,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,2,450.0,0.6988341939857501,0.012383269107584697,benzene-ua +379,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,8,372.0,0.5412667611668879,0.012207981516062444,trappe-ua +380,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,14,320.0,0.9862606638285569,0.007708115757399119,spce +381,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,4,320.0,0.7738548669078524,0.010353548171967786,oplsaa +382,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,6,300.0,0.9963120628700001,0.0066703674220633,spce +383,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,15,372.0,0.5417956681866667,0.011552371620819941,trappe-ua +384,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,10,372.0,0.5413554436067952,0.01223178337821508,trappe-ua +385,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,14,300.0,0.7954856921890427,0.007180401684918874,oplsaa +386,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,9,140.0,0.37576956862516664,0.003852461611911728,trappe-ua +387,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,1,300.0,0.9977340180695488,0.00757580013916952,spce +388,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,14,140.0,0.37588309768844436,0.004505802822255299,trappe-ua +389,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,1,280.0,0.8160482446223217,0.006516421227769767,oplsaa +390,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,3,140.0,0.375807932625,0.004528692433260066,trappe-ua +391,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,6,320.0,0.9851102497416667,0.0077402975833685455,spce +392,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,7,450.0,0.6981907664716667,0.013329377688751238,benzene-ua +393,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,9,300.0,0.7903282398358333,0.007967277878283456,oplsaa +394,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,3,300.0,0.7910139674366666,0.007165671994144134,oplsaa +395,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,12,140.0,0.3758938842102721,0.004619942184740388,trappe-ua +396,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,2,280.0,0.8148682419075,0.007004425757475908,oplsaa +397,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,7,140.0,0.37569221138549996,0.0038841599824276326,trappe-ua +398,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,14,140.0,0.37586133988214726,0.004565370427525002,trappe-ua +399,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,12,300.0,0.9981109279641666,0.006896965498224974,spce +400,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,6,300.0,0.9953006905240376,0.007826267159635794,spce +401,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,11,372.0,0.5427582696025,0.012162715618493069,trappe-ua +402,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,10,300.0,0.7915635582650578,0.006831986460110522,oplsaa +403,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,6,300.0,0.7937824000433333,0.006944415889039571,oplsaa +404,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,15,372.0,0.5415194005778334,0.01177575291530239,trappe-ua +405,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,0,280.0,1.0079171650568712,0.00716127843164248,spce +406,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,0,280.0,0.8160409822396852,0.006467201814367902,oplsaa +407,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,12,280.0,0.8168020577898962,0.008746002337582437,oplsaa +408,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,7,372.0,0.5419284319082895,0.012538509300535855,trappe-ua +409,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,5,140.0,0.37565626551066666,0.0037689509777983974,trappe-ua +410,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,9,300.0,0.9979079818847657,0.007616710019480988,spce +411,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,0,372.0,0.5170727772752874,0.01333049955100227,trappe-ua +412,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,13,450.0,0.6982687054207886,0.01346865895565812,benzene-ua +413,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,8,320.0,0.9859919454710833,0.00692124267245554,spce +414,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,3,372.0,0.542251237074534,0.012478005729386517,trappe-ua +415,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,15,140.0,0.3759269630691535,0.0045651983721113,trappe-ua +416,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,6,450.0,0.6991920642930118,0.013846457310199392,benzene-ua +417,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,8,372.0,0.5418097948743151,0.012841203711719698,trappe-ua +418,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,5,320.0,0.7682738681585699,0.008534376370559277,oplsaa +419,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,13,280.0,1.0065657111328123,0.007383494836009899,spce +420,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,1,320.0,0.9861463540371772,0.007782147098056933,spce +421,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,10,450.0,0.6938366443649733,0.02190279124866698,benzene-ua +422,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,1,320.0,0.773666007336275,0.010475958820709511,oplsaa +423,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,9,300.0,0.7914385761948001,0.0075191452148695055,oplsaa +424,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,5,450.0,0.6992561450223334,0.012288647962308582,benzene-ua +425,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,6,280.0,1.006818741786028,0.007258743296203964,spce +426,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,15,320.0,0.7674052363399999,0.00784987694232118,oplsaa +427,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,13,280.0,1.0067516876362281,0.007136110792185845,spce +428,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,8,140.0,0.37581671594706884,0.004563600525526552,trappe-ua +429,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,6,300.0,0.9979103188317276,0.007589863000207858,spce +430,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,3,300.0,0.7935359335442337,0.007091173985396441,oplsaa +431,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,2,320.0,0.7743499568429303,0.007435904149880346,oplsaa +432,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,10,140.0,0.37563769131708336,0.003802170838079311,trappe-ua +433,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,9,450.0,0.6982764972049247,0.013988537029547566,benzene-ua +434,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,14,300.0,0.9979951689508094,0.007506948841243013,spce +435,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,6,300.0,0.9978959193233493,0.007691297259358752,spce +436,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,7,300.0,0.9980017429924019,0.00727660436316241,spce +437,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,0,320.0,0.9865753723853644,0.00847316962297255,spce +438,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,0,320.0,0.7690305307995196,0.007782741263435766,oplsaa +439,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,6,372.0,0.541898219890353,0.01177931512930369,trappe-ua +440,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,12,450.0,0.7017361546534521,0.019924733532965276,benzene-ua +441,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,11,320.0,0.9862368463302614,0.007890255840502788,spce +442,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,0,320.0,0.9862231439242001,0.007925134365825188,spce +443,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,3,280.0,1.00774040665375,0.006539964663786401,spce +444,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,1,450.0,0.6993350071208333,0.013488187668717788,benzene-ua +445,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,3,280.0,0.8134731540058334,0.006635803215414433,oplsaa +446,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,11,300.0,0.9980384401741667,0.008178656464696071,spce +447,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,13,320.0,0.9844152899512061,0.007339187103087981,spce +448,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,3,300.0,0.9992533916883334,0.0071227021381791026,spce +449,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,3,300.0,0.9962973543078333,0.0074118286649472445,spce +450,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,14,280.0,0.8170429165383251,0.008336546438009218,oplsaa +451,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,2,372.0,0.5413699372195987,0.011937012348893416,trappe-ua +452,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,8,140.0,0.3760457489452166,0.004429535255013398,trappe-ua +453,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,12,280.0,0.8154049874090903,0.006537581519642339,oplsaa +454,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,12,280.0,1.0065542748062979,0.007246128762048185,spce +455,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,3,320.0,0.9860762875850877,0.008013770310411632,spce +456,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,6,372.0,0.5449264234638068,0.010837553027859877,trappe-ua +457,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,7,140.0,0.37588797739517876,0.004467969609261242,trappe-ua +458,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,8,280.0,0.8137915750191665,0.006589848354737021,oplsaa +459,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,6,300.0,0.7906274134566487,0.007093918703891053,oplsaa +460,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,3,300.0,0.7965322064472176,0.009148020385172151,oplsaa +461,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,12,372.0,0.5417425000561708,0.011860013461043163,trappe-ua +462,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,13,450.0,0.699065900658998,0.013592956714081481,benzene-ua +463,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,3,372.0,0.5418572967016666,0.01180882866251093,trappe-ua +464,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,7,320.0,0.9864135668899804,0.008011423428196135,spce +465,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,14,320.0,0.9867729618716666,0.007813550685060172,spce +466,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,0,320.0,0.7684447531808334,0.007520222773231653,oplsaa +467,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,5,450.0,0.6972178358358333,0.014128076755229323,benzene-ua +468,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,7,280.0,0.8168223346656027,0.00902034238431413,oplsaa +469,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,9,372.0,0.5422231058439154,0.011012140710204987,trappe-ua +470,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,13,280.0,1.0051595263305002,0.007937236524561242,spce +471,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,14,372.0,0.5416337608192416,0.012282728888811774,trappe-ua +472,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,6,280.0,0.8143300107108333,0.0063176433412925025,oplsaa +473,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,4,320.0,0.9862815806281126,0.007875472656679178,spce +474,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,2,280.0,0.8113634787835833,0.006457977435084869,oplsaa +475,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,12,140.0,0.3756805917304167,0.003974589414295766,trappe-ua +476,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,14,320.0,0.7686686329803271,0.007782011438816889,oplsaa +477,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,8,300.0,0.7935582087442641,0.0071661005810553435,oplsaa +478,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,12,300.0,0.795433011291403,0.006905306771510665,oplsaa +479,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,7,372.0,0.5351937830260911,0.019276871566334914,trappe-ua +480,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,10,320.0,0.7671995199011649,0.008197154173409854,oplsaa +481,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,9,320.0,0.9862917892525,0.006897005571938657,spce +482,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,8,300.0,0.7916764316774166,0.006115776237976927,oplsaa +483,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,5,372.0,0.541594788891423,0.011100531299568922,trappe-ua +484,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,8,140.0,0.3759363668517552,0.004586183126948571,trappe-ua +485,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,11,140.0,0.3756139065058333,0.004482385297523664,trappe-ua +486,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,5,280.0,1.0067165268621836,0.007273018878236298,spce +487,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,1,140.0,0.3759514588726284,0.0044809089415521215,trappe-ua +488,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,7,320.0,0.9870456707527501,0.007168103884069655,spce +489,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,12,372.0,0.5349466819069602,0.020627645418096426,trappe-ua +490,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,11,300.0,0.7960923995649765,0.01018991897406859,oplsaa +491,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,10,320.0,0.7720757348243467,0.007740662990568511,oplsaa +492,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,11,300.0,0.7938019851681415,0.007219976597636514,oplsaa +493,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,6,450.0,0.6998218592792068,0.014019515576937662,benzene-ua +494,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,5,320.0,0.9860349441641667,0.007584148288952039,spce +495,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,2,300.0,0.795763004033892,0.009728758505140815,oplsaa +496,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,4,280.0,0.8131865885078989,0.006366453650257795,oplsaa +497,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,3,320.0,0.9864733788846098,0.007996688994923512,spce +498,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,3,280.0,0.8160357591881836,0.006873077290044383,oplsaa +499,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,8,450.0,0.7087291510369513,0.01877351752135136,benzene-ua +500,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,3,372.0,0.5414103490804786,0.011777373198407605,trappe-ua +501,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,6,280.0,1.0071053662366667,0.008095057780390614,spce +502,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,15,300.0,0.9978780451735337,0.007578815493546172,spce +503,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,12,280.0,1.0094140222108334,0.0071554147502430636,spce +504,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,15,140.0,0.3758893814419316,0.004474151060083125,trappe-ua +505,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,14,300.0,0.7885900781909168,0.006399015090256513,oplsaa +506,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,6,300.0,0.795242535187826,0.007062267341489498,oplsaa +507,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,2,300.0,0.7914251200525,0.006273248702886748,oplsaa +508,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,9,372.0,0.5401197234033333,0.01192837906204082,trappe-ua +509,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,9,140.0,0.3759743053464101,0.004458036792804263,trappe-ua +510,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,1,450.0,0.698119891105557,0.014117915123281428,benzene-ua +511,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,1,140.0,0.37585042470999996,0.0045381914353834815,trappe-ua +512,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,12,140.0,0.37593841426671387,0.004498874868000353,trappe-ua +513,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,5,372.0,0.5333036570560903,0.020650682531301225,trappe-ua +514,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,0,450.0,0.6991906003665482,0.013648016609086265,benzene-ua +515,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,5,300.0,0.9978577767123181,0.00758649228083821,spce +516,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,8,280.0,1.0070353213043899,0.007356318506490168,spce +517,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,6,320.0,0.7693739749005339,0.0076861795456118105,oplsaa +518,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,4,450.0,0.6983458939075,0.013932506672254378,benzene-ua +519,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,12,140.0,0.3758343292793647,0.0045036878899677385,trappe-ua +520,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,0,372.0,0.5401766285816667,0.011429826812204004,trappe-ua +521,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,8,300.0,0.9970711326872318,0.007436218801201498,spce +522,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,8,320.0,0.9862776681565885,0.007898064509114368,spce +523,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,3,320.0,0.7747733939819615,0.007911729189834031,oplsaa +524,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,6,320.0,0.9863301507713785,0.00783862856135865,spce +525,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,3,280.0,1.0064721171767859,0.007450881951567006,spce +526,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,10,280.0,0.8116949869308334,0.006603455521496904,oplsaa +527,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,1,140.0,0.37599463004646716,0.004732573656251025,trappe-ua +528,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,0,300.0,0.9985115754719166,0.006482604358504377,spce +529,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,9,320.0,0.7734382660685369,0.0076193214022590066,oplsaa +530,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,9,280.0,0.8145224919976187,0.006602400685965209,oplsaa +531,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,9,372.0,0.5408571873395708,0.012067611126290689,trappe-ua +532,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,12,450.0,0.6970920343453252,0.014482641586451404,benzene-ua +533,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,0,300.0,0.795783996011541,0.006976731758365753,oplsaa +534,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,9,372.0,0.5404406273922501,0.010846131607897144,trappe-ua +535,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,4,372.0,0.5177680786963866,0.013258321972111466,trappe-ua +536,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,13,450.0,0.6928605747838174,0.022446689291575166,benzene-ua +537,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,11,320.0,0.7690303138903882,0.0077685017837780795,oplsaa +538,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,5,140.0,0.3759439794123231,0.004476897633250636,trappe-ua +539,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,1,320.0,0.7674110927811493,0.008389257460315838,oplsaa +540,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,11,320.0,0.7742422792968751,0.011100733265765005,oplsaa +541,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,13,300.0,0.9984664783557501,0.0061782043800652775,spce +542,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,8,280.0,1.0059567211575,0.006576641809657665,spce +543,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,4,300.0,0.7938150283704615,0.0073273069162571305,oplsaa +544,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,5,450.0,0.6981749889541382,0.013574206195639486,benzene-ua +545,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,6,320.0,0.9858474680508332,0.008305189246802503,spce +546,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,15,320.0,0.9861836371919241,0.007795100408521874,spce +547,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,4,300.0,1.0002364073392642,0.0076450859383014515,spce +548,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,15,372.0,0.5418447045264306,0.012010628478673761,trappe-ua +549,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,7,280.0,0.8161419203445466,0.0068760144944110405,oplsaa +550,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,12,280.0,1.0087260655499166,0.006337237858077808,spce +551,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,12,450.0,0.6985897688020833,0.013295076492532119,benzene-ua +552,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,5,280.0,0.8121649807775001,0.0067639058788048385,oplsaa +553,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,10,320.0,0.9869035540508333,0.0083094748627626,spce +554,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,11,320.0,0.7703883399800834,0.0070504402529335845,oplsaa +555,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,13,372.0,0.5410372612055,0.011055761448519653,trappe-ua +556,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,2,320.0,0.9860684853119095,0.00785098783643728,spce +557,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,15,320.0,0.9860971456240584,0.008005135679783245,spce +558,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,14,320.0,0.9873637511238333,0.006777803120559922,spce +559,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,3,320.0,0.9863158151060833,0.006373580517279445,spce +560,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,12,300.0,0.9989780557806667,0.0063270560531154645,spce +561,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,11,140.0,0.37579610025116666,0.0038766142027368716,trappe-ua +562,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,15,140.0,0.3754862433454743,0.004492073199721539,trappe-ua +563,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,15,280.0,1.0066104530545148,0.007324872728158247,spce +564,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,3,372.0,0.542642943071962,0.012464464431901927,trappe-ua +565,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,6,140.0,0.3759687232899406,0.004470262287471494,trappe-ua +566,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,15,300.0,0.9995392248825001,0.007691979293272957,spce +567,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,1,450.0,0.6991420664800646,0.013631032769859167,benzene-ua +568,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,6,280.0,0.8170783773439458,0.00915537526184371,oplsaa +569,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,7,320.0,0.7734619371948243,0.010202701874556618,oplsaa +570,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,3,140.0,0.37580982074175,0.003804269986895914,trappe-ua +571,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,15,372.0,0.5417161298223487,0.011883051228398918,trappe-ua +572,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,14,372.0,0.5400491942365834,0.011347445275558884,trappe-ua +573,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,5,320.0,0.7740751522071563,0.007438922574279723,oplsaa +574,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,5,280.0,0.8172095227661132,0.009245602511575449,oplsaa +575,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,12,140.0,0.37609236408583335,0.004465345800305899,trappe-ua +576,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,3,372.0,0.5413470058300639,0.012181560416133224,trappe-ua +577,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,0,372.0,0.5347753520919616,0.01925406668860225,trappe-ua +578,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,11,450.0,0.6990600557332405,0.013740702044878594,benzene-ua +579,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,9,320.0,0.7691121051884167,0.008052177694174262,oplsaa +580,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,8,320.0,0.9864132917816666,0.0074960313856051375,spce +581,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,1,320.0,0.9869752307003042,0.008147395565909776,spce +582,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,15,450.0,0.6991447879249999,0.01416678102215295,benzene-ua +583,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,3,372.0,0.5164041453724669,0.013230098250925512,trappe-ua +584,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,10,320.0,0.7725798686091784,0.008320640419673144,oplsaa +585,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,11,280.0,0.8103409564544594,0.006383655832243325,oplsaa +586,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,2,320.0,0.9878375358791667,0.008177549828040798,spce +587,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,13,280.0,0.8151797777091666,0.006335857962838295,oplsaa +588,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,3,300.0,0.7953530373417679,0.007221814600832896,oplsaa +589,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,8,320.0,0.7730793602901435,0.010765488123424894,oplsaa +590,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,11,372.0,0.5403839281442501,0.011401018638311236,trappe-ua +591,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,7,320.0,0.9862121363650286,0.007987748569333916,spce +592,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,8,450.0,0.6992663500195194,0.01356791305956228,benzene-ua +593,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,11,320.0,0.9868541175564342,0.007920847184315809,spce +594,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,13,320.0,0.76801707298,0.00829423456610005,oplsaa +595,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,10,140.0,0.37558520826389763,0.004424034514207391,trappe-ua +596,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,15,320.0,0.9865414279020833,0.0067053114847073604,spce +597,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,0,280.0,0.8130617130422907,0.0065270848191607105,oplsaa +598,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,6,280.0,0.81382947635,0.006508639167306392,oplsaa +599,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,8,372.0,0.5430219978116253,0.011842479724105268,trappe-ua +600,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,5,320.0,0.7666089339775833,0.008162723444735199,oplsaa +601,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,12,320.0,0.7737410780301586,0.007357552933449122,oplsaa +602,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,10,372.0,0.5409719219820833,0.011146191775024851,trappe-ua +603,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,8,280.0,0.8121252127253955,0.006791816032344079,oplsaa +604,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,8,320.0,0.9873374548787495,0.00703092725795552,spce +605,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,8,140.0,0.376029003570892,0.004447176146719467,trappe-ua +606,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,1,300.0,0.7923304148813334,0.00666825707791062,oplsaa +607,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,7,300.0,0.7951868060480237,0.0071224321660525594,oplsaa +608,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,3,300.0,0.9979000949783264,0.007795169841173322,spce +609,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,0,280.0,1.0085648553524167,0.006382679541475166,spce +610,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,10,280.0,0.8137685589880833,0.006057209705485861,oplsaa +611,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,5,300.0,0.7902697635266668,0.006953139615166792,oplsaa +612,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,4,320.0,0.9856235029125,0.008520453418962069,spce +613,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,15,320.0,0.984917314909346,0.007404004185626328,spce +614,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,2,300.0,0.7914398209433333,0.007716457134299562,oplsaa +615,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,2,280.0,1.0086950778517896,0.00781395263367265,spce +616,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,10,372.0,0.5422942145805855,0.012430765090963762,trappe-ua +617,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,6,372.0,0.5410575892857142,0.01254520540286468,trappe-ua +618,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,15,320.0,0.9875941432074999,0.007050082482682396,spce +619,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,2,320.0,0.9859455995832228,0.007754460050908088,spce +620,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,0,372.0,0.5415014061073204,0.01350183131985751,trappe-ua +621,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,4,140.0,0.3759904053405091,0.004430777688465354,trappe-ua +622,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,11,280.0,0.8162145892125001,0.006645869054838621,oplsaa +623,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,14,300.0,0.7923214867650485,0.006997825401853089,oplsaa +624,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,0,280.0,0.8131447807275001,0.006258672596336346,oplsaa +625,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,7,280.0,0.8142574091945429,0.006670490711967538,oplsaa +626,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,15,280.0,0.8122662816795452,0.006860429405045365,oplsaa +627,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,2,280.0,0.8145847386696295,0.006611031649074609,oplsaa +628,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,6,372.0,0.5410876865299167,0.011365444821594956,trappe-ua +629,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,8,280.0,1.006943578974202,0.007590653006623958,spce +630,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,6,320.0,0.7735293058141225,0.010742822809210923,oplsaa +631,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,5,280.0,1.004723115182564,0.007288614044011062,spce +632,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,2,140.0,0.37578525619558334,0.0037873761856411147,trappe-ua +633,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,11,280.0,0.816775449022456,0.008684185464191632,oplsaa +634,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,3,320.0,0.9855467827045372,0.006839654661539259,spce +635,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,14,320.0,0.7678897578542501,0.00744891875457162,oplsaa +636,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,5,450.0,0.698167279806753,0.014429295970539772,benzene-ua +637,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,11,300.0,1.0000846780521666,0.006373067888040589,spce +638,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,13,372.0,0.5422645670308696,0.010975543663794156,trappe-ua +639,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,10,320.0,0.9858812338739167,0.00768856283695592,spce +640,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,13,280.0,1.0076895375425,0.008394703504850408,spce +641,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,15,300.0,0.9977355128600064,0.007590681004790542,spce +642,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,2,140.0,0.37610047706052496,0.004445333017097113,trappe-ua +643,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,7,140.0,0.375551679835,0.004527566818796106,trappe-ua +644,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,6,280.0,1.0065554048219045,0.007740176684471612,spce +645,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,5,372.0,0.5422206894119064,0.011637225024949955,trappe-ua +646,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,14,140.0,0.37594815584335506,0.004477140295665294,trappe-ua +647,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,4,450.0,0.6978600145683738,0.014695286684963272,benzene-ua +648,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,1,300.0,0.99717434876,0.007304709305721152,spce +649,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,4,280.0,1.00558388197775,0.0065941968868314825,spce +650,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,13,320.0,0.7684699830479167,0.007094970424679121,oplsaa +651,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,13,280.0,1.0087080280270628,0.007046096098743166,spce +652,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,4,280.0,0.8157873092054018,0.007121351881117174,oplsaa +653,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,5,372.0,0.5406647302320833,0.011801638958479403,trappe-ua +654,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,15,300.0,0.7951136260629863,0.00606605786670879,oplsaa +655,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,4,450.0,0.6970589963865832,0.012798142644230064,benzene-ua +656,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,1,280.0,1.0065490110964277,0.007287152950416752,spce +657,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,3,320.0,0.7674184783725001,0.008030435991462886,oplsaa +658,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,15,300.0,0.9969455988866667,0.006788159091798569,spce +659,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,6,140.0,0.37600354369074995,0.0037539277460459765,trappe-ua +660,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,2,450.0,0.699154406989242,0.0140004772995371,benzene-ua +661,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,5,140.0,0.37596020293183374,0.004446095196589535,trappe-ua +662,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,13,320.0,0.7669410093583905,0.007906341132893681,oplsaa +663,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,11,140.0,0.37600832438409554,0.0045226567629944436,trappe-ua +664,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,8,320.0,0.7718317630475129,0.007885672625123647,oplsaa +665,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,6,320.0,0.7721288336519194,0.007677087470857117,oplsaa +666,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,6,280.0,0.8162833028353468,0.006776778621561033,oplsaa +667,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,12,320.0,0.7735422113896845,0.010847954608562572,oplsaa +668,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,10,320.0,0.9863013913702402,0.00787560581483044,spce +669,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,2,300.0,0.7958612557703635,0.007362508951016322,oplsaa +670,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,0,280.0,0.8153966322364804,0.00568562575289687,oplsaa +671,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,1,450.0,0.6994650150781666,0.01272902978057565,benzene-ua +672,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,0,280.0,1.0069781542098406,0.00722743681817426,spce +673,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,methaneUA,1,140.0,0.37575686219591664,0.003907937462065398,trappe-ua +674,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,9,280.0,0.8134449957166668,0.006690706905202126,oplsaa +675,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,9,320.0,0.7735514007323239,0.010573634299280715,oplsaa +676,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,9,280.0,1.0064419953128847,0.007264019108924244,spce +677,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,6,280.0,1.0077109362980556,0.0069149949170860345,spce +678,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,14,280.0,1.0032869390346733,0.006891782466315203,spce +679,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,3,320.0,0.9863367165278956,0.007925435183641796,spce +680,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,2,300.0,0.9990417438232034,0.00767077108179381,spce +681,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,0,300.0,0.7953302684219222,0.009150973031654698,oplsaa +682,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,2,320.0,0.7718769277985144,0.007812010608054679,oplsaa +683,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,11,320.0,0.9852332833199999,0.006907201893428938,spce +684,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,11,300.0,0.9968649534442376,0.007347108678639971,spce +685,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,15,140.0,0.37603593729878515,0.004810395719748191,trappe-ua +686,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,8,300.0,0.9978565923339844,0.007434176076645401,spce +687,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,15,372.0,0.5353929313818614,0.0229833213438208,trappe-ua +688,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,4,372.0,0.540822581488,0.011007581687299556,trappe-ua +689,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,9,300.0,0.7956255694378863,0.009906950349109407,oplsaa +690,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,8,320.0,0.7703281397675,0.007519827679323895,oplsaa +691,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,11,320.0,0.9862173314083108,0.008199670844903138,spce +692,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,7,300.0,1.0008742309408332,0.007026912526833037,spce +693,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,1,320.0,0.9864670722167969,0.008437640877631318,spce +694,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,14,372.0,0.5177885119127489,0.013221365252402851,trappe-ua +695,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,2,140.0,0.37594837476287063,0.004420723152718282,trappe-ua +696,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,14,320.0,0.7697446257533334,0.007587007318216773,oplsaa +697,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,13,320.0,0.7735091064617745,0.007777640752802039,oplsaa +698,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,8,280.0,1.0065988910546937,0.007365812072017833,spce +699,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,15,450.0,0.6995986759892544,0.013778419749406445,benzene-ua +700,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,2,280.0,1.0048504719137499,0.006379142389570026,spce +701,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,8,280.0,0.8146528524148415,0.006739487573703058,oplsaa +702,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,9,320.0,0.7692882571458334,0.007887915020583296,oplsaa +703,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,2,280.0,0.8167944277512809,0.008630727710900305,oplsaa +704,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,12,300.0,0.7954067346584388,0.010140930106391187,oplsaa +705,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,3,320.0,0.7722383510546883,0.007875489435290657,oplsaa +706,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,5,280.0,1.0057556494466666,0.0066756881242458965,spce +707,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,8,372.0,0.5415484530027117,0.012122997960091812,trappe-ua +708,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,11,280.0,1.0059813019320334,0.007791930139383405,spce +709,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,8,450.0,0.6990535581359166,0.01256370809742108,benzene-ua +710,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,10,300.0,0.9963947751258332,0.007290564377803033,spce +711,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,8,320.0,0.76798310769125,0.007185476078432684,oplsaa +712,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,4,300.0,0.998953649413,0.006442499081110856,spce +713,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,12,372.0,0.5419801383952247,0.011608398837888785,trappe-ua +714,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,1,450.0,0.6974403748584906,0.01438753577112739,benzene-ua +715,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,9,280.0,1.0072453630816665,0.005737288147605053,spce +716,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,0,280.0,1.0065872720555327,0.00730377721526939,spce +717,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,9,280.0,0.8161486822590157,0.008925205519450547,oplsaa +718,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,2,372.0,0.5414806063535709,0.012015909071329349,trappe-ua +719,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,5,300.0,0.7955808391987522,0.0073778368179550635,oplsaa +720,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,14,280.0,0.8130875343027292,0.006119080636785454,oplsaa +721,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,6,372.0,0.5344006298791246,0.022106752369030782,trappe-ua +722,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,0,450.0,0.6994948431933333,0.013602031521625322,benzene-ua +723,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,9,300.0,0.7916185291308334,0.007320356368805502,oplsaa +724,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,12,280.0,0.8178587194303968,0.00629777349172945,oplsaa +725,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,12,300.0,0.7926596721121894,0.007176982373313664,oplsaa +726,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,9,300.0,0.997857382418763,0.007543380220679017,spce +727,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,15,300.0,0.7916049825851498,0.007388773127790932,oplsaa +728,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,7,280.0,1.0074087050387501,0.005368799957904784,spce +729,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,12,300.0,0.7923055005983333,0.007205545763139161,oplsaa +730,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,12,280.0,0.8148081020029168,0.005846557819083378,oplsaa +731,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,7,320.0,0.98638174375,0.00760102979170911,spce +732,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,9,320.0,0.7690770267892362,0.007719487042658682,oplsaa +733,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,4,320.0,0.7680317650779167,0.007711332433525779,oplsaa +734,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,2,280.0,0.8157786315106779,0.006466227361942088,oplsaa +735,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,9,280.0,0.8166463807311646,0.006758642772310501,oplsaa +736,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,11,280.0,1.0092366902361667,0.0059821693339777255,spce +737,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,15,372.0,0.5408595045012778,0.011838809623408095,trappe-ua +738,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,13,140.0,0.37591447513134274,0.004471567522723255,trappe-ua +739,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,4,372.0,0.54177088648,0.011748052485546888,trappe-ua +740,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,11,320.0,0.7730220859529398,0.007957833831782741,oplsaa +741,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,14,140.0,0.3756717497783334,0.004494563669258968,trappe-ua +742,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,12,450.0,0.6993492619482427,0.013673631547893902,benzene-ua +743,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,7,320.0,0.9877806163475,0.007815804160769414,spce +744,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,11,300.0,0.9979852792335919,0.0075036969946214345,spce +745,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,9,320.0,0.9864611456605394,0.00783097306772355,spce +746,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,0,300.0,0.9975858592167341,0.0075259958153896765,spce +747,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,9,450.0,0.6999297281830833,0.012994506853120504,benzene-ua +748,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,4,140.0,0.3759395656325,0.004501848396972579,trappe-ua +749,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,11,372.0,0.5418143372530246,0.012159474995904855,trappe-ua +750,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,10,320.0,0.7686292744308333,0.007771543833596907,oplsaa +751,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,14,280.0,0.8131678767091667,0.006806595799732622,oplsaa +752,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,11,140.0,0.37588496196480176,0.004480619327745281,trappe-ua +753,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,7,300.0,0.7920408581316666,0.00735161969895814,oplsaa +754,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,13,280.0,0.8142750324042576,0.00666243892212281,oplsaa +755,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,14,280.0,1.00664588478284,0.007559084046712463,spce +756,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,12,280.0,0.8124716861369451,0.006524604220322466,oplsaa +757,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,6,450.0,0.697855375873209,0.014401830581255201,benzene-ua +758,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,11,280.0,1.006905895275959,0.007214583470385788,spce +759,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,2,300.0,0.7945732315508264,0.0072574913685926,oplsaa +760,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,10,140.0,0.37591562950219815,0.004470199241926525,trappe-ua +761,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,11,300.0,0.9977082022460938,0.007630760888266147,spce +762,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,9,300.0,0.9982129386399504,0.008459949290421638,spce +763,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,14,450.0,0.6966730879045792,0.01339554464043353,benzene-ua +764,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,3,450.0,0.6993213888484167,0.013047509113014312,benzene-ua +765,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,14,300.0,0.9965981137516666,0.006394929172423464,spce +766,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,8,372.0,0.5318274878563819,0.02343758016525732,trappe-ua +767,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,15,280.0,1.006528671195,0.005543448268481551,spce +768,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,6,320.0,0.7669607030134166,0.007937359914543293,oplsaa +769,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,13,320.0,0.9861700052045843,0.007989115164344232,spce +770,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,0,320.0,0.9863956380371095,0.008085499441095476,spce +771,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,14,320.0,0.771114344671691,0.005467588855999571,oplsaa +772,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,13,372.0,0.5172699248367948,0.013069471932818167,trappe-ua +773,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,13,140.0,0.37592282989424114,0.004421915037827521,trappe-ua +774,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,13,280.0,0.8167905316677305,0.006759816280620231,oplsaa +775,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,11,372.0,0.5413429934669798,0.012017474260770069,trappe-ua +776,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,13,300.0,0.7919298483902123,0.00692416253566258,oplsaa +777,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,3,280.0,1.0069867591600001,0.007060391213400274,spce +778,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,0,300.0,0.9978406075619748,0.0076577653482634,spce +779,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,4,140.0,0.3759107013590954,0.00450246787195913,trappe-ua +780,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,11,372.0,0.5418508241331423,0.01191837321236019,trappe-ua +781,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,11,300.0,0.7911897589405835,0.006506431830786075,oplsaa +782,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,benzeneUA,5,450.0,0.7049361904568143,0.020835163326602475,benzene-ua +783,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,4,280.0,1.0067065560905435,0.007285825656426089,spce +784,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,4,280.0,0.8117539980091666,0.006135062171159806,oplsaa +785,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,12,320.0,0.7704575499924999,0.008001961729044965,oplsaa +786,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,4,300.0,0.7958988156738281,0.009873039092474488,oplsaa +787,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,10,280.0,0.816406681232913,0.006481578620518244,oplsaa +788,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,13,320.0,0.7717863366226114,0.007791765028751822,oplsaa +789,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,1,140.0,0.3757613549621584,0.004385919240993131,trappe-ua +790,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,8,140.0,0.37551142773999996,0.004459083567311608,trappe-ua +791,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,12,320.0,0.9861588421002444,0.007828483270865598,spce +792,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,0,320.0,0.9861306269529955,0.007787041709608744,spce +793,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,1,140.0,0.37590609987613843,0.004464185529028196,trappe-ua +794,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,4,372.0,0.5418679826710294,0.011770237743931346,trappe-ua +795,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,2,140.0,0.3757274821665425,0.0045353804243167565,trappe-ua +796,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,7,280.0,0.8112717878500001,0.0064052048513826565,oplsaa +797,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,11,280.0,0.8094166237580833,0.006015903921957159,oplsaa +798,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,5,372.0,0.5416167326677871,0.011890481766921923,trappe-ua +799,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,4,280.0,0.8156018692423255,0.006775535385531124,oplsaa +800,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,2,280.0,1.0069502736044265,0.007132502249790056,spce +801,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,12,280.0,1.0067031590332032,0.007780283845039483,spce +802,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,8,280.0,0.813550890707,0.0060891946582719535,oplsaa +803,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,5,300.0,0.7936852701825369,0.0072734252760878184,oplsaa +804,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,4,320.0,0.9856009637319321,0.0071817575495459595,spce +805,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,8,300.0,0.9979152874085643,0.007640322715184304,spce +806,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,5,320.0,0.9867807803854166,0.006635797558091795,spce +807,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,ethanolAA,0,300.0,0.7908200466058334,0.006947755793544675,oplsaa +808,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,13,300.0,0.9982713174383334,0.006530466638132573,spce +809,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,1,372.0,0.5417154641683999,0.011745451275519875,trappe-ua +810,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,2,300.0,0.9971180573983334,0.007571524134150873,spce +811,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,12,320.0,0.7723526918459425,0.007769742389784054,oplsaa +812,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,2,450.0,0.6978925556189023,0.01488078174874399,benzene-ua +813,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,ethanolAA,1,320.0,0.7690643395149184,0.008077567946086068,oplsaa +814,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,5,372.0,0.5415657786768359,0.011954191029036663,trappe-ua +815,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,6,140.0,0.3760308378729022,0.004411409360282824,trappe-ua +816,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,13,372.0,0.5401617952675001,0.012080325756817207,trappe-ua +817,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,15,300.0,0.7900365734375,0.007101465070971194,oplsaa +818,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,10,320.0,0.986289200305557,0.007693733851959342,spce +819,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,10,280.0,1.0067277737312617,0.007373761899992628,spce +820,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,10,140.0,0.37603661989622444,0.004611573599548937,trappe-ua +821,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,8,300.0,0.9978957926466666,0.007246307426147069,spce +822,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,benzeneUA,4,450.0,0.6990951686344749,0.0136985541748159,benzene-ua +823,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,7,140.0,0.37603541668902385,0.00440179495122477,trappe-ua +824,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,2,140.0,0.3754438775883333,0.004641094528030489,trappe-ua +825,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,11,300.0,0.7913209644612619,0.006661665371586362,oplsaa +826,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,7,300.0,0.7956621350712246,0.009500661990911138,oplsaa +827,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,benzeneUA,12,450.0,0.6974881800866667,0.013715946430707138,benzene-ua +828,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,methaneUA,14,140.0,0.3760690195857137,0.004350930575829324,trappe-ua +829,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,7,450.0,0.6984179880432168,0.013843999054828292,benzene-ua +830,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,11,450.0,0.6995245285964167,0.012431142569102495,benzene-ua +831,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,8,300.0,0.9958648374141666,0.007259248338712633,spce +832,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,9,280.0,1.0081117118825522,0.00635924361344938,spce +833,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,15,320.0,0.7737614134433825,0.011039935170492003,oplsaa +834,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,methaneUA,4,140.0,0.3761201631097119,0.004473924387835528,trappe-ua +835,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,1,320.0,0.9862810328648334,0.006917999789602906,spce +836,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,15,280.0,0.8151265090441667,0.006183241771026139,oplsaa +837,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,7,372.0,0.5406500511929608,0.012451133201600267,trappe-ua +838,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,benzeneUA,4,450.0,0.697235391056398,0.0144014878637692,benzene-ua +839,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,13,372.0,0.5422233689228827,0.010907302821074782,trappe-ua +840,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,2,372.0,0.541206320445,0.012200984600943314,trappe-ua +841,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,12,372.0,0.5171071925241328,0.013065014450195762,trappe-ua +842,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,10,372.0,0.5425569344272803,0.011881319975542976,trappe-ua +843,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,14,300.0,0.7911542848533333,0.0069321985344406286,oplsaa +844,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,14,320.0,0.9860236744096794,0.007880049895046311,spce +845,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,5,372.0,0.5177284752981403,0.013106949561819112,trappe-ua +846,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,5,320.0,0.7738185653686523,0.011022770765343326,oplsaa +847,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,12,450.0,0.6977337563429048,0.014406855223721237,benzene-ua +848,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,methaneUA,9,140.0,0.3755330090591667,0.0044943725866549225,trappe-ua +849,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,10,280.0,1.0069786079871788,0.0073900978551079115,spce +850,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,7,300.0,0.9966529398876668,0.007384250450179614,spce +851,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,0,320.0,0.9858620908148333,0.00665041865701658,spce +852,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,6,320.0,0.9862234869446826,0.00788753216218063,spce +853,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,benzeneUA,13,450.0,0.6991593008645,0.012225775080712183,benzene-ua +854,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,ethanolAA,12,320.0,0.7673244306541964,0.007434864816514634,oplsaa +855,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,10,450.0,0.6985820812301342,0.013499777140983573,benzene-ua +856,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,9,280.0,1.0086945271040832,0.006040646196191828,spce +857,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,14,320.0,0.774085197124513,0.008110309613495693,oplsaa +858,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,6,280.0,1.0045740705189168,0.007208292750293378,spce +859,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,11,280.0,0.8156620453996208,0.0066532390090879075,oplsaa +860,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,0,320.0,0.9877909910333335,0.00844863003805165,spce +861,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,3,300.0,0.9977645997863708,0.0075625466927353325,spce +862,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,methaneUA,3,140.0,0.37600154714060346,0.004333925086611504,trappe-ua +863,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,14,280.0,1.0065807193563066,0.007230131820168812,spce +864,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,methaneUA,9,140.0,0.37596484289558874,0.004459901308959986,trappe-ua +865,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,benzeneUA,8,450.0,0.6972902939439799,0.013888524213779615,benzene-ua +866,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,12,320.0,0.9868125940716667,0.007282151520928618,spce +867,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,9,300.0,1.0014169668275,0.00751946918939084,spce +868,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,12,280.0,1.0074296680654204,0.0074685679851110185,spce +869,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,2,372.0,0.5416883111334466,0.012814938231782837,trappe-ua +870,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,6,300.0,0.7953123145961363,0.009261391430074843,oplsaa +871,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,12,372.0,0.5415355195635146,0.010594220027621554,trappe-ua +872,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,10,320.0,0.98786798296719,0.007428463459725297,spce +873,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,0,372.0,0.5399878586216666,0.011981435954573497,trappe-ua +874,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,6,320.0,0.7735832144345469,0.00787427061685085,oplsaa +875,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,11,300.0,0.7957597323403903,0.007490821848282488,oplsaa +876,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,3,320.0,0.7734236114208515,0.010399028185077725,oplsaa +877,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,11,320.0,0.9862186127672562,0.00784632642188575,spce +878,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,15,280.0,1.006765840313812,0.007026731788947236,spce +879,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,waterSPCE,2,320.0,0.9862742962436356,0.007811581971044455,spce +880,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,7,300.0,0.9978180897454958,0.007613634252325907,spce +881,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,14,372.0,0.5337384383678435,0.020334651650073636,trappe-ua +882,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,0,280.0,0.8166727674560547,0.009112707288534807,oplsaa +883,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,4,372.0,0.5422990620813933,0.01120787833759586,trappe-ua +884,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,ethanolAA,8,300.0,0.7955543220740807,0.010195874204255826,oplsaa +885,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,waterSPCE,9,300.0,0.9976323666371488,0.0076002456068711725,spce +886,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,11,372.0,0.5341181621601054,0.02145768280403366,trappe-ua +887,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,waterSPCE,4,320.0,0.9865380604990422,0.007816415041526656,spce +888,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,pentaneUA-constrain_bonds,1,372.0,0.540638173800088,0.012222063236672222,trappe-ua +889,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,ethanolAA,1,300.0,0.7920879047183335,0.007390358337742578,oplsaa +890,MoSDeF,MC,cassandra,waterSPCE,3,320.0,0.9863630509766668,0.006930322434781415,spce +891,MoSDeF,MD,hoomd,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,11,372.0,0.5165185205869622,0.013073428917694674,trappe-ua +892,MoSDeF,MC,mcccs,waterSPCE,6,320.0,0.9859111821605212,0.00726518800491578,spce +893,MoSDeF,MC,gomc,waterSPCE,6,300.0,0.9964185068468334,0.007505208651035612,spce +894,MoSDeF,MD,lammps-VU,ethanolAA,5,280.0,0.8160442707855227,0.006878367267176579,oplsaa +895,MoSDeF,MD,gromacs,pentaneUA-flexible_bonds,1,372.0,0.5342033739884694,0.02036168371305065,trappe-ua diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..65ab2de3 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..323c2a55 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..7f27a718 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4a6f0c86 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCandMD_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..f03527b4 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..6370f60e Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..7ad2d9fb Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..3901e2b3 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_associated_work_MCorMD_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..20697911 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..86222b97 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1a7733f4 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d21ce576 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCandMD_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..24d0e8de Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0c065b4f Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..9d3cba0a Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c3cfa708 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_ff-mol_MCorMD_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..aa8e6043 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_avg_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..20f7033a Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_avg_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0ca4244a Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0b0b1ec3 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCandMD_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..971af074 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_avg_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ad686d19 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_avg_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_scatter.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_scatter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..3b7180cd Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_scatter.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..700a7f04 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Combined/combined_forcefield_MCorMD_violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/Grouped-Comparison-violin.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/Grouped-Comparison-violin.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4cb3eb3a Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/Grouped-Comparison-violin.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/MoSDeF-ff-mol-False-violin-True_MoSDeF-ff-mol-False-violin-False_MoSDeF-ff-mol-True-violin-False.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/MoSDeF-ff-mol-False-violin-True_MoSDeF-ff-mol-False-violin-False_MoSDeF-ff-mol-True-violin-False.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4dc96cef Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/MoSDeF-ff-mol-False-violin-True_MoSDeF-ff-mol-False-violin-False_MoSDeF-ff-mol-True-violin-False.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/backup-discussion-fig1.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/backup-discussion-fig1.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..6fe9430f Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/backup-discussion-fig1.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/combined-ff-mol-True-scatter-False-45-False_combined-ff-mol-False-scatter-False-45-False.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/combined-ff-mol-True-scatter-False-45-False_combined-ff-mol-False-scatter-False-45-False.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..613cb960 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/combined-ff-mol-True-scatter-False-45-False_combined-ff-mol-False-scatter-False-45-False.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/combined-ff-mol-True-violin-False-45-False_combined-ff-mol-False-violin-False-45-False.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/combined-ff-mol-True-violin-False-45-False_combined-ff-mol-False-violin-False-45-False.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5ff55f01 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/combined-ff-mol-True-violin-False-45-False_combined-ff-mol-False-violin-False-45-False.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/molecule_stack-combined.pdf b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/molecule_stack-combined.pdf new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1bd6cb61 Binary files /dev/null and b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/figures/Stacked_Figures/molecule_stack-combined.pdf differ diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_comparison_plots.py b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_comparison_plots.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..c5384065 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_comparison_plots.py @@ -0,0 +1,1063 @@ +"""Functionality to generate figure plots to compare MoSDeF to RR relative errors.""" +import warnings + +warnings.filterwarnings("ignore") +import copy +import os +import re +import shutil +from collections import Counter + +# Plot settings and imports +import matplotlib +import matplotlib.pyplot as plt +import numpy as np +import pandas as pd +import seaborn as sns + +matplotlib.use("pdf") +import matplotlib.gridspec as gridspec +import matplotlib.ticker as mtick +import numpy as np +from matplotlib import rc +from matplotlib.ticker import ( + AutoMinorLocator, + FormatStrFormatter, + MaxNLocator, + MultipleLocator, + NullFormatter, + ScalarFormatter, + StrMethodFormatter, +) + +rc("font", **{"family": "serif", "serif": ["Times"]}) +rc("text", usetex=True) + +# plot settings +ms = 8 # markersize +xtickfs = 15 # xtickfontsize +xlabelfs = 18 # xlabelfontsize +ylabelfs = 20 # ylabelfontsize +ytickfs = 14 # ytickfontsize +titlefs = 14 # title size +legendfs = 9 +alpha = 0.2 + + +# equation to calculate RE for a pandas series +def _calculate_relative_error(ser): + dataArray = ser.to_numpy() + mean = np.nanmean(dataArray) + return (dataArray - mean) / mean * 100 + + +# 2 Load RR data +def _read_rr_csv(model): + df = pd.read_csv(f"csvs/{model}_data.csv", index_col=0) + pressure = float(model.split(" ")[3]) + df.insert(len(df.columns) - 2, "pressure", np.full(len(df.index), pressure)) + return df + + +# 4 filter RR data +def _filter_rr_data(df, model, remove_MC=True): + keep_labelsList = ["Program(Group)", "T / K", "ρ / kg m−3", "pressure"] + new_labelsList = ["engine", "temperature", "density", "pressure"] + df = df[keep_labelsList] + df.columns = new_labelsList + MCList = ["TOWHEE(BS)", "Ind.MC(PB)" "ms2*(KL)"] + + n_rows = len(df.index) + df.insert(1, "replicate", np.full(n_rows, 0), True) + df.insert(4, "density-std", np.full(n_rows, 0.0), True) + df.insert(5, "forcefield", np.full(n_rows, model.split()[0]), True) + df.insert(1, "molecule", np.full(n_rows, model.split()[1]), True) + df.insert(0, "associated_work", np.full(n_rows, "RR"), True) + df.insert( + 1, + "MCorMD", + list(map(lambda x: "MC" if x in MCList else "MD", df["engine"])), + ) + + return df + + +def _load_all_rr_data(): + rr_moleculeList = [ + "OPLS Ethane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS Ethane at 41 MPa", + "OPLS Ethane at 70 MPa", + "TraPPE Ethane at 5 MPa", + "TraPPE Ethane at 41 MPa", + "TraPPE Ethane at 70 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 5 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 41 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 70 MPa", + "OPLS Propane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS Propane at 41 MPa", + "OPLS Propane at 70 MPa", + "TraPPE Propane at 5 MPa", + "TraPPE Propane at 41 MPa", + "TraPPE Propane at 70 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 5 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 41 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 70 MPa", + "OPLS n-Butane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS n-Butane at 41 MPa", + "OPLS n-Butane at 70 MPa", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 5 MPa", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 41 MPa", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 70 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 5 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 41 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 70 MPa", + "OPLS iso-Butane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS iso-Butane at 41 MPa", + "OPLS iso-Butane at 70 MPa", + "TraPPE iso-Butane at 5 MPa", + "TraPPE iso-Butane at 41 MPa", + "TraPPE iso-Butane at 70 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 5 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 41 MPa", + "OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 70 MPa", + ] + hasse_dfList = [] + for molecule in rr_moleculeList: + hasseDF = _read_rr_csv(molecule) + hasse_dfList.append(_filter_rr_data(hasseDF, molecule, remove_MC=False)) + return hasse_dfList + + +def _mask_df(df): + # mask = ((df["molecule"] == "Ethane") & (df["forcefield"] == "TraPPE") #testing masks to check for outliers + # & (df["temperature"] == 298.0) & (df["engine"] == "ms2(KL)") + # & (df["pressure"] == 5) + # ) + # df = df[~mask] + mask = (df["molecule"] == "Ethane") & (df["engine"] == "ms2(KL)") + df = df[~mask] + mask = (df["molecule"] == "Ethane") & (df["engine"] == "GROMACS(KL)") + df = df[~mask] + # mask = ((df["molecule"] == "Ethane") & (df["forcefield"] == "TraPPE") + # & (df["temperature"] == 298.0) & (df["engine"] == "GROMACS(KL)") + # & (df["pressure"] == 5) + # ) + df = df[~mask] + df = df[ + ~( + (df["temperature"] == 298.0) + & (df["forcefield"] == "OPLSAMBER") + & (df["molecule"] == "Ethane") + ) + ] + df = df[~(df["molecule"] == "pentaneUA-flexible_bonds")] + df = df[~((df["engine"] == "gromacs") & (df["molecule"] == "benzeneUA"))] + + return df + + +def _transform_ff_names(df): + df["forcefield"] = df["forcefield"].transform( + lambda x: "TraPPE" if "ua" in x else x + ) + df["forcefield"] = df["forcefield"].transform( + lambda x: x.upper() if x == "oplsaa" else x + ) + df["forcefield"] = df["forcefield"].transform( + lambda x: "SPC/E" if x == "spce" else x + ) + df["ff-mol"] = df[["molecule", "forcefield"]].agg("-".join, axis=1) + df["ff-mol"] = df["ff-mol"].transform( + lambda x: re.sub("([a-zA-Z])", lambda y: y.groups()[0].upper(), x, 1) + if "Butane" not in x + else x + ) + + +def _sort_plotting_labels(df, x_label, y_label): + # Prepare colors + sortmolDict = { + "Ethane": 0, + "Propane": 1, + "n-Butane": 2, + "iso-Butane": 3, + "methaneUA": 4, + "pentaneUA-constrain_bonds": 5, + "pentaneUA-flexible_bonds": 9, + "benzeneUA": 6, + "waterSPCE": 7, + "ethanolAA": 8, + } + sortffmolDict = { + "Ethane-TraPPE": 1, + "Propane-TraPPE": 2, + "n-Butane-TraPPE": 3, + "iso-Butane-TraPPE": 4, + "Ethane-OPLS": 5, + "Propane-OPLS": 6, + "n-Butane-OPLS": 7, + "iso-Butane-OPLS": 8, + "Ethane-OPLSAMBER": 9, + "Propane-OPLSAMBER": 10, + "n-Butane-OPLSAMBER": 11, + "iso-Butane-OPLSAMBER": 12, + "MethaneUA-TraPPE": 13, + "PentaneUA-constrain_bonds-TraPPE": 14, + "BenzeneUA-TraPPE": 16, + "WaterSPCE-SPC/E": 17, + "EthanolAA-OPLSAA": 18, + } + if x_label == "molecule": + df["sortedindex"] = df["molecule"].apply( + func=lambda x: sortmolDict.get(x) + ) + elif x_label == "ff-mol": + df["sortedindex"] = df[x_label].apply( + func=lambda x: sortffmolDict.get(x) + ) + df = df.sort_values(by=["sortedindex"], ascending=True).copy() + color_labels = list(Counter(df[x_label].to_numpy()).keys()) + palette = sns.color_palette("colorblind", n_colors=len(color_labels)) + color_map = dict(zip(color_labels, palette)) + + xtick_labelsList = copy.deepcopy(color_labels) + for i in range(len(color_labels)): + for filter_label in [ + "AA", + "SPCE", + "UA", + "-constrain_bonds", + "-flexible_bonds", + ]: + if filter_label in color_labels[i]: + xtick_labelsList[i] = xtick_labelsList[i].replace( + filter_label, "" + ) + return color_labels, xtick_labelsList, color_map + + +def _plot_params(color_labels): + """Generate summary plots for the aggregate project.""" + fig, ax = plt.subplots( + 1, + 1, + sharex=False, + sharey=False, + figsize=(len(color_labels) * 0.5 + 3, 4), + ) + trans = plt.gca().transData + x_ticks = np.arange(len(color_labels)) + ax.set_xticks(x_ticks) + ax.set_axisbelow(True) + ax.grid(visible=True, which="major", axis="y", alpha=0.5, color="gray") + ax.set_xticks([], minor=True) + ax.set_yticks([], minor=True) + + return fig, ax + + +def _plot_scatter(df, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label): + x_ticks = np.arange(len(color_labels)) + for i, molecule in enumerate(color_labels): + series = df.loc[df[x_label] == molecule][y_label] + ydata = series[series.notnull()] + if len(x_ticks) > 1: + spread = (x_ticks[1] - x_ticks[0]) * 0.25 + else: + spread = 0.25 + offsets = np.linspace(-1 * spread, spread, len(ydata)) + xdata = np.full(len(ydata), x_ticks[i]) + offsets + ax.scatter( + x=xdata, + y=ydata, + color=color_map[molecule], + label=molecule, + s=np.full(len(ydata.index), 50), + edgecolors="black", + marker="o", + alpha=0.6, + ) + # ax.axvline(x=6.5, linestyle="--", color="k") + + +def _plot_violin(df, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label): + x_ticks = np.arange(len(color_labels)) + for i, molecule in enumerate(color_labels): + series = df.loc[df[x_label] == molecule][y_label] + ydata = series[series.notnull()] + if len(x_ticks) > 1: + spread = (x_ticks[1] - x_ticks[0]) * 0.25 + else: + spread = 0.25 + print( + f"Maximum deviation is: {max(abs(ydata)):.2f} for molecule {color_labels[i]}" + ) + offsets = np.linspace(-1 * spread, spread, len(ydata)) + xdata = np.full(len(ydata), x_ticks[i]) + offsets + ax.violinplot([ydata], positions=[i], showextrema=True) + + +def _plot_box(df, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label): + x_ticks = np.arange(len(color_labels)) + for i, molecule in enumerate(color_labels): + series = df.loc[df[x_label] == molecule][y_label] + ydata = series[series.notnull()] + if len(x_ticks) > 1: + spread = (x_ticks[1] - x_ticks[0]) * 0.25 + else: + spread = 0.25 + offsets = np.linspace(-1 * spread, spread, len(ydata)) + xdata = np.full(len(ydata), x_ticks[i]) + offsets + ax.boxplot([ydata], positions=[i]) + + +import textwrap + + +def _wrap_labels(ax, width, break_long_words=False, rotation=45): + labels = [] + for label in ax.get_xticklabels(): + text = label.get_text() + labels.append( + textwrap.fill(text, width=width, break_long_words=break_long_words) + ) + if rotation > 0: + ax.set_xticklabels( + labels, + rotation_mode="anchor", + rotation=rotation, + ha="right", + size=xtickfs, + ) + else: + ax.set_xticklabels( + labels, + rotation_mode="anchor", + rotation=rotation, + ha="center", + size=xtickfs, + ) + + +def _general_plot_formatting( + df, + ax, + splitby, + figdir, + combMCMD, + xtick_labelsList, + color_labels, + average_replicas, + ymax=None, + rotation=0, + wrap_labels=True, +): + # tick params + ax.tick_params(axis="y", labelsize=ytickfs) + ax.tick_params(axis="x", labelsize=xtickfs) + ax.set_xlim([-0.5, len(color_labels) - 0.5]) + if ymax is None: + maxy = max(np.abs(df["Relative_Error"])) * 1.05 + else: + maxy = ymax + ax.set_ylim([-maxy, maxy]) + ax.yaxis.set_major_locator(plt.MaxNLocator(3)) + x_ticks = np.arange(len(color_labels)) + ax.set_xticks(x_ticks) + ax.set_axisbelow(True) + ax.grid(visible=True, which="major", axis="y", alpha=0.5, color="gray") + # ax.axhline(y = 0, color = 'black', alpha=0.5, linestyle = '--', zorder=-1) + ax.tick_params(which="both", width=1) + ax.set_xticks([], minor=True) + ax.tick_params(which="minor", length=4, axis="y", bottom=True) + ax.yaxis.set_minor_locator(AutoMinorLocator(2)) + + if splitby == "associated_work": + ax.set_xticklabels( + xtick_labelsList, ha="center", rotation_mode="anchor", size=15 + ) + elif figdir == "MoSDeF": + xtick_labelsList = list( + map(lambda lab: "-\n".join(lab.split("-")), xtick_labelsList) + ) + ax.set_xticklabels(xtick_labelsList, size=xlabelfs, rotation=rotation) + else: + ax.set_xticklabels( + xtick_labelsList, + size=xlabelfs, + rotation_mode="anchor", + rotation=rotation, + ha="right", + ) + if wrap_labels: + _wrap_labels(ax, width=12, break_long_words=True, rotation=rotation) + ax.set_ylabel(r"$100\times\Delta\rho / \rho$", size=ylabelfs) + + +def _save_single_scatter_labels( + fig, ax, combMCMD, average_replicas, figdir, splitby, plot_type +): + if combMCMD: + MCMDStr = "MCandMD" + else: + MCMDStr = "MCorMD" + + if average_replicas: + avgStr = "_avg" + else: + avgStr = "" + fname = ( + f"figures/{figdir}/{figdir}_{splitby}_{MCMDStr}{avgStr}_{plot_type}.pdf" + ) + print(f"Plotting {fname}") + fig.tight_layout() + fig.savefig(fname, dpi=900) + + +def single_plot_comparisons( + df, splitby, combMCMD, plot_type, average_replicas=False, figdir="combined" +): + """Plot deviations split into splitby groupings on xaxis and compared to their statepoint and/or MD/MC means.""" + if average_replicas: + df = copy.deepcopy( + df.groupby( + [ + "molecule", + "forcefield", + "engine", + "MCorMD", + "associated_work", + "temperature", + "pressure", + ] + )["density"] + .mean() + .reset_index() + ) + + df = _mask_df(df) + + if combMCMD: + groupREList = ["molecule", "temperature", "forcefield", "pressure"] + else: + groupREList = [ + "MCorMD", + "molecule", + "temperature", + "forcefield", + "pressure", + ] + df["Relative_Error"] = df.groupby(groupREList)["density"].transform( + _calculate_relative_error + ) + + _transform_ff_names(df) + + x_label = splitby #'molecule', "forcefield", "associated_work" + y_label = "Relative_Error" + + color_labels, xtick_labelsList, color_map = _sort_plotting_labels( + df, x_label, y_label + ) + fig, ax = _plot_params(color_labels) + + if plot_type == "scatter": + _plot_scatter(df, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label) + elif plot_type == "violin": + _plot_violin(df, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label) + else: + return + + _general_plot_formatting( + df, + ax, + splitby, + figdir, + groupMCMD, + xtick_labelsList, + color_labels, + average_replicas, + ) # formatting for all plots + _save_single_scatter_labels( + fig, ax, groupMCMD, average_replicas, figdir, splitby, plot_type + ) + plt.close() + + return ax + + +def _plot_stack_params(stack): + """Initialize subplots with shared x axis.""" + fig = plt.figure(figsize=(9, 6)) + gs = fig.add_gridspec(len(stack), hspace=0) + stackax = gs.subplots(sharex=True, sharey=False) + + return fig, stackax + + +def _plot_stack_params_multix(stack, hspace=0.5): + """Initialize subplots with shared x axis.""" + fig = plt.figure(figsize=(9, 9)) + gs = fig.add_gridspec(len(stack), hspace=hspace) + stackax = gs.subplots(sharex=False, sharey=False) + + return fig, stackax + + +def stack_plot_comparisons(df, stack, ymax=None): + """Stack multiple plots on each other to generate a single figure.""" + # Initialize Figure + fig, axs = _plot_stack_params(stack) + + # Iterate through stack to generate plot + for ax, sta in zip(axs, stack): + if sta["figdir"] in ["MoSDeF", "RR"]: + stackDF = df.loc[df["associated_work"] == sta["figdir"]].copy() + else: + stackDF = df.copy() + + if sta["average_replicas"]: + stackDF = copy.deepcopy( + stackDF.groupby( + [ + "molecule", + "forcefield", + "engine", + "MCorMD", + "associated_work", + "temperature", + "pressure", + ] + )["density"] + .mean() + .reset_index() + ) + + stackDF = _mask_df(stackDF) + + if sta["combMCMD"]: + groupREList = ["molecule", "temperature", "forcefield", "pressure"] + else: + groupREList = [ + "MCorMD", + "molecule", + "temperature", + "forcefield", + "pressure", + ] + stackDF["Relative_Error"] = stackDF.groupby(groupREList)[ + "density" + ].transform(_calculate_relative_error) + # print(stackDF.loc[stackDF["Relative_Error"].abs() > 3]) + + _transform_ff_names(stackDF) + x_label = sta["splitby"] #'molecule', "forcefield", "associated_work" + y_label = "Relative_Error" + color_labels, xtick_labelsList, color_map = _sort_plotting_labels( + stackDF, x_label, y_label + ) + + if sta["plot_type"] == "scatter": + _plot_scatter( + stackDF, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label + ) + elif sta["plot_type"] == "violin": + _plot_violin( + stackDF, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label + ) + else: + return + # color_labels = list(Counter(df[x_label].to_numpy()).keys()) + + _general_plot_formatting( + stackDF, + ax, + sta["splitby"], + sta["figdir"], + sta["combMCMD"], + xtick_labelsList, + color_labels, + sta["average_replicas"], + ymax=ymax, + rotation=sta.get("rotation", 0), + wrap_labels=sta.get("wrap_labels", True), + ) # format all plots + # remove extra labels + axs[0].set_ylabel("") + axs[2].set_ylabel("") + + fig_names = [] + for sta in stack: + fig_names.append("-".join(list(map(str, sta.values())))) + fname = f"figures/Stacked_Figures/{'_'.join(fig_names)}.pdf" + print(f"Plotting {fname}") + fig.tight_layout() + fig.savefig(fname, dpi=500, bbox_inches="tight", overwrite=True) + + +def stack_plot_multix(stack): + """Stack multiple plots on each other with differing xaxis labels on each.""" + # Initialize Figure + fig, axs = _plot_stack_params_multix(stack) + + # Iterate through stack to generate plot + for ax, sta in zip(axs, stack): + ax.axvline( + x=sta["seperator_line_pos"], + color="black", + alpha=0.75, + linestyle="--", + zorder=-2, + ) + # generate filteredDF + if sta["figdir"] in ["MoSDeF", "RR"]: + df = sta["df"] + stackDF = df.loc[df["associated_work"] == sta["figdir"]].copy() + else: + df = sta["df"] + stackDF = df.copy() + + if sta["average_replicas"]: + stackDF = copy.deepcopy( + stackDF.groupby( + [ + "molecule", + "forcefield", + "engine", + "MCorMD", + "associated_work", + "temperature", + "pressure", + ] + )["density"] + .mean() + .reset_index() + ) + + stackDF = _mask_df(stackDF) + + if sta["combMCMD"]: + groupREList = ["molecule", "temperature", "forcefield", "pressure"] + else: + groupREList = [ + "MCorMD", + "molecule", + "temperature", + "forcefield", + "pressure", + ] + stackDF["Relative_Error"] = stackDF.groupby(groupREList)[ + "density" + ].transform(_calculate_relative_error) + print( + "Number of larger values: ", + len(stackDF.loc[stackDF["Relative_Error"].abs() > 0.70].index), + ) + print( + "Number of smaller values: ", + len(stackDF.loc[stackDF["Relative_Error"].abs() < 0.70].index), + ) + # print(stackDF.loc[stackDF["Relative_Error"].abs() > 0.50]) + + _transform_ff_names(stackDF) + x_label = sta["splitby"] #'molecule', "forcefield", "associated_work" + y_label = "Relative_Error" + color_labels, xtick_labelsList, color_map = _sort_plotting_labels( + stackDF, x_label, y_label + ) + + if sta["plot_type"] == "scatter": + _plot_scatter( + stackDF, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label + ) + elif sta["plot_type"] == "violin": + _plot_violin( + stackDF, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label + ) + else: + return + color_labels = list(Counter(df[x_label].to_numpy()).keys()) + + _general_plot_formatting( + stackDF, + ax, + sta["splitby"], + sta["figdir"], + sta["combMCMD"], + xtick_labelsList, + color_labels, + sta["average_replicas"], + ymax=sta["ymax"], + ) # format all plots + axs[0].set_ylabel("") + axs[2].set_ylabel("") + + fname = f"figures/Stacked_Figures/{'molecule_stack'}-{sta['figdir']}.pdf" + print(f"Plotting {fname}") + fig.tight_layout() + fontsize = 20 + axs[2].text(3.65, 5.8, "MoSDeF", fontdict={"size": fontsize}) + axs[2].text(3.65, 29.7, "MoSDeF", fontdict={"size": fontsize}) + axs[2].text(3.65, 53.8, "MoSDeF", fontdict={"size": fontsize}) + axs[2].text(3.1, 5.8, "RR", fontdict={"size": fontsize}) + axs[2].text(3.1, 29.7, "RR", fontdict={"size": fontsize}) + axs[2].text(0.8, 53.8, "RR", fontdict={"size": fontsize}) + fig.savefig(fname, dpi=500, bbox_inches="tight", overwrite=True) + + +def looper_for_plotting_single_data(df): + """Seperate out plotting data from source specific dataframes.""" + for filter_method in ["MoSDeF", "RR", None]: + if filter_method: + df = copy.deepcopy(densityDF) + df = df.loc[df["associated_work"] == filter_method] + for use_replica_avg in (True, False): + for splitby in ["ff-mol", "forcefield", "associated_work"]: + for combMCMDMCMD in [True, False]: + for plot_type in ["scatter", "violin", "box"]: + if filter_method is None: + single_plot_comparisons( + df.copy(), + splitby=splitby, + combMCMD=combMCMD, + plot_type=plot_type, + average_replicas=use_replica_avg, + figdir="combined", + ) + else: + single_plot_comparisons( + df.copy(), + splitby=splitby, + combMCMD=combMCMDMCMD, + plot_type=plot_type, + average_replicas=use_replica_avg, + figdir=filter_method, + ) + df = copy.deepcopy(densityDF) + + +def plot_rr_mosdef_mosdef_avg(fullDF): + """Generate the overall averages for intrawork sources and get a total distribution.""" + ylabelfs = 20 + + splitby = "associated_work" + combMCMD = False + plot_type = "violin" + average_replicas = [False, False, True] + figdir = "combined" + df = fullDF.copy() + df = _mask_df(df) + groupREList = [ + "MCorMD", + "molecule", + "temperature", + "forcefield", + "pressure", + ] + df["Relative_Error"] = df.groupby(groupREList)["density"].transform( + _calculate_relative_error + ) + _transform_ff_names(df) + x_label = splitby #'molecule', "forcefield", "associated_work" + y_label = "Relative_Error" + + # labels should be Round Robin, MoSDeF, MoSDeF-Averaged + # color_labels, xtick_labelsList, color_map = _sort_plotting_labels(df, x_label, y_label) + color_labels = ["RR", "MoSDeF", "MoSDeF-Averaged"] + dfs = list( + map( + lambda x: df.loc[df["associated_work"] == x].copy(), + color_labels[:2], + ) + ) + + # generate final plotting df + df3 = fullDF.copy() + df = ( + df.groupby( + [ + "molecule", + "forcefield", + "engine", + "MCorMD", + "associated_work", + "temperature", + "pressure", + ] + )["density"] + .mean() + .reset_index() + ) + df = _mask_df(df) + groupREList = [ + "MCorMD", + "molecule", + "temperature", + "forcefield", + "pressure", + ] + df["Relative_Error"] = df.groupby(groupREList)["density"].transform( + _calculate_relative_error + ) + dfs.append(df.loc[df["associated_work"] == "MoSDeF"]) + fig, ax = _plot_params(color_labels) + + if plot_type == "scatter": + _plot_scatter( + stackDF, fig, ax, color_labels, color_map, x_label, y_label + ) + elif plot_type == "violin": + x_ticks = np.arange(len(color_labels)) + for i, iDF in enumerate(dfs): + series = iDF[y_label] + ydata = series[series.notnull()] + if len(x_ticks) > 1: + spread = (x_ticks[1] - x_ticks[0]) * 0.25 + else: + spread = 0.25 + print( + f"Maximum deviation is: {max(abs(ydata)):.2f} for grouping {color_labels[i]}" + ) + offsets = np.linspace(-1 * spread, spread, len(ydata)) + xdata = np.full(len(ydata), x_ticks[i]) + offsets + ax.violinplot([ydata], positions=[i], showextrema=True) + + xtick_labelsList = ["Round Robin", "MoSDeF", "MoSDeF-Averaged"] + _general_plot_formatting( + dfs[0], + ax, + splitby, + figdir, + combMCMD, + xtick_labelsList, + color_labels, + average_replicas, + ymax=8, + ) # format all plots + ax.set_ylabel(r"$100\times\Delta\rho / \rho$", size=ylabelfs) + + fname = f"figures/Stacked_Figures/{'Grouped-Comparison'}-{plot_type}.pdf" + print(f"Plotting {fname}") + fig.tight_layout() + fig.savefig(fname, dpi=500, bbox_inches="tight", overwrite=True) + + +def print_errors_for_text(df): + """Print out relative errors for discussion and conclusion in the manuscript.""" + df = _mask_df(df) + # std error FF RR + df_RR = df.loc[(df["associated_work"] == "RR")].copy() + groupREList = [ + "MCorMD", + "molecule", + "temperature", + "forcefield", + "pressure", + ] + df_RR["Relative_Error"] = df_RR.groupby(groupREList)["density"].transform( + _calculate_relative_error + ) + RR_sim_std = df_RR["Relative_Error"].std() + print( + f"Round Robin STD Error is {df_RR['Relative_Error'].std()}, Max Error is {df_RR['Relative_Error'].abs().max()}" + ) + + # std error FF MoSDeF + df_mosdef = df.loc[(df["associated_work"] == "MoSDeF")].copy() + groupREList = [ + "MCorMD", + "molecule", + "temperature", + "forcefield", + "pressure", + ] + df_mosdef["Relative_Error"] = df_mosdef.groupby(groupREList)[ + "density" + ].transform(_calculate_relative_error) + mosdef_sim_std = df_mosdef["Relative_Error"].std() + print( + f"MoSDeF STD Error is {df_mosdef['Relative_Error'].std()}, Max Error is {df_mosdef['Relative_Error'].abs().max()}" + ) + + # std error FF MoSDeF average of 16 + groupREList = [ + "MCorMD", + "molecule", + "temperature", + "forcefield", + "pressure", + ] + df_mosdef_avg = df.loc[(df["associated_work"] == "MoSDeF")].copy() + df_mosdef_avg = copy.deepcopy( + df_mosdef_avg.groupby( + [ + "molecule", + "forcefield", + "engine", + "MCorMD", + "associated_work", + "temperature", + "pressure", + ] + )["density"] + .mean() + .reset_index() + ) + df_mosdef_avg["Relative_Error"] = df_mosdef_avg.groupby(groupREList)[ + "density" + ].transform(_calculate_relative_error) + mosdef_avg_std = df_mosdef_avg["Relative_Error"].std() + print( + f"MoSDeF Best Practices STD Error is {df_mosdef_avg['Relative_Error'].std()}, Max Error is {df_mosdef_avg['Relative_Error'].abs().max()}" + ) + + print(f"Comparable MoSDeF Decrease: {RR_sim_std/mosdef_sim_std}") + print(f"Best Practices MoSDeF Decrease: {RR_sim_std/mosdef_avg_std}") + mean = df_mosdef_avg["Relative_Error"].mean() + length_RE = len(df_mosdef_avg["Relative_Error"]) + print( + f"MoSDeF CI for all errors: {mean} +- {mosdef_avg_std/np.sqrt(length_RE)*1.96}" + ) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + mosdefDF = pd.read_csv("csvs/job_density_data.csv", index_col=0) + mosdefDF.insert( + len(mosdefDF.columns), + "pressure", + np.full(len(mosdefDF.index), 0.101325), + ) + + hasse_dfList = _load_all_rr_data() + + # 4 combine data into one dataframe + densityDF = mosdefDF.loc[ + mosdefDF["molecule"] != "pentaneUA-flexible_bonds" + ].copy() + densityDF = pd.concat([densityDF, *hasse_dfList], ignore_index=True) + df = copy.deepcopy(densityDF) + + # generate individual scatter and violin plots + # looper_for_plotting_single_data(df) + + # generate stacked plots + + stack1 = [ + { + "figdir": "MoSDeF", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": True, + "plot_type": "violin", + "average_replicas": False, + }, + { + "figdir": "MoSDeF", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": False, + "plot_type": "violin", + "average_replicas": False, + }, + { + "figdir": "MoSDeF", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": False, + "plot_type": "violin", + "average_replicas": True, + }, + ] + + stack_plot_comparisons(df, stack1, ymax=0.8) + + stack2 = [ + { + "figdir": "combined", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": True, + "plot_type": "scatter", + "average_replicas": False, + "rotation": 45, + "wrap_labels": False, + }, + { + "figdir": "combined", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": False, + "plot_type": "scatter", + "average_replicas": False, + "rotation": 45, + "wrap_labels": False, + }, + ] + + # stack_plot_comparisons(df, stack2) # try other plotting + + stack3 = [ + { + "figdir": "combined", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": True, + "plot_type": "violin", + "average_replicas": False, + "rotation": 45, + "wrap_labels": False, + }, + { + "figdir": "combined", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": False, + "plot_type": "violin", + "average_replicas": False, + "rotation": 45, + "wrap_labels": False, + }, + ] + + # stack_plot_comparisons(df, stack3) + + # compare TraPPE -> all + df1 = copy.deepcopy(df).loc[ + df["forcefield"].isin(["TraPPE", "trappe-ua", "benzene-ua"]) + ] + df2 = copy.deepcopy(df).loc[df["forcefield"].isin(["OPLS", "spce"])] + df3 = copy.deepcopy(df).loc[df["forcefield"].isin(["OPLSAMBER", "oplsaa"])] + stack_mol_by_mol_basis = [ # Add text above MoSDeF and RR sections + { + "df": df1, + "figdir": "combined", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": False, + "plot_type": "violin", + "average_replicas": False, + "ymax": 2, + "seperator_line_pos": 3.5, + }, + { + "df": df2, + "figdir": "combined", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": False, + "plot_type": "violin", + "average_replicas": False, + "ymax": 2, + "seperator_line_pos": 3.5, + }, + { + "df": df3, + "figdir": "combined", + "splitby": "ff-mol", + "combMCMD": False, + "plot_type": "violin", + "average_replicas": False, + "ymax": 8, + "seperator_line_pos": 3.5, + }, + ] + + # Compare TraPPE -> TraPPE + # compare OPLS -> SPC/E + # compare OPLS AMBER -> OPLS Ethanol + stack_plot_multix(stack_mol_by_mol_basis) + + plot_rr_mosdef_mosdef_avg(densityDF.copy()) + + print_errors_for_text(densityDF.copy()) diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_densities.py b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_densities.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5d0ce339 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_densities.py @@ -0,0 +1,210 @@ +"""Generate CSV from job docs for job densities.""" +import os + +import camelot +import numpy as np +import pandas as pd +import signac + +updated_masses = { + "methaneUA": 16.043, + "pentaneUA-flexible_bonds": 72.151, + "pentaneUA-constrain_bonds": 72.151, + "pentaneUA": 72.151, + "benzeneUA": 78.114, + "waterSPCE": 18.015, # 18.015324, + "ethanolAA": 46.069, # 46.068672, +} + + +def load_mosdef_jobs(): + """Load MoSDeF densities from job docs.""" + # Load by molecule, temperature, forcefield + densitiesDict = {} + p = signac.get_project("./") + sampled_jobsDict = {} + for i, job in enumerate(p): + if not job.isfile("signac_statepoint.json"): + continue + filter_list = [ + ( + job.sp.engine == "mcccs" + and job.sp.mass != updated_masses[job.sp.molecule] + ), + job.sp.engine == "lammps-UD", + job.sp.ensemble != "NPT", + job.sp.molecule == "pentaneUA", + ] + if np.any(filter_list): + continue + + print(f"{i/len(p)*100:.1f}% done") + try: + sampled_jobsDict[job] = ( + job.doc["npt_density_avg"], + job.doc["npt_density_std"], + ) + # job.doc['npt/sampling_results']["density"] + except: + return job.id, job.doc, job.sp + return sampled_jobsDict + + +headers = [ + "associated_work", + "MCorMD", + "engine", + "molecule", + "replicate", + "temperature", + "density", + "density-std", + "forcefield", +] +MCMDDict = dict() +for engines, enginetype in list( + zip( + [("cassandra", "gomc", "mcccs"), ("lammps-VU", "gromacs", "hoomd")], + ("MC", "MD"), + ) +): + for engine in engines: + MCMDDict.update({engine: enginetype}) + + +def generate_mosdef_job_csv(): + """Create a csv of all data for mosdef jobs based on statepoint to read into dataframes.""" + if os.path.exists("csvs/job_density_data.csv"): + print("Density data is already generated at csvs/job_density_data.csv.") + return + job_densityDict = load_mosdef_jobs() + row_list = [] + for job in job_densityDict: + inputs = [ + "MoSDeF", + MCMDDict[job.sp.engine], + job.sp.engine, + job.sp.molecule, + job.sp.replica, + job.sp.temperature, + job_densityDict[job][0], + job_densityDict[job][1], + job.sp.forcefield_name, + ] + row_list.append(dict((key, val) for key, val in zip(headers, inputs))) + df = pd.DataFrame(row_list) + df.to_csv("csvs/job_density_data.csv") + + +def _generate_csv_from_PDF(molecule): + """Methods to generate dataframe from PDF supplied for paper SI.""" + page = molecule_pageDictionary[molecule] + + # Read remote pdf into a list of DataFrame + link = "Hasse_SI.pdf" # must have access locally for this python file to load it. + tables = camelot.read_pdf(link, flavor="stream", pages=page, edge_tol=500) + if len(tables) == 1: + table = tables[0] + molecule_nameStr = table.df[1][0] + if molecule in [ + "OPLS Ethane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS Propane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS n-Butane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS iso-Butane at 5 MPa", + ]: + df = table.df[table.df.columns[1:]][2:] + df.columns = np.arange(len(df.columns)) + elif "AMBER" in molecule: + df = table.df[table.df.columns[:]][2:] + else: + df = table.df[table.df.columns[:]][1:] + row_start = 1 + np.where(df[0] == "Program(Group)")[0][0] + headers = df.iloc[row_start - 1] + newDF = pd.DataFrame(df.values[row_start:], columns=headers) + else: + # need to combine table0 and table1 parts + df = pd.concat((tables[0].df, tables[1].df), axis=0) + header_ids = np.where(df[0] == "Program(Group)")[0] + if len(header_ids) == 2: + row_start = 1 + header_ids[0] + row_end = header_ids[1] - 2 + headers = df.iloc[row_start - 1] + newDF = pd.DataFrame(df.values[row_start:row_end], columns=headers) + elif len(header_ids) == 1: + row_start = 1 + header_ids[0] + headers = df.iloc[row_start - 1] + newDF = pd.DataFrame(df.values[row_start:], columns=headers) + + for i in range(len(newDF.index)): + headerInt = int(4 * np.floor(i / 4)) + header = newDF.iloc[headerInt]["Program(Group)"] + newDF.iloc[i]["Program(Group)"] = header + + # we will change the data type + # of id column to str by giving + # the dict to the astype method + columns = list(newDF.columns[1:]) + + for c in columns: + newDF[c] = pd.to_numeric(newDF[c], errors="coerce") + newDF["statepoint"] = "temp: " + newDF["T / K"].astype(str) + newDF["Relative_Error"] = newDF.groupby("statepoint")[ + "ρ / kg m−3" + ].transform(_calculate_relative_error) + newDF.to_csv(f"csvs/{molecule}_data.csv") + + +def _calculate_relative_error(ser): + """Calculate relative density error for all engines at that statepoint.""" + dataArray = ser.to_numpy() + mean = np.nanmean(dataArray) + return (dataArray - mean) / mean * 100 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + generate_mosdef_job_csv() + + molecule_pageDictionary = { + "OPLS Ethane at 5 MPa": "8", + "OPLS Ethane at 41 MPa": "9", + "OPLS Ethane at 70 MPa": "10", + "TraPPE Ethane at 5 MPa": "11", + "TraPPE Ethane at 41 MPa": "12", + "TraPPE Ethane at 70 MPa": "13", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 5 MPa": "14,15", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 41 MPa": "15,16", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 70 MPa": "16,17", + "OPLS Propane at 5 MPa": "18", + "OPLS Propane at 41 MPa": "19", + "OPLS Propane at 70 MPa": "20", + "TraPPE Propane at 5 MPa": "21", + "TraPPE Propane at 41 MPa": "22", + "TraPPE Propane at 70 MPa": "23", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 5 MPa": "24-25", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 41 MPa": "25-26", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 70 MPa": "26-27", + "OPLS n-Butane at 5 MPa": "28", + "OPLS n-Butane at 41 MPa": "29", + "OPLS n-Butane at 70 MPa": "30", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 5 MPa": "31", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 41 MPa": "32", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 70 MPa": "33", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 5 MPa": "34,35", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 41 MPa": "35,36", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 70 MPa": "36,37", + "OPLS iso-Butane at 5 MPa": "38", + "OPLS iso-Butane at 41 MPa": "39", + "OPLS iso-Butane at 70 MPa": "40", + "TraPPE iso-Butane at 5 MPa": "41", + "TraPPE iso-Butane at 41 MPa": "42", + "TraPPE iso-Butane at 70 MPa": "43", + "OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 5 MPa": "44,45", + "OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 41 MPa": "45,46", + "OPLSAMBER iso-Butane at 70 MPa": "46,47", + } + for molecule in molecule_pageDictionary: + print(f"Generating CSV for: {molecule}") + print("################################") + print("################################") + _generate_csv_from_PDF(molecule) + print("\n\nCompleted Generating all CSVs in the directory csvs/\n\n") diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_scatter_plots.py b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_scatter_plots.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4316fe9c --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/generate_scatter_plots.py @@ -0,0 +1,163 @@ +"""Analyze csvs in ./csvs in order to create scatter plots of the density differences found in the SI of 10.1021/acs.jctc.7b00489.""" + +import camelot +import matplotlib.pyplot as plt +import numpy as np +import pandas as pd +import seaborn as sns + +np.random.seed(0) +import matplotlib.transforms as transforms + + +def _create_scatter_plot(summary_df, molecule, title, savefig=False): + """Generate summary files for the aggregate project.""" + plt.rcParams.update( + { + "axes.titlesize": 20, + "axes.labelsize": 20, + "axes.titleweight": "bold", + "axes.labelweight": "bold", + "font.weight": "bold", + "xtick.labelsize": 20, + "ytick.labelsize": 20, + } + ) + sns.set_style("whitegrid") + fig = plt.figure(figsize=(10, 10)) + offset = lambda p: transforms.ScaledTranslation( + p / 72, 0, plt.gcf().dpi_scale_trans + ) + trans = plt.gca().transData + + x_label = "T / K" + y_labels = ["ρ / kg m−3", "Relative_Error"] + y_label = y_labels[1] + + color_labels = summary_df["Program(Group)"].unique() + palette = sns.color_palette("colorblind", n_colors=len(color_labels)) + color_map = dict(zip(color_labels, palette)) + offsets = np.linspace(-12, 12, len(color_labels)) + x_ticks = np.arange(len(color_labels)) + for offseti, my_engine in zip(offsets, color_labels): + series = summary_df.loc[summary_df["Program(Group)"] == my_engine] + data = series[series.notnull()] + ax = plt.scatter( + x=data[x_label] + offseti, + y=data[y_label], + color=color_map[my_engine], + label=my_engine, + s=np.full(len(data.index), 40), + edgecolors="black", + ) + plt.legend(color_labels) + plt.xlabel(x_label) + plt.ylabel(y_label) + val_min = summary_df[y_label].min() + val_max = summary_df[y_label].max() + + # plt.ylim(val_min - .2 * val_min, val_max + .2 * val_max) + plt.title(title, y=1.0, pad=15) + plt.tight_layout() + if savefig: + plt.savefig(f"figures/{molecule}_summary_scatter.pdf") + return fig + + +def generate_REPlot_by_molecule(molecule, savefig=True): + """Compare errors in density for engines in csvs.""" + if "AMBER" in molecule: + return # only look at molecules with opls and trappe forcefield + newDF = pd.read_csv(f"csvs/{molecule}_data.csv", index_col=0) + title = f"SI Data from Hans Hasse for {molecule}" + x = _create_scatter_plot(newDF, molecule, title, savefig=savefig) + + +def _generate_csv_from_PDF(molecule): + """Methods to generate dataframe from PDF supplied for paper SI.""" + page = molecule_pageDictionary[molecule] + + # Read remote pdf into a list of DataFrame + link = "Hasse_SI.pdf" # must have access locally for this python file to load it. + tables = camelot.read_pdf(link, flavor="stream", pages=page) + + if "AMBER" in molecule: + return + + table = tables[0] + molecule_nameStr = table.df[1][0] + if molecule in [ + "OPLS Ethane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS Propane at 5 MPa", + "OPLS n-Butane at 5 MPa", + ]: + df = table.df[table.df.columns[1:]][2:] + df.columns = np.arange(len(df.columns)) + elif "AMBER" in molecule: + df = table.df[table.df.columns[:]][2:] + else: + df = table.df[table.df.columns[:]][1:] + row_start = 1 + np.where(df[0] == "Program(Group)")[0][0] + headers = df.iloc[row_start - 1] + newDF = pd.DataFrame(df.values[row_start:], columns=headers) + for i in range(len(newDF.index)): + headerInt = int(4 * np.floor(i / 4)) + header = newDF.iloc[headerInt]["Program(Group)"] + newDF.iloc[i]["Program(Group)"] = header + + # we will change the data type + # of id column to str by giving + # the dict to the astype method + columns = list(newDF.columns[1:]) + + for c in columns: + newDF[c] = pd.to_numeric(newDF[c], errors="coerce") + newDF["statepoint"] = "temp: " + newDF["T / K"].astype(str) + newDF["Relative_Error"] = newDF.groupby("statepoint")[ + "ρ / kg m−3" + ].transform(_calculate_relative_error) + newDF.to_csv(f"csvs/{molecule}_data.csv") + + +def _calculate_relative_error(ser): + """Calculate relative density error for all engines at that statepoint.""" + dataArray = ser.to_numpy() + mean = np.nanmean(dataArray) + return (dataArray - mean) / mean * 100 + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + molecule_pageDictionary = { + "OPLS Ethane at 5 MPa": "8", + "OPLS Ethane at 41 MPa": "9", + "OPLS Ethane at 70 MPa": "10", + "TraPPE Ethane at 5 MPa": "11", + "TraPPE Ethane at 41 MPa": "12", + "TraPPE Ethane at 70 MPa": "13", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 5 MPa": "14,15", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 41 MPa": "15,16", + "OPLSAMBER Ethane at 70 MPa": "16,17", + "OPLS Propane at 5 MPa": "18", + "OPLS Propane at 41 MPa": "19", + "OPLS Propane at 70 MPa": "20", + "TraPPE Propane at 5 MPa": "21", + "TraPPE Propane at 41 MPa": "22", + "TraPPE Propane at 70 MPa": "23", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 5 MPa": "24-25", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 41 MPa": "25-26", + "OPLSAMBER Propane at 70 MPa": "26-27", + "OPLS n-Butane at 5 MPa": "28", + "OPLS n-Butane at 41 MPa": "29", + "OPLS n-Butane at 70 MPa": "30", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 5 MPa": "31", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 41 MPa": "32", + "TraPPE n-Butane at 70 MPa": "33", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 5 MPa": "34,35", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 41 MPa": "35,36", + "OPLSAMBER n-Butane at 70 MPa": "36,37", + } + for molecule in molecule_pageDictionary: + print(f"Generating Plot for: {molecule}") + print("################################") + print("################################") + generate_REPlot_by_molecule(molecule, savefig=True) diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/plotting.py b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/plotting.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..aebe5061 --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/Comparison_Figures/plotting.py @@ -0,0 +1,160 @@ +"""Utility methods for plotting data.""" +import pathlib +import textwrap + +import matplotlib.pyplot as plt +import numpy as np +import numpy.typing as npt +import scipy + +from reproducibility_project.src.analysis.equilibration import is_equilibrated + + +def plot_data_with_t0_line( + filename: str, + a_t: npt.ArrayLike, + vline_scale: float = 1.1, + threshold_fraction: float = 0.0, + threshold_neff: int = 1, + overwrite: bool = False, + title: str = None, + data_plt_kwargs: dict = None, + vline_plt_kwargs: dict = None, +) -> None: + """Plot data with a vertical line at beginning of equilibration. + + Parameters + ---------- + a_t : numpy.typing.ArrayLike + 1-D time dependent data + vline_scale : float, optional, default=1.1 + Scale the min and max components of the vertical line. + threshold_fraction : float, optional, default=0.0 + Threshold_fraction to error out on if threshold fraction of data is not equilibrated. + threshold_neff : int, optional, default=1 + Threshold amount of uncorrelated samples to error out on if threshold amount of data is not equilibrated. + overwrite : bool, optional, default=False + Do not write to filename if a file already exists with the same name. + Set to True to overwrite exisiting files. + title : str, optional + Set the title of the plot + data_plt_kwargs : dict, optional, default={} + Pass in a dictionary of keyword arguments to plot the data. + vline_plt_kwargs : dict, optional, default={} + Pass in a dictionary of keyword arguments for the + """ + path = pathlib.Path(filename) + if path.is_file() and not overwrite: + raise FileExistsError( + f"Cannot write {path.name}, file already exists at: {path.absolute()}. Set overwrite=True to replace file." + ) + + _, t0, g, Neff = is_equilibrated( + a_t, + threshold_fraction=threshold_fraction, + threshold_neff=threshold_neff, + nskip=1, + ) + + ymin = np.min(a_t) - np.min(a_t) * (np.abs(1 - vline_scale)) + ymax = np.max(a_t) + np.max(a_t) * (np.abs(1 - vline_scale)) + + if data_plt_kwargs is None: + data_plt_kwargs = {} + if vline_plt_kwargs is None: + vline_plt_kwargs = {} + for key, val in { + "color": "b", + "linestyle": "-", + "label": "Property", + }.items(): + if data_plt_kwargs.get(key) is None: + data_plt_kwargs[key] = val + + for key, val in { + "colors": "r", + "linestyles": "--", + "label": "t_0={0:d}\ng={1:.2f}\nNeff={2:d}", + }.items(): + if vline_plt_kwargs.get(key) is None: + if key == "label": + vline_plt_kwargs[key] = val.format(t0, g, int(Neff)) + else: + vline_plt_kwargs[key] = val + + fig, ax = plt.subplots() + + line1 = ax.plot(a_t, **data_plt_kwargs) + vline1 = ax.vlines(x=t0, ymin=ymin, ymax=ymax, **vline_plt_kwargs) + + ax.legend(loc="best") + + if title is None: + plt.suptitle("Property") + else: + plt.suptitle(title) + + plt.tight_layout() + fig.savefig( + str(path.absolute()), + ) + plt.close() + + +def mean_confidence_interval(m, se, confidence=0.95): + """Calculate mean confidence_interval.""" + se = np.array(se) + n = 16 + h = se * scipy.stats.t.ppf((1 + confidence) / 2.0, n - 1) + return h + + +def wrap_labels(ax, width, break_long_words=False): + """Wrap labels if string is too long.""" + labels = [] + for label in ax.get_xticklabels(): + text = label.get_text() + labels.append( + textwrap.fill(text, width=width, break_long_words=break_long_words) + ) + ax.set_xticklabels(labels, rotation=0) + + +# Colors +symbols = {} +symbols["cassandra"] = "o" +symbols["mcccs"] = "^" +symbols["gomc"] = "s" +symbols["gromacs"] = "x" +symbols["hoomd"] = "v" +symbols["lammps-VU"] = "D" +# symbols[ "LAMMPS-UD"] = ">" + +colors = {} +colors["cassandra"] = "#009392" # (23/256, 109/256, 156/256) +colors["mcccs"] = "#39B1B5" # (194/256, 135/256, 32/256) +colors["gomc"] = "#9CCB86" # (21/256, 138/256, 106/256) +colors["gromacs"] = "#E9E29C" # (186/256, 97/256, 26/256) +colors["hoomd"] = "#EEB479" # (193/256, 130/256, 181/256) +colors["lammps-VU"] = "#E88471" # (188/256, 146/256, 110/256) +colors["fix"] = "#FF7F00" +colors["flex"] = "#007FFF" +# colors_dict = {all_engine_molecule: all_engine_colors, +# pentane_fixed: pentane_fixed_colors, +# pentane_flexible: pentane_flexible_colors} + +pretty_names = { + "mcccsflex": "MCCCS-MN-FlexOH", + "mcccsfix": "MCCCS-MN-FixOH", + "lammps-VUflex": "LAMMPS-FlexOH", + "lammps-VUfix": "LAMMPS-FixOH", + "cassandra": "Cassandra", + "mcccs": "MCCCS-MN", + "gomc": "GOMC", + "gromacs": "GROMACS", + "hoomd": "HOOMD-Blue", + "lammps-VU": "LAMMPS", +} + + +figsize = (9, 6) diff --git a/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/matplotlibrc b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/matplotlibrc new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b8ceac0b --- /dev/null +++ b/reproducibility_project/src/analysis/matplotlibrc @@ -0,0 +1,627 @@ +### MATPLOTLIBRC FORMAT + +# This is a sample matplotlib configuration file - you can find a copy +# of it on your system in +# site-packages/matplotlib/mpl-data/matplotlibrc. If you edit it +# there, please note that it will be overwritten in your next install. +# If you want to keep a permanent local copy that will not be +# overwritten, place it in the following location: +# unix/linux: +# $HOME/.config/matplotlib/matplotlibrc or +# $XDG_CONFIG_HOME/matplotlib/matplotlibrc (if $XDG_CONFIG_HOME is set) +# other platforms: +# $HOME/.matplotlib/matplotlibrc +# +# See http://matplotlib.org/users/customizing.html#the-matplotlibrc-file for +# more details on the paths which are checked for the configuration file. +# +# This file is best viewed in a editor which supports python mode +# syntax highlighting. Blank lines, or lines starting with a comment +# symbol, are ignored, as are trailing comments. Other lines must +# have the format +# key : val # optional comment +# +# Colors: for the color values below, you can either use - a +# matplotlib color string, such as r, k, or b - an rgb tuple, such as +# (1.0, 0.5, 0.0) - a hex string, such as ff00ff - a scalar +# grayscale intensity such as 0.75 - a legal html color name, e.g., red, +# blue, darkslategray + +#### CONFIGURATION BEGINS HERE + +# The default backend; one of GTK GTKAgg GTKCairo GTK3Agg GTK3Cairo +# MacOSX Qt4Agg Qt5Agg TkAgg WX WXAgg Agg Cairo GDK PS PDF SVG +# Template. +# You can also deploy your own backend outside of matplotlib by +# referring to the module name (which must be in the PYTHONPATH) as +# 'module://my_backend'. +backend : TkAgg + +# If you are using the Qt4Agg backend, you can choose here +# to use the PyQt4 bindings or the newer PySide bindings to +# the underlying Qt4 toolkit. +#backend.qt4 : PyQt4 # PyQt4 | PySide + +# Note that this can be overridden by the environment variable +# QT_API used by Enthought Tool Suite (ETS); valid values are +# "pyqt" and "pyside". The "pyqt" setting has the side effect of +# forcing the use of Version 2 API for QString and QVariant. + +# The port to use for the web server in the WebAgg backend. +# webagg.port : 8888 + +# If webagg.port is unavailable, a number of other random ports will +# be tried until one that is available is found. +# webagg.port_retries : 50 + +# When True, open the webbrowser to the plot that is shown +# webagg.open_in_browser : True + +# When True, the figures rendered in the nbagg backend are created with +# a transparent background. +# nbagg.transparent : False + +# if you are running pyplot inside a GUI and your backend choice +# conflicts, we will automatically try to find a compatible one for +# you if backend_fallback is True +#backend_fallback: True + +#interactive : False +#toolbar : toolbar2 # None | toolbar2 ("classic" is deprecated) +#timezone : UTC # a pytz timezone string, e.g., US/Central or Europe/Paris + +# Where your matplotlib data lives if you installed to a non-default +# location. This is where the matplotlib fonts, bitmaps, etc reside +#datapath : /home/jdhunter/mpldata + + +### LINES +# See http://matplotlib.org/api/artist_api.html#module-matplotlib.lines for more +# information on line properties. +lines.linewidth : 0.8 # line width in points +#lines.linestyle : - # solid line +#lines.color : C0 # has no affect on plot(); see axes.prop_cycle +#lines.marker : None # the default marker +lines.markeredgewidth : 0.8 # the line width around the marker symbol +#lines.markersize : 6 # markersize, in points +#lines.dash_joinstyle : miter # miter|round|bevel +#lines.dash_capstyle : butt # butt|round|projecting +#lines.solid_joinstyle : miter # miter|round|bevel +#lines.solid_capstyle : projecting # butt|round|projecting +#lines.antialiased : True # render lines in antialiased (no jaggies) + +# The three standard dash patterns. These are scaled by the linewidth. +#lines.dashed_pattern : 2.8, 1.2 +#lines.dashdot_pattern : 4.8, 1.2, 0.8, 1.2 +#lines.dotted_pattern : 1.1, 1.1 +#lines.scale_dashes : True + +markers.fillstyle: none # full|left|right|bottom|top|none + +### PATCHES +# Patches are graphical objects that fill 2D space, like polygons or +# circles. See +# http://matplotlib.org/api/artist_api.html#module-matplotlib.patches +# information on patch properties +patch.linewidth : 0.8 # edge width in points. +#patch.facecolor : C0 +#patch.edgecolor : black # if forced, or patch is not filled +#patch.force_edgecolor : False # True to always use edgecolor +#patch.antialiased : True # render patches in antialiased (no jaggies) + +### HATCHES +#hatch.color : k +#hatch.linewidth : 1.0 + +### Boxplot +#boxplot.notch : False +#boxplot.vertical : True +#boxplot.whiskers : 1.5 +#boxplot.bootstrap : None +#boxplot.patchartist : False +#boxplot.showmeans : False +#boxplot.showcaps : True +#boxplot.showbox : True +#boxplot.showfliers : True +#boxplot.meanline : False + +#boxplot.flierprops.color : 'k' +#boxplot.flierprops.marker : 'o' +#boxplot.flierprops.markerfacecolor : 'none' +#boxplot.flierprops.markeredgecolor : 'k' +#boxplot.flierprops.markersize : 6 +#boxplot.flierprops.linestyle : 'none' +#boxplot.flierprops.linewidth : 1.0 + +#boxplot.boxprops.color : 'k' +#boxplot.boxprops.linewidth : 1.0 +#boxplot.boxprops.linestyle : '-' + +#boxplot.whiskerprops.color : 'k' +#boxplot.whiskerprops.linewidth : 1.0 +#boxplot.whiskerprops.linestyle : '-' + +#boxplot.capprops.color : 'k' +#boxplot.capprops.linewidth : 1.0 +#boxplot.capprops.linestyle : '-' + +#boxplot.medianprops.color : 'C1' +#boxplot.medianprops.linewidth : 1.0 +#boxplot.medianprops.linestyle : '-' + +#boxplot.meanprops.color : 'C2' +#boxplot.meanprops.marker : '^' +#boxplot.meanprops.markerfacecolor : 'C2' +#boxplot.meanprops.markeredgecolor : 'C2' +#boxplot.meanprops.markersize : 6 +#boxplot.meanprops.linestyle : 'none' +#boxplot.meanprops.linewidth : 1.0 + +### FONT +# +# font properties used by text.Text. See +# http://matplotlib.org/api/font_manager_api.html for more +# information on font properties. The 6 font properties used for font +# matching are given below with their default values. +# +# The font.family property has five values: 'serif' (e.g., Times), +# 'sans-serif' (e.g., Helvetica), 'cursive' (e.g., Zapf-Chancery), +# 'fantasy' (e.g., Western), and 'monospace' (e.g., Courier). Each of +# these font families has a default list of font names in decreasing +# order of priority associated with them. When text.usetex is False, +# font.family may also be one or more concrete font names. +# +# The font.style property has three values: normal (or roman), italic +# or oblique. The oblique style will be used for italic, if it is not +# present. +# +# The font.variant property has two values: normal or small-caps. For +# TrueType fonts, which are scalable fonts, small-caps is equivalent +# to using a font size of 'smaller', or about 83%% of the current font +# size. +# +# The font.weight property has effectively 13 values: normal, bold, +# bolder, lighter, 100, 200, 300, ..., 900. Normal is the same as +# 400, and bold is 700. bolder and lighter are relative values with +# respect to the current weight. +# +# The font.stretch property has 11 values: ultra-condensed, +# extra-condensed, condensed, semi-condensed, normal, semi-expanded, +# expanded, extra-expanded, ultra-expanded, wider, and narrower. This +# property is not currently implemented. +# +# The font.size property is the default font size for text, given in pts. +# 10 pt is the standard value. +# +#font.family : sans-serif +#font.style : normal +#font.variant : normal +#font.weight : medium +#font.stretch : normal +# note that font.size controls default text sizes. To configure +# special text sizes tick labels, axes, labels, title, etc, see the rc +# settings for axes and ticks. Special text sizes can be defined +# relative to font.size, using the following values: xx-small, x-small, +# small, medium, large, x-large, xx-large, larger, or smaller +#font.size : 10.0 +#font.serif : DejaVu Serif, Bitstream Vera Serif, New Century Schoolbook, Century Schoolbook L, Utopia, ITC Bookman, Bookman, Nimbus Roman No9 L, Times New Roman, Times, Palatino, Charter, serif +#font.sans-serif : DejaVu Sans, Bitstream Vera Sans, Lucida Grande, Verdana, Geneva, Lucid, Arial, Helvetica, Avant Garde, sans-serif +#font.cursive : Apple Chancery, Textile, Zapf Chancery, Sand, Script MT, Felipa, cursive +#font.fantasy : Comic Sans MS, Chicago, Charcoal, Impact, Western, Humor Sans, xkcd, fantasy +#font.monospace : DejaVu Sans Mono, Bitstream Vera Sans Mono, Andale Mono, Nimbus Mono L, Courier New, Courier, Fixed, Terminal, monospace + +### TEXT +# text properties used by text.Text. See +# http://matplotlib.org/api/artist_api.html#module-matplotlib.text for more +# information on text properties + +#text.color : black + +### LaTeX customizations. See http://wiki.scipy.org/Cookbook/Matplotlib/UsingTex +#text.usetex : True # use latex for all text handling. The following fonts + # are supported through the usual rc parameter settings: + # new century schoolbook, bookman, times, palatino, + # zapf chancery, charter, serif, sans-serif, helvetica, + # avant garde, courier, monospace, computer modern roman, + # computer modern sans serif, computer modern typewriter + # If another font is desired which can loaded using the + # LaTeX \usepackage command, please inquire at the + # matplotlib mailing list +#text.latex.unicode : False # use "ucs" and "inputenc" LaTeX packages for handling + # unicode strings. +#text.latex.preamble : # IMPROPER USE OF THIS FEATURE WILL LEAD TO LATEX FAILURES + # AND IS THEREFORE UNSUPPORTED. PLEASE DO NOT ASK FOR HELP + # IF THIS FEATURE DOES NOT DO WHAT YOU EXPECT IT TO. + # preamble is a comma separated list of LaTeX statements + # that are included in the LaTeX document preamble. + # An example: + # text.latex.preamble : \usepackage{bm},\usepackage{euler} + # The following packages are always loaded with usetex, so + # beware of package collisions: color, geometry, graphicx, + # type1cm, textcomp. Adobe Postscript (PSSNFS) font packages + # may also be loaded, depending on your font settings + +#text.dvipnghack : None # some versions of dvipng don't handle alpha + # channel properly. Use True to correct + # and flush ~/.matplotlib/tex.cache + # before testing and False to force + # correction off. None will try and + # guess based on your dvipng version + +#text.hinting : auto # May be one of the following: + # 'none': Perform no hinting + # 'auto': Use FreeType's autohinter + # 'native': Use the hinting information in the + # font file, if available, and if your + # FreeType library supports it + # 'either': Use the native hinting information, + # or the autohinter if none is available. + # For backward compatibility, this value may also be + # True === 'auto' or False === 'none'. +#text.hinting_factor : 8 # Specifies the amount of softness for hinting in the + # horizontal direction. A value of 1 will hint to full + # pixels. A value of 2 will hint to half pixels etc. + +#text.antialiased : True # If True (default), the text will be antialiased. + # This only affects the Agg backend. + +# The following settings allow you to select the fonts in math mode. +# They map from a TeX font name to a fontconfig font pattern. +# These settings are only used if mathtext.fontset is 'custom'. +# Note that this "custom" mode is unsupported and may go away in the +# future. +#mathtext.cal : cursive +#mathtext.rm : serif +#mathtext.tt : monospace +#mathtext.it : serif:italic +#mathtext.bf : serif:bold +#mathtext.sf : sans +#mathtext.fontset : dejavusans # Should be 'dejavusans' (default), + # 'dejavuserif', 'cm' (Computer Modern), 'stix', + # 'stixsans' or 'custom' +#mathtext.fallback_to_cm : True # When True, use symbols from the Computer Modern + # fonts when a symbol can not be found in one of + # the custom math fonts. + +#mathtext.default : it # The default font to use for math. + # Can be any of the LaTeX font names, including + # the special name "regular" for the same font + # used in regular text. + +### AXES +# default face and edge color, default tick sizes, +# default fontsizes for ticklabels, and so on. See +# http://matplotlib.org/api/axes_api.html#module-matplotlib.axes +#axes.facecolor : white # axes background color +#axes.edgecolor : black # axes edge color +axes.linewidth : 0.8 # edge linewidth +#axes.grid : False # display grid or not +#axes.titlesize : large # fontsize of the axes title +#axes.titlepad : 6.0 # pad between axes and title in points +axes.labelsize : 12.0 # fontsize of the x any y labels +#axes.labelpad : 4.0 # space between label and axis +#axes.labelweight : normal # weight of the x and y labels +axes.labelcolor : black +#axes.axisbelow : 'line' # draw axis gridlines and ticks below + # patches (True); above patches but below + # lines ('line'); or above all (False) + +#axes.formatter.limits : -7, 7 # use scientific notation if log10 + # of the axis range is smaller than the + # first or larger than the second +#axes.formatter.use_locale : False # When True, format tick labels + # according to the user's locale. + # For example, use ',' as a decimal + # separator in the fr_FR locale. +#axes.formatter.use_mathtext : False # When True, use mathtext for scientific + # notation. +#axes.formatter.useoffset : True # If True, the tick label formatter + # will default to labeling ticks relative + # to an offset when the data range is + # small compared to the minimum absolute + # value of the data. +#axes.formatter.offset_threshold : 4 # When useoffset is True, the offset + # will be used when it can remove + # at least this number of significant + # digits from tick labels. + +# axes.spines.left : True # display axis spines +# axes.spines.bottom : True +# axes.spines.top : True +# axes.spines.right : True + + +#axes.unicode_minus : True # use unicode for the minus symbol + # rather than hyphen. See + # http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plus_and_minus_signs#Character_codes +#axes.prop_cycle : cycler('color', +# ['1f77b4', 'ff7f0e', '2ca02c', 'd62728', +# '9467bd', '8c564b', 'e377c2', '7f7f7f', +# 'bcbd22', '17becf']) + # color cycle for plot lines + # as list of string colorspecs: + # single letter, long name, or + # web-style hex +#axes.autolimit_mode : data # How to scale axes limits to the data. + # Use "data" to use data limits, plus some margin + # Use "round_number" move to the nearest "round" number +#axes.xmargin : .05 # x margin. See `axes.Axes.margins` +#axes.ymargin : .05 # y margin See `axes.Axes.margins` + +#polaraxes.grid : True # display grid on polar axes +#axes3d.grid : True # display grid on 3d axes + +### DATES +# These control the default format strings used in AutoDateFormatter. +# Any valid format datetime format string can be used (see the python +# `datetime` for details). For example using '%%x' will use the locale date representation +# '%%X' will use the locale time representation and '%%c' will use the full locale datetime +# representation. +# These values map to the scales: +# {'year': 365, 'month': 30, 'day': 1, 'hour': 1/24, 'minute': 1 / (24 * 60)} + +# date.autoformatter.year : %Y +# date.autoformatter.month : %Y-%m +# date.autoformatter.day : %Y-%m-%d +# date.autoformatter.hour : %m-%d %H +# date.autoformatter.minute : %d %H:%M +# date.autoformatter.second : %H:%M:%S +# date.autoformatter.microsecond : %M:%S.%f + +### TICKS +# see http://matplotlib.org/api/axis_api.html#matplotlib.axis.Tick +xtick.top : True # draw ticks on the top side +xtick.bottom : True # draw ticks on the bottom side +xtick.major.size : 6 # major tick size in points +xtick.minor.size : 3 # minor tick size in points +xtick.major.width : 0.8 # major tick width in points +xtick.minor.width : 0.4 # minor tick width in points +#xtick.major.pad : 3.5 # distance to major tick label in points +#xtick.minor.pad : 3.4 # distance to the minor tick label in points +#xtick.color : k # color of the tick labels +xtick.labelsize : 10 # fontsize of the tick labels +xtick.direction : in # direction: in, out, or inout +xtick.minor.visible : True # visibility of minor ticks on x-axis +xtick.major.top : True # draw x axis top major ticks +xtick.major.bottom : True # draw x axis bottom major ticks +xtick.minor.top : True # draw x axis top minor ticks +xtick.minor.bottom : True # draw x axis bottom minor ticks + +ytick.left : True # draw ticks on the left side +ytick.right : True # draw ticks on the right side +ytick.major.size : 6 # major tick size in points +ytick.minor.size : 3 # minor tick size in points +ytick.major.width : 0.8 # major tick width in points +ytick.minor.width : 0.4 # minor tick width in points +#ytick.major.pad : 3.5 # distance to major tick label in points +#ytick.minor.pad : 3.4 # distance to the minor tick label in points +#ytick.color : k # color of the tick labels +ytick.labelsize : 10 # fontsize of the tick labels +ytick.direction : in # direction: in, out, or inout +ytick.minor.visible : True # visibility of minor ticks on y-axis +ytick.major.left : True # draw y axis left major ticks +ytick.major.right : True # draw y axis right major ticks +ytick.minor.left : True # draw y axis left minor ticks +ytick.minor.right : True # draw y axis right minor ticks + + +### GRIDS +#grid.color : b0b0b0 # grid color +#grid.linestyle : - # solid +#grid.linewidth : 0.8 # in points +#grid.alpha : 1.0 # transparency, between 0.0 and 1.0 + +### Legend +legend.loc : best +legend.frameon : False # if True, draw the legend on a background patch +legend.framealpha : 1.0 # legend patch transparency +#legend.facecolor : inherit # inherit from axes.facecolor; or color spec +#legend.edgecolor : 0.8 # background patch boundary color +#legend.fancybox : True # if True, use a rounded box for the + # legend background, else a rectangle +#legend.shadow : False # if True, give background a shadow effect +#legend.numpoints : 1 # the number of marker points in the legend line +#legend.scatterpoints : 1 # number of scatter points +#legend.markerscale : 1.0 # the relative size of legend markers vs. original +legend.fontsize : 8 +# Dimensions as fraction of fontsize: +#legend.borderpad : 0.4 # border whitespace +#legend.labelspacing : 0.5 # the vertical space between the legend entries +#legend.handlelength : 2.0 # the length of the legend lines +#legend.handleheight : 0.7 # the height of the legend handle +#legend.handletextpad : 0.8 # the space between the legend line and legend text +#legend.borderaxespad : 0.5 # the border between the axes and legend edge +#legend.columnspacing : 2.0 # column separation + +### FIGURE +# See http://matplotlib.org/api/figure_api.html#matplotlib.figure.Figure +#figure.titlesize : large # size of the figure title (Figure.suptitle()) +#figure.titleweight : normal # weight of the figure title +figure.figsize : 3.25, 3.25 # figure size in inches +figure.dpi : 300 # figure dots per inch +#figure.facecolor : white # figure facecolor; 0.75 is scalar gray +#figure.edgecolor : white # figure edgecolor +#figure.autolayout : False # When True, automatically adjust subplot + # parameters to make the plot fit the figure +#figure.max_open_warning : 20 # The maximum number of figures to open through + # the pyplot interface before emitting a warning. + # If less than one this feature is disabled. + +# The figure subplot parameters. All dimensions are a fraction of the +#figure.subplot.left : 0.125 # the left side of the subplots of the figure +figure.subplot.right : 0.98 # the right side of the subplots of the figure +#figure.subplot.bottom : 0.11 # the bottom of the subplots of the figure +figure.subplot.top : 0.98 # the top of the subplots of the figure +#figure.subplot.wspace : 0.2 # the amount of width reserved for blank space between subplots, + # expressed as a fraction of the average axis width +#figure.subplot.hspace : 0.2 # the amount of height reserved for white space between subplots, + # expressed as a fraction of the average axis height + + +### IMAGES +#image.aspect : equal # equal | auto | a number +#image.interpolation : nearest # see help(imshow) for options +#image.cmap : viridis # A colormap name, gray etc... +#image.lut : 256 # the size of the colormap lookup table +#image.origin : upper # lower | upper +#image.resample : True +#image.composite_image : True # When True, all the images on a set of axes are + # combined into a single composite image before + # saving a figure as a vector graphics file, + # such as a PDF. + +### CONTOUR PLOTS +#contour.negative_linestyle : dashed # dashed | solid +#contour.corner_mask : True # True | False | legacy + +### ERRORBAR PLOTS +errorbar.capsize : 3 # length of end cap on error bars in pixels + +### HISTOGRAM PLOTS +#hist.bins : 10 # The default number of histogram bins. + # If Numpy 1.11 or later is + # installed, may also be `auto` + +### SCATTER PLOTS +#scatter.marker : o # The default marker type for scatter plots. + +### Agg rendering +### Warning: experimental, 2008/10/10 +#agg.path.chunksize : 0 # 0 to disable; values in the range + # 10000 to 100000 can improve speed slightly + # and prevent an Agg rendering failure + # when plotting very large data sets, + # especially if they are very gappy. + # It may cause minor artifacts, though. + # A value of 20000 is probably a good + # starting point. +### SAVING FIGURES +#path.simplify : True # When True, simplify paths by removing "invisible" + # points to reduce file size and increase rendering + # speed +#path.simplify_threshold : 0.1 # The threshold of similarity below which + # vertices will be removed in the simplification + # process +#path.snap : True # When True, rectilinear axis-aligned paths will be snapped to + # the nearest pixel when certain criteria are met. When False, + # paths will never be snapped. +#path.sketch : None # May be none, or a 3-tuple of the form (scale, length, + # randomness). + # *scale* is the amplitude of the wiggle + # perpendicular to the line (in pixels). *length* + # is the length of the wiggle along the line (in + # pixels). *randomness* is the factor by which + # the length is randomly scaled. + +# the default savefig params can be different from the display params +# e.g., you may want a higher resolution, or to make the figure +# background white +#savefig.dpi : figure # figure dots per inch or 'figure' +#savefig.facecolor : white # figure facecolor when saving +#savefig.edgecolor : white # figure edgecolor when saving +savefig.format : pdf # png, ps, pdf, svg +#savefig.bbox : standard # 'tight' or 'standard'. + # 'tight' is incompatible with pipe-based animation + # backends but will workd with temporary file based ones: + # e.g. setting animation.writer to ffmpeg will not work, + # use ffmpeg_file instead +#savefig.pad_inches : 0.1 # Padding to be used when bbox is set to 'tight' +#savefig.jpeg_quality: 95 # when a jpeg is saved, the default quality parameter. +#savefig.directory : ~ # default directory in savefig dialog box, + # leave empty to always use current working directory +#savefig.transparent : False # setting that controls whether figures are saved with a + # transparent background by default + +# tk backend params +#tk.window_focus : False # Maintain shell focus for TkAgg + +# ps backend params +#ps.papersize : letter # auto, letter, legal, ledger, A0-A10, B0-B10 +#ps.useafm : False # use of afm fonts, results in small files +#ps.usedistiller : False # can be: None, ghostscript or xpdf + # Experimental: may produce smaller files. + # xpdf intended for production of publication quality files, + # but requires ghostscript, xpdf and ps2eps +#ps.distiller.res : 6000 # dpi +#ps.fonttype : 3 # Output Type 3 (Type3) or Type 42 (TrueType) + +# pdf backend params +#pdf.compression : 6 # integer from 0 to 9 + # 0 disables compression (good for debugging) +#pdf.fonttype : 3 # Output Type 3 (Type3) or Type 42 (TrueType) + +# svg backend params +#svg.image_inline : True # write raster image data directly into the svg file +#svg.fonttype : 'path' # How to handle SVG fonts: +# 'none': Assume fonts are installed on the machine where the SVG will be viewed. +# 'path': Embed characters as paths -- supported by most SVG renderers +# 'svgfont': Embed characters as SVG fonts -- supported only by Chrome, +# Opera and Safari +#svg.hashsalt : None # if not None, use this string as hash salt + # instead of uuid4 + +# docstring params +#docstring.hardcopy = False # set this when you want to generate hardcopy docstring + +# Set the verbose flags. This controls how much information +# matplotlib gives you at runtime and where it goes. The verbosity +# levels are: silent, helpful, debug, debug-annoying. Any level is +# inclusive of all the levels below it. If your setting is "debug", +# you'll get all the debug and helpful messages. When submitting +# problems to the mailing-list, please set verbose to "helpful" or "debug" +# and paste the output into your report. +# +# The "fileo" gives the destination for any calls to verbose.report. +# These objects can a filename, or a filehandle like sys.stdout. +# +# You can override the rc default verbosity from the command line by +# giving the flags --verbose-LEVEL where LEVEL is one of the legal +# levels, e.g., --verbose-helpful. +# +# You can access the verbose instance in your code +# from matplotlib import verbose. +#verbose.level : silent # one of silent, helpful, debug, debug-annoying +#verbose.fileo : sys.stdout # a log filename, sys.stdout or sys.stderr + +# Event keys to interact with figures/plots via keyboard. +# Customize these settings according to your needs. +# Leave the field(s) empty if you don't need a key-map. (i.e., fullscreen : '') + +#keymap.fullscreen : f, ctrl+f # toggling +#keymap.home : h, r, home # home or reset mnemonic +#keymap.back : left, c, backspace # forward / backward keys to enable +#keymap.forward : right, v # left handed quick navigation +#keymap.pan : p # pan mnemonic +#keymap.zoom : o # zoom mnemonic +#keymap.save : s # saving current figure +#keymap.quit : ctrl+w, cmd+w # close the current figure +#keymap.grid : g # switching on/off a grid in current axes +#keymap.yscale : l # toggle scaling of y-axes ('log'/'linear') +#keymap.xscale : L, k # toggle scaling of x-axes ('log'/'linear') +#keymap.all_axes : a # enable all axes + +# Control location of examples data files +#examples.directory : '' # directory to look in for custom installation + +###ANIMATION settings +#animation.html : 'none' # How to display the animation as HTML in + # the IPython notebook. 'html5' uses + # HTML5 video tag. +#animation.writer : ffmpeg # MovieWriter 'backend' to use +#animation.codec : h264 # Codec to use for writing movie +#animation.bitrate: -1 # Controls size/quality tradeoff for movie. + # -1 implies let utility auto-determine +#animation.frame_format: 'png' # Controls frame format used by temp files +#animation.ffmpeg_path: 'ffmpeg' # Path to ffmpeg binary. Without full path + # $PATH is searched +#animation.ffmpeg_args: '' # Additional arguments to pass to ffmpeg +#animation.avconv_path: 'avconv' # Path to avconv binary. Without full path + # $PATH is searched +#animation.avconv_args: '' # Additional arguments to pass to avconv +#animation.mencoder_path: 'mencoder' + # Path to mencoder binary. Without full path + # $PATH is searched +#animation.mencoder_args: '' # Additional arguments to pass to mencoder +#animation.convert_path: 'convert' # Path to ImageMagick's convert binary. + # On Windows use the full path since convert + # is also the name of a system tool.