JVC - Entrega 1 – Documentación técnica#96
Open
javixtc wants to merge 121 commits intoLIDR-academy:mainfrom
Open
JVC - Entrega 1 – Documentación técnica#96javixtc wants to merge 121 commits intoLIDR-academy:mainfrom
javixtc wants to merge 121 commits intoLIDR-academy:mainfrom
Conversation
…rontend development
…emove 'poc' prefix
… vs video) based on image presence Added User Story 2 (P1): Output Type Indication - System indicates podcast when no image selected - System indicates video when image is selected - Added 4 new functional requirements (FR-016 to FR-019) - Added 3 new success criteria (SC-011 to SC-013) - Updated Key Entities to reflect output type derivation - Added edge cases for output type transitions - Clarified Out of Scope: podcast/video generation deferred to future US - Maintained strict business focus without technical details
Complete vertical pipeline following Constitution 2.0.0 Pipeline: BDD API Domain Application Infra Controllers Frontend Contracts E2E CI/CD Each phase includes exact locations, artifacts, criteria, prohibitions, and gates Coverage minimums: Domain 90%, App 80%, Controllers 80%, FE 70% Estimated effort: 8-10 developer days
Added detailed prompts for implementing a meditation generation system using Java microservices, Spring Boot, and modern architecture patterns. The prompts include structured guidelines for technical implementation, system design, and development workflow to support a 30-hour MVP project with React frontend, Spring backend, PostgreSQL database, and cloud deployment on Fly.io.
|
Important Review skippedToo many files! This PR contains 283 files, which is 133 over the limit of 150. ⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (11)
📒 Files selected for processing (283)
You can disable this status message by setting the Use the checkbox below for a quick retry:
📝 WalkthroughWalkthroughAdded comprehensive MVP documentation for a Meditation Generation Platform, including architectural design, four user stories, backlog prioritization, and detailed ticket breakdowns across authentication, content composition, video generation, and playback features. Changes
Estimated code review effort🎯 3 (Moderate) | ⏱️ ~25 minutes Poem
🚥 Pre-merge checks | ✅ 3✅ Passed checks (3 passed)
✏️ Tip: You can configure your own custom pre-merge checks in the settings. ✨ Finishing Touches🧪 Generate unit tests (beta)
Tip Try Coding Plans. Let us write the prompt for your AI agent so you can ship faster (with fewer bugs). Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. Comment |
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 8
🤖 Fix all issues with AI agents
In `@docs/01-PRD-design-document.md`:
- Around line 236-256: Fix typos in the US4 BDD scenario examples by inserting
missing spaces and correcting phrasing: update "theuseris" to "the user is",
"Then the APIreturns" to "Then the API returns", "Andeach" to "And each", "Given
theuser hasno" to "Given the user has no", "When they requestGET/meditations" to
"When they request GET /meditations", "Then the APIreturns anempty" to "Then the
API returns an empty", "Given theuser hassome meditationsin DONEandsomein" to
"Given the user has some meditations in DONE and some in", "Then the
APIreturnsall" to "Then the API returns all", and "Andonly" to "And only" in the
US4 BDD text block so each phrase reads with proper spacing and grammar.
- Around line 183-200: Update the US3 BDD scenario text in the PRD (the block
starting "Given a Jobexistsin SQS...") to fix spacing typos: replace
"Jobexistsin" with "Job exists in", "Thentextis enrichedusing" with "Then text
is enriched using", "audioisgenerated" with "audio is generated", "Meditation
statusis updatedto" with "Meditation status is updated to", "OpenAI returns
anerror" with "OpenAI returns an error", "Meditation statusissettoERROR" with
"Meditation status is set to ERROR", and "anerror logis" with "an error log is"
so the US3 BDD steps read correctly.
- Line 59: In the BDD scenario string "When the user logsin via SPA" (search for
that exact phrase in docs/01-PRD-design-document.md), fix the typo by replacing
"logsin" with the correct two-word phrase "logs in" so the step reads "When the
user logs in via SPA".
- Around line 120-133: Update the BDD scenario text to fix spacing typos:
replace "theuseris" with "the user is", "basetextfor" with "base text for",
"Meditationrecordis" with "Meditation record is", and "Jobis publishedto SQSfor"
with "Job is published to SQS for" so the Given/When/Then examples read
correctly in the doc (search for those exact strings in the BDD block to locate
the lines to change).
In `@docs/02.User-Stories.md`:
- Around line 121-135: The state names are inconsistent between the scenarios
("en proceso/completada") and the notes/acceptance criteria
(PENDING/ERROR/DONE); pick one canonical naming scheme (either Spanish
human-readable like "en proceso/completada/error" or the uppercase enum style
PENDING/ERROR/DONE) and apply it everywhere: update the Scenario headings and
GIVEN/THEN lines (e.g., "existe una meditación en el sistema con estado 'en
proceso'") and the notes/acceptance criteria to use the chosen names, and also
update any referenced enums/constants or API contract examples to match the same
identifiers (PENDING/ERROR/DONE or en_proceso/completada/etc.) so tests, docs
and API remain consistent.
- Around line 40-42: Update the three bullets about authentication to correct
HTTP status guidance: change the sentence that currently says "Las respuestas
técnicas corresponden a 401 cuando las credenciales son inválidas y 403 cuando
el token es inválido o está expirado" so that it states 401 is returned for
missing/invalid/expired authentication (tokens invalid/expired) and 403 is
returned only for authenticated users who lack permission (authorization
failure); keep the references to AWS Cognito and JWT validation and ensure the
second bullet still says the token is validated on each request (no code
changes).
In `@docs/03.Backlog-tickets.md`:
- Around line 44-47: The document mixes Spanish phrases into English in the
block containing "**1 Story Point (SP) = 4-6 horas developer manual**" and "Con
**Cline/Copilot Agent = 0.3-0.5h/SP** (tu boost x10)"; update these phrases for
consistency by either translating them to English (e.g., "4-6 hours per
developer (manual)" and "(your ~10x boost)") or moving the Spanish versions into
a clearly labeled bilingual section, and ensure the strings "**1 Story Point
(SP) = 4-6 horas developer manual**" and "tu boost x10" are replaced or
relocated accordingly.
In `@docs/06.US3-TIckets.md`:
- Around line 198-223: The worker currently hardcodes a 20% simulated error
rate; make this configurable and disabled in production by adding properties
(e.g., meditation.worker.simulateErrors=false and
meditation.worker.errorRate=0.2) and reading them in MeditationGenerationWorker
(the class with the `@SqsListener` method that simulates processing) via `@Value` or
a `@ConfigurationProperties` bean, defaulting simulateErrors to false and
errorRate to 0.0; ensure the production Spring profile overrides the property to
false, update integration tests to toggle the flag for success and error paths,
and document the new properties in US3-08 acceptance criteria and docs.
🧹 Nitpick comments (9)
docs/03.Backlog-tickets.md (1)
79-88: Language consistency: Spanish section in English document.Lines 79-88 contain Spanish text. While the content is valuable, mixing languages within a single document can reduce clarity and accessibility. Consider translating to English or moving to a separate localized version.
docs/04.US1-TIckets.md (1)
329-343: Document the limitation of memory-only token storage.The acceptance criteria specify that tokens are stored in memory only with no persistence (no localStorage, no cookies). This means users will lose their authenticated session on page refresh, requiring them to log in again.
While this is acceptable for US1 MVP scope, consider adding a note in the "Out of scope" section or as a known limitation to set proper expectations for implementers and stakeholders.
Example addition after line 331:
- **Known limitation**: User session is lost on page refresh/reload (acceptable for US1 MVP).docs/05.US2-TIckets.md (1)
64-78: Consider adding rate limiting and content validation requirements to API contract.The API contract defines endpoints for AI generation and preview but doesn't specify:
- Rate limiting policies (e.g., max requests per user per minute) to protect against abuse
- Maximum payload sizes for requests
- Content validation rules (e.g., max text length, allowed file types for uploads)
While these might be implementation details, defining them in the API contract ensures consistent behavior across implementations and helps prevent resource exhaustion issues.
docs/06.US3-TIckets.md (2)
212-223: Consider increasing VisibilityTimeout for video processing workload.The worker configuration specifies
VisibilityTimeout=30s(line 222). However, video generation typically involves:
- AI text enrichment (OpenAI API call)
- TTS generation (audio processing)
- Image generation
- FFmpeg rendering
These operations can easily exceed 30 seconds, especially if AI services experience latency. A timeout that's too short will cause:
- Duplicate processing (message becomes visible again while still processing)
- Wasted resources
- Potential race conditions in status updates
Consider increasing to 5-10 minutes for video processing workloads, or making it configurable based on job type.
212-214: Add DLQ monitoring to observability requirements.The worker correctly implements a Dead Letter Queue for poison messages (line 214), but there's no mention of monitoring or alerting for DLQ messages. Messages in the DLQ represent permanently failed meditation generation requests that users are waiting for.
Consider adding a ticket or acceptance criteria for:
- CloudWatch metric/alarm on DLQ message count
- Periodic DLQ review process
- User notification strategy for permanently failed meditations
This could be added to US3-14 (Champion Guide DoD) or as part of observability requirements.
docs/07.US4-TIckets.md (1)
232-246: Consider longer expiry time for signed playback URLs.The S3 signed URL generator uses a 5-minute expiry (line 234). While this is secure, it's quite restrictive for video playback:
- Users browsing their meditation list might take >5 minutes to select which to play
- URLs expire before being used, requiring a page refresh
- Poor UX if URL expires during playback
Standard practice for video playback URLs is 15-60 minutes. Consider:
- 15 minutes as a reasonable balance between security and UX
- Making expiry configurable via environment variable
- Implementing URL refresh logic in the frontend
5-minute expiry is more suitable for upload URLs than playback URLs.
docs/02.User-Stories.md (1)
17-36: Use fenced code blocks for multi‑line Gherkin.Single backticks render inline code; the scenarios are multi‑line and should be fenced for correct Markdown rendering and readability.
Suggested edit
-`textFeature: Acceso seguro al Meditation Builder +```gherkin +Feature: Acceso seguro al Meditation Builder Scenario: Usuario se identifica correctamente Given existe un usuario registrado en el sistema de meditación When se identifica correctamente en la aplicación Then puede acceder al Meditation Builder And puede usar las funciones de creación y gestión de meditaciones ... - Scenario: Sesión expirada impide el acceso + Scenario: Sesión expirada impide el acceso Given el usuario se había identificado anteriormente And su sesión ya no es válida When intenta acceder al Meditation Builder Then el acceso es rechazado - And el usuario es informado de que debe identificarse de nuevo` + And el usuario es informado de que debe identificarse de nuevo +```Also applies to: 62-90, 115-135, 161-180
prompts.md (2)
19-26: Prefer proper headings for “Prompt X” labels.Markdownlint flags MD036 because bold text is used as headings. Use
###/####headings instead for consistent structure and TOC behavior.Example fix
-**Prompt 1:** +#### Prompt 1 ... -**Prompt 2:** +#### Prompt 2 ... -**Prompt 3:** +#### Prompt 3Also applies to: 154-216, 220-257, 262-307, 312-329
303-308: Use ATX heading style consistently.Line range shows a setext-style heading; lint expects ATX.
Suggested edit
-**Prompt 3:** -reescribe cada US con tus recomendaciones para que sea BDD puro ---- +#### Prompt 3 +reescribe cada US con tus recomendaciones para que sea BDD puro +---
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| Given the user has a Cognito account | ||
| When the user logsin via SPA |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fix typo in BDD scenario.
"logsin" should be "logs in" (two words).
📝 Proposed fix
- When the user logsin via SPA
+ When the user logs in via SPA📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
Suggested change
| When the user logsin via SPA | |
| When the user logs in via SPA |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In `@docs/01-PRD-design-document.md` at line 59, In the BDD scenario string "When
the user logsin via SPA" (search for that exact phrase in
docs/01-PRD-design-document.md), fix the typo by replacing "logsin" with the
correct two-word phrase "logs in" so the step reads "When the user logs in via
SPA".
Comment on lines
+120
to
+133
| Given theuseris authenticated | ||
| When they submit a basetextfor a meditation | ||
| Then a Meditationrecordis createdwith status PENDING | ||
| And a Jobis publishedto SQSfor processing | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| **Edge Case:** | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| Given the submitted text is empty | ||
| When the user submits it | ||
| Then the API rejects the request with validation error | ||
| And no Meditation or Job is created | ||
| ``` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fix multiple typos in BDD scenario examples.
Several words are missing spaces:
- Line 120: "theuseris" → "the user is"
- Line 121: "basetextfor" → "base text for"
- Line 122: "Meditationrecordis" → "Meditation record is"
- Line 123: "Jobis publishedto SQSfor" → "Job is published to SQS for"
📝 Proposed fix
- Given theuseris authenticated
- When they submit a basetextfor a meditation
- Then a Meditationrecordis createdwith status PENDING
- And a Jobis publishedto SQSfor processing
+ Given the user is authenticated
+ When they submit a base text for a meditation
+ Then a Meditation record is created with status PENDING
+ And a Job is published to SQS for processing🧰 Tools
🪛 markdownlint-cli2 (0.18.1)
128-128: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified
(MD040, fenced-code-language)
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In `@docs/01-PRD-design-document.md` around lines 120 - 133, Update the BDD
scenario text to fix spacing typos: replace "theuseris" with "the user is",
"basetextfor" with "base text for", "Meditationrecordis" with "Meditation record
is", and "Jobis publishedto SQSfor" with "Job is published to SQS for" so the
Given/When/Then examples read correctly in the doc (search for those exact
strings in the BDD block to locate the lines to change).
Comment on lines
+183
to
+200
| Given a Jobexistsin SQS | ||
| When the media-worker consumes the Job | ||
| Thentextis enrichedusing OpenAI | ||
| And audioisgenerated via TTS | ||
| And image/video is generated | ||
| And final video is rendered with FFmpeg | ||
| And videois uploadedto S3 | ||
| And Meditation statusis updatedto DONE | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| **Edge Case:** | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| Given OpenAI returns anerror | ||
| When the media-worker processes the Job | ||
| Then Meditation statusissettoERROR | ||
| And anerror logis generated | ||
| ``` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fix typos in US3 BDD scenario examples.
Multiple words are missing spaces:
- Line 183: "Jobexistsin" → "Job exists in"
- Line 185: "Thentextis enrichedusing" → "Then text is enriched using"
- Line 186: "audioisgenerated" → "audio is generated"
- Line 190: "Meditation statusis updatedto" → "Meditation status is updated to"
- Line 196: "OpenAI returns anerror" → "OpenAI returns an error"
- Line 198: "Meditation statusissettoERROR" → "Meditation status is set to ERROR"
- Line 199: "anerror logis" → "an error log is"
🧰 Tools
🪛 markdownlint-cli2 (0.18.1)
195-195: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified
(MD040, fenced-code-language)
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In `@docs/01-PRD-design-document.md` around lines 183 - 200, Update the US3 BDD
scenario text in the PRD (the block starting "Given a Jobexistsin SQS...") to
fix spacing typos: replace "Jobexistsin" with "Job exists in", "Thentextis
enrichedusing" with "Then text is enriched using", "audioisgenerated" with
"audio is generated", "Meditation statusis updatedto" with "Meditation status is
updated to", "OpenAI returns anerror" with "OpenAI returns an error",
"Meditation statusissettoERROR" with "Meditation status is set to ERROR", and
"anerror logis" with "an error log is" so the US3 BDD steps read correctly.
Comment on lines
+236
to
+256
| Given theuseris authenticated | ||
| When they requestGET /meditations | ||
| Then the APIreturns a listofall meditationsfor thatuser | ||
| Andeach meditation includes: id, input_text, status, video_url (if DONE) | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| **Edge Case 1 (No meditations):** | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| Given theuser hasno meditations | ||
| When they requestGET/meditations | ||
| Then the APIreturns anempty list | ||
| ``` | ||
|
|
||
| **Edge Case 2 (Partial completion):** | ||
|
|
||
| ``` | ||
| Given theuser hassome meditationsin DONEandsomein PROCESSING | ||
| When they requestGET /meditations | ||
| Then the APIreturnsall meditationswith theircurrent status | ||
| Andonly the DONE meditationsinclude the video_url |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fix typos in US4 BDD scenario examples.
Multiple words are missing spaces:
- Line 236: "theuseris" → "the user is"
- Line 238: "Then the APIreturns" → "Then the API returns"
- Line 239: "Andeach" → "And each"
- Line 245: "Given theuser hasno" → "Given the user has no"
- Line 246: "When they requestGET/meditations" → "When they request GET /meditations"
- Line 247: "Then the APIreturns anempty" → "Then the API returns an empty"
- Line 253: "Given theuser hassome meditationsin DONEandsomein" → "Given the user has some meditations in DONE and some in"
- Line 255: "Then the APIreturnsall" → "Then the API returns all"
- Line 256: "Andonly" → "And only"
🧰 Tools
🪛 markdownlint-cli2 (0.18.1)
244-244: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified
(MD040, fenced-code-language)
252-252: Fenced code blocks should have a language specified
(MD040, fenced-code-language)
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In `@docs/01-PRD-design-document.md` around lines 236 - 256, Fix typos in the US4
BDD scenario examples by inserting missing spaces and correcting phrasing:
update "theuseris" to "the user is", "Then the APIreturns" to "Then the API
returns", "Andeach" to "And each", "Given theuser hasno" to "Given the user has
no", "When they requestGET/meditations" to "When they request GET /meditations",
"Then the APIreturns anempty" to "Then the API returns an empty", "Given theuser
hassome meditationsin DONEandsomein" to "Given the user has some meditations in
DONE and some in", "Then the APIreturnsall" to "Then the API returns all", and
"Andonly" to "And only" in the US4 BDD text block so each phrase reads with
proper spacing and grammar.
Comment on lines
+40
to
+42
| - La identificación se implementa con AWS Cognito y tokens JWT sin estado en el servidor. | ||
| - El token se valida en cada petición a endpoints protegidos. | ||
| - Las respuestas técnicas corresponden a 401 cuando las credenciales son inválidas y 403 cuando el token es inválido o está expirado. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Fix HTTP status guidance for auth failures.
401 is for missing/invalid/expired authentication; 403 is for authenticated but not authorized. The current note inverts that for invalid/expired tokens.
Suggested correction
-- Las respuestas técnicas corresponden a 401 cuando las credenciales son inválidas y 403 cuando el token es inválido o está expirado.
+- Las respuestas técnicas corresponden a 401 cuando faltan o son inválidas/expiradas las credenciales, y 403 cuando el usuario está autenticado pero no tiene permisos.📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
Suggested change
| - La identificación se implementa con AWS Cognito y tokens JWT sin estado en el servidor. | |
| - El token se valida en cada petición a endpoints protegidos. | |
| - Las respuestas técnicas corresponden a 401 cuando las credenciales son inválidas y 403 cuando el token es inválido o está expirado. | |
| - La identificación se implementa con AWS Cognito y tokens JWT sin estado en el servidor. | |
| - El token se valida en cada petición a endpoints protegidos. | |
| - Las respuestas técnicas corresponden a 401 cuando faltan o son inválidas/expiradas las credenciales, y 403 cuando el usuario está autenticado pero no tiene permisos. |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In `@docs/02.User-Stories.md` around lines 40 - 42, Update the three bullets about
authentication to correct HTTP status guidance: change the sentence that
currently says "Las respuestas técnicas corresponden a 401 cuando las
credenciales son inválidas y 403 cuando el token es inválido o está expirado" so
that it states 401 is returned for missing/invalid/expired authentication
(tokens invalid/expired) and 403 is returned only for authenticated users who
lack permission (authorization failure); keep the references to AWS Cognito and
JWT validation and ensure the second bullet still says the token is validated on
each request (no code changes).
docs/02.User-Stories.md
Outdated
Comment on lines
121
to
135
| Then se crea una nueva meditación en el sistema con estado "en proceso" | ||
| And se registra que la meditación debe ser procesada para generar el vídeo | ||
|
|
||
| Scenario: Rechazar generación de vídeo sin texto | ||
| Given el usuario está autenticado | ||
| And no ha definido el texto de la meditación | ||
| When solicita generar el vídeo de la meditación | ||
| Then la solicitud es rechazada | ||
| And el usuario es informado de que debe completar el texto de la meditación | ||
|
|
||
| Scenario: Marcar la meditación como fallida tras un error de procesamiento | ||
| Given existe una meditación en el sistema con estado "en proceso" | ||
| When se produce un error al procesar la generación del vídeo | ||
| Then la meditación pasa a estado "error" | ||
| And el motivo del fallo queda registrado para diagnóstico interno` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Align state names across scenarios and notes.
Acceptance criteria use “en proceso/completada”, while notes define PENDING/ERROR/DONE. This will cause ambiguity in API contracts and tests. Pick one naming scheme and apply consistently.
Possible alignment (example)
-Then se crea una nueva meditación en el sistema con estado "en proceso"
+Then se crea una nueva meditación en el sistema con estado "PENDING"
...
-Scenario: Reproducir una meditación completada
+Scenario: Reproducir una meditación completada
...
-And existe una meditación suya con estado "completada"
+And existe una meditación suya con estado "DONE"Also applies to: 139-141, 169-177
🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[grammar] ~121-~121: Cambia la palabra o signo.
Context: ...ón en el sistema con estado "en proceso" And se registra que la meditación debe s...
(QB_NEW_ES_OTHER_ERROR_IDS_REPLACEMENT_OTHER)
[grammar] ~122-~122: Aquí puede haber un error.
Context: ...debe ser procesada para generar el vídeo Scenario: Rechazar generación de vídeo s...
(QB_NEW_ES)
[grammar] ~124-~124: Cambia la palabra o signo.
Context: ...: Rechazar generación de vídeo sin texto Given el usuario está autenticado An...
(QB_NEW_ES_OTHER_ERROR_IDS_REPLACEMENT_SPACE)
[grammar] ~125-~125: Cambia la palabra o signo.
Context: ...to Given el usuario está autenticado And no ha definido el texto de la medita...
(QB_NEW_ES_OTHER_ERROR_IDS_REPLACEMENT_SPACE)
[grammar] ~126-~126: Cambia la palabra o signo.
Context: ...no ha definido el texto de la meditación When solicita generar el vídeo de la med...
(QB_NEW_ES_OTHER_ERROR_IDS_REPLACEMENT_SPACE)
[grammar] ~127-~127: Cambia la palabra o signo.
Context: ...licita generar el vídeo de la meditación Then la solicitud es rechazada And e...
(QB_NEW_ES_OTHER_ERROR_IDS_REPLACEMENT_SPACE)
[grammar] ~128-~128: Cambia la palabra o signo.
Context: ...ación Then la solicitud es rechazada And el usuario es informado de que debe ...
(QB_NEW_ES_OTHER_ERROR_IDS_REPLACEMENT_SPACE)
[grammar] ~135-~135: Elimina la puntuación
Context: ...fallo queda registrado para diagnóstico interno` Notas técnicas - Esta historia introd...
(QB_NEW_ES_OTHER_ERROR_IDS_UNNECESSARY_PUNCTUATION)
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In `@docs/02.User-Stories.md` around lines 121 - 135, The state names are
inconsistent between the scenarios ("en proceso/completada") and the
notes/acceptance criteria (PENDING/ERROR/DONE); pick one canonical naming scheme
(either Spanish human-readable like "en proceso/completada/error" or the
uppercase enum style PENDING/ERROR/DONE) and apply it everywhere: update the
Scenario headings and GIVEN/THEN lines (e.g., "existe una meditación en el
sistema con estado 'en proceso'") and the notes/acceptance criteria to use the
chosen names, and also update any referenced enums/constants or API contract
examples to match the same identifiers (PENDING/ERROR/DONE or
en_proceso/completada/etc.) so tests, docs and API remain consistent.
Comment on lines
+44
to
+47
| **1 Story Point (SP) = 4-6 horas developer manual** (estándar Agile). | ||
|
|
||
| Con **Cline/Copilot Agent = 0.3-0.5h/SP** (tu boost x10). | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Inconsistent language mixing in documentation.
Lines 44 and 46 contain Spanish text ("horas developer manual", "tu boost x10") mixed within an English document. For consistency and broader accessibility, consider using English throughout or clearly separating language sections.
📝 Suggested revision
-**1 Story Point (SP) = 4-6 horas developer manual** (estándar Agile).
+**1 Story Point (SP) = 4-6 hours manual development** (Agile standard).
-Con **Cline/Copilot Agent = 0.3-0.5h/SP** (tu boost x10).
+With **Cline/Copilot Agent = 0.3-0.5h/SP** (your 10x boost).📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
Suggested change
| **1 Story Point (SP) = 4-6 horas developer manual** (estándar Agile). | |
| Con **Cline/Copilot Agent = 0.3-0.5h/SP** (tu boost x10). | |
| **1 Story Point (SP) = 4-6 hours manual development** (Agile standard). | |
| With **Cline/Copilot Agent = 0.3-0.5h/SP** (your 10x boost). |
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In `@docs/03.Backlog-tickets.md` around lines 44 - 47, The document mixes Spanish
phrases into English in the block containing "**1 Story Point (SP) = 4-6 horas
developer manual**" and "Con **Cline/Copilot Agent = 0.3-0.5h/SP** (tu boost
x10)"; update these phrases for consistency by either translating them to
English (e.g., "4-6 hours per developer (manual)" and "(your ~10x boost)") or
moving the Spanish versions into a clearly labeled bilingual section, and ensure
the strings "**1 Story Point (SP) = 4-6 horas developer manual**" and "tu boost
x10" are replaced or relocated accordingly.
Comment on lines
+198
to
+223
| **US3-08 — SQS Worker Skeleton for Job Processing** | ||
|
|
||
| **Type:** Task | ||
|
|
||
| **Layer / Scope:** Infrastructure | ||
|
|
||
| **Description:** | ||
|
|
||
| Consumer skeleton: receive job→call use case→update status. Simulate processing. | ||
|
|
||
| **Out of scope:** Real video generation (US4). | ||
|
|
||
| **Acceptance Criteria:** | ||
|
|
||
| - **`backend/src/main/java/com/meditation/infrastructure/worker/MeditationGenerationWorker.java`** @SqsListener | ||
| - Idempotent: skip if !PENDING. 20% simulated error rate. | ||
| - LocalStack: job→status ERROR/DONE, retries=3, DLQ poison handling | ||
|
|
||
| **Attachments / Artifacts:** | ||
|
|
||
| - Worker + integration tests | ||
|
|
||
| **AI Execution Hints:** | ||
|
|
||
| VisibilityTimeout=30s, MaxReceives=3. Random error simulation. Separate Spring profile. | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Ensure simulated error rate is configurable and disabled in production.
Line 213 specifies a "20% simulated error rate" in the worker for testing. While this is excellent for testing resilience during development, ensure this behavior is:
- Controlled by a configuration flag or environment variable
- Explicitly disabled in production environments
- Documented as a testing-only feature
A hardcoded error rate accidentally left enabled in production would cause unnecessary failures and poor user experience.
💡 Suggested acceptance criteria addition
Add to US3-08 Acceptance Criteria:
- Simulated error rate controlled by environment variable (default: false)
- Error simulation explicitly disabled in production configuration
- Integration tests verify both success and error simulation paths🧰 Tools
🪛 markdownlint-cli2 (0.18.1)
198-198: Emphasis used instead of a heading
(MD036, no-emphasis-as-heading)
🤖 Prompt for AI Agents
In `@docs/06.US3-TIckets.md` around lines 198 - 223, The worker currently
hardcodes a 20% simulated error rate; make this configurable and disabled in
production by adding properties (e.g., meditation.worker.simulateErrors=false
and meditation.worker.errorRate=0.2) and reading them in
MeditationGenerationWorker (the class with the `@SqsListener` method that
simulates processing) via `@Value` or a `@ConfigurationProperties` bean, defaulting
simulateErrors to false and errorRate to 0.0; ensure the production Spring
profile overrides the property to false, update integration tests to toggle the
flag for success and error paths, and document the new properties in US3-08
acceptance criteria and docs.
added 19 commits
January 27, 2026 15:18
- Phase 1: Created all project directories with .gitkeep files - Backend: domain, application, infrastructure packages - Tests: BDD, contracts, e2e structures - Frontend: api, components, pages, hooks, state directories - Phase 2: BDD First (YELLOW state achieved) - compose-content.feature: 8 consolidated scenarios - ComposeContentSteps.java: All step definitions with PendingException - ComposeContentBDDTest.java: JUnit Platform runner - Tests run: 8, Errors: 8 (PendingException - YELLOW ) - Verified all scenarios execute and show PENDING status - Fixed pom.xml testSourceDirectory (Maven standard) - Commented cucumber-spring dependency (not needed for YELLOW phase) Next: Phase 3 - API First (OpenAPI definition)
- Created complete OpenAPI 3.0.3 specification - File: compose-content.yaml (650+ lines) - 11 operations covering 8 core capabilities: 1. createComposition Scenario 1 (Access Builder) 2. updateText Scenario 2 (Manual Text Entry) 3. generateText Scenario 3 (AI Text Gen/Enhancement) 4. generateImage Scenario 4 (AI Image Generation) 5. getOutputType Scenarios 5 & 6 (Output Type) 6. previewMusic Scenario 7 (Music Preview) 7. previewImage Scenario 8 (Image Preview) + selectMusic, setImage, removeImage, getComposition - Request/Response schemas: 11 DTOs defined - Error handling: 400, 404, 429, 503, 500 responses - All operationIds aligned with use case names - Capabilities mapped to BDD scenarios in comments - YAML structure validated (openapi 3.0.3 compliant) - Added comprehensive .gitignore: - Maven target/ directory excluded - Node modules, build artifacts excluded - Test reports, coverage excluded - IDE files, OS temp files excluded Next: Phase 4 - Domain Layer (Value Objects, Entities, Ports)
…(T015-T025) **Value Objects Created** (Immutable, TDD): - TextContent: Meditation text with preservation invariant (10k char max) - 10 unit tests: validation, immutability, value equality - OutputType: PODCAST vs VIDEO enum - 5 unit tests: enum values, valueOf - MusicReference: Optional music catalog reference - 6 unit tests: validation, value equality - ImageReference: Optional image reference (manual/AI) - 7 unit tests: validation, value equality **Aggregate Root Created**: - MeditationComposition: Core domain entity - Business logic: getOutputType() (image == null PODCAST, else VIDEO) - 15 unit tests: creation, updates, output type derivation - Enforces invariants: ID required, TextContent mandatory **Inbound Ports (Use Cases)**: - ComposeContentUseCase: 7 methods (create, update, select, set, remove, get) - GenerateTextUseCase: generateText(), enhanceText() - GenerateImageUseCase: generateImage() **Outbound Ports (External Services)**: - MediaCatalogPort: music/image catalog access (preview, validation) - TextGenerationPort: AI text generation service - ImageGenerationPort: AI image generation service **Tests Summary**: - 43 domain unit tests PASSING (100% coverage) - Zero framework dependencies (pure Java) - DDD invariants enforced - BDD still YELLOW (8 scenarios pending - expected) **Fixed**: - .gitignore: Changed 'out/' to '/out/' (excluded IntelliJ root, not ports/out/) Next: Phase 5 - Application Layer (Use Case Services)
**Patrón aplicado:** Siguiendo MeditationComposition.java **Value Objects refactorizados:** TextContent.java: final class record MusicReference.java: final class record ImageReference.java: final class record **Cambios implementados:** - Constructor compacto con validación (Objects.requireNonNull) - Eliminados getters manuales (getValue() value() auto-generado) - Eliminados equals/hashCode/toString (auto-generados por record) - Inmutabilidad garantizada por record - Validaciones preservadas en constructor canónico compacto - TextContent mantiene helper method length() **Tests actualizados:** - TextContentTest: 10 tests adaptados a record accessor value() - MusicReferenceTest: 6 tests adaptados - ImageReferenceTest: 7 tests adaptados - MeditationCompositionTest: 18 tests reescritos para API inmutable - Uso de factory methods create() - Tests de Clock injection - Tests de inmutabilidad (withX retorna nuevas instancias) - Tests de timestamps (createdAt/updatedAt) - Tests de Optional accessors - Tests de operaciones encadenadas **Diferencias con old API:** - getValue() value() (convención records) - NullPointerException esperada (Objects.requireNonNull) - Immutable API: withText(), withMusic(), withImage() retornan nuevas instancias **Tests Summary:** - 46 domain tests PASSING (100% coverage) - OutputTypeTest: 5 tests - ImageReferenceTest: 7 tests - MeditationCompositionTest: 18 tests - MusicReferenceTest: 6 tests - TextContentTest: 10 tests - BDD: 8 scenarios YELLOW (pending - esperado) Next: FASE 2 - Actualizar ComposeContentUseCase a UUID
**Breaking Change:** Port signature actualizado **Cambios:** ComposeContentUseCase.java: String compositionId UUID compositionId - updateText(UUID, ...) - selectMusic(UUID, ...) - setImage(UUID, ...) - removeImage(UUID) - getOutputType(UUID) - getComposition(UUID) - CompositionNotFoundException(UUID) constructor **Justificación:** - Alineado con MeditationComposition record (usa UUID id) - Tipo seguro evita errores de casting - Mejor semántica de dominio (UUID es identifier, String es text) **Impacto:** Application Layer (Phase 5): servicios deben actualizar firmas Infrastructure Controllers (Phase 7): parsear UUID de path params DTOs (Phase 7): mapear String UUID OpenAPI (ya tiene format: uuid): sin cambios necesarios **Compilación:** BUILD SUCCESS Next: Phase 5 - Application Layer (ComposeContentService implementation)
…opilot - Crear java21-best-practices.md con patrones obligatorios: - Records para Value Objects y Entities - UUID para identificadores (no String) - Clock injection para timestamps determinísticos - API inmutable con métodos withX() - Optional accessors para campos nullable - Validación en compact constructor - Actualizar engineering-guidelines.md con referencia - Actualizar backend.instructions.md con reglas de dominio - Actualizar copilot-instructions.md con jerarquía de fuentes
- Translate java21-best-practices.md to English - Translate copilot-instructions.md to English - Translate engineering-guidelines.md to English All instruction files are now in English for consistency
…on content composition - Implemented ComposeContentService to orchestrate composition operations. - Created GenerateTextService for AI text generation and enhancement. - Developed GenerateImageService for AI image generation. - Added TextLengthValidator to enforce text length constraints. - Introduced ValidationResult class for validation outcomes. - Created domain exceptions: CompositionNotFoundException and MusicNotFoundException. - Defined CompositionRepositoryPort for composition persistence operations. - Added unit tests for ComposeContentService, GenerateTextService, GenerateImageService, and TextLengthValidator.
- Add AiTextMapper for mapping between domain model and AI text service DTOs. - Implement ImageGenerationAiAdapter with integration tests using WireMock. - Create MediaCatalogAdapter with integration tests for media catalog service. - Add TextGenerationAiAdapter with integration tests for AI text generation service. - Implement unit tests for AiImageMapper and AiTextMapper to validate mapping logic. - Update tasks in project specification to reflect completed implementations.
…rvices and media catalog
…sition API - Introduced CompositionResponse, CreateCompositionRequest, ErrorResponse, GenerateTextRequest, ImagePreviewResponse, ImageReferenceResponse, MusicPreviewResponse, OutputTypeResponse, SelectMusicRequest, SetImageRequest, TextContentResponse, and UpdateTextRequest DTOs for handling API requests and responses. - Implemented CompositionDtoMapper for converting between domain models and DTOs. - Created unit tests for CompositionDtoMapper to ensure correct mapping between domain and DTOs. - Developed integration tests for MeditationBuilderController to validate API endpoints and request handling.
…d image generation capabilities - Added components for text editing, music selection, and image preview. - Created hooks for managing compositions, generating text and images. - Integrated Zustand for local state management in the Meditation Builder. - Established a responsive layout for the Meditation Builder page. - Implemented error handling for AI generation processes. - Added tests for Zustand store functionality. - Configured TypeScript and Vite for the project.
added 30 commits
February 17, 2026 09:25
T011: React UI Components - Generated OpenAPI TypeScript client (typescript-fetch) - Components: StateLabel, MeditationCard, MeditationList, MeditationPlayer - Spanish labels + state-based styling - Accessibility: ARIA labels, semantic HTML - Play button disabled for non-COMPLETED meditations T012: State Management - React Query hooks: useMeditationList, usePlaybackInfo - Zustand store: playerStore (UI state) - Server-state (React Query) vs UI-state (Zustand) separation - Error handling: 404/409 responses with Spanish messages T013: Page & Routing - MeditationLibraryPage: Full integration - React Router v6: /library route + navigation - QueryClientProvider setup - Type-safe imports with vite-env.d.ts Build: SUCCESS (npm run build) Dependencies: react-router-dom@^6 added Tech Stack: - React 18, TypeScript 5.3 - TanStack React Query 5.17 - Zustand 4.4 - React Router 6 - Vite 5
- Updated test results to reflect successful test run. - Added E2E tests for meditation library listing, playback flow, and error handling. - Verified that meditations are listed with correct state labels and playback functionality. - Ensured error handling for playback failures is correctly displayed to users. - Marked implementation tasks as complete in project documentation.
… Meditations implementation
…for records and validation
…ties - Updated AiTextRequest to use new property accessors for model and parameters. - Changed OpenAI API key in application-local.yml and application.yml for testing. - Modified GenerateMeditationContentServiceTest to verify background image handling. - Adjusted MeditationOutputTest to replace Optional checks with null checks for media URLs and image references. - Updated GenerateMeditationContractTest and MeditationGenerationControllerTest to use fixed timestamps for consistency. - Refactored integration tests for ImageGenerationAiAdapter and TextGenerationAiAdapter to use new OpenAiProperties structure. - Updated PlaybackInfoServiceTest, ListMeditationsServiceTest, and PlaybackValidatorTest to use fixed timestamps for testing. - Adjusted PostgreSqlMeditationRepositoryAdapterIT to use fixed timestamps for all insertions and checks.
- Updated CSS styles to enhance the design system with new color tokens, typography, and button styles. - Improved button hover effects and added new button sizes. - Refined text editor styles for better usability and aesthetics. - Adjusted meditation library page layout and header styles for improved readability. - Changed error messages and button labels from Spanish to English for consistency. - Updated E2E tests to reflect the new English text in the UI.
- Adjusted Playwright test reports to reflect updated test counts and execution times. - Enhanced Firefox launch options in Playwright configuration to disable hardware acceleration and improve stability. - Updated API calls in upload-client and useGenerateImage hooks to use environment variable for base URL. - Modified MeditationPlayer component to improve error handling and UI feedback for media playback errors. - Added media playback error handling in MeditationLibraryPage to provide user-friendly messages without resetting the player. - Implemented route handling in e2e tests to prevent media loading errors from fake S3 URLs.
…vercel configuration)
…ocumentation for meditation content generation
…improved environment handling
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Summary by CodeRabbit
✏️ Tip: You can customize this high-level summary in your review settings.