FLT

FLT brings floating point support to C compilers lacking the capability. It is meant as a bridge to allow immediate development of floating point code in lieu of official native support at some future date.

Usage

FLT requirements:

• gcc v9.0 or later (v9.0+); uses the -fdiagnostics-format=json option
• PHP v7.0 or later (v7.0+)
• the target compiler, e.g. cc65, should support an unsigned 32-bit integer type, e.g. uint32_t
• the source code should be ANSI C or later; K&R will NOT be supported!

To use FLT in your project:

• clone this repository or download the source code
• (optional) create a FLT library flt.lib by compiling the source files flt-*.c (see below for an example)
• convert your C *.c with floating point code to FLT *-flt.c using the PHP script flt.php
• compile *-flt.c as usual

Example to generate «flt-repo»/flt/eg/averages:

	cd «flt-repo»/flt
	php flt.php -i eg/averages.c -o eg/averages-flt.c
	gcc -o eg/averages eg/averages-flt.c flt-*.c

You can review «flt-repo»/flt/eg/averages-flt.c (code will be at the end) and you will see it has no floating point code – all converted to FLT.

For the cc65 suite, you will probably want to do something like this. Assumes the «flt-repo»/flt/flt-*.c files have been compiled to «flt-repo»/flt/flt.lib, and the paths of cc65, ca65, and ld65 are in $PATH.

	cd «flt-repo»/flt
	php flt.php -i eg/averages.c -o eg/averages-flt.c -x '-I «cc65-repo»/cc65/include'
	cc65 -t «target» eg/averages-flt.c
	ca65 -t «target» eg/averages-flt.s
	ld65 -o eg/averages -t «target» eg/averages-flt.o flt.lib -L «cc65-repo»/cc65/lib «target».lib

Another interesting example file is «flt-repo»/flt/eg/paranoia.c adapted by Sumner & Gay. Building and running this will give you an idea of any remaining defects or flaws in FLT and help you decide whether you want to use it.

To compile «flt-repo»/flt/eg/paranoia.c using gcc (it is probably too big to run in an 8-bit system):

	cd «flt-repo»/flt
	php flt.php -i eg/paranoia.c -o eg/paranoia-flt.c -x '-DNOSIGNAL -DSingle'
	gcc -o eg/paranoia eg/paranoia-flt.c flt-*.c

It is recommended to build «flt-repo»/flt/flt.lib and link to it to reduce the size of executables. For the cc65 suite, there is a build script available as «flt-repo»/flt/build-cc65. Edit the build script to point XCC to where the cc65 repo is located, revise TGT as required, and run the script to build the «flt-repo»/flt/flt.lib library.

Other interesting examples:

• «flt-repo»/flt/eg/flops.c – Inspired by flops.c, see how blazing fast your machine is! 😉

• «flt-repo»/flt/eg/mandelfloat.c – A fun little program borrowed from mandelfloat.c. Sample output:

	***************************************************
	***************************************************
	****************###################****************
	************###########################************
	*********#################################*********
	*******####%%%%%%%%%$$$-=$$%%###############*******
	******##%%%%%%%%$$$$==.%$+=$$$%%#############******
	*****#%%%%%%%$$$==#=*#=  -#+.$$%%%############*****
	****%%%%%$$--==--*           #-$%%%%###########****
	***#$$$$==.*    =.            *$$%%%############***
	***                         $+-$$%%%%###########***
	***#$$$$==.*    =.            *$$%%%############***
	****%%%%%$$--==--*           #-$%%%%###########****
	*****#%%%%%%%$$$==#=*#=  -#+.$$%%%############*****
	******##%%%%%%%%$$$$==.%$+=$$$%%#############******
	*******####%%%%%%%%%$$$-=$$%%###############*******
	*********#################################*********
	************###########################************
	****************###################****************
	***************************************************
	***************************************************

For the cc65 suite, there is a build script available as «flt-repo»/flt/eg/build-cc65 for the sample programs. Edit the build script to point XCC to where the cc65 repo is located, revise TGT and EXT as required, then run the script. For the target, it will build executables for averages, mandelfloat, and flops. For the host, it will build executables for errors (needs to compare with standard floating point functions), tests (too large for 8-bit systems), and paranoia (also too large for 8-bit systems).

Be sure to adhere to the licensing terms provided in this and other repositories mentioned here to ensure proper usage and compliance.

How It Works

Versions of gcc v9.0+ have an option -fdiagnostics-format=json to output errors and warnings in JSON. The JSON indicates exactly where the issues are including error messages, line numbers, and column positions. With a bit of substitution hocus-pocus to deliberately generate errors, it is possible to use gcc and PHP to parse the source code and determine where to substitute FLT code!

Inspiration

The cc65 repository for the cc65 suite of tools has a multi-user multi-year project under development to support native floating point, but as they mention "You can not use any of this to write software yet. Don’t bother." There still appears to be a lot of work remaining. I considered contributing to the project but in reviewing the code, I felt the commitment to ramp-up was too much for what I can offer.

I thought instead "Would it be possible to do a light integration with no modifications to the existing compiler?" Say alias a 32-bit integer as a float type, and write functions with that? While writing the floating point routines was easy enough (except for pow – so many special cases!), I was stuck on converting floating point code to FLT. I researched many options like: adapting a C99 parser in Python, or using CIL via OCaml, or a C++ to C converter. But they were all lacking.

On a hunch, I looked at gcc v9.0+ and noticed it highlighted the locations of offending code during compilation. I thought, okay, I’ll have to write a clunky parser for the error output. But then I looked through the man options and saw -fdiagnostics-format=json to output errors in JSON. That was the key! The current version can still have problems with some C code, but it is a very good first step.

While the cc65 suite of tools was the inspiration, there are a lot of other "tiny" compilers targeting microprocessors without native floating point support which could benefit from FLT.

Features

• FLT corresponds to IEEE 754 single-precision floating point with one sign bit, eight exponent bits, and 24 significand bits (23 explicitly stored).
• As well as single-precision floating point, double-precision floating point literals, variables, and functions are also converted to FLT and flt_*. The C standard only specifies that the type double provides at LEAST as much precision as the type float, so this is permitted!
• Provides NaN, ±infinity, ±zero, and subnormal numbers
• Functions provided, can also use float versions, e.g. sinf, cosf, tanf, …
  • mathematical operators: +, -, *, /, +=, -=, *=, /=, ++, --
  • comparison operators: ==, >, <, >=, <=, !=
  • ldexp, frexp, modf, fmod
  • fabs, round, trunc, ceil, floor
  • sqrt, hypot
  • log, log10, log2, exp, exp10, exp2, pow
  • sin, cos, tan, asin, acos, atan, atan2
  • sinh, cosh, tanh, asinh, acosh, atanh
  • isinf, isnan, isnormal, issubnormal, iszero, isfinite
  • atof, ftoa, ltof, ultof, ftol, ftoul
  • fmin, fmax, fsgn

Current Limitations

These limitations may be revised as the project evolves:

• The accuracy of FLT is NOT professional grade and should NOT be used in mission-critical applications where errors can have serious consequences!
• As well, FLT is NOT optimized for speed or space. It is basically a temporary solution to provide floating point support in C compilers currently lacking it.
• Currently gcc -fdiagnostics-format=json v9.0+ does not provide enough information to parse certain constructions such as a cast spanning multiple lines, or the scanf example below. It is recommended to thoroughly test the programs after compiling to ensure correct functionality.
• I/O functions are limited in how many float parameters can be specified in a single function call. For *printf, up to 15 "%e"/"%E" & five "%f"/"%F" parameters, and for *scanf, up to five parameters of any format can be specified.
• Some expressions involving *scanf may behave differently in FLT. In particular, constructions like: if (1 == scanf("%10f", &f)) { … } will be converted to incorrect code. The 1 == is problematic so rather than trying to support this construction, suggest revising to something like: if (scanf("%10f", &f) == 1) { … }.
• Also note that FLT parameters in *scanf are handled as strings with reduced criteria with respect to what is valid or not. So a call like sscanf("X Y Z", "%f %f %f", …); may return 3 indicating three "matches". A workaround is to use !isnan() on each variable to confirm if it is valid.
• Similar to above, FLT parameters in *printf are also handled as strings, so padding is restricted to spaces for FLT values.
• The variadic functions vprintf, vscanf, and related are not supported.
• The approximations used in atan, and exp2 could display some accuracy issues near boundary conditions. This also includes these dependent functions: asin, acos, atan2, exp, exp10, pow, sinh, cosh, and tanh.

Precision

The worst-case precisions for the default approximations, in decimal digits, are:

fn	digits
sin	7.4†
cos	7.4†
atan	7.1†
exp2	6.9
log2	7.2†‡

† The maximum precision for FLT would be expected to be 7.2 decimal digits. Note however the ULP is permitted to be inaccurate in standard floating point functions, so instead of compounding errors by comparing FLT values with those from float functions, they were compared with those from double functions. This is how precisions greater than 7.2 decimal digits were achieved. In summary, sin & cos are very good, log2 is satisfactory, and atan is "good enough".

‡ The default log2 uses a CORDIC routine which requires between zero to 60 floating point operations per invocation (average of 30). Building with -DPOLY_LOG2 will use a polynomial approximation which requires 20 floating point operations, but accuracy drops to 6.6 decimal digits.

License

This repository is governed by a dual license – one for individual users and another for commercial users. Please review the respective licenses in the repository for complete details. For commercial distribution rights, a separate Commercial License is required, which can be obtained by contacting the repository owner russell.s.harper@gmail.com.

Your use of this code is subject to these license terms.

---

If you have any questions and/or suggestions, would like to discuss commercial distribution rights, or if you find FLT useful for your project, feel free to contact:

Russell Harper

russell.s.harper@gmail.com

2023-10-16