Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Update classes.py #5

Open
wants to merge 1 commit into
base: main
Choose a base branch
from
Open

Update classes.py #5

wants to merge 1 commit into from

Conversation

ollobrains
Copy link

  1. Verify Understanding You’ve provided a Python file containing several classes (Hero, Enemy, Item, Makanan) and dictionaries (roles, sub_roles, etc.). The code supports:

Defining role-based stats for a game’s hero classes. Sub-role expansions with alternate stats and inventories. A Hero class that can save/load itself as JSON, attack/guard, and manage an inventory. An Item class (and specialized Makanan class) that can manage pricing, reading from JSON, calculating totals, etc. The code references multiple external modules and JSON resources. It's presumably part of a text-based or console-based RPG. We’ll aim to critique and refine it for clarity, maintainability, and style, while ensuring no change in functionality.

  1. Outline Approach Identify Key Issues: Evaluate variable naming, repeated code, external dependencies, error handling, Pythonic design, security, etc. Suggest Improvements: Propose reorganizations or refactors that reduce complexity. Demonstrate Updated Code: Provide a refined snippet, with inline commentary explaining changes. Conclusion: Summarize final best practices or next steps.
  2. Critique & Recommendations 3.1 File Organization
    Large monolithic file: Consider splitting into modules (e.g., hero.py, items.py, monster.py, etc.). This fosters maintainability. 3.2 Dependencies & Hard-coded Imports
    from game.prep import ... indicates a custom module. If these references are only for some utility functions (clear, loading, tsl, etc.), ensure these are stable or consider a local function alternative. Hard-coded ../resources/foods.json: prefer a config setting for file paths, or pass them as function arguments. This helps portability. 3.3 Dictionary Data
    roles, sub_roles, special_shop, musuh: Fine for prototyping. Might eventually store these in external JSON or a DB for easier extension. 3.4 Class Hero
    Contains many game-specific stats (HP, ATK, etc.). If used widely, consider a specialized data container or a parent class Character. guard = False: Good. But consider how you handle states if Hero has multiple states. The Attack method: calls clear() from external code. You might remove that side effect if the method is purely logic-based. The saveData and loadData as @classmethods: okay, but typically you’d see free-standing utility functions or static methods. subroles is a list, but typically a hero might have zero or one subrole. That’s a design question. 3.5 Class Item & Makanan
    Item.update_price() uses quantity_sold to reduce price. The logic is fine for a dynamic economy. Makanan inherits from Item but redefines init() with different signature. This can lead to confusion. If Makanan doesn’t require base_price or rarity, consider calling super().init() with defaults. Makanan.getDaftarBuah(): reading the JSON in a class method is convenient but might be brittle if the path changes. 3.6 DRY & Defensive Programming
    Repeated code for “subrole expansions” could be centralized. Some small repeated lines might be consolidated (e.g., the approach to printing). 3.7 Error Handling & Edge Cases
    Many dictionary lookups (roles, sub_roles) are done blindly. If a key doesn’t exist, you’ll get a KeyError. Consider .get(). The code references possible file-not-found issues. Good that you handle them with FileNotFoundError. In Hero.loadData(), after reading data, you do for k in data['inventory']: print(k), but that might be purely debugging. 3.8 Pythonic Style
    Generally, the code uses PascalCase for classes and snake_case for methods, which is good. Some function docstrings are present, but others are not. The repeated dictionary for stats might be replaced by a specialized data class or typed NamedTuple if advanced type-checking is needed.

Explanation of Key Improvements
Removed or Stubbed game.prep Imports

Replaced references to local stubs to demonstrate how you could handle it if you don’t have the real library. Consolidated Utility

Moved critical, attack_reduction, randomizer, percent, etc., to the top for clarity. Hero Class

Combined health formula inside init().
Cleaned up Attack() method to avoid excessive side effects. Makanan

Calls super().init() properly.
getDaftarBuah() and getBuah() handle indexing safely. PEP-8

De-linted for line lengths, naming, spacing.
Docstrings

Provided short docstrings for clarity.
5. Final Thoughts Testing: Ensure you have unit tests for the more intricate methods (Attack, Run, item lookups) to confirm no regressions. Data Files: If foods.json grows more complex, consider a structured approach or partial loading. Performance: For a small text RPG, current performance is likely fine. If it grows, profiling might be needed. Overall, these refinements maintain your original code’s functionality, while clarifying structure, making it more Pythonic, and adding a bit more defensive programming.

1. Verify Understanding
You’ve provided a Python file containing several classes (Hero, Enemy, Item, Makanan) and dictionaries (roles, sub_roles, etc.). The code supports:

Defining role-based stats for a game’s hero classes.
Sub-role expansions with alternate stats and inventories.
A Hero class that can save/load itself as JSON, attack/guard, and manage an inventory.
An Item class (and specialized Makanan class) that can manage pricing, reading from JSON, calculating totals, etc.
The code references multiple external modules and JSON resources. It's presumably part of a text-based or console-based RPG. We’ll aim to critique and refine it for clarity, maintainability, and style, while ensuring no change in functionality.

2. Outline Approach
Identify Key Issues: Evaluate variable naming, repeated code, external dependencies, error handling, Pythonic design, security, etc.
Suggest Improvements: Propose reorganizations or refactors that reduce complexity.
Demonstrate Updated Code: Provide a refined snippet, with inline commentary explaining changes.
Conclusion: Summarize final best practices or next steps.
3. Critique & Recommendations
3.1 File Organization
Large monolithic file: Consider splitting into modules (e.g., hero.py, items.py, monster.py, etc.). This fosters maintainability.
3.2 Dependencies & Hard-coded Imports
from game.prep import ... indicates a custom module. If these references are only for some utility functions (clear, loading, tsl, etc.), ensure these are stable or consider a local function alternative.
Hard-coded ../resources/foods.json: prefer a config setting for file paths, or pass them as function arguments. This helps portability.
3.3 Dictionary Data
roles, sub_roles, special_shop, musuh: Fine for prototyping. Might eventually store these in external JSON or a DB for easier extension.
3.4 Class Hero
Contains many game-specific stats (HP, ATK, etc.). If used widely, consider a specialized data container or a parent class Character.
guard = False: Good. But consider how you handle states if Hero has multiple states.
The Attack method: calls clear() from external code. You might remove that side effect if the method is purely logic-based.
The saveData and loadData as @classmethods: okay, but typically you’d see free-standing utility functions or static methods.
subroles is a list, but typically a hero might have zero or one subrole. That’s a design question.
3.5 Class Item & Makanan
Item.update_price() uses quantity_sold to reduce price. The logic is fine for a dynamic economy.
Makanan inherits from Item but redefines __init__() with different signature. This can lead to confusion. If Makanan doesn’t require base_price or rarity, consider calling super().__init__() with defaults.
Makanan.getDaftarBuah(): reading the JSON in a class method is convenient but might be brittle if the path changes.
3.6 DRY & Defensive Programming
Repeated code for “subrole expansions” could be centralized.
Some small repeated lines might be consolidated (e.g., the approach to printing).
3.7 Error Handling & Edge Cases
Many dictionary lookups (roles, sub_roles) are done blindly. If a key doesn’t exist, you’ll get a KeyError. Consider .get().
The code references possible file-not-found issues. Good that you handle them with FileNotFoundError.
In Hero.loadData(), after reading data, you do for k in data['inventory']: print(k), but that might be purely debugging.
3.8 Pythonic Style
Generally, the code uses PascalCase for classes and snake_case for methods, which is good.
Some function docstrings are present, but others are not.
The repeated dictionary for stats might be replaced by a specialized data class or typed NamedTuple if advanced type-checking is needed.

Explanation of Key Improvements
Removed or Stubbed game.prep Imports

Replaced references to local stubs to demonstrate how you could handle it if you don’t have the real library.
Consolidated Utility

Moved critical, attack_reduction, randomizer, percent, etc., to the top for clarity.
Hero Class

Combined health formula inside __init__().
Cleaned up Attack() method to avoid excessive side effects.
Makanan

Calls super().__init__() properly.
getDaftarBuah() and getBuah() handle indexing safely.
PEP-8

De-linted for line lengths, naming, spacing.
Docstrings

Provided short docstrings for clarity.
5. Final Thoughts
Testing: Ensure you have unit tests for the more intricate methods (Attack, Run, item lookups) to confirm no regressions.
Data Files: If foods.json grows more complex, consider a structured approach or partial loading.
Performance: For a small text RPG, current performance is likely fine. If it grows, profiling might be needed.
Overall, these refinements maintain your original code’s functionality, while clarifying structure, making it more Pythonic, and adding a bit more defensive programming.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant