Skip to content

feat(review): migrate from code-review-ai to comprehensive-review (v55)#50

Merged
b33eep merged 1 commit intomainfrom
fix/migrate-comprehensive-review
Feb 27, 2026
Merged

feat(review): migrate from code-review-ai to comprehensive-review (v55)#50
b33eep merged 1 commit intomainfrom
fix/migrate-comprehensive-review

Conversation

@b33eep
Copy link
Owner

@b33eep b33eep commented Feb 27, 2026

Summary

  • Replace code-review-ai plugin with comprehensive-review (upstream removed on Feb 19)
  • /do-review now spawns 2 agents by default (architect-review + code-reviewer)
  • New --security / --full flags add security-auditor as 3rd agent
  • Automatic migration for existing users on --update

Problem

The code-review-ai plugin was removed from the wshobson/agents marketplace (commit). New installations fail with "Failed to install code-review-ai".

Solution

Migrate to comprehensive-review — the official replacement in the same marketplace. The architect-review agent is byte-identical. The new plugin adds code-reviewer and security-auditor agents, which are now integrated into /do-review.

Agent orchestration:

/do-review              -> architect-review + code-reviewer  (parallel)
/do-review --security   -> + security-auditor
/do-review --full       -> + security-auditor (alias)

Test plan

  • ./tests/test.sh — all 30 scenarios pass
  • ./tests/test.sh 24 — do-review scenario specifically (19 tests)
  • Verified comprehensive-review:architect-review agent works via Task tool
  • Verified architect-review.md is identical between old and new plugin
  • Manual: fresh install selects and installs comprehensive-review
  • Manual: --update from v54 migrates tracking + plugin

Files Changed

  • external-plugins.json — plugin ID rename
  • commands/do-review.md — multi-agent rewrite with --security/--full flags
  • commands/design.md — 3 reference updates
  • lib/update.sh — v55 migration logic
  • templates/base/global-CLAUDE.md — review agent section
  • templates/VERSION — 54 -> 55
  • tests/scenarios/24-do-review.sh — updated + new assertions
  • 8 website pages + 1 renamed (.mdx)
  • README.md, CLAUDE.md, CHANGELOG.md — reference updates

@b33eep b33eep requested a review from cheorges February 27, 2026 08:28
- Rename plugin in external-plugins.json and update install/update logic
- Migrate do-review command: 2 agents default, --security/--full for 3rd
- Add v55 migration in update.sh (tracking rename, partial-failure handling)
- Add test scenario 29 for do-review command validation
- Update website docs for comprehensive-review plugin
@b33eep b33eep force-pushed the fix/migrate-comprehensive-review branch from 1fca695 to 43d12e4 Compare February 27, 2026 09:24
@cheorges
Copy link
Collaborator

👍

@b33eep b33eep merged commit eef54d5 into main Feb 27, 2026
2 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants