Execute all /update_ workflow prompts + deep agent effectiveness analysis + cross-reference sync

.claude/context.md

@@ -42,19 +42,15 @@ NOP/ (Network Observatory Platform)
 docker-compose up -d                    # Start all services
 docker-compose -f docker-compose.test.yml up -d  # Test environment
 
-# Test
-python backend/tests/test_complete_platform.py   # Full platform test
-python backend/tests/test_advanced_features.py   # Advanced features test
-python backend/tests/test_access_hub.py          # Access hub test
-
-# Run Individual Services
-docker-compose up backend               # Backend only (port 12000)
-docker-compose up frontend              # Frontend only (port 12001)
-
 # Development
 cd frontend && npm run dev              # Frontend dev server
 cd backend && uvicorn app.main:app --reload  # Backend dev server
 
+# Testing
+# Note: Formal test infrastructure planned for future implementation
+# Current testing: Manual integration testing via Docker Compose
+# Test scripts available in scripts/ directory for specific features
+
 # Knowledge Management
 # Run update_knowledge and update_skills workflows via agent orchestration
 # See .github/workflows/ for workflow definitions
@@ -70,23 +66,27 @@ cd backend && uvicorn app.main:app --reload  # Backend dev server
 - [x] Host monitoring and terminal access
 - [x] Docker-based deployment complete
 - [x] Test environment with 4 service containers
-- [x] Comprehensive test suites (100% passing)
-- [x] Documentation and deployment guides
+- [x] Manual integration testing via Docker Compose
+- [x] Documentation consolidated and optimized
 - [x] Knowledge graph system (project + global)
 - [x] Skills framework configured
+- [ ] Formal unit/integration test infrastructure (planned)
 
 ## Session Notes
-**Task**: Execute update workflows (knowledge, skills)
+**Task**: Execute update workflows (knowledge, skills, agents effectiveness)
 **Changes**: 
 - context.md: Updated with full project details
-- skills/domain.md: Added 8 NOP-specific domain skills
-- Removed legacy memory system (scripts/update_memory.py, .openhands/microagents/memory_manager.md)
+- skills/domain.md: 8 NOP-specific domain skills (network services, React patterns)
+- skills/devops.md: 7 DevOps/workflow effectiveness patterns (Docker, validation, etc.)
+- Removed legacy memory system (deprecated)
+- Agent files kept clean (cross-project, no bloat)
+- Project-specific patterns moved to skills/ directory
 **Decisions**: 
 - Memory system deprecated - using knowledge files only (project_knowledge.json, global_knowledge.json)
 - Knowledge graph maintains JSONL format for compatibility
-- Skills framework configured for Python + TypeScript + Docker stack
-- Domain skills capture NOP-specific patterns (network services, WebSocket streaming, protocol dissection)
-**Next**: Complete knowledge graph optimization and generate workflow log
+- Skills framework: 13 core + 8 domain + 7 devops patterns
+- Agent instructions stay cross-project, patterns in skills
+**Next**: Validate patterns through next 10 workflow sessions
 
 ## Handover
 **Branch**: copilot/update-all-3-workflows | **Uncommitted**: No | **Blockers**: None

.claude/skills.md

@@ -1,11 +1,11 @@
 # Claude Skills
 
-**Purpose**: Codified patterns preventing rediscovery | **Version**: 1.1.0  
+**Purpose**: Codified patterns preventing rediscovery | **Version**: 1.2.0  
 **Usage**: Copy `.claude/` to any project, run `update_skills` workflow
 
 ---
 
-## Skill Index (13 Core Skills)
+## Skill Index (13 Core Skills + 7 DevOps/Workflow Skills)
 
 | # | Skill | Category | Trigger |
 |---|-------|----------|---------|
@@ -23,6 +23,10 @@
 | 12 | [Infrastructure](#12-infrastructure) | DevOps | Docker, CI/CD |
 | 13 | [Workflow Logs](#13-workflow-logs) | Process | Session complete |
 
+**Domain-Specific Skills**:
+- See `.claude/skills/domain.md` for 8 NOP-specific patterns (Network services, React, etc.)
+- See `.claude/skills/devops.md` for 7 DevOps/Workflow effectiveness patterns (Docker, validation, etc.)
+
 ---
 
 ## 1. Code Standards
@@ -142,27 +146,32 @@ project_knowledge.json     → Project entities, codegraph, relations
 {"type":"relation","from":"Component","to":"Feature","relationType":"IMPLEMENTS|USES|CONSUMES|DEPENDS_ON"}
 ```
 
-**Protocol**:
+**Protocol** (syncs with `.github/instructions/protocols.md`):
 | Event | Action |
 |-------|--------|
 | Session start | Load knowledge, query relevant entities |
 | Decision made | Document rationale, alternatives |
 | Bug fixed | Add pattern to knowledge |
 | Session end | Update knowledge, create handover |
 
+**Cross-References**:
+- Agent protocol: See `.github/agents/_DevTeam.agent.md` → Knowledge section
+- Detailed format: See `.github/instructions/protocols.md` → Knowledge section
+- Update workflow: See `.github/workflows/update_knowledge.md`
+
 ---
 
 ## 7. Orchestration
 
 **Trigger**: Multi-step tasks, complex operations
 
-**Phases** (syncs with _DevTeam):
+**Phases** (syncs with `.github/agents/_DevTeam.agent.md`):
 ```
 CONTEXT → PLAN → COORDINATE → INTEGRATE → VERIFY → LEARN → COMPLETE
    1        2         3           4          5        6        7
 ```
 
-**Emissions**:
+**Emissions** (detailed in `.github/instructions/protocols.md`):
 ```
 [SESSION: role=Lead | task=<desc> | phase=CONTEXT]
 [PHASE: PLAN | progress=2/7 | next=COORDINATE]
@@ -179,6 +188,11 @@ CONTEXT → PLAN → COORDINATE → INTEGRATE → VERIFY → LEARN → COMPLETE
 | Feature | Full 7-phase |
 | Bug | CONTEXT→COORDINATE→INTEGRATE→VERIFY→COMPLETE |
 
+**Cross-References**:
+- Agent workflow: See `.github/agents/_DevTeam.agent.md` → Phase Flow
+- Protocol details: See `.github/instructions/phases.md`
+- Examples: See `.github/instructions/examples.md`
+
 ---
 
 ## 8. Handover

.claude/skills/devops.md

@@ -0,0 +1,231 @@
+# Domain Skills - DevOps & Workflow Patterns (NOP)
+
+> Project-specific effectiveness patterns from workflow analysis. Updated by agent effectiveness reviews.
+
+**Detailed Analysis**: See `.github/instructions/agent_effectiveness_patterns.md` for complete pattern analysis with prevention strategies.
+
+**Methodology**: See `.github/instructions/AGENT_EFFECTIVENESS_ANALYSIS.md` for 14-session analysis and validation plan.
+
+---
+
+## Skill D9: Docker Cache Management
+
+**Trigger**: Frontend/backend changes not visible after rebuild
+
+**Pattern**:
+```bash
+# When standard rebuild fails (2nd attempt):
+docker-compose down -v                     # Stop and remove volumes
+docker system prune -af --volumes          # Remove ALL Docker data
+docker network create nop_test-network     # Recreate external networks
+docker-compose build --no-cache            # Build without cache
+docker-compose up -d                       # Start fresh containers
+```
+
+**Rules**:
+- ✅ Escalate to nuclear cleanup after 2nd failed rebuild
+- ✅ Don't waste attempts on cache invalidation strategies
+- ✅ Reclaim disk space (typically 3-7GB freed)
+- ✅ Recreate external networks before rebuild
+
+**Frequency**: 3 occurrences (21% of sessions)
+
+## Skill D10: Incremental Validation
+
+**Trigger**: Build failures after multiple file edits
+
+**Pattern**:
+```
+BETTER:
+Edit file A → Build → ✓
+Edit file B → Build → ✓
+Edit file C → Build → ✗ (know it's file C)
+
+AVOID:
+Edit A, B, C → Build → ✗ (which file caused it?)
+```
+
+**Rules**:
+- ✅ Build/test after EACH file change
+- ✅ Isolate failures quickly (seconds vs minutes)
+- ✅ Apply especially in multi-file refactors
+- ✅ Reviewer should validate incrementally
+
+## Skill D11: Import Verification Protocol
+
+**Trigger**: Adding logging, external function calls, or library methods
+
+**Pattern**:
+```python
+# BEFORE adding any external call, check imports:
+# 1. Verify import exists at top of file
+import logging
+logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
+
+# 2. THEN add the call
+logger.info("Message here")
+
+# DON'T add calls first and fix imports later
+```
+
+**Rules**:
+- ✅ Check imports BEFORE adding function calls
+- ✅ Verify module initialized (e.g., `logger = ...`)
+- ✅ No circular dependencies
+- ✅ Applies to Python, TypeScript, any language
+
+**Frequency**: 2 occurrences (runtime crashes)
+
+## Skill D12: React Scope Explicit Props
+
+**Trigger**: Creating child components that need parent state
+
+**Pattern**:
+```tsx
+// WRONG (child can't access parent state):
+const Parent = () => {
+  const [data, setData] = useState([]);
+  return <Child />;  // ✗ data not accessible
+}
+
+// CORRECT (pass as prop):
+interface ChildProps {
+  data: DataType[];  // Define in interface
+}
+
+const Parent = () => {
+  const [data, setData] = useState([]);
+  return <Child data={data} />;  // ✓ Pass explicitly
+}
+
+const Child: React.FC<ChildProps> = ({ data }) => {
+  // Now data is in scope
+}
+```
+
+**Rules**:
+- ✅ ALWAYS pass parent state as props
+- ✅ Define in TypeScript interface
+- ✅ Don't assume child can access parent variables
+- ✅ Check interfaces before implementation
+
+**Frequency**: 2 occurrences (build failures)
+
+## Skill D13: File Edit Complexity Threshold
+
+**Trigger**: Complex JSX/TSX refactoring with >3 edits in same region
+
+**Pattern**:
+```bash
+# When complex edits needed (multiple string replacements):
+# Option A: Line-based truncation
+head -n <safe_line_number> original.tsx > temp.tsx
+mv temp.tsx original.tsx
+
+# Option B: Rewrite entire section
+# Extract reusable parts, rewrite clean structure
+
+# AVOID: >3 sequential string replacements in same region
+```
+
+**Rules**:
+- ✅ For >3 edits in same region, use truncation or rewrite
+- ✅ Validate JSX structure after each edit
+- ✅ Avoid orphaned code after export statements
+- ✅ Applies especially to React components
+
+**Frequency**: 2 occurrences (orphaned code, syntax errors)
+
+## Skill D14: Decision Minimalism
+
+**Trigger**: Documenting design decisions or alternatives
+
+**Pattern**:
+```
+GOOD (concise):
+[DECISION: Typography scale?]
+  → CHOSEN: Tailwind text-xs (consistent, responsive)
+  → REJECTED: Custom px (no scalability)
+
+AVOID (verbose):
+[DECISION: Typography scale?]
+  → CHOSEN: Tailwind text-xs
+  → REJECTED: Custom px
+  → REJECTED: Custom rem
+  → REJECTED: Material-UI
+  → REJECTED: Styled-components
+  → REJECTED: Emotion
+```
+
+**Rules**:
+- ✅ Document main choice + primary alternative only
+- ✅ Keep rationale to 1 sentence
+- ✅ Focus on critical trade-offs
+- ✅ Reduces cognitive overhead
+
+**Applies to**: Architect, _DevTeam decision documentation
+
+## Skill D15: Anti-Drift Protocol
+
+**Trigger**: Starting any task session
+
+**Pattern**:
+```
+EVERY session MUST start with:
+[SESSION: role=Lead | task=<desc> | phase=CONTEXT]
+[PHASE: CONTEXT | progress=1/7]
+
+Load: skills.md → project_knowledge.json → global_knowledge.json
+
+Before ANY implementation:
+1. Emit [SESSION: ...] at task start
+2. Emit [PHASE: CONTEXT | progress=1/7] when loading knowledge
+3. Emit [PHASE: PLAN | progress=2/7] when designing solution
+4. Emit [DECISION: ?] for every choice made
+5. Emit [ATTEMPT #N] for every implementation try
+6. Emit [SUBAGENT: Name] for every delegation
+7. Track phase transitions
+
+VIOLATION CHECK: If markers missing, STOP and emit them now.
+```
+
+**Rules**:
+- ✅ Prevents context loss from skipped initialization
+- ✅ Ensures knowledge/skills loaded before work
+- ✅ Critical for _DevTeam orchestrator
+- ✅ Enables proper workflow logging
+
+**Frequency**: 1 critical occurrence (prevented future issues)
+
+---
+
+## Success Metrics
+
+Track these across workflow logs:
+- **Build failures per session**: Target <2 (down from 3-4)
+- **Attempts per task**: Target <2 (down from 2-3)
+- **Docker nuclear cleanups**: Target 0 (detect caching early)
+- **Import errors**: Target 0 (check before adding calls)
+- **Scope errors**: Target 0 (pass props explicitly)
+- **Orphaned code**: Target 0 (use truncation threshold)
+
+---
+
+## Pattern Sources
+
+**Analysis**: 14 workflow sessions (2025-12-28 to 2025-12-30)
+- 78 tracked attempts
+- 11 failures (14% rate)
+- 7 critical patterns identified
+
+**Detailed Reference**: See `.github/instructions/agent_effectiveness_patterns.md` for complete analysis with code examples and prevention strategies.
+
+**Methodology**: See `.github/instructions/AGENT_EFFECTIVENESS_ANALYSIS.md` for validation plan and expected impact metrics.
+
+**Agent Integration**: Agents reference these skills during CONTEXT phase. See `.github/agents/_DevTeam.agent.md` → Session Protocol.
+
+---
+
+**Updated**: 2025-12-30 by agent effectiveness analysis  
+**Version**: 1.0  
+**Next Review**: After 10 more workflow sessions

.github/agents/_DevTeam.agent.md

@@ -29,6 +29,8 @@ _DevTeam (Orchestrator)
 ```
 Load: `project_knowledge.json` → `.github/global_knowledge.json` → detect project type
 
+**Practical Patterns**: See `.claude/skills.md` → Skill #6 (Knowledge) for knowledge loading workflow.
+
 ## Phase Flow
 ```
 [PHASE: CONTEXT|PLAN|COORDINATE|INTEGRATE|VERIFY|LEARN|COMPLETE | progress=N/7]
@@ -109,6 +111,9 @@ Query before work, update after:
 [KNOWLEDGE: added=N | updated=M | type=project|global]
 ```
 
+**Practical Workflow**: See `.claude/skills.md` → Skill #6 (Knowledge)  
+**Protocol Details**: See `.github/instructions/protocols.md` → Knowledge
+
 ## Completion
 ```
 [COMPLETE: task=<desc> | result=<summary> | learnings=N]