Skip to content

[Junie]: feat: create report on Crontab plugin enhancements #24

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Open
wants to merge 1 commit into
base: main
Choose a base branch
from
Open

[Junie]: feat: create report on Crontab plugin enhancements #24

Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
1 commit
Select commit
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension
Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
119 changes: 119 additions & 0 deletions crontab_plugin_feature_analysis.md
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,119 @@
# Crontab Plugin Feature Analysis

## Executive Summary

The Crontab Plugin provides comprehensive support for crontab files in JetBrains IDEs. It currently offers a solid foundation of features including syntax highlighting, validation, human-readable schedule descriptions, and integration with external tools like crontab.guru.

This analysis identifies current features and proposes potential enhancements to improve the plugin's functionality and user experience. The recommended features for prioritization focus on quick wins with high impact, such as enhanced human-readable descriptions and templates/snippets, while also suggesting more substantial improvements for future development.

## Current Features

### 1. Basic Language Support
- **File Type Recognition**: Recognizes `.crontab` and `.cron` files as Crontab files
- **Syntax Highlighting**: Highlights different elements of crontab files
- **Parser and PSI Structure**: Provides a parser and PSI structure for crontab files
- **Comments Support**: Provides support for comments in crontab files

### 2. Schedule Visualization and Validation
- **Human-Readable Schedule Folding**: Allows folding cron expressions into human-readable descriptions
- **Schedule Validation and Quick Fixes**: Validates crontab schedules and provides quick fixes for common issues

### 3. Integration with External Tools
- **Crontab.guru Integration**: Allows opening cron schedules in crontab.guru for visualization and explanation
- **Run Command in Terminal**: Allows running crontab commands directly from the editor

### 4. IDE Integration Features
- **Structure View**: Provides a structure view for crontab files
- **Documentation**: Provides documentation for crontab elements
- **Inlay Hints**: Provides inlay hints for crontab expressions in string literals
- **Completion**: Provides completion for crontab shortcuts
- **Language Injection**: Injects crontab language into string literals in other languages

For a detailed list with file references, see [current_features.md](current_features.md).

## Potential New Features

### 1. Enhanced Schedule Visualization

| Feature | Description | Benefits | Difficulty | Development Speed |
|---------|-------------|----------|-----------|-------------------|
| Visual Cron Expression Editor | A graphical editor for creating and editing cron expressions | Makes it easier to create and understand cron expressions | High | Slow (3-4 weeks) |
| Schedule Timeline Visualization | A timeline view showing when a cron job will run | Helps understand execution patterns | Medium | Medium (2 weeks) |
| Enhanced Human-Readable Descriptions | Improve descriptions for complex expressions | Better folding and inlay hints | Low | Fast (3-5 days) |

### 2. Advanced Validation and Analysis

| Feature | Description | Benefits | Difficulty | Development Speed |
|---------|-------------|----------|-----------|-------------------|
| Schedule Conflict Detection | Detect when multiple jobs might run simultaneously | Helps avoid resource conflicts | Medium | Medium (1-2 weeks) |
| Resource Usage Estimation | Estimate resource usage based on job frequency | Helps optimize schedules | High | Slow (3-4 weeks) |
| Enhanced Linting and Best Practices | Additional inspections for common mistakes | Improves reliability | Low-Medium | Medium (1-2 weeks) |

### 3. Integration Enhancements

| Feature | Description | Benefits | Difficulty | Development Speed |
|---------|-------------|----------|-----------|-------------------|
| Cron Job Simulation | Simulate execution in a controlled environment | Allows testing without production impact | High | Slow (3-4 weeks) |
| System Crontab Integration | Integration with system crontab | Unified interface for management | Medium | Medium (2 weeks) |
| CI/CD Integration | Validate crontab files in build process | Ensures validity before deployment | Medium | Medium (1-2 weeks) |

### 4. User Experience Improvements

| Feature | Description | Benefits | Difficulty | Development Speed |
|---------|-------------|----------|-----------|-------------------|
| Crontab Templates and Snippets | Predefined templates for common patterns | Easier creation of common jobs | Low | Fast (3-5 days) |
| Cron Job Grouping and Organization | Features for grouping and organizing jobs | Better management of many jobs | Medium | Medium (1-2 weeks) |
| Cron Job Documentation Generation | Generate docs from comments and metadata | Improved understanding and maintenance | Low-Medium | Medium (1 week) |

### 5. Advanced Features

| Feature | Description | Benefits | Difficulty | Development Speed |
|---------|-------------|----------|-----------|-------------------|
| Multi-Environment Support | Support for different crontab formats | Wider range of users | High | Slow (3-4 weeks) |
| Cron Job Monitoring and Alerting | Integration with monitoring systems | Ensures jobs run correctly | High | Slow (3-4 weeks) |
| Cron Job Migration and Conversion | Tools for migrating between formats | Easier environment transitions | Medium-High | Medium-Slow (2-3 weeks) |

For detailed descriptions of each feature, see [potential_new_features.md](potential_new_features.md).

## Recommendations for Prioritization

Based on the difficulty, development speed, and potential impact, here are the recommended features to implement first:

1. **Enhanced Human-Readable Descriptions**: Low difficulty, fast development, high impact
- Improve the CronScheduleDescriber to handle more complex expressions
- Enhance folding and inlay hints for better readability

2. **Crontab Templates and Snippets**: Low difficulty, fast development, high impact
- Create predefined templates for common cron job patterns
- Leverage existing IDE template/snippet functionality

3. **Enhanced Linting and Best Practices**: Low-Medium difficulty, medium development, high impact
- Add inspections for common mistakes and best practices
- Provide quick fixes for identified issues

4. **Schedule Timeline Visualization**: Medium difficulty, medium development, high impact
- Show when jobs will run over a specified period
- Help users understand execution patterns

5. **Cron Job Documentation Generation**: Low-Medium difficulty, medium development, medium impact
- Generate documentation based on comments and metadata
- Improve understanding and maintenance of cron jobs

These features provide a good balance of quick wins and substantial improvements that will enhance the user experience without requiring excessive development time.

## Long-term Vision

For the long-term development of the plugin, consider implementing more advanced features such as:

1. **Visual Cron Expression Editor**: A graphical editor integrated into the IDE
2. **System Crontab Integration**: Direct management of system cron jobs
3. **Multi-Environment Support**: Support for different crontab formats and environments
4. **Cron Job Monitoring and Alerting**: Integration with monitoring systems

These features would significantly enhance the plugin's capabilities but require more substantial development effort.

## Conclusion

The Crontab Plugin already provides a solid foundation of features for working with crontab files in JetBrains IDEs. By implementing the recommended enhancements, the plugin can become an even more powerful tool for developers who work with cron jobs, making it easier to create, understand, and maintain crontab schedules.

The prioritized features focus on improving the user experience and providing immediate value, while the long-term vision outlines more ambitious enhancements that could be implemented in future versions.
59 changes: 59 additions & 0 deletions current_features.md
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,59 @@
# Current Features of the Crontab Plugin

## 1. Basic Language Support
- **File Type Recognition**: Recognizes `.crontab` and `.cron` files as Crontab files
- [CrontabFileType.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/language/CrontabFileType.kt)
- [plugin.xml](src/main/resources/META-INF/plugin.xml) (file type registration)

- **Syntax Highlighting**: Highlights different elements of crontab files
- [CrontabSyntaxHighlighter.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/language/CrontabSyntaxHighlighter.kt)
- [CrontabAnnotator.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/language/CrontabAnnotator.kt)

- **Parser and PSI Structure**: Provides a parser and PSI structure for crontab files
- [Crontab.bnf](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/language/parser/Crontab.bnf) (grammar definition)
- [CrontabParserDefinition.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/language/parser/CrontabParserDefinition.kt)

- **Comments Support**: Provides support for comments in crontab files
- [CrontabCommenter.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/CrontabCommenter.kt)

## 2. Schedule Visualization and Validation

- **Human-Readable Schedule Folding**: Allows folding cron expressions into human-readable descriptions
- [CronScheduleFoldingBuilder.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/CronScheduleFoldingBuilder.kt)
- [CronScheduleDescriber.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/CronScheduleDescriber.kt)

- **Schedule Validation and Quick Fixes**: Validates crontab schedules and provides quick fixes for common issues
- [CrontabScheduleTimeRangeInspection.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/inspections/CrontabScheduleTimeRangeInspection.kt)
- [CrontabInspectionUtil.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/inspections/CrontabInspectionUtil.kt)
- [CrontabScheduleQuickFix.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/inspections/CrontabScheduleQuickFix.kt)

## 3. Integration with External Tools

- **Crontab.guru Integration**: Allows opening cron schedules in crontab.guru for visualization and explanation
- [CrontabGuruIntention.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/actions/CrontabGuruIntention.kt)
- [OpenCrontabGuruAction.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/actions/OpenCrontabGuruAction.kt)
- [CrontabGuruUtils.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/CrontabGuruUtils.kt)

- **Run Command in Terminal**: Allows running crontab commands directly from the editor
- [CrontabRunCommandMarkerContributor.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/CrontabRunCommandMarkerContributor.kt)
- [CrontabRunCommandAction.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/actions/CrontabRunCommandAction.kt)

## 4. IDE Integration Features

- **Structure View**: Provides a structure view for crontab files
- [CrontabStructureViewFactory.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/structureView/CrontabStructureViewFactory.kt)
- [CrontabStructureViewModel.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/structureView/CrontabStructureViewModel.kt)

- **Documentation**: Provides documentation for crontab elements
- [CrontabDocumentationProvider.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/documentation/CrontabDocumentationProvider.kt)
- [CrontabDocumentationUtils.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/documentation/CrontabDocumentationUtils.kt)

- **Inlay Hints**: Provides inlay hints for crontab expressions in string literals
- [CrontabInlayHintsProvider.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/CrontabInlayHintsProvider.kt)
- [CrontabInlayHintsProviderFactory.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/CrontabInlayHintsProviderFactory.kt)

- **Completion**: Provides completion for crontab shortcuts
- [CrontabShortcutCompletionContributor.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/ide/completion/CrontabShortcutCompletionContributor.kt)

- **Language Injection**: Injects crontab language into string literals in other languages
- [CrontabLanguageInjector.kt](src/main/kotlin/com/github/xepozz/crontab/language/CrontabLanguageInjector.kt)
115 changes: 115 additions & 0 deletions potential_new_features.md
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,115 @@
# Potential New Features for the Crontab Plugin

Based on an analysis of the current features and common crontab functionality, here are potential new features that could be added to the plugin:

## 1. Enhanced Schedule Visualization

### 1.1. Visual Cron Expression Editor
- **Description**: A graphical editor for creating and editing cron expressions, similar to crontab.guru but integrated into the IDE
- **Benefits**: Makes it easier for users to create and understand cron expressions without having to remember the syntax
- **Difficulty**: High (requires UI development and integration with the existing parser)
- **Development Speed**: Slow (estimated 3-4 weeks)

### 1.2. Schedule Timeline Visualization
- **Description**: A timeline view that shows when a cron job will run over a specified period (e.g., next 24 hours, next week)
- **Benefits**: Helps users understand the actual execution pattern of their cron jobs
- **Difficulty**: Medium (requires date/time calculation and UI development)
- **Development Speed**: Medium (estimated 2 weeks)

### 1.3. Enhanced Human-Readable Descriptions
- **Description**: Improve the CronScheduleDescriber to handle more complex expressions (ranges, lists, steps, combinations)
- **Benefits**: Better folding and inlay hints for complex expressions
- **Difficulty**: Low (enhancing existing functionality)
- **Development Speed**: Fast (estimated 3-5 days)

## 2. Advanced Validation and Analysis

### 2.1. Schedule Conflict Detection
- **Description**: Detect when multiple cron jobs might run at the same time, potentially causing resource conflicts
- **Benefits**: Helps users avoid performance issues and unexpected behavior
- **Difficulty**: Medium (requires analyzing multiple schedules and detecting overlaps)
- **Development Speed**: Medium (estimated 1-2 weeks)

### 2.2. Resource Usage Estimation
- **Description**: Estimate resource usage (CPU, memory) based on the frequency of cron jobs and optional metadata
- **Benefits**: Helps users optimize their cron schedules for resource usage
- **Difficulty**: High (requires complex analysis and possibly integration with system monitoring)
- **Development Speed**: Slow (estimated 3-4 weeks)

### 2.3. Enhanced Linting and Best Practices
- **Description**: Additional inspections for common crontab mistakes and best practices (e.g., avoiding running jobs exactly on the hour)
- **Benefits**: Helps users write more efficient and reliable cron schedules
- **Difficulty**: Low to Medium (depends on the complexity of the rules)
- **Development Speed**: Medium (estimated 1-2 weeks)

## 3. Integration Enhancements

### 3.1. Cron Job Simulation
- **Description**: Simulate the execution of cron jobs in a controlled environment to test their behavior
- **Benefits**: Allows users to test their cron jobs without actually running them in production
- **Difficulty**: High (requires creating a simulation environment)
- **Development Speed**: Slow (estimated 3-4 weeks)

### 3.2. System Crontab Integration
- **Description**: Integration with the system crontab to view, edit, and manage actual cron jobs on the system
- **Benefits**: Provides a unified interface for managing cron jobs
- **Difficulty**: Medium (requires system access and permissions)
- **Development Speed**: Medium (estimated 2 weeks)

### 3.3. CI/CD Integration
- **Description**: Integration with CI/CD systems to validate crontab files as part of the build process
- **Benefits**: Ensures crontab files are valid before deployment
- **Difficulty**: Medium (requires integration with CI/CD systems)
- **Development Speed**: Medium (estimated 1-2 weeks)

## 4. User Experience Improvements

### 4.1. Crontab Templates and Snippets
- **Description**: Predefined templates and snippets for common cron job patterns
- **Benefits**: Makes it easier for users to create common cron jobs
- **Difficulty**: Low (leveraging existing template/snippet functionality)
- **Development Speed**: Fast (estimated 3-5 days)

### 4.2. Cron Job Grouping and Organization
- **Description**: Features for grouping and organizing cron jobs (e.g., by purpose, frequency, or resource usage)
- **Benefits**: Helps users manage large numbers of cron jobs
- **Difficulty**: Medium (requires UI development and data model changes)
- **Development Speed**: Medium (estimated 1-2 weeks)

### 4.3. Cron Job Documentation Generation
- **Description**: Generate documentation for cron jobs based on comments and metadata
- **Benefits**: Helps users understand and maintain their cron jobs
- **Difficulty**: Low to Medium (depends on the complexity of the documentation)
- **Development Speed**: Medium (estimated 1 week)

## 5. Advanced Features

### 5.1. Multi-Environment Support
- **Description**: Support for different crontab formats and environments (e.g., standard cron, Quartz, Spring)
- **Benefits**: Makes the plugin useful for a wider range of users
- **Difficulty**: High (requires supporting multiple formats and environments)
- **Development Speed**: Slow (estimated 3-4 weeks)

### 5.2. Cron Job Monitoring and Alerting
- **Description**: Integration with monitoring and alerting systems to track cron job execution and failures
- **Benefits**: Helps users ensure their cron jobs are running correctly
- **Difficulty**: High (requires integration with external systems)
- **Development Speed**: Slow (estimated 3-4 weeks)

### 5.3. Cron Job Migration and Conversion
- **Description**: Tools for migrating cron jobs between different formats and systems
- **Benefits**: Helps users move cron jobs between environments
- **Difficulty**: Medium to High (depends on the complexity of the formats)
- **Development Speed**: Medium to Slow (estimated 2-3 weeks)

## Recommendations for Prioritization

Based on the difficulty, development speed, and potential impact, here are the recommended features to implement first:

1. **Enhanced Human-Readable Descriptions** (1.3): Low difficulty, fast development, high impact
2. **Crontab Templates and Snippets** (4.1): Low difficulty, fast development, high impact
3. **Enhanced Linting and Best Practices** (2.3): Low to Medium difficulty, medium development, high impact
4. **Schedule Timeline Visualization** (1.2): Medium difficulty, medium development, high impact
5. **Cron Job Documentation Generation** (4.3): Low to Medium difficulty, medium development, medium impact

These features provide a good balance of quick wins and substantial improvements that will enhance the user experience without requiring excessive development time.