Bake reflection into the experiment loop#282
Bake reflection into the experiment loop#282alexbenari wants to merge 1 commit intokarpathy:masterfrom
Conversation
Bake some reflection into the idea loop: - each idea is briefly summarized and grounded prior to execution - a brief post-mortem is recorded The resulting musings.md seems to contribute to idea generation quality. It also serves as a useful learning aid for ML theory and its application.
|
@alexbenari A memorizable text file for the agent is a good idea. Do not forget to instruct the agent to read this file before starting. A prompt-engineered I experimented with a historical file-based context approach in my fork of autoresearch repo, highlighted in discussion #234, and I agree that historical file-system context works well. |
|
It might be useful for resuming agent work as you suggest, although for that purpose musings.md specifically seems somewhat of an overkill. A much smaller file would do (perhaps even the existing |
Nevertheless, memorizable text file for agent is still a good idea. |
…context mgmt, low-VRAM, eval guide PR karpathy#291 — Data integrity verification for downloads Adds Content-Length size verification and Parquet metadata validation (pq.read_metadata) before committing downloaded shards. Catches truncated or corrupted files from network interruptions before they get sealed with a SHA-256 hash. Layered on top of our existing atomic .tmp rename and SHA-256 sidecar verification. PR karpathy#282 — Bake reflection into the experiment loop Adds musings.md initialization to setup, plus pre-experiment rationale (step 2: explain the idea and its ML grounding) and post-experiment reflection (step 9: record outcome and interpretation). Leaves a learning trail for humans and may improve agent idea generation quality. Issue karpathy#298 — Subagent delegation for context window preservation Adds a "Context management" section to program.md with a subagent prompt template. The main agent holds research state; subagents handle mechanical steps (commit, train, extract metrics). Verbose output dies with the subagent, keeping the primary context clean over 50+ experiment runs. PR karpathy#299 — Low-VRAM auto-detection (cherry-picked universal parts) Adds VRAM detection: GPUs with < 6GB automatically get reduced hyperparameters (batch=32, seq=256, depth=4, SSSL window pattern). Introduces TRAIN_SEQ_LEN variable used throughout model config, dataloader, and evaluation. Also adds seq_len and max_steps optional parameters to evaluate_bpb() for flexible eval on constrained hardware. Skipped: hardware-specific torch/kernels downgrades, 1050 Ti tuning. PR karpathy#303 — Guide for evaluating experiment results at scale New docs/evaluating-results.md covering noise floor estimation (awk one-liner for median pairwise delta), when to trust an improvement (1.5x noise floor rule), Pareto efficiency analysis, and useful one-liners for results.tsv at scale. Optional: PR karpathy#276 — Deterministic keep/discard policy engine Standalone contrib/policy_engine.py (60 lines) + test suite (9 tests). Evaluates experiments by val_bpb improvement vs complexity tradeoff. NOT wired into the training loop — available as an optional decision aid. Placed in contrib/ to signal its optional nature. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Summary
This updates
program.mdto add a lightweight reflection step before and after each experiment.The workflow now asks the agent to:
musings.mdfile during setuptrain.pyThe resulting
musings.mdleaves behind a useful learning trail for humans (at least this human) interested in the nuances of ML theory and their application.It may also improve the agent's idea generation quality by making the loop more systematic, though that would need more deliberate validation.
Changes
musings.mdinitialization to the experiment setup checklistTesting