Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Trade Mall (Trade Outpost Alternate) #2365

Open
wants to merge 4 commits into
base: master
Choose a base branch
from
Open

Trade Mall (Trade Outpost Alternate) #2365

wants to merge 4 commits into from

Conversation

Cheackraze
Copy link
Member

@Cheackraze Cheackraze commented Nov 3, 2024

About the PR

Adds an alternative trade outpost for some round variation. After lots of playtesting and feedback of the original outpost, this one aims to resolve some of the broader player feedback. Mostly of, it being too large and isolating of the areas, and while having lots of blank space to make player spaces is a sound idea, only the large abandoned atrium ever really got used.

Big thanks to mariusdemeier and trucy_deuxy for initial layout and design work.

TODO:
[ ] add cameras
[ ] modify kitchen dock (it needs 3 more tiles of clearance to fit a bocadillo)
[ ] power pass, make sure everything is properly powered (kitchen and atm area had issues)

Why / Balance

Variety/Feedback

How to test

Load up a normal (non-debug) round of frontier. There will be a 50/50 chance of it spawning. You may have to restartroundnow a few times if it doesnt roll right.

Media

TradeMall-0

Requirements

Breaking changes

Changelog

🆑

  • add: Added the Trade Mall, an alternate to the Trade Outpost.

@github-actions github-actions bot added Map-POI Map - POI No C# labels Nov 3, 2024
@PeccNeck
Copy link
Contributor

PeccNeck commented Nov 3, 2024

I've already voiced this once in the Discord forum post, but I'm very iffy about having separate areas for guard and NFSD. They've definitely been nicely decorated, but it ends up feeling redundant to me (NFSD especially, who have their entire POI). They also both share the same basic access, too (Security), so there's nothing stopping the Guard from waltzing over to NFSD and vice versa.

Semi-related, sad to see the NFSD intercom in the Guard section didn't make the cut, as they have no direct channels to NFSD otherwise, but at least there's one in the office on the other side of the hall.

And completely separately, I've just noticed that the decals for Cargo Bay 3 overlap the dark tiles on one side and are overlapped by them on the other.

@Cheackraze
Copy link
Member Author

this office is actually intended as a shared nfsd/sec guard post, to be manned by either. I mainly just wanted to give them both their own secured docking access, as the reasoning behind the 'split'. Overall i concurr

image

I've already voiced this once in the Discord forum post, but I'm very iffy about having separate areas for guard and NFSD. They've definitely been nicely decorated, but it ends up feeling redundant to me (NFSD especially, who have their entire POI). They also both share the same basic access, too (Security), so there's nothing stopping the Guard from waltzing over to NFSD and vice versa.

Semi-related, sad to see the NFSD intercom in the Guard section didn't make the cut, as they have no direct channels to NFSD otherwise, but at least there's one in the office on the other side of the hall.

And completely separately, I've just noticed that the decals for Cargo Bay 3 overlap the dark tiles on one side and are overlapped by them on the other.

The cargo bay area is mostly untouched from the original designer, but I can go in and alter the decals when I make my final pass

@blackknight954
Copy link
Contributor

So overall this just looks like a revamped trade outpost? Why the 1/2 chance to spawn one or the other?

@Cheackraze
Copy link
Member Author

So overall this just looks like a revamped trade outpost? Why the 1/2 chance to spawn one or the other?

for variety? why not?

@blackknight954
Copy link
Contributor

So overall this just looks like a revamped trade outpost? Why the 1/2 chance to spawn one or the other?

for variety? why not?

Yeah I guess, but I'm imagining that trade outpost is just gonna remain a ghost town whereas the mall is gonna get all the action, but we'll see.

@protagon
Copy link

protagon commented Nov 4, 2024

Looks good. Will be a good test run having it 50/50, then we can see if it's worth removing/overhauling the old one in comparison

@Cheackraze
Copy link
Member Author

So overall this just looks like a revamped trade outpost? Why the 1/2 chance to spawn one or the other?

for variety? why not?

Yeah I guess, but I'm imagining that trade outpost is just gonna remain a ghost town whereas the mall is gonna get all the action, but we'll see.

my intent with the closed up shops is to be more heavy-handed doing the same thing the original is trying to do. So, players making shops and populating it a bit more might carry over to the original trade outpost, which is set up for the same kind of thing but just is a little lighter in its suggestions for it

@Houtblokje
Copy link
Contributor

Overall, looks pretty good, I definitely like the shape and most of the layout. Especially the cargo area looks pretty cool, since you can easily reach and interact with the other cargo rooms, which I think was one of the big issues with the current trade station.

but I had a few questions about this new layout. Mainly:
I see the mail office and the janitorial office here. Does this mean those facilities will be removed from Frontier outpost? Will their jobs be located on Trade? if so, is there a console to re-open the slots?
If this station is going to have a little medical area, maybe it could also get a cryo area, to take the pressure off frontier outpost during the end of game rush and to lure people more to it?

Not sure how I feel about the big open area, it often goes unused since nobody knows its allowed to be modified and what modifications are allowed, but I guess it is nice to have a big space to do fun stuff in.

The STC room could do with a water cooler.

@Cerebral-Error
Copy link

Overall, looks pretty good, I definitely like the shape and most of the layout. Especially the cargo area looks pretty cool, since you can easily reach and interact with the other cargo rooms, which I think was one of the big issues with the current trade station.

but I had a few questions about this new layout. Mainly: I see the mail office and the janitorial office here. Does this mean those facilities will be removed from Frontier outpost? Will their jobs be located on Trade? if so, is there a console to re-open the slots? If this station is going to have a little medical area, maybe it could also get a cryo area, to take the pressure off frontier outpost during the end of game rush and to lure people more to it?

Not sure how I feel about the big open area, it often goes unused since nobody knows its allowed to be modified and what modifications are allowed, but I guess it is nice to have a big space to do fun stuff in.

The STC room could do with a water cooler.

There does look like there's a small Cryo area up near the North end of the station, right next to the toilets. There's a pair of cryo chambers.

@Houtblokje
Copy link
Contributor

Overall, looks pretty good, I definitely like the shape and most of the layout. Especially the cargo area looks pretty cool, since you can easily reach and interact with the other cargo rooms, which I think was one of the big issues with the current trade station.
but I had a few questions about this new layout. Mainly: I see the mail office and the janitorial office here. Does this mean those facilities will be removed from Frontier outpost? Will their jobs be located on Trade? if so, is there a console to re-open the slots? If this station is going to have a little medical area, maybe it could also get a cryo area, to take the pressure off frontier outpost during the end of game rush and to lure people more to it?
Not sure how I feel about the big open area, it often goes unused since nobody knows its allowed to be modified and what modifications are allowed, but I guess it is nice to have a big space to do fun stuff in.
The STC room could do with a water cooler.

There does look like there's a small Cryo area up near the North end of the station, right next to the toilets. There's a pair of cryo chambers.

Ah I see it. I expected it near medical however, so maybe something similar can be created instead of the toilets across from medical?

@Cheackraze
Copy link
Member Author

Overall, looks pretty good, I definitely like the shape and most of the layout. Especially the cargo area looks pretty cool, since you can easily reach and interact with the other cargo rooms, which I think was one of the big issues with the current trade station.
but I had a few questions about this new layout. Mainly: I see the mail office and the janitorial office here. Does this mean those facilities will be removed from Frontier outpost? Will their jobs be located on Trade? if so, is there a console to re-open the slots? If this station is going to have a little medical area, maybe it could also get a cryo area, to take the pressure off frontier outpost during the end of game rush and to lure people more to it?
Not sure how I feel about the big open area, it often goes unused since nobody knows its allowed to be modified and what modifications are allowed, but I guess it is nice to have a big space to do fun stuff in.
The STC room could do with a water cooler.

There does look like there's a small Cryo area up near the North end of the station, right next to the toilets. There's a pair of cryo chambers.

Ah I see it. I expected it near medical however, so maybe something similar can be created instead of the toilets across from medical?

the intent is to make people walk through the station to get to it. Same with having the ATM/shipyard console on the opposite end of the Cargo console. It may 'feel like a pain in the ass' but the intent is that you should walk all through the station with the goal of players having chance interactions in the hallways etc.

As for the janitor/mail, we dont plan on removing them from frontier outpost, its more just another space that they can choose to use instead.

@Houtblokje

This comment was marked as off-topic.

@arimah arimah self-assigned this Nov 5, 2024
@arimah arimah removed their assignment Nov 5, 2024
@github-actions github-actions bot added the Status: Needs Review This PR is awaiting reviews label Nov 5, 2024
@PeccNeck PeccNeck mentioned this pull request Nov 5, 2024
2 tasks
@PeccNeck
Copy link
Contributor

PeccNeck commented Nov 5, 2024

Went ahead and submitted some bits and tweaks on #2373, take a look when you can.

PeccNeck and others added 3 commits November 6, 2024 13:08
* trade mall 2: the wrath of spess

* fix my own decal mistakes

* poi name to trade mall
@dvir001
Copy link
Contributor

dvir001 commented Nov 10, 2024

Fixed warp point and metadata.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Map-POI Map - POI No C# Status: Needs Review This PR is awaiting reviews
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

8 participants