Skip to content

Comments

feat(001-baseline-sdd-spec): complete baseline SDD specification — all 13 phases#2

Merged
softwaresalt merged 16 commits intomainfrom
001-baseline-sdd-spec
Feb 14, 2026
Merged

feat(001-baseline-sdd-spec): complete baseline SDD specification — all 13 phases#2
softwaresalt merged 16 commits intomainfrom
001-baseline-sdd-spec

Conversation

@softwaresalt
Copy link
Owner

Summary

Implements the complete baseline Software Design Document (SDD) specification for csv-managed v1.0.x across 13 phases, validating all 59 functional requirements (FR-001 through FR-059) against the existing codebase.

What Changed

Source Code (9 files modified)

File Changes
src/data.rs Replace panic! in Value::Ord with deterministic variant_index() fallback for heterogeneous comparisons
src/io_utils.rs Remove sole unsafe block — use safe std::str::from_utf8 instead of from_utf8_unchecked
src/schema_cmd.rs Replace 3 .expect() calls with .context()/? propagation on user-reachable paths
src/schema.rs Convert value_column_type to return Result<ColumnType>; replace 4 .expect() calls with ? propagation; add failure-path test for Schema::load
src/stats.rs Replace partial_cmp().unwrap() in median sort with f64::total_cmp()
src/frequency.rs Replace 2 .expect() calls with .context()/?
src/index.rs Add Rustdoc to all 22 public items; add 2 failure-path unit tests
src/filter.rs Add Rustdoc to all 4 public items; add 3 failure-path unit tests
src/verify.rs, src/append.rs, src/columns.rs, src/install.rs, src/join.rs Add module-level //! Rustdoc

Tests (1 new file, 6 new unit tests across modules)

  • tests/edge_cases.rs — 14 integration tests covering: empty CSV, header-only CSV, unknown filter column, malformed derive expression, empty stdin, decimal precision overflow, column rename transparency, multiple filter AND semantics, sort without index fallback
  • 6 failure-path unit tests in filter.rs, index.rs, schema.rs

Specification & Documentation

  • specs/001-baseline-sdd-spec/ — complete spec, plan, tasks (all 144 tasks marked complete), data model, contracts, quickstart, research, checklists
  • docs/ — ADRs, CLI help, operation guides, schema examples, pipeline documentation
  • .copilot-tracking/memory/ — session memory files for all 13 phases

Quality Gates

Gate Result
cargo test --all ✅ 229 passed, 0 failed, 1 ignored
cargo clippy --all-targets --all-features -- -D warnings ✅ Zero warnings
cargo doc --no-deps ✅ Builds clean
cargo fmt --check ✅ Clean
Quickstart examples validation ✅ All documented workflows verified
FR cross-reference (59 FRs) ✅ 100% coverage confirmed

Constitution Compliance

  • ✅ No unsafe blocks (removed the sole instance in io_utils.rs)
  • ✅ No unwrap()/expect() in library code (all 11 instances remediated)
  • ✅ All public items have /// Rustdoc comments
  • anyhow::Result with .with_context() throughout
  • ✅ Streaming-first architecture — no full-file buffering in row processing
  • ✅ Every public parser has at least one failure-path test

Code Review Findings Resolved

ID Category Severity Description Resolution
RI-01 Correctness CRITICAL Value::Ord panics on heterogeneous variants Replaced with deterministic variant_index() fallback
RI-02 Security HIGH unsafe { from_utf8_unchecked } in io_utils Replaced with safe from_utf8 + error propagation
RI-03 Convention HIGH 3 .expect() calls on user-triggered paths Converted to .context()/?
RI-04 Convention MEDIUM partial_cmp().unwrap() in median sort Replaced with total_cmp()
RI-05 Convention MEDIUM 2 .expect() calls in frequency.rs Converted to .context()/?
RI-06 Convention MEDIUM 4 .expect() calls in schema.rs Refactored value_column_type to Result; all converted to ?
RI-07 Convention LOW Missing module docs (3 files) Added //! module-level Rustdoc

Deferred Items (out of scope)

  • schema.rs at 3,195 lines — split into submodules (architectural refactor)
  • process.rs execute() at 210 lines — extract phases (refactor)
  • Streaming median algorithm — currently uses Vec<f64> accumulator
  • println! in verify.rs/schema_cmd.rs — near CLI output boundary, acceptable

- mark T001-T004 as complete in tasks.md

- verify cargo build --release, test, clippy, fmt all pass

- validate all 6 spec artifacts exist

- add phase 1 session memory

Spec: specs/001-baseline-sdd-spec/

Tasks: T001, T002, T003, T004

✅ - Generated by Copilot
…tting validation

Tasks completed:
- T005-T009: Data type system audit (ColumnType 10 variants, boolean 6 formats,
  date canonicalization, currency symbols/parentheses, decimal precision max 28)
- T010-T013: I/O & encoding audit (delimiter auto-detection, encoding_rs,
  stdin/stdout, QuoteStyle::Always per FR-054)
- T014-T017: Observability audit (timing output, RUST_LOG verbosity, outcome
  logging, exit codes 0/1)
- T018-T021, T145-T151: Module-level Rustdoc added to 11 source files
- T152: Data type parsing tests added (boolean all 6 formats, date/datetime
  failure paths, currency symbol coverage, parentheses negative)
- T153: Observability tests added (exit codes, timing, outcome logging,
  log verbosity control)

Fix: Changed QuoteStyle::Necessary to QuoteStyle::Always (FR-054)

Spec: specs/001-baseline-sdd-spec/
ADR: docs/adrs/0001-csv-output-quoting-strategy.md
…ference validation

- audit all 11 FR (FR-001 through FR-011) against source: all PASS

- verify 6 acceptance scenario tests (T033-T038): all covered

- add schema probe placeholder fill test for NA-behavior coverage

- enhance snapshot test with SHA-256 hash assertion

- mark all 18 phase 3 tasks (T022-T039) complete in tasks.md

specs/001-baseline-sdd-spec/

🔍 - Generated by Copilot
… and US3 verification

- wire --exclude-columns into process pipeline (T042, FR-019)
- add exclude-columns projection tests (T055, T060)
- add multi-file schema verify test (T068, T070)
- audit and validate all Phase 4 tasks T040-T060 against existing code
- audit and validate all Phase 5 tasks T061-T070 against existing code
- mark all Phase 4 and Phase 5 tasks complete in tasks.md

Spec: specs/001-baseline-sdd-spec/tasks.md
ADR: docs/adrs/0002-exclude-columns-projection.md

🔧 - Generated by Copilot
…alidation

- validate FR-034 through FR-040 against existing index and process code

- verify all 5 acceptance scenario tests (T078-T082) in tests/cli.rs

- add best_match_selects_longest_prefix_variant test for FR-037 coverage gap

- add load_rejects_incompatible_index_version test for FR-039 coverage gap

- mark T071-T083 complete in tasks.md

📊 - Generated by Copilot
…d frequency analysis

- audit stats.rs: count, min, max, mean, median, stddev for numeric/temporal (T084)

- audit frequency.rs: top-N distinct values with counts and percentages (T085)

- audit filtered statistics: filter application before computing (T086)

- verify existing tests for acceptance scenarios 1-4 (T087-T090)

- add decimal/currency precision tests for acceptance scenario 5 (T091-T092)

📊 - Generated by Copilot
…idation

- audit append.rs against FR-048 (header-once), FR-049 (header consistency), FR-050 (schema validation)
- add 6 integration tests for US6 acceptance scenarios in tests/cli.rs
- mark all 7 Phase 8 tasks (T093-T099) complete in tasks.md
- record session memory for phase 8

🧩 - Generated by Copilot
…pport

- audit stdin pipeline, encoding transcoding, preview mode (T100-T102)

- verify process|stats pipeline and encoding tests (T103-T104)

- add preview_mode_emits_table_not_csv_in_pipeline test (T105-T106)

Spec: specs/001-baseline-sdd-spec/

🔧 - Generated by Copilot
- implement concat string function for FR-030 in src/expr.rs
- add module-level and function-level Rustdoc to src/expr.rs
- add 8 unit tests for concat, if, row_number, positional aliases
- add 3 integration tests for concat derive, row_number expr, positional aliases
- mark all 11 Phase 10 tasks (T107–T117) complete in tasks.md

🔧 - Generated by Copilot
- audit src/columns.rs confirms position, name, datatype, rename display
- add schema_columns_displays_renames_in_output test for acceptance scenario 2
- mark Phase 11 tasks T118, T119, T154, T120 complete in tasks.md

✅ - Generated by Copilot
- audit src/install.rs confirms version, force, locked, root per FR-055
- add install_command_defaults_without_optional_flags test
- add install_command_reports_error_on_nonzero_exit test
- mark Phase 12 tasks T121, T122, T123, T124 complete in tasks.md

✅ - Generated by Copilot
…ng Concerns

- T125-T133: add 14 edge case integration tests (empty CSV, header-only, unknown filter column, malformed derive, empty stdin, decimal overflow, column rename, multiple filters, sort fallback)

- T134-T139: add Rustdoc to all public items in index.rs (22), filter.rs (4), verify.rs (1), append.rs (1), stats.rs (1), frequency.rs (2); module-level docs on all 6 files

- T155-T156: add 6 failure-path unit tests for parse_filters, expand_covering_spec, Schema::load; document hot-path allocation findings

- T140-T144: full test suite passes (110 unit + all integration), clippy clean, cargo doc clean, quickstart validated, 59 FRs cross-referenced at 100% coverage

specs/001-baseline-sdd-spec/ | All 13 phases complete

🏁 - Generated by Copilot
- RI-01: replace panic! in Value::Ord with deterministic variant_index() fallback

- RI-02: remove sole unsafe block in io_utils.rs, use safe std::str::from_utf8

- RI-03: replace 3 expect() calls in schema_cmd.rs with context()/? propagation

- RI-04: replace unwrap() in stats median sort with f64::total_cmp

- RI-05: replace 2 expect() calls in frequency.rs with context()/?

- RI-06: convert value_column_type to Result, replace 4 expect() calls in schema.rs

- RI-07: add module-level Rustdoc to columns.rs, install.rs, join.rs

🔧 - Generated by Copilot
Copilot AI review requested due to automatic review settings February 14, 2026 22:03
Copy link

Copilot AI left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Pull request overview

This pull request implements the complete baseline Software Design Document (SDD) specification for csv-managed v1.0.2, documenting the existing codebase across 13 phases and validating all 59 functional requirements.

Changes:

  • Documented the existing csv-managed v1.0.2 baseline implementation as a formal SDD specification
  • Added comprehensive specification artifacts including plan, research, data model, contracts, and quickstart documentation
  • Added 20 new integration tests and 6 unit tests covering edge cases and acceptance scenarios

Reviewed changes

Copilot reviewed 63 out of 64 changed files in this pull request and generated no comments.

Show a summary per file
File Description
specs/001-baseline-sdd-spec/* Complete baseline SDD specification with 13 phases, 144 tasks, and 59 FR coverage
tests/edge_cases.rs New edge case test suite with 14 integration tests
tests/cli.rs Added 10 integration tests for append, install, and observability
tests/schema.rs Added 3 integration tests for schema probe and verify
tests/process.rs Added 3 integration tests for derived columns and expressions
tests/stats.rs Added 2 integration tests for decimal/currency precision
tests/stdin_pipeline.rs Added 1 integration test for preview mode in pipelines
src/data.rs Added 6 unit tests for boolean, date, and currency parsing
src/index.rs Added 2 unit tests for failure paths
src/filter.rs Added 3 unit tests for filter parsing
src/schema.rs Added 1 unit test for schema load failure
.copilot-tracking/* Session memory files and checkpoints from all 13 phases
.github/agents/* Added 5 agent definitions for workflow automation
.github/skills/* Added 2 skill definitions for workflow automation
docs/adrs/* Added 2 architecture decision records
.hve-tracking.json HVE core tracking configuration
.vscode/mcp.json MCP server configuration
lib/hve-core Submodule update to d3bdd7aad

@softwaresalt softwaresalt requested a review from Copilot February 14, 2026 22:08
@softwaresalt softwaresalt self-assigned this Feb 14, 2026
Copy link

Copilot AI left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Pull request overview

Copilot reviewed 63 out of 64 changed files in this pull request and generated no new comments.

@softwaresalt softwaresalt merged commit e2d21c7 into main Feb 14, 2026
11 of 13 checks passed
@softwaresalt softwaresalt deleted the 001-baseline-sdd-spec branch February 14, 2026 22:20
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant