2020_05_28 F2light FFNS VFNS diff kink

• apfel jumping with 31=FFNS3 and 32=ZM-VFNS

Subtracting id:31 - id:32, in table 'logs'
==========================================

F2light
-------
        x          Q2     APFEL    yadism  yadism_error  rel_err[%]
0   0.001   90.000000  0.004645  0.004646  1.814315e-08    0.008493
1   0.010   90.000000  0.002682  0.002681  3.299448e-09   -0.022001
2   0.100   90.000000  0.001531  0.001555  1.448204e-09    1.540779
3   0.150   90.000000  0.001355  0.001389  2.376978e-09    2.520521
4   0.525   90.000000 -0.000826 -0.000830  7.743137e-10    0.419948
5   0.900   90.000000 -0.000018 -0.000022  1.482378e-11   17.759394
6   0.010    1.000000  0.002148  0.002168  3.187782e-09    0.924930
7   0.010    1.668101  0.003315  0.003327  3.669741e-09    0.365612
8   0.010    2.782559  0.014566  0.004433  3.662129e-09  -69.562988
9   0.010    4.641589  0.004837  0.004842  3.635528e-09    0.100174
10  0.010    7.742637  0.004780  0.004783  3.598419e-09    0.057375
11  0.010   12.915497  0.004532  0.004534  3.547382e-09    0.030632
12  0.010   21.544347  0.004108  0.004109  3.492211e-09    0.013406
13  0.010   35.938137  0.003578  0.003578  3.426233e-09   -0.001740
14  0.010   59.948425  0.003065  0.003065  3.356251e-09   -0.010127
15  0.010  100.000000  0.002586  0.002586  3.284475e-09   -0.023422

31:

F2light with theory=313 using CT14llo_NF6
        x          Q2     APFEL    yadism  yadism_error  rel_err[%]
0   0.001   90.000000  1.129428  1.129467  9.469461e-09    0.003482
1   0.010   90.000000  0.593638  0.593696  1.722088e-09    0.009783
2   0.100   90.000000  0.354019  0.353788  7.558691e-10   -0.065163
3   0.150   90.000000  0.318201  0.317794  1.240634e-09   -0.127690
4   0.525   90.000000  0.088386  0.088419  4.060406e-10    0.037758
5   0.900   90.000000  0.000584  0.000621  7.737074e-12    6.400593
6   0.010    1.000000  0.310263  0.310204  1.840845e-09   -0.019132
7   0.010    1.668101  0.395419  0.395386  2.081168e-09   -0.008109
8   0.010    2.782559  0.419045  0.419030  2.047941e-09   -0.003687
9   0.010    4.641589  0.445166  0.445164  2.008506e-09   -0.000449
10  0.010    7.742637  0.472144  0.472155  1.964239e-09    0.002314
11  0.010   12.915497  0.499036  0.499058  1.916868e-09    0.004401
12  0.010   21.544347  0.525306  0.525338  1.868039e-09    0.006151
13  0.010   35.938137  0.550784  0.550826  1.814862e-09    0.007600
14  0.010   59.948425  0.575141  0.575192  1.762530e-09    0.008835
15  0.010  100.000000  0.598310  0.598370  1.711695e-09    0.009993

Theory for 31

{'ID': 22,
 'PTO': 1,
 'FNS': 'FFNS',
 'DAMP': 0,
 'IC': 0,
 'ModEv': 'EXA',
 'XIR': 1.0,
 'XIF': 1.0,
 'NfFF': 3,
 'MaxNfAs': 6,
 'MaxNfPdf': 6,
 'Q0': 1,
 'alphas': 0.11800000000000001,
 'Qref': 91.2,
 'QED': 0,
 'alphaqed': 0.007496251999999999,
 'Qedref': 1.777,
 'SxRes': 0,
 'SxOrd': 'LL',
 'HQ': 'POLE',
 'mc': 2,
 'Qmc': 2,
 'kcThr': 1.0,
 'mb': 4,
 'Qmb': 4,
 'kbThr': 1.0,
 'mt': 173.07,
 'Qmt': 173.07,
 'ktThr': 1.0,
 'CKM': '0.97428 0.22530 0.003470 0.22520 0.97345 0.041000 0.00862 0.04030 0.999152',
 'MZ': 91.1876,
 'MW': 80.398,
 'GF': 1.1663787e-05,
 'SIN2TW': 0.23126,
 'TMC': 0,
 'MP': 0.938,
 'Comments': 'LO baseline for small-x res',
 'global_nx': 0,
 'EScaleVar': 1,
 '_modify_time': '2020-05-28 16:55:04.904839'}

32:

F2light with theory=314 using CT14llo_NF6
        x          Q2     APFEL    yadism  yadism_error  rel_err[%]
0   0.001   90.000000  1.134073  1.134113  8.673688e-09    0.003503
1   0.010   90.000000  0.596319  0.596377  1.577360e-09    0.009640
2   0.100   90.000000  0.355550  0.355343  6.923347e-10   -0.058246
3   0.150   90.000000  0.319556  0.319183  1.136344e-09   -0.116461
4   0.525   90.000000  0.087559  0.087589  3.682731e-10    0.034151
5   0.900   90.000000  0.000565  0.000600  7.086703e-12    6.030161
6   0.010    1.000000  0.312411  0.312372  1.346938e-09   -0.012641
7   0.010    1.668101  0.398733  0.398713  1.588573e-09   -0.005002
8   0.010    2.782559  0.433611  0.423463  1.614187e-09   -2.340299
9   0.010    4.641589  0.450003  0.450006  1.627022e-09    0.000632
10  0.010    7.742637  0.476924  0.476937  1.634180e-09    0.002866
11  0.010   12.915497  0.503568  0.503592  1.630514e-09    0.004637
12  0.010   21.544347  0.529414  0.529447  1.624172e-09    0.006207
13  0.010   35.938137  0.554363  0.554404  1.611371e-09    0.007540
14  0.010   59.948425  0.578207  0.578257  1.593721e-09    0.008735
15  0.010  100.000000  0.600896  0.600956  1.572780e-09    0.009850

Theory for 32

{'ID': 22,
 'PTO': 1,
 'FNS': 'ZM-VFNS',
 'DAMP': 0,
 'IC': 0,
 'ModEv': 'EXA',
 'XIR': 1.0,
 'XIF': 1.0,
 'NfFF': 3,
 'MaxNfAs': 6,
 'MaxNfPdf': 6,
 'Q0': 1,
 'alphas': 0.11800000000000001,
 'Qref': 91.2,
 'QED': 0,
 'alphaqed': 0.007496251999999999,
 'Qedref': 1.777,
 'SxRes': 0,
 'SxOrd': 'LL',
 'HQ': 'POLE',
 'mc': 2,
 'Qmc': 2,
 'kcThr': 1.0,
 'mb': 4,
 'Qmb': 4,
 'kbThr': 1.0,
 'mt': 173.07,
 'Qmt': 173.07,
 'ktThr': 1.0,
 'CKM': '0.97428 0.22530 0.003470 0.22520 0.97345 0.041000 0.00862 0.04030 0.999152',
 'MZ': 91.1876,
 'MW': 80.398,
 'GF': 1.1663787e-05,
 'SIN2TW': 0.23126,
 'TMC': 0,
 'MP': 0.938,
 'Comments': 'LO baseline for small-x res',
 'global_nx': 0,
 'EScaleVar': 1,
 '_modify_time': '2020-05-28 16:55:04.920883'}

might be related to https://github.com/scarrazza/apfel/issues/22